October 11, 2021

Today I was at the postoffice, simply to drop off a couple of letters.  Two ladies were wanting to do some business there, but the doors were locked, and they seemed confused.  It was Monday, after all.  I made a mindless quip: blame Columbus.  I hadn’t thought of the quip till the situation came up.  But coming home just now I thought it wasn’t particularly funny.  It wasn’t even thought out….

I’m here solely because of colonizing by white Europeans, of whom Christopher Columbus was one of the first.  Genetically I’m 100% European stock, French and German (they group the two nationalities together in my ancestral tree).  My first French-Canadian forebears was in N. America before 1620, but when he came North America was already well populated with a large assortment of native peoples.

And the story continues from there.

But I’ll leave that aside for this day, for which Indigenous People’s day is gradually gaining more traction.

Today, an offering from the Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian, here.

Tomorrow, a zoom offering from World Without Genocide, In commemoration of Indigenous Peoples’ Day, “Genocide of the American Indians:  From 1492 to Today” will be held on Tuesday, October 12, 7:00-9:00 pm CT. Register here.

Personally, I’ve had a bit of a walk with this issue in the last several months, becoming acquainted with an ancient Metis cemetery at Pembina ND.  If you’re interested, you can read my account about it here.  I am grateful to Ed Jerome and Ruth Swan for their many years of advocacy about this sacred ground.

Louts

There are two links in this post which I hope you’ll read in their entirety.

With all that is swirling around the “news” universe, this post is motivated by local action threatening local public education. This week was the week that the National School Boards Association, felt it necessary to sound the alarm to all of us about loutish behavior engaged in by a few people people who should know better, but represent a danger we as a society should not tolerate.

More below, about the title of the post, and the specific motivation for this particular post.

*

Elections for school boards are traditionally low-hanging political ‘fruit’.  In relative terms, few people pay attention to the issues and vote in such elections and mischief can be and is done.  There is an important school election in my school district Nov. 2, 2021 – an off year.  In our last local school election, 2019, also an off year, it appears that fewer than 10% of the over 65,000 eligible voters actually voted for candidates.

In my school district, this Fall, there are 9 candidates for the available school board positions.  You have to actively seek out information about them.  Four of them appear quite clearly to be what I would call ‘bullet ballot’ stealth candidates, who are clearly running together, supposedly non-partisan, but unquestionably partisan, and who seem basically anti-mask, anti-vaxx, and anti diversity, and opposed to a needed increase in the local school tax.  In such local elections, little attention is usually paid, which makes them even more dangerous than the rest.  This is where individual networks make the essential difference.  Every election has consequences, long after.  We are certainly learning this.

Know what is happening in your district this November, and vote, well informed.

*

We all know louts.  You may have a different name for the ones you know, but they’re all basically the same.

As I was thinking about the protests against masks and vaccinations etc, now encroaching on schools everywhere, I got to thinking about patterns which I think are relevant for all of us to consider, as we need to confront loutish behavior.

This is not a matter of ‘everybody does it’.  We are talking about a small minority.  But, today there is a pretty clear distinction in partisan political behavior over a long period of time.  There are two clear examples of this, in my opinion.

In 2000, Al Gore won the popular vote against George W. Bush for President of the United States, and were it not for a Supreme Court decision in mid-December of 2000, where Gore conceded for the sake of the country, he should have been President.  Any reader likely knows more about this history and can fill in the blanks.  Gore was vilified by some for not fighting longer; he valued more a continuation of our Democracy.

Twenty years later, In 2020, Joe Biden won both popular and electoral vote for President, and the losing candidate and his acolytes are still declaring the election was stolen, against overwhelming evidence to the contrary.  We’ve all been through January 6 and all the rest of the subsequent nonsense.  Laws are being changed in many places to make voting more difficult and easier to overturn results.  The strategy is very clear: to make it easier for one side to manipulate future elections.

Re “lout”.

We’ve witnessed loutish behavior before – it was especially obvious after the election of Barack Obama in 2008, and the subsequent tea-party eruptions as the Affordable Care Act and such were being fought meeting-to-meeting in our local districts.

Make no mistake, louts won, back then.  But they weren’t winners.

I was thinking, today, about our national Congress, Senate and Executive Branch, the highest elected officials in this nation.  There are about 538 of them in all, and within their ranks are the exact same kinds of actors we would see in any community of similar size.  It is easy to despise the Congress we ourselves have elected.  It is “Congress R US”, truly.  We get exactly what we deserve.

Recently my friend Jeff sent over an article from his University Bulletin.  It is short, but very well worth a read.  Here it is.  Put yourself in the room described in the article about a real situation, and ask yourself, “what would I have done?”  Citizens like all of us have considerable power.  Now’s time to begin to exercise it…but we need to get off the couch!

POSTNOTE:

“Lout” has a very simple definition: generally, it is considered an uncouth and aggressive man or boy.

All of us know louts.  Of course, as we know well, there are women louts as well.  And all sorts of variations of bullying, in my opinion, a very close cousin of lout.  “Jerk” is another printable word that comes to mind.

I am particularly disturbed about the stupid and dangerous behavior in or near the school setting.

I’ve said often, and I can prove it, that I’ve spent an entire lifetime in public education.  At the front-end, both parents were already veteran teachers by the time I was born.  Today, 81 years later, one grandchild is in a local high school; one daughter is a substitute teacher in a public school; another daughter is a Middle School Principal and has been a public school administrator for years.  In between, I was a public school teacher, and then a long-time representative of public school teachers.  I haven’t seen it all, but I’ve seen lots.

Years ago, school districts took on bullying behavior successfully within their schools.  Now the bullying is happening outside, and today we have to be the antidote for this development.

Be aware, and go to work.

COMMENTS (more at the end of this section): 

from SAK: As usual I enjoyed & was “informed” by your post.

I would, however, quibble with one sentence if I may & it is this: ” It is “Congress R US”, truly.  We get exactly what we deserve.”

Somehow I don’t think the system is working as well as you hope. Congress & most other elected chambers everywhere are not perfectly representative & they are not a miniature mirror image of the society at large. Compare the elected chambers to the general population on the basis of the racial makeup, the median worth or income, & in the case of the Senate even the geographical distribution (state size). I am no out & out optimist à la Voltaire’s Candide and certainly agree that louts abound but in general & as a whole we do deserve much better than we get!

Best wishes & warm regards.

Response from Dick: Thanks for feedback.  To borrow a phrase, “the fly in the ointment” in the U.S. is and has always been the careless use (or non-use) of the franchise: the right to vote.  Even in the marquee elections, as for President, a third or more of the people who are eligible to vote, don’t take the time to even cast a ballot.  Some might think that they are sending a message with their non-vote, but the message isn’t quite what they believe it is.  They are “voting” but in a manner inimical to their own interests.  As I mention, in the most recent school board election here, 10% or likely less of those eligible actually voted for the representatives charged with administering a school district with over 18,000 students.  I could go on.  Ours is a very sloppy democracy, and we will collectively pay for this in the long run, including those who choose to exploit the system as they see it.  Thanks again.  Always great to hear fro you.

from Marion: Good stuff, Dick! Thanks much!

from Jeff: Good one Dick.

from Tony: Great information.  Timely.  Thanks.

from Norm:  You were generous with your response to your conservative friends regarding the matter of loutish behavior [see comment from Jim, below].  He seems to consider Thompsons totally political dumb-ass behavior in Hugo as just as serious as the Trump cult followers trying to over throw the election let alone all of the pressures that the man-child was putting on the important members of the executive office to do just that in the days that preceded January 6.

That was not only loutish behavior on the part of those who stormed the capitol and Trump as well but it was treason behavior as well.
Yes, Thompson is a complete selfish dumb-ass whose behavior in Hugo and his subsequent political dumb-ass justifications as “poor me ain’t it just awful that they is a criticizing me because I am black (that claim has become so f–king tiresome in such cases!) hurt us at the polls in 2020 and will also do that at the polls in 2022 as I have repeatedly said all along.
On the other hand, he did not try to facilitate and overthrow of the Constitution that he had taken an oath to protect as the insecure, ignorant, arrogant, five-time draft dodger did!
*
Response from Dick: Norm speaks of a local Minnesota elected state legislator, essentially now operating as a lone wolf kind of individual.
*
from Flo: An important reminder of my reasons for running successfully for two terms on the school board way back when! The same crap is happening all over, this time about “Critical Race Theory”.  I’m too tired to run, but I will be in closer contact with our Superintendent and Board members. It’s really scary times here in Hubbard County.
*
from Brian: Great post, yay!
*
from Dick: Oct 11 I asked my school administrator daughter a “pop/top of the head” question.  I said it’s become my opinion that our two “tribes” in the current U.S. seem basically the “we’s” and the “me’s” – the first tend to look at themselves as part of a community, greater than themselves; the second cannot conceive of any interest other than their own.  She seemed to resonate with my general perception.  At this point in time, I asked, how would you see your public community divided at this moment. She hardly hesitated.  about 60-40, the 60 being we.  It was the first time I’d posed the question; I had no opinion since I’ve been out of the profession for many years.

 

 

Peace and Justice

Our friend, Molly, likes to send around some favorite poems at seasons of the year.  Autumn began on September 22.  Here are her Fall selections – three pages: 2021 Fall poems.  Thank you, Molly.

*

A week ago I was interviewed via Zoom as one of many participants in an international DNA project.  The interview was brief and in my recollection there were five questions.  One of them was “What’s identity for you?”  I asked for time to think about this one, and overnight came up with a pretty long list.  But the meat of my response to the question was also brief: “At 81 years, I think I can honesty say my preferred identity is to be part of the human race, which to me is all-inclusive.

Anyone who walks the same planet as I do knows that we live in tribes now.  My ideal is probably seen as naive.  But I’ll stand my ground.  We’re in this walk to the future together, whoever we are, wherever we live.

*

This post is the last for September, and like the previous five (see the archive), this relates to the post 9-11-01 world in which we live.

I title this post, simply, Peace and Justice.  If you have an interest in peace and justice for all, I want to strongly recommend the two initiatives which follow.  I know both persons over a lot of years; they have good ideas, they work hard and they deserve support.  I especially encourage your sharing this post and information with others.

The U.S. Peace Memorial Foundation:

I met Dr. Michael Knox in 2006 and have promoted his initiative since the beginning.  I’d encourage your purchase of the book, and becoming a founding member of the organization yourself.  This is a long term project.

The Peace Memorial Foundation website is here.  On July 17, 2021, the Tampa Bay Times published a column about the proposed US Peace Memorial. I joined the US Peace Memorial Foundation as a Founding Member in 2006 and served as Coordinator for MN for many years. The Foundation now has 427 Founding Members. They come from forty-five states (plus the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands). I’m proud to say that 10 percent (43) of these supporters live in Minnesota. All information about the initiative, how to donate, etc., are easily available at the website.  I’m proud to say that I was the 27th founding member of this Foundation, and the first from Minnesota.  

The 309 page book, which I purchased through Barnes and Noble is filled with useful information.  

Portraits of Peace by John Noltner.

I met John Noltner at a meeting of the Minnesota Alliance of Peacemakers about ten years ago.  He was in the process of reinventing himself – the near meltdown of the U.S. economy in 2008 forced a change in focus from previous work with major magazines and in the corporate world.  He has done amazing work – Portraits of Peace is his third book, just released.  Until it was interrupted by the pandemic, his series called “A Peace of My Mind” was in four exhibits traveling nationwide.  His website is well worth a visit.  The first panel gives information about the book.

I’ve had Portraits of Peace for only a few days, and chose to read a random selection of three chapters from the 31 chapters in the 201 page book.  Each chapter tells a story, many, perhaps most, with a single photograph, and in my opinion, each chapter would be worthy of a book club discussion group – one chapter at a time.  Each are gentle calls to action.  This is not a book for speed reading.  The selections are usually 5-10 pages, brimming with food for thought and personal reflection.  The subjects are ordinary people from all over the country, all representing the diversity that is America.     This book is readily available anywhere you like to buy books.

Check back for more topics on current issues beginning in early October.

Forward

Today is [Last Sunday was] the World Day of Migrants and Refugees, observed by the Catholic Church since 1914; I learned about this in an excellent column by Janice Andersen in our church newsletter, which can be read here:  Janice Andersen: An ever wider “we“.  A separate, younger observance is the United Nations World Refugee Day.  We are a nation of immigrants; one need not look further than the daily news to see that this is a critical and current issue.

*

“Back in the day”, well, actually two weeks ago, I had planned a post looking forward after the 20 year anniversary of 9-11-01.  As it happens, several days previous to 9-11-21 this site was hacked by someone, somewhere, who didn’t interfere with my site; rather rendered my own site inaccessible to me.  This has happened once before, about two years ago.  In this business, even small fry like me don’t escape the marauders.

September 8 I did my own retrospective on the last 20 years.  It’s “Snake bit“, if you wish.

There’s been a lot under the bridge in even the few days since 9-11-2021.  Just a few comments on this, the first day of the rest of our lives.

It does not seem a good strategy to try to go forward by becoming immobilized by what happened in the past.

A twin occurrence seems particularly instructive to me as I write.

For many years I’ve been a subscriber to our magnificent Minnesota Orchestra.

Our opening Minnesota Orchestra concert in 2001 happened to be September 21.  This was 10 days after 9-11-01.   Maestro Eije Oue (Japanese) raised his baton, leading the Orchestra in a rousing rendition of the Star Spangled Banner.  It was magnificent, and it was moving.  Unforgettable.  (I looked to see if this was on YouTube.  No luck.  My recollection was it was not on the printed program.)

About the same exact time, 9-20-2001, maestro Kurt Masur (German) led the New York Philharmonic similarly.  You can watch it here.  It seems much more subdued than the Minneapolis version I remember on near the same day.  The same notes; different tone.)

Twenty years later, we were in the same Minneapolis hall as in 2001, and Maestro Osmo Vanska (native of Finland), in his final year of a long tenure with the Minnesota Orchestra, also raised his baton, once again a rousing rendition of our national anthem.  This was in the printed program “John Stafford Smith/arr. Stanislaw Skrowacewski.  The Star-Spangled Banner“.  2021 matched the 2001 memory for me.

Skrowacewski was the revered long-time, 1960-79, music director of the Minnesota orchestra.  (Here’s a version from You Tube featuring the Coast Guard Band.)  September 23, 2021, was the first full concert of the full Minnesota Orchestra since the Pandemic brought our lives to a halt in March of 2020.  It was an evening to celebrate a return.

In my opinion:

In 2001, 9-11 was a huge shock to the national psyche.  In my opinion, we lost an opportunity in how we responded to 9-11 and this has been a huge millstone around our collective necks ever since.  Masur’s Star Spangled banner came across as solemn and depressed compared to the Oue’s rendition I heard almost the same night in 2001.  The NY Phil reading of our national anthem seemed to accurately reflect our national attitude going forward.

In 2021, sitting near where I sat in 2001, I was hearing a determined and hopeful national anthem from an Orchestra which had recovered from a near two year lockout in mid-decade.  It felt good to be listening.  I remembered the 2001 anthem in Mpls similarly.

Last Thursday the Orchestra was also aware of and pointing out other issues we need to confront.  To get in the hall, we needed to provide proof of being vaccinated, and masks were mandatory.  There were no protests.  The hall was filled to capacity.

But there was more: in the program itself, which included Max Bruch’s Scottish Fantasy and Beethoven’s 5th, was an 8 minute piece by composer Jessie Montgomery, simply entitled “Banner”.   Here is how the program booklet described the piece Minnesota Orchestra Sep 23 2021.  Take the time to read the few paragraphs.

Forward?

I wish everyone could hear the Minnesota Orchestra Star Spangled Banner, both the 2001 and 2021 versions.

I think 9-11-2001 found the U.S. in a “hole” – perceived loss of power and control.  Rather than working towards a rational solution then, our society proceeded to dig the hole deeper as the generation went on, as witnessed by endless and fruitless war.

Twenty years after “9-11”, our new 9-11 day will forever be January 6, 2021.  This was the day our own chickens came home to roost.  Our ‘terrorists’ now are home grown.  As we have come to learn, simply by living our lives, we have been driven apart into warring tribes, even within our own families and associates.

If there is to be hope forthcoming, and I believe there is reason for hope, it has to come from each and every individual citizen doing his or her part to carry us forward.

If our function is to be casual spectators, only expected to be critics, we will get the inevitable unpleasant results.  To win takes all of us.

I hope you agree.

POSTNOTE: Early in September an intriguing Opinion Quiz came via the New York Times: “If America had six Parties, Which would you belong to?”  It’s an easy opinion quiz – 20 questions, maybe 5 minutes, instant and personal assessment.  If you can access the quiz, I highly recommend it.

We are a nation of 330,000,000 people, and too often it seems we seem to have the idea that the only opinion that matters is our own personal opinion…and a society cannot function, much less an entire nation or even a family, where “my way or the highway” seems a prevalent ideology.  Even worse is the forced choice between two extreme options: us or them.  We are at that point in this divided society.  Our all too obvious flirtation with the fantasy of an authoritarian dictatorship is an ill wind, blowing.

Snake bit

Today I was driving in a nearby quiet neighborhood.  I was meeting another car in a street narrowed to one lane by two vehicles parked on opposite sides.  The occupant of one, a young man, was sort of a traffic cop, though that wasn’t necessary.  But it was a nice touch.  But mostly I noticed the young mans pick-up which had a very large Gadsden flag mounted at the edge of the truck bed.  These days that coiled snake yellow flag seems favored by people who fancy themselves rebels (my opinion).

For those who like to think that we’re back on the right track in this country, I beg to differ.  The Gadsden Guy was only the most recent piece of evidence that trouble is not that far beneath the surface, and the trouble will likely come from within our own citizens including friends, neighbors and relatives.

Much of the inciting we see every day in the American commons of internet or television especially.  Role models are governors and state legislators saying “go to hell” on things like masking, etc.  Or people who disrupt school board meetings, on and on.  Why used to be rare has become common.

We’re a big country with lots of people, and there are brilliant and diabolical organizers out there who are willing and able to make trouble, and who have plenty of money to work with, and willing minions at the local level.  And of course there’s the tribal leader who’s modus operandi is to get revenge and enlists angry people in assorted ways most of us probably don’t see.

Many of us have friends and relatives who are police and military, former and present, some who were or still are open and even outspoken support of anti-government, though they are part of this same government.  We tend to close our eyes to this: this a free country, after all.

But the rubber has hit the road.  Selective enforcement of the law: in the case of January 6, a slow response to a crisis because the people in the chain of command who had to authorize action, delayed response.  We were accustomed to a usual and customary role of our law keepers, and their chain of command.  And we still are.  But the deviations from normal in the recent – and not so recent – past have been significant.

Timothy McVeigh, who murdered hundreds in Oklahoma City in 1995,  was a Boy Scout and from the military, we must remember.  Today’s militia groups include in their membership people with lots of military experience, with nothing good on their minds.  Perhaps we are fortunate to have witnessed the graphic demonstration of this on Jan. 6, first hand; and witnessing ever since the efforts made by some to disrupt and upset any investigation or punishment of those involved.  I wonder what the guy with the Gadsden Flag was saying?

This has been evolving for years.

Just this week I was going through a box of papers, and came across something I knew I had, somewhere, but couldn’t find.  There it was, something I wrote back in the fall of 2001, including three pages from a U.S. News and World Report from September, 2000.  Here it is: 9 11 2001 Three vignettes.  Look especially at pages 3 and 4, keeping in mind that this is from 20 years ago.  It is worth a look as the 20th anniversary of September 11, 2001, approaches.

I have no idea what if anything will happen from this point on.  Nobody does.  But you can bet that preparations are being made, just in case.  We can no longer be naive.  There is doubtless planning taking place.

Each of us is either part of the solution, or of the problem.  Where do you stand?

POSTNOTE: My reflections 20 years after 9-11-2001 on the anniversary day, Saturday 9-11-2021.  (9-11 was a Tuesday in 2000.)

9-11-01

My first post about the 20th anniversary of 9-11-01 is here.

My personal quest is to learn from our nations experience in the last twenty years, and help make a contribution to a better world in what time I have left.  Another, possibly final, post on the topic will be published on 9-11-2021.

*

September 11, 2001, I was part of a crew of volunteers from Basilica of St. Mary working on a new Habitat for Humanity home which had been under construction for some time.

Our crew began its work on September 10, and was on scene for two weeks.  I recall there was a great outpouring of volunteers in the days following 9-11-01, so many that there was not enough work to be done.  People would drive up and ask if they could help.  I suspect others have similar stories at that time of national stress.  I was there probably for 7 of the 10 days.

I remember this porch (below) especially since my son-in-law John was helping when this porch was being constructed 9-11.  When I took the below photo, in the late Fall of 2001, the house was essentially complete, and the dedication and presentation to the family was in January of 2002.  The family still lives in the home. (A photo of the porch and crew on 9-11-01 can be seen here.)

I’ve watched several retrospectives on 9-11-01 in the past week, most recently last night on the NY Firemen first on the scene after the first plane hit the first tower.

I have been to New York City only once in my life, and that was in late June of 1972 for a few hours when I took the snapshots at the end of this post.  At the time, one of the towers had been completed and was occupied; the second was nearing completion.  We did not go into the building; we just wanted to see it.

At the end of October, 2001, we went on a vacation trip to London, which had been scheduled long before 9-11.  I remember the kindness and welcoming of the English on that trip.

Back home, unfortunately, the mood of our nation was war, and that has been our last 20 years, largely.  I think the danger of the Kabul suicide bomber at the end of August, could be – I certainly hope it isn’t – our new 9-11-01.  Wars have started on actions by a single person or a small group.  We didn’t, and we don’t, need war to get to peace.  War is a fork in the road best not taken.  Too much can go too wrong.

Sadly and ironically, the day the World Trade Centers were destroyed was days after the United Nations General Assembly meeting at the UN in Manhattan had approved a resolution setting September 21 of each year as the International Day of Peace.  A celebration was taking place at the UN Plaza when the first plane hit the tower not that far away.  I still have the video produced by the English group Peace One Day (scroll to the end and read the review written by someone.  The film is worth watching, if you have any interest in peace.)

*

Here is some information about the losses on 9-11-01 and in the subsequent years of war.  I think these numbers are reasonably accurate, though I know there are certainly other pieces of data that are similar, but not identical.

Data about the deaths at the time of 9-11-01 at the three sites.

Afghanistan cost of war between 2001 and 2021, data from Associated Press.

We always seem to amplify our own losses, and minimize those suffered by others in our wars.

World Trade Center New York City, end of June, 1972, by Dick Bernard

World Trade Center New York City June, 1971 photo by Dick Bernard

Snapshot of United Nations, New York City, Dick Bernard , Late June, 1972

POSTNOTE of concern: I have rarely written about 9-11-01 at this space.  One time vividly comes to mind, and that was the day I visited the International Peace Garden shared by North Dakota and Manitoba.  You can read it here.   I published it July 23 2009.  Succinctly, the tragedy we are re-viewing now, became a pretext to going to endless war, which hopefully ended on August 30, 2021.  Have we learned anything?  It remains to be seen.  Other posts about 9-11 can be accessed in the archive section at right, for Sep 2 2011, Sep 9, 2011,  Sep 11 2017, Sep 10, 2019.  Simply call up the month and year, then click on the specific calendar date.

Decay within.

Individual citizens, like myself, and you, will decide whether this experiment called the United States of America will succeed or fail.  January 6 was the first and very major wakeup call about a genuine crisis attacking our democracy.  The assault continues.  We sit idly by, and we invite disaster.

Related posts: August 30 and September 6.

*

This morning, as every morning, I delivered the Sports section of our paper across the driveway to our neighbor, then off for coffee.

We live in a town home, and share a driveway with three other families.  Rick, whose home adjoins ours, was in the doorway of his garage.  He’s often out early, the same time as I, and we’re casual friends.  Good folks, good neighbors, both ways.  This day Rick wanted to talk, and said he was reading a book about how America is destroying itself from within by Mark Levin.  It puzzled me.  First time in all the years I’ve known him that a political topic has ever come up.  I know the family politics – polar opposite of ours – and I said I didn’t know of the book, nor Mark Levin;  that what he posed would probably take a very long conversation.  We went on with our respective day.

Back home some time later I google’d “Mark Levin destroying itself from within”.  Levin’s a long-time conservative commentator, and there was a book with a similar thrust that he authored in 2005.  That book is my best guess what Rick was talking about.  (2005 was 16 years ago, the first year of George Bush’s second term, and we were full tilt into the Iraq War at the time.)  If you’re curious, google it.

The previous evening had come an e-mail from a relative, a retired PhD in political science in Montreal.  At the end of his e-mail he said “I’m reading a lot about the state of democracy in the States.  Fascinating but scary.”  The e-mail came at 8:29 p.m.

At 7:36 had come another e-mail from a good friend about the Supreme Court non-decision on the new Texas abortion law:  “How did only 80,000 Nazi officers control Germany, a country of 60 million? By identifying “the enemies” and asking citizens to report their fellows to the Gestapo or other Nazi group for persecution and/or death. Turn citizen against citizen. Divide and conquer.

If you follow the news at all, you can probably gather the drift.  Vigilantes are being empowered.  To those who say “good”, be very careful what you pray for.

The non-decision by the U.S. Supreme Court in the Texas case on Wednesday is the immediate most recent cause, but the rainstorm has become a flood of epic proportions particularly since a certain person lost the 2020 election by over 7 million votes.  But the raining on democracy itself began long before, consciously and deliberately, by operatives wishing to take permanent control of this government, supposedly “of the people, by the people and for the people“.

Heather Cox Richardson catches the essence of some of the critical political history here.  It’s not a long read, but a good one.  She’s not the first I’ve heard, recently, talk about “dog catches car” – it’s more fun to chase the car, than to catch it.  What do you do when you win?  I would suspect the Taliban has that quandary in Afghanistan ‘as we speak’.  So did the Nazis, when their “1,000 year Reich” began to unravel only 10 years into their regime.  Be careful what you pray for.  Yes the victims can also be the perpetrators.

But this is a deadly serious matter and we are well advised to take our heads out of the sand.  If we give a damn, we get to work.  It’s our gig, not someone else’s.  One person, one action at a time.

Personally, I’m struggling with how best to address another e-mail I got from a relative last Sunday.  This one was one of those insane “forwards” which ends “Author unknown”.  It is the laundry list of the radical right fears and hates.  Here is the forward in its entirety: Ken anon letter Aug 28 2021.    The handwritten comments are mine.  I apologize for the brevity.  It would take many pages to do justice in a response.  I expect to add somewhat more detail to my response to this, perhaps this weekend.  Check back.  [Sep 5.  See postnote.]

As for the “author unknown”, I’ve watched this evolve over the years in the misinformation industry.  In the naive old days, which are really fairly recent, they would attach a real name to a quotation even if the person named was not responsible for the quote, which may or may not have been true.  The most recent example that comes to mind was a quote by Abraham Lincoln I saw in a North Dakota church bulletin a couple of years ago.  Unfortunately, there are people keep close tabs on Lincoln’s quotations, and it was an easy search to find out that Lincoln never said what was attributed to him in the bulletin.

The Priest apologized to me, and said he got a sheet including such quotes from parishioners he trusted…just how this works.  He was conned by his own flock.  Did he learn his lesson?  He’s in another state.  I don’t know.

If you look at the Ken letter, and I recommend that you do, what you have by this prolific and infamous author, “anon”, is a listing of things that a certain group of people fear or hate.

Caveat emptor.

Some ideas for a long weekend:

  1. Last Monday I had the opportunity to watch, for the first time, the film Hunger Games (2012).  It is worth your time.  It is fiction, but it is thought provoking.  It was a very successful series of books and movie.
  2. You probably know the name “Julian Assange“.  Whatever your personal feelings about him, an organization in which I’m active is offering a particular opportunity between now and September 16.  All details are here.  Scroll down.  Preregistration is required if you wish to join the program; the films are available on line and on your own.  Watch before the conversation.

COMMENTS:

from Jane:    Every woman has a right to choose whether or not to give birth.  And every woman also has a right to choose whether or not to get an experimental injection that is proving to be more dangerous in many instances than COV$D itself.

response from Dick: I decided to ask Center for Disease Control (CDC) about this first.  Here.  Then I went to the link provided by Jane, which is here.

from Marion: Thanks, Dick. I read the link. Most of it either new to me or lost to my 94-year-old memory.

POSTNOTE Sep. 5, from Dick: I don’t see any reasonable way to confront “Ken anon” (above).  It would be evidence against feelings, and if feelings dominate, evidence will make no difference whatsoever to either the author (who will always be unknown) and the person who sent it to me in the first place.   So, I’ll just let it be.  I did rescan the pdf, in particular high-lighting words and phrases which seem most relevant to the sender.

 

Hunger Games

A few years ago I heard about a book then a film called “The Hunger Games”.  It didn’t much interest me.  I neither read the books, nor saw the movie.

That changed Monday night: I was invited to a showing of the movie and I went.

It is described as a “dystopian” novel and thus film.

Nonetheless, at the end of the film I would highly recommend it as good food for adult discussion about contemporary America.

Here’s the wiki article about Hunger Games.

I’ll say no more about it, than to say I watched the entire film with a few teenagers.  And I recommend it as food for both thought and discussion, but as a possibility for action.

9-11-2001

President Biden’s remarks on leaving Afghanistan August 31, 2021.  Here’s some commentary about it: Just Above Sunset: Some Explaining.

More About 9-11:  post of September 6, 2021

*

I’ll click ‘publish’ on this when August 31 begins in Afghanistan, 9 hours before Minnesota.  The intention of this post is strictly to encourage each reader to assess his/her personal feelings about the 20 years – a generation – since 9-11-2001; then to also personally reflect on how he/she commits to approach the 20 years upcoming.

Previous recent posts relating in whole or part to Afghanistan: August 16, 19, 26, 28 2021.  Access through archive section at right.

*

Remembering 9-11-01, some thoughts from 20 years ago:

5th grade student, Lester’s, art, early October 2001 suburban Minneapolis MN.   This flag is prominent in my home office.  Somewhere here at home I have over 30 pieces of writing by elementary students after 9-11-01, a common cathartic technique.

Personal communications as saved by myself between September 10 and 24, 2001, appear here (12 pages): Sep 10 to 24 2001.  Except for the first two pages from Sep 10, 2001, I only include content that specifically relates to 9-11.  At that time, my normal e-mail traffic was a family letter I tried to do every two weeks.  9-11 quickly erupted into a communications frenzy – people needed to talk.  Some years ago I printed out the first 100 days of such dialogue, which filled two business envelope boxes.  These were donated to, and accepted by, the Minnesota Historical Society for posterity.

Referring to specific pages in the attachment: page 3) The three photos referenced can be seen here (scroll down, this space also includes my comments from a year after 9-11-01; 4) my sister Mary Ann’s comments.  She was at the WTC 4 days before 9-11; 5-7) first person survivor from the towers written immediately after escaping; 8) from a church bulletin, note comment about bullying; 11) “perhaps the most important…”; 12) note the Priests comments in a church homily the Sunday after 9-11.

*

My grandson, Spencer, is an active duty Marine, though not in Afghanistan.  He was one and a half on 9-11-01, recently turning 21.  Those Marines killed at Kabul were largely in his cohort.  When he was in high school I prepared a simple page on the human cost of war to the United States.  The data is of 2016, and he and his teacher found it of interest.  It is here: War Deaths U.S.002

*

Just Above Sunset for August 30 f you wish a good collection of opinions about the carnage at the Kabul airport.  If nothing else, read the last sentence.

Joyce sends on “Innocence and Folly” from The Weekly Sift.

COMMENTS: Check end of post for more.

from Mary: May as well ‘weigh in’!  Somehow I can not quite understand why this Afghan exit had to become such a big deal…don’t folks know how to fade out of the picture?  I will give some of the dubious credit  for the lumps to the 24 hour news cycles and the Monday Morning experts.  Human Rights aside – maybe they should not be – but we can not think that we can fix everything!!  We were uninvited and unwelcome and long ago outlived our usefulness in fixing this tribal society – there is and always will be plenty to do in the USA should Americans want to accept a real challenge…we live in a world of health care and infrastructure and education challenge and shady slimy stuff getting in the way of too many political decisions.   Afghanistan – Another sad example of the futility of revenge.

Dick in response:  I have been noticing over the last few years in particular a conscious and deliberate effort to make the United States a “tribal” society too.  Take your pick: urban/rural; race; women/men; religion…division has been useful to some operatives; not to a United country, and we will pay the price.

from Jermitt: Powerful read!  There is no way to leave a country after “losing the war”, without criticism and perhaps bloodshed.  Yes, perhaps a mass evacuation may have started earlier, but who would have forecasted the folding of the Afghan military.  No one.  I believe Biden had only one reasonable option and he did what was best for all the allies and the U.S.

The Peace Pole.

Thursday’s post, Seeing Ike, began with some comments about Afghanistan, but I said not a single word about the terrorist attacks on the same day.  Why?  Very simply, when I wrote the piece – published at 12:16 pm CDT, terror attacks in Kabul were not at all on my radar.  Kabul time is 9 hours ahead of here.  The major story was probably out there in fragments but still developing as I was writing, unawares.  Even in these times of instant communication, verification is sought before anything official is said, but difficult in the best of circumstances; still, essential especially because of so much misinformation.  (Earlier posts about the current Afghanistan Crisis are at August 16 and 19.  August 31, deadline day for withdrawal from Afghanistan, will be my first post relating to 9-11-01.)

The opinions are endless now, and in many ways “empty and meaningless” (to use a phrase I once heard that really applies here).  Everybody appearing behind a microphone is, as someone mentioned, in “CYA” mode: impolitely, “cover your ass”.  That is simple: deflect and blame.  The wisdom of hindsight is 20-20, of course, particularly when you can fashion your message without any intrusion of facts that don’t support your own position.

Molly, yesterday, sent an interesting blog post which seems reasonably fair and balanced.  Molly says: “Friends, This morning, a blogger I follow linked to this amazing story-within-a-story (which I had not seen elsewhere) regarding yesterday’s tragedy in Kabul… Quiet, unsung, acting for the reasons that make us proud and humble that these people represent our country and us. The Pineapple Express.  500 people. May we stay worthy of these Veterans and their work.

Personal disclosure: my grandson, Spencer, is a Marine on active duty at this moment in history, although not in this particular theatre.

The Peace Pole

Thursday we elected to go to the program on the Gandhi Mahal grounds, as advertised in Wednesdays blog.  The program was outside; the forecast for the time was near 100% probability of rain.  The decision was made by organizer David Logsdon to hold the program ‘rain or shine’.  It was a hike to get to the site; there could be nobody there and a thunderstorm pending even if there were people.  We went anyway.

I would estimate that 30 of us, “soaking wet”,  showed up.  And the weather followed through, basically it was near impossible to avoid “soaking wet”.  Most of us huddled under a large umbrella; some of us, including organizer David Logsdon, decided to welcome the rain (which is badly needed here).  We were under the umbrella…it didn’t help much!  There was no wind, thankfully, but it rained for much of the time.

Nonetheless back home I wrote Dave and a few others:  “last night was one of the most inspiring events I’ve been to in many, many years.  Thank you for organizing it.  (The weather added to, rather than detracted from, the significance of the evening.)“.  Showing up is the essence of organizing.

The purpose of the event was to re-declare the site of Gandhi Mahal as a Peace Site, and to present owner Ruhel Islam with a temporary Peace Pole in anticipation of a new restaurant and complex in coming years.  The restaurant was destroyed by fire in the events following the murder of George Floyd in 2020.

Special guest Larry Long performed several songs, and subsequently wrote his thoughts at his Facebook page, shared here with his permission:

Ruhel Islam was honored with a PEACE POLE from Veterans for Peace & World Citizens on the sacred grounds of Gandhi Mahal restaurant – only a block from the 3rd Precinct in our beloved Longfellow community. The gathering was called Longfellow Rising: Another Evening of Peace, Love, and Curry.
As our friend Ruhel said following the loss of George Floyd, “Gandhi Mahal may have felt the flames last night [May 29, 2020], but our firey drive to help protect and stand with our community will never die! Peace be with everyone.” Ruhel also said, “Let my building burn, justice needs to be served. . . We can rebuild, but we cannot bring George Floyd’s life back.”
Gandhi Mahal is in fact being rebuilt at the very same location upon an even stronger foundation. To include an aquaponics community garden and fish farm.
As Mahatma Gandhi said, “We but mirror the world. All the tendencies present in the outer world are to be found in the world of our body. If we could change ourselves, the tendencies in the world would also change. As a man changes his own nature, so does the attitude of the world change towards him. This is the divine mystery supreme. A wonderful thing it is and the source of our happiness. We need not wait to see what others do.”
Thank you Dave Logsdon, Anita White, Thomas LaBlanc, Scott Fultz, Dawn Goodwin, Dick Bernard and so many others for participating and organizing this glorious event in the Longfellow neighborhood where my children where my children were raised.
Peace and all good Larry

Here are some photos from the evening.  (It did rain buckets for a significant part of the two hour program; fortunately unaccompanied by wind and a minimum of thunder and lightning.)

Ruhel Islam, Gandhi Mahal, August 26, 2021

Martha Roberts, representing World Citizen, rededicates GandhiMahal site as a Peace Site.  Dave Logsdon, who organized the event, is at left.

Some of the audience August 26.  This is the site where Gandhi Mahal stood until May 29, 2020.

Larry Long (at right) and Scott Fultz perform August 26

Dawn Goodwin, White Earth, environmental activist fresh from environmental protests at MN State Capitol, spoke at the gathering.

POSTNOTE:  Tomorrow, a few comments about Assumption; August 31, a post preliminary to the 20th anniversary of 9-11-01.  Do check back.

COMMENTS:

from Jerry:  Dick, thanks for the report on yesterday’s gathering at the peace site.  When you sent a notice about this gathering, I wanted to be there and support Rubel Islam and rebuilding Gandhi Mahal, but I knew my condition would not make it feasible.  I have good thoughts of this site.  I’m sorry you got wet but God knew we needed the rain.  I’m on a two week wait and see if my hip heals enough to avoid surgery.

from Kathy:  Love this positive message!  Thank you for sharing!  “….rain down, rain down, rain down your love on your people….”

Dick, responding to Kathy:  Thank you very much for this.  Here’s a good version on YouTube.  It was a spiritual moment for us, for sure.