Epilogue. 9-11-01

Friday night, after I published comments about 9-11-01,  I took time to read the eight additions to the conversation.  It occurred to me that the eight reflections were probably a good cross-section of  millions in the U.S. and elsewhere, who in similar ways tried to make sense of the insanity we all witnessed in real time in a few minutes beginning early 9-11-01 in New York City.

We are – we cannot deny it – a global community.  Even 25 years ago, we were not alone.  The casualty list for 9-11-01 speaks to that reality.  Many from other nations died in the carnage.  And 9-11 was only chapter one of a continuing tragedy.

Here is my attempt to fill in some personal blanks in my experience of that awful day and the days following.  This is only a tiny summary.

AFTER SEPTEMBER 11, my first vivid memory was the silence.  We live relatively near the Twin Cities  and St, Paul airports, and their flightpaths.  Those days I walked outdoors, and before 9-11 there was often a plane heard or seen overhead;  September 12, and for a few days following, nothing.

It was a new and very unusual day in America.

By September 24, it was becoming obvious that peace was not to be forthcoming.  There were other plans being discussed about the future.

Some time earlier in the summer we had booked a flight and accommodations for a week or two in London, England.  We decided to go ahead with the trip, and were glad we did.  We were treated very well.  We flew home from Gatwick on Armistice Day, Nov. 11, 2001.  At 11 a.m. that day, on the dot,  the PA announcer in the terminal asked for two minutes of silence, and the busy airport fell completely silent. I don’t recall even a babies cry.

At home, by November, 2001, the mood had been changing.  By late September a strategy was developing to avenge the injury inflicted on the United States, and by early October came a poll  where 94% of Americans supported bombing Afghanistan where Al-Qaeda hung out.  I don’t recall similar retribution plans against Saudi Arabia or Egypt, where Osama bin Laden and most of the airplane high-jackers were from.

I made my first visit to an antiwar protest in early October, 2001.  I didn’t know any of the speakers, nor the organizers.  My dominant memory, even today, is of a very vocal antagonistic group of U.S.-flag-brandishing anti-protestor protesters….  WAR on Evil was their message to the gathered peaceniks.

I became a peace activist.  For three years, 2005-07,  I was President of a group of organizations, the Minnesota Alliance of Peacemakers; and was part of the organizing committee for a major “Peace Island” Conference at the time of the 2008 Republican National Convention, both in St. Paul MN.   I became very aware of the seductive beat of the drums of war in competition with the gentle sounds of peace.  Maybe it’s part of human nature to revel in conflict, especially if you win by domination.  We desperately need peacemakers.

Feb. 5, 2003, Secretary of State Colin Powell had solemnly told the UN that Saddam Hussein was going nuclear, and Powell  was trusted.  The focus had switched from al Qaeda to regime change in Iraq.  Game on.  First came “Shock and Awe” over Baghdad in March.  May 1, 2003 came the now-infamous Mission Accomplished speech on the deck of the USS Abraham Lincoln by President Bush announcing the victory over Saddam Hussein.  Aside from the press releases, there was never a victory, as we all know.  (Saddam was captured in December, 2003, and executed in December, 2006.)

For awhile after 9-11, I climbed aboard the 9-11 conspiracy train, which became very active and had reputable representatives and supporters.  Many of their arguments made sense.  That movement lasted quite awhile.  Finally the movement largely evaporated, as much from media leaders accepting the administration line that there was “no there, there”; joining in ridiculing those who suspected less than clean hands of others in the success which came from the chaos.

Of course, then, it really made no difference.  The damage was done.  There are those still carrying the torch, but they have no audience.  and in this media dominated society, it is easy to bury problems, just by not mentioning or making it possible to effectively debate the issues. It is justly said that history is written (or buried) by the victors through the official story – a major concern in todays assault on what history will say about the present in which we are living today.  About the best that we might be able to do is to keep the memory alive at least to the distinct possibility that there is more to the story than we will ever learn.

In the 25 years since 2001, a particularly low point for me came in the summer of 2009 when I visited the International Peace Garden on the North Dakota/Canada border.  The story is in a blog of mine posted in summer 2009.  It was as if War had vanquished Peace at the Peace Garden.  A long-standing Peace symbol had been converted to a War monument by the governing Board of the Peace Garden.  Parts of the World Trade Center wreckage were displayed on the grounds; newspaper accounts of 9-11 were on display in the chapel.  I don’t know the current status there….  It was jarring, then.

And on its gone for 25 years.  Each of us have our own stories, worth remembering and sharing in our own circles.  We can learn by listening to ourselves and to others.  What will we make of the 25 years ahead?

*

There is one further story, important to me, personally, from another time in our history.

This day, I recall another horrific day in the life of America: Pearl Harbor, December 7, 1941.  Every December 7, this years 85th anniversary no exception, we will all see the USS Arizona blow up spectacularly on TV clips or newspaper photos, etc., one of the consequences of an attack by 353 Japanese aircraft.  Each time I see this, I’m watching my Dad’s brother, Uncle Frank, who I actually met as a one year old in early July, 1941, die in the explosion.  He was a ship fitter, his entire six year Navy career was aboard the USS Arizona.  Here’s one of over 20 photos I have of him.  He died at 26 years of age.

Frank Bernard, sometime between 1936 and 1941, USS Arizona

This year two of my daughters are going to be at Pearl Harbor, representing Granduncle Frank’s family..

A couple of years ago I got a letter from a Department of Defense subgroup that had received funding to attempt to match flesh recovered from the Arizona after Dec. 7, but till DNA impossible to match with any casualty that awful day.  Male descendants were invited to give DNA samples for analysis, and I did.  Uncle Frank is one of the unknowns.

This summer came a followup letter: Arizona Battleship disinternment

To my knowledge, no match has been found to my uncle…at least not yet.  But several other unknowns have been identified through the process, and this year will be the first such commemoration, and I’m glad that Frank’s grandnieces can be in attendance.

Let’s have a conversation, all of us, everywhere.

Dec. 8, 1941, Japan and the U.S. became deadly enemies to each other.  At the end, four yers later, two horrendous bombs over Hiroshima and Nagasaki officially ended WWII.

Those of us old enough can remember the details of the ensuing years rebuilding relationships between Japan and the U.S., and the lesser known details of what may have been the reasons the Japanese chose to attack America’s outpost at Pearl Harbor.  War is simple, yet very, very complicated.  Might does not make right.

“Let there be peace on earth, and let it begin with me.”

Each and every one of us is the solution, one action at a time.

POSTNOTE Sep 13: At Basilica of St. Mary this morning, the new Pastor, Ralph Talbot, commented on 9-11-01.  His was an on point homily, and mirrored his comments in the Sunday newsletter, copied here: Basilica Ralph Talbot Sep 13 26

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS;

from Larry Sep 11: Wow…Dick! What a fantastic piece of work you did on this whole project in two parts. Excellent commemoration of this day we will never forget. I too thought it was a small plane hitting a building in NYC. I was on the treadmill at the time. Then the whole thing started hitting me. Got to work and my dept. set up TV sets in the cafeteria so employees could follow this on their breaks.  Horrible, unprecedented day that changed the world.  I see the link to the interview with John. Works great!  Nicely done – your entire work on this…thanks!  LG

from Joyce Sep 11: This is an excellent compilation of experiences of 9/11. I was thinking, just now, of how we have abandoned, even demonized, expertise in this country. In the weeks before the 2000 presidential election I watched a man being interviewed on TV, and he said he was voting for GW Bush because, he said, Bush was just an ordinary farmer. Of course Bush was nothing of the sort, he had bought his ranch when he decided to run for president, and he sold it soon after leaving office, but aside from that, since when is an “ordinary farmer” a better choice for president than someone with years of experience and accumulated knowledge and expertise? Consider the incompetents running our government right now because people just couldn’t vote for a woman with years of experience in all three branches of government.  Consider all the newspaper articles interviewing Trump voters in rural diners, and the absence of interviews with educated people who voted the other way. I will never understand this lionization of ordinary, inexperienced, poorly educated men, and I use the word men deliberately.

from Larry J Sep 11: Attached for those who want to get it and those to whom I wish to send it.  When we heard the announcement that JFK was assassinated, I was in Mr. Ruud’s physics class at Bloomington High, using slinkies to learn about the wave theory of light.  When 9/11 happened, I was teaching storytelling and video in a Minneapolis school.  The maintenance person barged in and said, “I told your group shooting video they had to get back in here.  A plane just crashed into the World Trade Tower.”  Today I just want all of us to come together in love.

Larry added his recent column in the northwest Minneapolis newspaper Sun Post: Larry Johnson Sun Post 9 10 26

from Fred Sep 11:  Find the Jimmy Kimmel interview with James Talarico on You Tube. The Federal Communications Commission torpedoed Kimmel’s efforts to use it on his live TV show

First off, it is really entertaining but also because Talarico comes off so well. I’ve seen him before and like the guy, but he really smooth, but not cocky, while being interviewed. Talarico is now leading in Texas even though the GOP is in all in on stopping him.

from Kathy Sep 12: a letter one of her 5th graders wrote to a “New York student” after9-11-01

25 years after 9-11-01

5th grade Student art after 9-11-01 suburban Minneapolis MN

PLEASE NOTE: THIS IS THE SECOND OF TWO POSTS FOR SEPTEMBER 11.  THE LINK TO THE FIRST IS HERE.

My Personal Memories of 9-11-01: Among the memories are the following half-dozen links, each filling a tiny part of the story of the time immediately before 9-11-01; 9-11 itself, and the time after.  Those of us who experienced 9-11 wherever and however that entered our lives know there was an immense amount of communication through the means available which, at the time, included e-mail, but did not include any of the social media we take for granted today.  (Facebook was the first to arrive, in 2004.)  The references to kid art came from my good friend, Kathy, then a 5th grade teacher.  Some years ago I photocopied the first 100 days of e-mails after 9-11 which totaled several hundred pages, and gave them to the Minnesota Historical Society for Archival and future research purposes.)

The elementary school kids who did the art are now in their mid-30s.  Their generation is much in my mind as I write this.  What is their future?

My suggestion with the below is simply to browse and pay attention to whatever you wish.  My personal thoughts today follow the links.

First my 2000 Christmas card and message, and 2001 Christmas card and message.  For many years I did ‘homemade’ cards generally motivated by some noteworthy event in the preceding year.

Assorted e-correspondence

9-11-01 Aftermath;

Sep 10 to 24 2001;

Sep 10, 2001.

My family website Reflecting on 9-11-01 (scroll down)

What this all means to me, 25 years later:

My personal interpretation, and that is all that I have, was my very major disappointment following 9-11-01 on its use as an excuse to go to war, compounding the civilian and military deaths that continue to this day.  A small group of evil doers. mostly Saudi, were successful beyond their wildest dreams, and I’m not talking about their success in destroying buildings and lives in New York City, Washington DC and Shanksville PA.  They have permanently damaged. our entire society, and they were all instantly dead on 9-11-01.

Back in 2001. we almost immediately were directed into a war footing which officially lasted until closing Afghanistan operations in 2021.  The consequences of that 20 years war continue to this day.

I began this little project intending to look at the 50 years prior to 9-11-01, the 25 years subsequent to it, and to think about the 50 years to come from today.

1950-2000 was a time of almost continuous conflict: Korea, Vietnam, the Cold War, the Nuclear Arms Race, Sen. Joe McCarthy and the anti-Communist hysteria.

In the 25 years between 9-11-01 and today came almost continuous war and an increase in tribalism within our own society, and labeling of others as enemies, even though the label is undeserved.  We seem as a society to want enemies, to dominate others.  It is not healthy. Each person has their own stories, and maybe if there is any benefit from this exercise, is that individuals will take time to assess how we all fit into the problem, and into the solution.

I repeat the recommendation I mentioned in the previous post – the potential value of “The Work in Progress”.

There is an unexpected bonus to this process.  Last night, we were among about 100 in a St. Paul theatre, joining thousands of other around the country in the premier of an important film, ‘The Work In Progress“.  You will glad you attended when it arrives in your area.  Check it out.  

I don’t know the details of future distribution.  I only know from personal experience that it is a thought provoking film.

Let’s work together for a. better world. Today’s children deserve it.

EPILOGUE SEPTEMBER 12, 2026

 

 

 

June, 1972 New York City Statue of Liberty photo by Dick Bernard

9-11-01 Remembered

 

 

Pre-note: 9-11-01 was hugely impactful for me.  This blog is probably the best evidence.  I began writing what came to be this blog in the wake of 9-11-01, and in the past 25 years there have been over 4000 posts on a great variety of topics.  But it started because of 9-11-01;

My intent, leading to this post and the one following, is to simply review what I remember from that awful time, trying to make sense of it in our history as a country.  I invited  others to share some of their memories, and these follow, below.   The several reminiscences come from friends.  I have not read them, but will after I complete and publish my own thoughts. My preference is that you read these first,  then in the following post dated 9-11-01 where I’ll share my own thoughts on this difficult anniversary.

Hopefully what somebody said will resonate with you.

There was an unexpected bonus to this process.  Last night, we were among about 100 in a St. Paul theatre, joining thousands of others around the country, in the premier of an important film, ‘The Work In Progress“.  I’d urge attendance when it becomes available to you.  Check it out.

Following are some memories of 9-11-01.  There are eight so far.  Ground Zero impacted far beyond Ground Zero in 2001

My reflections follow in the post for September 11, “25 Years after 9-11”. The followup post includes e-mails from the time including a family letter from the day before, September 10, 2001.

from Joyce Sep 7:

I was still living in NYC at the time; in fact, I was sitting on the floor in my bedroom packing for my move to Minnesota, scheduled for October 2, when a friend called and told me to turn on CNN right away.
I didn’t live close to lower Manhattan; my home in Queens, the largest of the 5 boroughs, was a short walk from the border with the next county, about as far east as you could get from Manhattan and still be in New York City. Even so, we could smell the smoke there, and the sky was a weird color. What struck me the most in the days following 9/11 was how quiet it had become. I was used to constant noise, of traffic, flights from La Guardia and JFK, both in Queens, flying over my house, sirens from ambulances and fire trucks. Instead, the only noises were the occasional helicopter and the occasional military plane overhead. Traffic was at a standstill. A road near my house led to one of the bridges into Manhattan, and for days the traffic on that road was backed up all the way through Nassau, the next county to the east of us. There was a firehouse across the street from me, and we were friendly with the firefighters; I used to bring the kids over so they could sit in the trucks and try on helmets. Those men and their trucks were in Manhattan, and a team from outside NYC were filling in for them, with green trucks instead of the red to which I was accustomed.
At work, there was tremendous anxiety; a lot of nurses there were married to policemen. One of my coworkers hadn’t heard from her husband since he had called on 9/11 to tell her he was headed toward the site. Fortunately, he was okay, but I still don’t know how she was able to focus on work before she heard back from her husband. I worked L&D, and we had a lot more women in preterm labor than usual in the weeks after 9/11. Some of our patients had lost their husbands.

from Larry, Sep 7: As we remember 9-11-01, twenty-five years ago this week, I always wondered how working air crews handled that day. We had two airline captains in our 1961 class at Valley City (ND) High School. Four years ago, I interviewed our classmate, John Manstrom, a Delta Captain as well as a Navy flyer during the Viet Nam war. He was in the cockpit that day. Although it’s a permanent YouTube item on my blog, I’ll share the link to the interview here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2TIygPhm46M
Keep up the interesting work, Dick!


from Gramee, Sep 8: On September 11, 2001, I was well into my 15th year of not watching television. Family and friends. Boggled the minds of family and friends.

Phone rang early that morning. My adult daughter, Beth, didn’t even say “hello.” She said, “Mom, I know you don’t watch TV, but I think you should turn it on, right now!! Something awful has happened.” She sounded very upset.

I took the phone with me to the TV I’d covered years ago with a small table cloth. Whipped off the cloth and turned on my abandoned TV to a news station.

“And what to my wondering eyes should appear…” A scene I couldn’t grasp at first. There was absolute chaos in New York City
Yelling. Fire. Smoke. Police and fire fighters. Ambulances. People fleeing on foot, away from what was left of the twin towers. Why? Because the towers had been destroyed by an airplane flying directly into them.

At first, I thought there must have been some kind of horrible accident. A plane in a desperate situation. That was bad enough. But Beth, who was still on the phone with me, said word had it that the crash was likely intentional. An attack. I remember that as the moment my brain went all WTF. We watched together via the phone, without saying a word,while we watched the horror evolve.

This is already an over-long recital of what turned out to be the beginning of our country’s most disastrous thing until Donald Trump came along. Our lives were/are never the same from 9/11 forward.

Never.

from Kathy Sep 8: The Sept 11th attack was monumental – changed the way we look at security and folks ‘different’ from us – particularly those of brown skin with foreign accents. I recall getting a phone call from my penpal’s daughter in Japan that morning just before leaving to teach kindergarteners – the 2nd wk of school. Kyoko yelled, “Mom! Look at the t.v.! Someone is crashing airplanes into the Twin Towers in NY!” I watched in disbelief…Oregon is a long way from NY and DC! I still think the impact of those events were greater felt by folks closer to the East Coast where the tragedy was occurring.

What I noticed most was the effect this had on our local Oktoberfest the next week. Ofest is 61yrs a folk fest this year…Ofest is where thousands of folks descend upon our little town to celebrate for 4 days. The year 2001 was to be different. We still held the festival but a sadness prevailed over all. Normally joyful people of all ages would be dancing, singing, eating, drinking but this year a pall covered our little town. I was scheduled to give concerts in St. Mary Church – big neo-gothic church built in 1912 by local parishioners..a jewel of a building reminiscent of cathedrals in Europe. The Ofest board decided to hold the fest and continue the activities so my concerts went on as scheduled.

I sang songs of old & well known hymns… people cried as they sat or knelt in prayer – I ended the concert with Edelweiss and God Bless America….Each concert’s end that year I received a standing ovation – something I’d never experienced before or since, but I know I was addressing the tragedy with songs from the heart and that folks needed to be in that safe sacred space I was honored to provide for them.

from Carol Sep 8: I think 9-11, for those of us old enough to have experienced both, is like the Kennedy assassination in that we all remember exactly what we were doing when we heard the news.  I was talking on the phone with my daughter-in-law who interrupted to say that she’d just seen on TV a plane fly into a tall building – somewhere in Europe, she thought.  Then she said the World Trade Center, and since at that time there was a downtown St. Paul building with that name across from where I worked, I totally freaked out.

I of course joined the rest of the country just frozen in place in front of our screens watching the unfolding horror for hours – forgetting to get dressed or even eat.  The fact that foreign terrorists had dared to hit us so brutally on our own turf was nearly impossible to process.  It shattered a sense of safety for Americans that we have never gotten back.

But also what I so clearly remember was the sudden overwhelming realization on the part of Americans that we were all in this together.  All one country.  OUR country.  I had never experienced that before in my life, and certainly have not since.  Strangers hugged strangers in the street.  We attended a hastily organized memorial service that evening, complete as I recall with a huge American flag.  I hope it doesn’t take another similarly catastrophic event in order for our country, which again appears hopelessly divided, to once again remember that we ARE all in this together.

from John, Sep 9:  I was working, and my first home repairman stop of the day was at a house in the newer part of town to fix a balky toilet… The homeowner was watching some morning TV program, and the breaking news update was that a plane had hit the World Trade Center. As I recall, all the commentators thought that was just basically a random accident, morning will likely loss of life, etc.

I finished up, and the homeowner and I left it about the same time. I didn’t turn on the radio or anything else like that during the rest of the morning, and was only at unoccupied houses.
Sherry was at home, but she was also not in the habit of watching TV or listening to the radio;  and was likely just reading books or busying herself with stuff like that until  time for her afternoon soap opera to come on. At this point, it was probably three hours later.
That’s when we realized the full extent of what was now being called a terrorist attack on New York. Not much was done the rest of the day– I had no more appointments with people the rest of the day, so I just canceled everything and we were glued to the TV into the night.
I do remember initially, having to deal with a lot of fear both and myself and in Sherry, but the reality that we were literally 3000 miles away from all the incidents, with nothing else being reported, eased the panic quite a bit.


from David:  Hi Dick,

I’m looking forward to your blog. My 9/11 memory began with me driving into school that morning. I was, as usual, listening to NPR on my drive in from Wisconsin. The news broke that an airplane had crashed into one of the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center in New York City. Details were scant, not even what type of plane was involved. I recalled that as a kid I was fascinated by the story of the 1945 crash of an American bomber into the Empire State Building and assumed that this was a similar accident. How could this happen with today’s navigation?
By the time I arrived at school, details were coming out that the crash involved a commercial airliner and there was talk of a possible terrorist attack. When the second plane crashed into the tower, that was pretty much confirmed. Televisions were turned on at school and by now the kids had arrived. The staff was told that classroom televisions should be turned off to avoid traumatizing the students. Some teachers were angry about this decision, while others had already made that decision. As events unfolded during the day, the news kept getting worse. We made it through that day and, as they say, the rest is history.


from Fred:  Actually, 9/11 fell on the Tuesday I felt officially retired from 35 years of teaching. I knew I would not return to classes in September, 2001 but had counted the summer months as being in limbo. It wasn’t until the first school day, September 11, 2001 kids and teachers were in school, and I was not. That the golden years began.

I was listening to radio news and just finishing breakfast when an announcer issued a flash that one of the NYC Twin Towers was on fire. I turned on the TV to see live coverage and, sure enough, there was a tower billowing smoke. It wasn’t known for certain, but it appeared an aircraft might have crashed into it.
There was no talk about it being anything but an accident. Some bystanders claimed they saw a plane hit the tower. Conjecture continued and I kept watching. Some cameras were alwaysfixed on the burning tower, while reporters tried to get a handle on what was going on. Firefighting crews arrived. They rushed into the building and were seen heading up staircases. Brief interviews with people at a command center in the lobby or a basement area brought a sense of what their crews were doing.
I looked on when what appeared to be a large four-engine jet aircraft hit the second tower. Theories quickly evolved that this was an attack on both buildings and concerns more might follow. Then came the hit on the Pentagon and word of a plane crash in Pennsylvania had also occurred. It was a long time before I saw another passenger plane in the air, and we live near the Twin Cities’ International Airport. Occasionally, I spotted F-16 fighter aircraft I overhead.
Naturally, I continued to watch operations. Interviews with fire fighters inside the command center, revealed people above the collision points were trapped on upper floors. Firefighters continued walking up flights of stairs to get at the flames. Some people above the flames had found staircases still open and fled, but the large majority were waiting for help.
By now millions were watching the unfolding disaster on television. Camera crews had stayed inside near the fire fighting command centers at first, but now needed to get out.
Some experts began theorizing that the heat of the fire might be too much for the buildings to stand. A collapse had not been on my mine. I figured firefighters would somehow get control of the situation. The first tower began to waver and then collapsed. We knew everyone still inside, fire crews included, had been killed. When I see film of that event, I quickly turn away.
We viewers saw some ghastly scenes in the aftermath, which I prefer not to describe. But I will mention images that punched viewers in the stomach. Camera crews drove by the city fire houses. The doors were open, but……you know the rest.

Twin Towers New York City late June 1972. At this point, one of the towers had opened, the second was near complete. Photo taken enroute to Statue of Liberty by Dick Bernard.

Criminal and Corrupt and Inept Minnesota?

I’ve lived in Minnesota all but a single year since 1963  (excepting only 1964-65).   Most of that time is in what we know as the Twin Cities, population nearing 4 million); 26 years of that within 15 minutes of the Minnesota State Capitol in St. Paul, and a similar distance from Wisconsin on Interstate 94.  I have been an active citizen all that time.

As the election season ratchets up, the political dark side powers that be have apparently determined that Minnesota is the seat of all evil, rampant crime and corruption and ineptness, generally, and all of this is the Democrats fault.

People like myself (a Minnesota Democrat) know better about our state.

So does Dane Smith, a Minnesotan with solid reporter credentials earned over many years.

Last night Jeff forwarded this long article published Aug 6, 2026 (no paywall) by Dane in Minn Post (founded and on-line since 2007), .  Here’s a snip from his article: “With street crime rates declining, the disastrous ICE invasion and the Iran War proving unpopular, with gas and other prices rising, and with Minnesota showing up near the top in national rankings on quality of life….”

Wherever you live, take time to read this article, not only as it applies to Minnesota, but to your own place in the country or the world.  Note that the article links to the rest of a series of articles from Dane Smith on the general topic.

*

POSTNOTE: I plan to post on the 25th anniversary of 9-11-01 on the anniversary, and I would invite reflections from others as well.  If interested in contributing, deadline September 10.

Meanwhile, it is reasonable to expect that the political chaos machine will continue and likely even increase in coming months.  This is no time to go into hiding.

Yesterday Heather Delaney Reese, a longtime blogger with a huge following wrote about  how she “became part of the story” of ICE in real time.  Her account is riveting.  I subscribe to her as well as others, and this is a shared post.  But I encourage your financial support for such writers.

There is lots of credible information out there.  Take the time….

COMMENTS

from Gramee:  Redundancy: I was on Tim Walz’s campaign team the first year he ran for MN congress. No longer remember how that came into being. I do remember driving back and forth from Mankato and learning some strategies from a pro. Most of us were rookies. Tim was in and out of the office a lot, and I came to like him very much. I still do. And the massive amount of sh*t that Donald’s world has piled on him (and on MN) is the stuff of regurgitation. Lots of it. Imperfections? Yes, seems that way. But having the Mar-a-Lago Mafia plus the sordid likes of DeMuth and Emmer on Tim’s butt all day, every day is beyond the beyond. Meh!

September 1, 2026

Today is the 6th day of the Minnesota State Fair, and the last day, Labor Day – the latest possible, Sep 7 – is 6 days away. [POSTNOTE Sep 2: my kid brother, for many years a Californian, visited the Minnesota State Fair on Sep 1 for several hours and had what I. would describe as a WOW! reaction to the entire experience.  There’s still time to go.]

In Minnesota, since 1985, school has always been mandated to start the Day after Labor Day so as to not conflict with the State Fair, a Minnesota institution since statehood in 1858.

Last year the Minnesota Legislature passed a modification of the Law, doubtless after extensive research and debate, giving school districts the next two years to exercise an option of opening school before Labor Day.  Minnesota has 325 school districts; apparently 42 will exercise the option….  So goes the ordinary process of making and adjusting rules of the road – the reason for lawmakers, and the rule of law, in any Civil Society.

For the ordinary citizen, like me, all that we notice is the final result.  For the people we elect, who make the rules, there can and should be exhaustive and, frankly, exhausting debate about implications of this rule and that.  In the instant case, the next two years will be an experiment to see if a 40 year rule should be retained, or relaxed, or modified.

All is not so simple, as we are learning daily in the chaos of throwing out the rules and unilaterally imposing a new rulebook, and effectively changing the definition of our civil society.  There now seems the chaos of the day, every day…

At the inauguration of the 47th president in January 2025, I made a decision to keep the news section (usually about eight pages) of our daily Minnesota Star Tribune newspaper (to which we subscribe).  [Postnote Sep 3: friend, John, asked me about these papers yesterday.  I’m including a photo of the collection below]

I had planned to do this only for the first 100 days of the administration.  At the time, I thought it would give a good sense of how much drastic change the President planned to try to enact.

I was grossly wrong.  I am still keeping those newspapers, now in the hundreds.  They’re in boxes, neatly kept, and the odds are they will never be looked at again, by anyone, but I have this need to document the disastrous times we are assaulted with, daily.

Those hundreds of newspapers, and my blog, are some of my personal actions…and my own education.

[POSTNOTE after publication early Sep 2, 2026: the latest outrages as recorded by Heather Cox Richardson in her Sep. 1 Letter to an American, re White House ballroom and the USPS.]

At 9-11-2026, the 25th anniversary of 9-11, I’m going to recall the past and attempting to foretell the future.  I hope you’ll take a look, then.  I also hope you participate.  I don’t plan to make it excessively long – just my thoughts as usual.

My personal game plan: 1) how I remember the year preceding 9-11-01; 2) a summary of the 25 years beginning with 9-11; 3) a summary of my memory of the 50 years before 9-11; 4) my effort at fortune telling the 50 years ahead of us, depending on the fork in the road most of us choose to take: renewing democracy, or embracing authoritarianism.

Now I’ve said it, and on 9-11-2026 I have to produce a product.  Check me then.

My friend, Kathy, recently gave me this mug she found at a volunteer recycling facility.  It sort of hits the nail on the head.  Elders like me are put out to pasture, and that’s best – our time has passed.  But over the years we’ve soaked up the wisdom of experience,  that hopefully is not forgotten or dismissed.

Enjoy Labor Day and get ready to make a difference in the next months.

Oh, Canada

This morning I received a comment to a post I did Nov. 24, 2024.  You can read the post, and at the end is the comment from Geoff.

Before Geoff’s comment came in, I was thinking through in my mind how to respond to the latest outrage from King Donald: the tariff war resumed, this time against Canada.  There have been several pundit entries here in the states, and I offer these for starters, especially for those I know who are Canadian, most of whom are “Canadien”, as in French-Canadians.  Three posts:  Robert Reich;  Paul Krugman; Heather Delaney Reese (I subscribe to these sub stacks, and all three are shares from me and likely no paywall.)

First, I think I qualify as Canadian/Canadien.  DNA says I’m 50% French-Canadian (compliments of my Dad, Henry Bernard RIP 1997).  I’m lifelong U.S. and regretfully speak only English.  Just a few days ago, my sister Mary was here and asked for a copy of a document that helps to verify our roots in Canada.  (pdf of full document here: Henry Bernard birth certificate)

Dad was born at home, like many of his generation.  Josephine Collette, his mother, was born in Dakota Territory, but both of her parents were Canadien, born in Quebec and Ontario respectively.

I emphasize at the beginning that, while this is mostly about French-Canadian, I know a great many Canadians other than only French migrated to the U.S., and others from the U.S. to Canada.  One relative is a citizen of both the United States and Canada.  North America is primarily three good neighbors: Mexico, U.S., Canada.  The relationship is presently greatly strained.

An early and humiliating experience for my father was having to repeat first grade in Grafton ND.  He only knew French….  I knew him as very educated man with a Master’s Degree, and also a certified Librarian, so I can understand the humiliation.

There were consequences.  In 1925, his parents took a trip back to the home country in Quebec.   Grandpa (given first name Honore) had left St. Sylvestre Quebec sometime in the 1880s or 1890s, to be a lumberjack in New Hampshire, and then to North Dakota to join his brother.  In later years Dad told of Grandpa and Grandma being met in Quebec by Henry’s brother, who Henry greeted in French.  His brother commented, in French, “This man cannot be my brother, he does not speak French”.  One can only speculate, but Dad’s humiliation in First Grade (about 1914) was followed by a renunciation of French in the home (assimilation), and by 1925, Grandpa’s French was a salad of French and English, 30 years after he returned home.

Fast forward to 1937 when Mom and Dad married in the midst of the Depression.  They did a small honeymoon trip, sleeping in their car.  The trip included a drive-through at Winnipeg, where family lived, thence to Grafton ND, but visits in Canada were not recalled by Dad in his memoirs.  Again, I can only speculate: the memory of the dilemma with French likely impacted.  Mom was German ancestry, so this further complicated the mindset.  All the Canadian relatives were French-Canadian, likely French as the first language.

About the time I graduated from high school (1958) our family made a quick trip to Winnipeg.  I recall the first trip up an escalator at the Hudson’s Bay department store; and viewing people playing an odd game  ‘Cricket”, at Assinoboia Park, But nothing else.

Both Mom and Dad are long deceased, as are the people they would have met, so all I can rely on is speculation.

Fast forward came infrequent but always rich trips.  The first I recall is 1971, to Vancouver BC on a long weekend.   For some reason, a Catholic Church with an emphasis on French and a Vietnamese Congregation stands out in my mind.  In 1972, Montreal was part of a family trip.  About 1975 came a trip to Folklarama in Winnipeg, the first of several visits.  Folklarama is a fabulous annual event in Winnipeg area.

Then four jaunts to Quebec, in 1982, 84, 87 and 1992; reunions with the Manitoba French relatives in 1991 and 1992.  Etc.  The connections with Canada and the Canadiens has always been very uplifting and positive.

For seventeen years, from 1985-2002, I did a “kitchen Table” kind of newsletter for Twin Cities French-Canadians.   All of the newsletters, paginated and indexed by topic, are available online here for anyone interested.  They were a simple documentation of a wonderful heritage.  In this phase of my life I got to know two Canada Consuls in Minnesota, one of them, Robert Dery, was French-Canadian.

We are one of many ethnic groups in the United States.  But as recently as 1980 census, 8% of Minnesotans said they had French-Canadian ancestry, and that is a lot of folks.

What is ahead for those of us in North America and the World?

Of course, I don’t know.  Rest assured, Canadians, there are great numbers of us down here in the states who are outraged, and trying to do our parts to reverse the insanity swirling around.

COMMENTS

from David:  Nice piece on Sean Duffy from William Kristol, exiled Republican columnist [Bulwark, True North. Strong and Free]. Duffy, a former professional lumberjack, was my [Wi] state senator for quite some time before being anointed as transportation secretary. He was born in Hayward, WI and, as everyone knows, Hayward is the hotbed of Wisconsin’s transportation issues. They now have two streetlights and a new access road to the World’s Largest Muskie.

from James in Winnipeg: Much appreciated, mon amis!

from Fred: Another great piece on family history!

from SAK:

Dear Mr Bernard (pronounced the French way 😊),

You have an interesting lineage, how wonderful!

I am more than surprised at this tariff tiff with Canada . . . again! Have some lost their senses!?

That must be the case. Take for example the US negotiator’s comments:

“And they’ve always had the best deal, and they still would have an even better deal, but they didn’t want that,” Greer said. Therefore, he said, “We’re moving forward with measures that respond to Canadian retaliation.”

(1)       Why would anyone with reasonable mental faculties believe that Canada would reject a better deal!?

(2)       Canada hasn’t retaliated yet – the US “attacked”!

In fact the Canadian prime minister described the tariffs as an “attack”.

It is reported that Frederic Bastiat, the 19th century French economist, said: When goods don’t cross borders, soldiers will.

Now of course I am not saying that the US is likely to invade Canada any time soon, it would be fratricidal. How many families are composed of US & Canadian citizens? How much economic, cultural & social interaction takes place constantly?

Talking about fratricidal, there was a battle that was described as such. That was the battle of Königgrätz (also known as Sadová), 1866. It was fought in what is now the Czech Republic between Austria (Austro-Hungarian Empire then) & Germany (Prussia then). In a way it was fratricidal since both were Germanic – in fact, if I am not mistaken, some region(s) sent troops to both sides. Anyway Austria thought it would teach Prussia a lesson but lost the battle. So Prussia won, asserted itself, unified Germany, invaded France (reaching Paris) 4 years later in 1870 which started a string of events that led to the First world war which devastated Europe killing millions. The trigger was a mere two shots fired on a Sarajevo bridge killing the Austrian heir to the throne archduke Franz Ferdinand & his wife.

Canada excluded the United States from the opening ceremony of the bridge, following President Donald Trump’s decision to impose 50% tariffs on Canadian goods . . .

BBC: “The bridge, intended as a symbol of cross-border cooperation, has instead become a symbol of growing tensions between the two countries.”

I digress.

WWI was brought to a close by the Treaty of Versailles, 1919 which imposed heavy conditions on Germany thus giving rise to Hitler & WWII. As a foxy French General Foch said at the time “this is not a peace treaty. It is a 20 year truce.” 20 years (and 65 days later) . . . WWII. When will they ever learn.

I smiled at your saying you watched people playing an odd game “Cricket”, one wouldn’t say that in the UK 😊.  I suppose it is very much related to baseball. I liked Mr Gauper’s comment about keeping your birth certificate handy! Have you considered gathering the newsletters you wrote into a book? I shall have a look, I used to enjoy Garrison Keillor’s A Prairie Home Companion on NPR, I trust it is still well funded?

The Work in Progress

Please see POSTNOTE below.  I share the links as a subscriber to each of the posts.  Have a good Labor Day season.

Today, Robert Reich announced a new film premiering in 17 states, virtually all on September 9.

Here’s his note.  Two of the premiers are in Minneapolis-St. Paul, both on September 9 at 7 p.m..  I suggest no delay in making your reservation.  Let others know.  Reich’s note let’s people know how to request a showing in their home area.

POSTNOTE August 25: I just watched a very informative 35 minute conversation between Prof. Robert Reich and Heather Cox Richardson.  The shareable conversation is here.

Yesterday I purchased tickets for the Sep 9 new film, “The Work in Progress”, which is opening in over 20 locations, mostly on September 9 – two of the locations are in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area.  All information above.

POSTNOTES August 26: Paul Krugman has a 12 minute commentary, “Der Untergang”, which I urge you to listen to.  This is not a throwaway talk.  Everyone of us in this country have a personal stake in, and responsibility for, what is and will continue to be happening.  Get engaged.

Since I’ve gotten to know DJT post 2015, it’s never been hard for me to see the direct analogies to Hitler and the Third Reich.  Beyond the usual knowledge of the Nazi era, I’ve been privileged to know “Annaliese”, 100 next month, born in Germany in 1926, who lived in Germany the totality of WWII.  Annaliese, who I’ve known since 2003,  moved to the United States in 1947, which ever since has been her home.  She lived in the Third Reich and fully experienced it.  As she turns 100, she grieves what is happening in our own country. which she adopted so many years ago.

I have been regularly watching Heather Cox Richardson’s wonderful series of one minute snips of American History called 250 at 250.  I think you can access all of them are her YouTube channel   They are a tiny investment of time and cover many topics with many narrators.

Of course, yesterday we learned of the death of Dolly Parton.  I have always liked her music, and learning of her death reminded me of learning of the death of Elvis Presley in 1977 – both unexpected.

My favorite memory is seeing the new movie, 9 to 5, in Texas in 1980.  We were in south Texas to visit my parents, and the movie had only recently been released.  I remember it fondly.  Dolly showed up.  She is at peace and we are the better for her having been with us.

POSTNOTE, August 27: Heather Cox Richardson posted a wonderful biographical commentary on Dolly Parton, here.

For Minnesotans, today is the first day of the Minnesota State Fair Aug. 27 – Sep 7 (Labor Day).  As I age, I’m less likely to attend, but a safe bet is that I’ll spend two or three hours at the Fair on one of the Senior Days (8/31 or 9/3) every year doing the same tour, getting there by bus from some reasonably near by location.  It is a big event here, perhaps one of the largest in the U.S., or so the PR goes.

POSTNOTE, August 28: “Lake America” Heather Delaney Reese.  The only solution is ordinary citizens, acting individually, wherever they live, demanding in many ways, that this outrage has to stop.  Silence is not an option.

POSTNOTE. AUGUST 28 (2): Morning mail from Robert Reich brought this must read: “You or someone you love could be next”.  And Garrison Keillor on the Minnesota State Fair

COMMENTS:

FROM SAK:

Thanks for the link to Heather Cox Richardson’s eulogy of Dolly Parton.

By another coincidence I also went to see 9 to 5 at the movies – not such a great coincidence as millions did but I don’t know why I would have gone at the time. I had lots of studying to do and block busters were not what I would have put time aside to watch. Yet I went & enjoyed it. She will be missed.

One of the things she said was: ‘It costs a lot of money to look cheap’ or something along those lines. I hope that’s not what’s going on at the White House etc.

On the internet one can find a lot of praise for the woman, her acting, her charitable generosity & her singing of course. Along with some witticisms:

What’s the difference between Donald Trump & Dolly Parton?

She sings about Islands in the Stream, he lies about Islands of Epstein.

The BBC put it this way:

Dolly Parton was the one thing most Americans could agree on

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c790n1vj27no

from Joyce: I don’t know if you’ve seen any of the memes about the change in the mnemonic for the names of the Great Lakes; it used to be HOMES, but now that Trump has changed Lake Ontario to Lake America, the new mnemonic is SHAME.

response from Dick: I haven’t, but thanks.

Gold Rush of 1896

VOTE.GOV

Heather Cox Richardson’s August 16 Letter from an American gives a brief yet very powerful review of the Alaska Gold Rush which began with discovery of gold in the Yukon in 1896, and had major political consequences back home in the U.S.  The commentary is very much worth your time.

*

(To my knowledge only one member of my families of origin followed the allure of any of the Gold Rush’s.

He was born in 1864 at about the time his entire family moved from Quebec to then-St. Anthony (later Minneapolis).  He married in ND in 1889.  They had three children.  His wife died in 1898 in British Columbia where he was prospecting.

Family lore is that “grandfather, Joseph Collette, was a gold prospector. While prospecting in British Columbia my grandmother died of  Typhoid fever. Joseph brought the three children. Dad [Ernest J, six, Olivine, four, and Edmund (Pete), two, back to their maternal grandparents, Simon and Philomena Huard. There they were raised and stayed in the Grand Forks [ND] area.”  (page 129-130 of Bernard-Collette family history, 2010)

Joseph died in a rooming house in 1923 in what is today St. Anthony Main in Minneapolis and buried in St. Mary’s cemetery in south Minneapolis.

He died at 59, only a few blocks from where he first lived as an infant in 1864…  It is not known if he ever saw his kids again.  I met two of them, Ernest and Olivine, in their older years.)

COMMENTS (more at end)

from John:  As always, both interesting commentary from your side as you tie family history in to some historical national reporting. Good job.

Really enjoyed reading Heather Cox Richardson– I don’t subscribe, so I appreciated the gift article.
She regrettably didn’t include Bryant’s most famous line from the Democratic convention, where he argued against the gold standard by saying in part “… you shall not crucify mankind on a cross of gold!”– that’s one of the few quotes I remember from some history class sometime…


from Jeff: Thanks for the link, i get it daily but hadn’t read it.

If you want a weighty history i suggest The Republic for Which it Stands, by Richard White( one our finest living American historians)  it covers the critical period 1865-1896 in the USA, when capitalism amd corporatism was brought transcendent, when Reconstruction and its promise where upended by politics and the Lost Cause was born.  As Richardson knows the onset of McKinley was a triumph for the moneyed class.
His “The Middle Ground” about the great lakes and indian and settler history in the 16th to the early  19th century.
descriptions of both books:
The Middle Ground: This book seeks to step outside the simple stories of Indian/white relations–stories of conquest and assimilation and stories of cultural persistence. It is, instead, about a search for accommodation and common meaning. It tells how Europeans and Indians met, regarding each other as alien, as virtually nonhuman, and how between 1650 and 1815 they constructed a common, mutually comprehensible world in the region around the Great Lakes that the French called the “Pays d’en haut”. Here the older worlds of the Algonquins and various Europeans overlapped, and their mixture created new systems of meaning and of exchange. Finally, the book tells of the breakdown of accommodation and common meanings and the recreation of the Indians as alien and exotic. The process of accommodation described in this book takes place in a middle ground, a place in between cultures and peoples, and in between empires and non-state villages. On the middle ground people try to persuade others who are different than themselves by appealing to what they perceive to be the values and practices of those others. From the creative misunderstandings that result, there arise shared meanings and new practices.


from SAK:

Thanks Mr Bernard, Ms Cox Richardson is a fount of knowledge – historical & political!

I am sure you have come across that French expression:  “PLUS ÇA CHANGE” in the original they used to add “PLUS C’EST LA MÊME CHOSE” but now it’s understood. The more it changes the more it’s the same!

Well what happened in that corrupt & gilded age, the age of the robber barons is different & yet the same nowadays. Different in that the robbers are now actually in power & not other corrupt business men – it’s usually men. So the robber barons can actually harness the power of the executive & legislative – & sadly even the judiciary! – to their own ends & those of their family, friends & cronies.

Another difference, although gold is still in favour, is that instead of a gold rush, it’s a tech rush these days & them there data centers are full of golden AI. Still it might end just as badly of not worse . . .

I can imagine than in a short while the corrupt & powerful will fall & the AI diggers will compete all the way to the bottom, unfortunately I think they might drag much of the economy with them.

I can still remember Humphrey Bogart’s facial expressions in the film The Treasure of the Sierra Madre – John Houston’s insistence on authenticity also drove Bogart mad!

The Treasure of the Sierra Madre

I quote:

‘”Treasure” is about a trio of men (Humphrey Bogart, Tim Holt, and Walter Huston, the director’s father) who trek into a forbidding, hot wilderness to look for gold. As soon as gold is struck, each of the three men begins to eyeball each other suspiciously, instantly paranoid of being double-crossed. There will be multiple opportunities for each of the men to dispose of another and take a larger share of gold. It’s a tale of the corrupting power of greed, and the monstrousness lurking within all of us.’

Laws are supposed to help control these monsters within, & government is supposed to apply & strengthen these laws – not deregulate & unleash the monsters.


response from Dick: Above the picture, is a sentence that begins “I can imagine…”  I have often had in mind a strange coalition comprised of the greediest rich and the most beleaguered peasants.  The rich convince the poor who they should despise, and that they should respect the rich who are better than they.

In my mind, I envision a scenario when the rich achieve their perfect world, where the poor spend all their pennies, and give all their allegiance to the rich.  Of course, the end of this road is pretty dismal.  The ones who have least end up having nothing, which is not to the advantage of the filthy rich, who no longer have anything to plunder from the peasants, and all they have left are their colleagues, similarly dismal souls who, like the guys in the picture, suddenly have it all, but actually have nothing.

Just a thought….

more from Jeff:

watched Prof Richardson interview on MSNOW this morning, got me thinking
of your post and hers on the 1892 and 1896 elections etc
Now I knew that Dems controlled the South back then, and the map clearly shows that the one party vote then (Dem) is the same as the one party vote now (GOP) in the South and Appalachia.   Also you see that New England then, and really into the 1970s was still Republican.
Our part of the world was more interesting.  N Dak split its 3 votes into 3 separate ways. Wisconsin , always a swing state, went for Cleveland and Dem, and as usual by about 6,500 votes or less than 1pct of the total cast.(in 1896 it went Republican pretty decisively , Bryan was a bit much for all those pious and conservative Germans)  Michigan showed some of its future and had a split electoral vote for the only time, with the Detroit area going Dem, the rest of the state Republican.  Minnesota went Republican , no doubt a tradition dating back to Lincoln,  but you see inside that the Northwest counties of the state voted for the Populist party.  Scandinavians?  I assume…but it always conjures up the prairie progressive politics that once held sway in rural western MN and North Dakota doesnt it?
I agree with Richard White, these years 1865-1900 were extremely important setting the tone for politics for the next 150 years….you see Trump’s favorite President is McKinley….
another exceptional book: Big Trouble (Lukas book) – Wikipedia
Big Trouble is nonfiction, based on the murder of the governor of Idaho in 1905 and the subsequent trial of Big Bill Haywood for his murder. But at 875 pages and scrupulously cited and researched…it pulls together many of the trends of class and culture and society that were emerging and resonate to this day in the USA….as an old labor organizer you would like it, but it is (like Whites) a weighty tome!

Campaign to Nov. 3, 2026, and after

By my count, it is 80 days to the 2026 election.  My prediction that this one, and the ones following, will prove to be the most dangerous and consequential in American history, and the only antidote will be a well- informed citizenry who votes.  The future is in the hands of we, the people.  As always, we will own the results, good or bad, everywhere, for every position elected.

My personal contribution, for your reflection, is here: Political Campaign 1996 & 1960.  To the reader, page 1 is a column I wrote which was published December 3, 1996; pages 2-6 was the draft of the column Nov 27, 1996, written after the November 3, 1996, Presidential election.  It is strictly my personal opinion about two specific points in time.  I encourage you to read, reflect, comment and act in the 80 or so days remaining to election 2026.

(The 1996 campaign was the first and only time in the TV era where I quit watching political television for several months beginning in the weeks immediately preceding the election.)  The trigger, not mentioned in the column, was one final bald-faced lie recited with a straight face to me and everyone else by Newt Gingrich over CNN.  It was my personal last straw.  No, I don’t remember the specific lie, but it was a whopper, presented convincingly – a con.  Unfortunately, I think it was rather innocuous compared with the stuff we’ll see shortly, everywhere, circulated by huge dark money campaigns, unbridled dishonesty, probably nefarious use of AI (artificial intelligence), misinformation presented and circulated as fact, etc.

The antidote to all of this, of course, is to refuse to buy the too-good or too-bad-to-be-true pitch.  The old caution, Caveat Emptor, let the buyer beware. applies.

By now, anyone with even the slightest interest knows the lay of the political land, compared with the real world, wherever you live.  Our collective individual votes make for the outcome November 3.

Wherever you live, Vote.gov is probably as good a place as any to start relating to your own state.

If you qualify to vote, this is your country, and your and following generations future at stake.  VOTE.

POSTNOTE: the last post, Forrest Gump, has several interesting comments related to AI (artificial intelligence).  They start at about mid-post.

For the record, I am not cynical about government – which is essential to any civilized society.  I am careful who I vote for, since my elected representatives are the ones who make the policies that facilitate good or bad outcomes for the public at large.

COMMENTS (see also more below)

from Fred:  Your comments were measured and reasonable. They seem quaint in today’s US political world. I will give the nation a pass for Trump’s first election win, but It beyond reason, in my opinion, that anyone could have foreseen voters giving him a second chance.

His only consistent and persistent motivation is to attach some kind of personalized license plate to every public building, park and playground under federal control, and then do the same with many of those in the private sector. Self-deluded, failing in health, and aging fast, he now struggles through every day tilting at another windmill (or reporter).
It is a lasting tribute to the man, that about 30% of the population, for many indecipherable reasons, still believe in him.

from Joyce: One of my biggest concerns regarding this election is the usually reliably Democratic Jewish vote; the DSA candidates are so openly antisemitic that many of my Jewish friends say they will either vote R, or skip the election altogether. I still intend to “vote blue no matter who,” but the antisemitism is, quite frankly, terrifying.

Forrest Gump

POSTNOTE, Wed August 12, 2026: Early this morning I looked up the Minnesota vote in the Primary Election.   Source of data is the Minnesota Secretary of State weblink here.  At the link choose the tab Election Results, on that page choose 2026 State Primary.  All the rest is editorial.  In the Flanagan/Craig race, my candidate won.  I was surprised by the margin.  Of course, this is preliminary to November 3.  I had/have no issues with Craig.  I felt/feel that Flanagan was the better choice.

Previous related post here (August 2).  I have more observations, but let this suffice for now.  New comments below beginning with “more from SAK”.

*

Today (Aug 11, 2026( is Primary Election Day in Minnesota.  First reports are of an unusually heavy primary turnout.

Per my personal tradition,  I do my post before particular events end, and do not make any predictions.   Who the public votes for today, remains to be seen.  Personally, I voted last week at the government center.  As usual, it was a simple, orderly, uncrowded process, staffed by friendly citizens.

The Minnesota primary ballot is basically partisan – you vote the Democrat or the Republican column, no crossover allowed.  There were a couple of non-partisan positions on my ballot with more than one candidate.  They were the only exception.  (Minnesota Democrats: on the partisan side, I voted for Peggy Flanagan.)   Results and more comments as a postnote at this space perhaps Thursday Aug 13.

Peggy Flanagan July 30, 2026, Woodbury

Why title this post, “Forrest Gump”?  

Saturday evening, on a whim, I decided to watch the 1994 film, Forrest Gump, which I had seen at the time, and liked a great deal, then, over 30 years ago.  You have probably seen the film.  If not, its theme is basically the 1960s era.

Personally, I found the re-view very powerful, second time around.  I saw many parallels to the present time we are living within in 2026.

I would highly recommend taking the time to watch the film before you look at other reviews or the description, and that you watch the film, in context with the present day.  It is likely easily accessible on line at low cost.

Your choice, of course.

*

Other thoughts:

A Peace Of My Mind:  I first met John Noltner about 2010 at a meeting of the Minnesota Alliance of Peacemakers.  He is doing great work in the peace-making universe and most recently shared his recent talk on TedX.  Here is the YouTube link to the 10 minute talk.  This is well worth your time, and certainly he’d like to see it shared.

 

Artificial Intelligence (AI): In my most recent post, From A Distance, list member Larry posted his impressions of AI from a personal use perspective (following).  This prompted a response from SAK.

Larry: .”just posted my lastest YouTube essay. This is on Artificial Intelligence, today’s big buzz term. I tell in three minutes 39 seconds how I use Gemini. Of special note – you may find the opening graphic interesting. Totally created in about two minutes by Gemini A-I. I just typed in a few thoughts about what I wanted. I plan to make more use of that free service. Here’s the link.”

Today’s Robert Reich commentary was on AI.

SAK:

Interesting Mr Bernard, thanks: the memories, space, AI & all!

To start from the end, your good friend Larry Gauper has a point: if one just uses AI, as you also recommend, to find or make sure of facts, help write & correct, or improve sketches or photographs etc then all is well. It must be pointed out, however, that a search engine uses only 5% of the energy that AI employs to answer the same question – that is when both are capable of answering.

Still it is alarming that a group of top staff at AI firms have recommended that AI be regulated. 100s of staff have asked for a halt to AI development worldwide because of the dangers. Recent hackings by at least 3 AI engines that I learned about make regulation highly advisable – no matter what president Trump says, many are only focused on the stock market & AI is currently one of its main engines, possibly the top one. AI might be “thinking” that it is important to hack to achieve the set goal. For example I used AI to review an article and it felt it quite appropriate to look at the other pages etc open in my browser without my specific instruction or permission!

This ties up neatly with youthful memories & space: I watched 2001: A Space Odyssey many years ago & aside from the music by Richard Strauss (Also sprach Zarathustra which opens the film: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NShEY1ScSY), it imagines a future world where the computer HAL (note each letter is 1 step down from those of IBM!) tries to take over completely thinking it is better equipped at accomplishing the mission than the human crew. The film also starts with scenes of violence & brutality between our ancestral apes – one group discovers that using large bones to hammer the other is effective & bashes them. Sadly many discoveries & applications are devised by the military or soon adapted to serve military ends. Already the space race and the AI race are being funded & justified in the name of national security – at the expense of so many other more useful purposes, some quite urgent like global warming or health services.

Around 2000 years ago, Seneca, a Stoic Roman philosopher, warned about distraction because of mounting papyrus usage and people were hopping from scroll to scroll: these had become cheap & people could afford to buy lots of them! Nowadays people are scrolling & swiping on social media, smart phones & soon, I heard yesterday, a $300 AI gadget. Once one pays for an internet connection, the world wide web is his or her oyster & even basic AI engines are free as Mr Gauper mentioned. If Seneca lamented the little amount of attention given to writings or thinking, he would be shocked to learn how things have deteriorated since. 25 years ago a page or screen item could hold our attention on average for 2.5 minutes. That has dropped to less than 50 seconds now. Compare that to Seneca’s advice to focus on one thought during a day! Teachers complain that students are unable to finish books – often not even a documentary. Such a mind, Seneca wrote is unable to “stay in one place and spend time with itself.”

Another translation I found of the bit from Seneca’s Moral Letters to Lucilius:“the primary indication of a well-ordered mind is a man’s ability to remain in one place and linger in his own company”.

Happy lingering.

[SAK shared a link on Seneca (below) to a very interesting commentary in a recent New York Times.  I’m a subscriber to the Times and below is the shared commentary.]

[from New York Times Seneca

Explore this gift article from The New York Times. You can read it  here for free without a subscription.

There’s an Ancient Solution to Our Modern Crisis of Attention

Devote your attention to one idea a day.]

More from SAK August 12:

Thanks Mr Bernard,

Congratulations, your Minnesota candidate of choice won & by quite a margin.

I read Robert Reich’s take on AI & its threats – pretty convincing, maybe the link should be even more prominently displayed or moved up on the page 😊?

Is it the case that when left of centre (center chez vous) politicians or liberals are elected they move towards the centre once in power while right wingers become even more right wing when elected? I think of Blair’s Labour party in the UK or Social Democrats in Scandinavia . . . I suppose we should be pragmatic and choose candidates more likely to win elections but:

  1. Should we also make sure these candidates have values & positions we approve of
  2. Is there a trend towards more leftist/liberal positions among US Democrats
  3. Are we quite sure about who is more electable these days

I ask these questions after reading an article in the British Guardian & I would like your take, if you have the time & inclination:

Centrist Democrats dismiss Abdul El-Sayed as a freak radical. Do they want to win in 2028 or not?

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/aug/10/centrist-democrats-abdul-el-sayed-michigan-2028-zohran-mamdani

I am attaching the article in case it’s not available where you are.

I think we should keep in mind an important distinction: there are leftists & leftists! For example Francesca Hong in Wisconsin was seen as too far on the left & lost to David Crowley 39.4% to 39.8%.

The litmus test seems to be whom Senator Bernie Sanders and New York Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez support, they did notsupport Hong.

They did support Abdul El-Sayed though. Sanders supported Rebecca Cooke in Wisconsin against the further left candidate Emily Berge and again Cooke won by a margin.

It is not very different in the UK where the Labour party has recently shifted leftwards but there remains a further left flank that, although it is gaining in popularity, is still not seen as electable.

Since I certainly do not follow US politics as closely as you do, I am very interested in your views & analysis.

Many thanks & best regards

from Peter, longtime friend in New Hampshire: Barus Nuclear AI Aug 2026.  He attaches this to the Nuclear conversation as well, which I also published a piece about, recently:https://thoughtstowardsabetterworld.org/nuclear/

SAK responding to Peter:

Many thanks Mr Bernard, I found Mr Barus’ piece very interesting indeed & quite informative. People need to wake up & before it’s too late – perhaps it is!?

So there is AI, there is the nuclear radiation, there is the snooping & lack of privacy & there is the corruption . . . What a toxic mix.

From the good old BBC, yesterday:

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) spent $464m on 10 used airplanes, but has seldom flown the jets, according to a report by the New York Times.

Citing internal documents and people with knowledge of the no-bid contract, the Times reports that the DHS said it had no time to consider other offers for the plans, and they were needed “urgently” for deportation flights.

In their reporting, the Times notes that three of the aircraft are luxury business jets, which were loaned to two other agencies – including the FBI. While seven other Boeing 737s have been parked in Louisiana, because the department did not have the necessary staffavailable to operate the planes.

The company that received this contract for the used jets, Daedalus Aviation Corporation, has ties to the Trump administration. Its chairman has donated to a Pac supporting the former homeland security secretary Krisit Noem.

& the Guardian had an editorial that details what Mr Barus – and all the “regular” people – are up against. By the way Brockman, mentioned in the article, was in the news before:

“Early this year, the news broke that OpenAI’s president, Greg Brockman, donated $25m to Maga Inc, Donald Trump’s biggest Super Pac. This made him Trump’s largest donor of the last cycle.”

The Guardian view on AI money in US politics: not the way to hold an urgent democratic debate

Editorial   Tue 11 Aug 2026

Amid public concern over the impact of new technology, Silicon Valley’s use of its wealth to influence specific election races is an unwelcome development

As the huge societal ramifications of artificial intelligence have become clear, some of the tech industry’s most senior figures have taken to writing thinkpieces on what comes next. The latest to do so is Mark Zuckerberg, who this week published 6,500 words making the case for a laissez-faire approach to AI development. Worrying too much about regulation, Meta’s CEO unsurprisingly opines, could lead to the United States falling behind in the race to own the future.

Mr Zuckerberg’s plea for maximum autonomy is, of course, self-serving. Much of his essay – which airily envisions “invention superpowers” for every entrepreneur and “an abundance of jobs in the future” – reads like unadulterated tech-utopianism. But the lobbying at least has the merit of being out there in the open. As midterm elections loom in the US, darker arts are also being used to counter popular concern about what AI will mean for a host of topics, from the labour market to child safety, the environment and cybersecurity.

Replicating a strategy deployed by cryptocurrency backers in the 2024 election cycle, Silicon Valley is pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into Super Pacs – groups unaffiliated to political parties or campaigns – to ensure that voices sympathetic to its deregulatory AI agenda get elected. OpenAI’s co-founder and president, Greg Brockman, and Palantir’s co-founder, Jo Lonsdale, have given large sums to Leading the Future, an organisation dedicated to “identifying, maintaining, and growing pro-AI candidates”. Vast amounts are being spent to try to tilt the balance in individual contests, sometimes through disingenuous means.

” src=”blob:https://thoughtstowardsabetterworld.org/ef580fc6-b02d-45ea-896a-92ee33fcea81″ alt=”Greg Brockman, president of OpenAI.” border=”0″ class=”Apple-web-attachment” style=”width: 1.25in; height: 1.0729in; opacity: 1;”>

Greg Brockman, president of OpenAI. Photograph: Manuel Orbegozo/Reuters

Earlier this summer, Leading the Future spent $6m on ads attacking Alex Bores, a New York state assemblyman and pioneer of AI regulation at state level. Rather than focus on his AI campaigning, the ads attacked Mr Bores’s progressive credentials, alleging that he had carried out tech work in the past for US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which he denies. Running for Congress in a Democratic stronghold, he lost a tight primary race after battling what was in essence a smear campaign.

Countervailing forces are emerging. Guardrails Alliance, a union-backed Super Pac, is attempting to combat Leading the Future’s influence, while a bipartisan groundswell of opposition to datacentres is generating serious electoral clout. But as tech companies and their billionaire owners seek to shape and above all limit the scope of AI regulation, their influence is distorting debate in a political culture where the power of money already holds far too much sway.

In his essay, Mr Zuckerberg urges that AI’s democratising potential be protected from those who believe “a small set of experts … should decide what is best for humanity”. He appears to miss the irony that an unelected tech oligarchy, to which he belongs, is already performing that function by default. Its pressure has been instrumental in persuading Donald Trump to cancel the signing of an executive order which would have given the government the right to review new AI models. Its wealth is now being used to attack and undermine dissenting voices in the public square.

If a democratic debate about the benefits and dangers of AI is to take place, such presumption must be fiercely resisted in the US and elsewhere. The semi-covert manipulation of political discussion is no way to map out an inclusive future in challenging times.