Airplanes

Last Friday – three days ago – came the grounded air traffic crisis: planes not in the air for some unknown reason.

We don’t fly any more.  Last time we were in a plane was four years ago, enroute Nov. 10, 2022, to my sisters 80th birthday in upstate New York, plane change in New York City on a Wednesday mid-afternoon  (Nov 9, 2022 photo, photo by myself).  One family member is an airline pilot and had completed his flight some hours before the shutdown.  I don’t proclaim myself an expert on air transportation.  My personal opinion, which I added to my Friday post (third para), was based on nothing more than personal observations over the years.  I choose to leave it unedited.  The Richardson and Krugman commentaries which follow, both received this morning, add to the informed knowledge base.

Today’s column by Heather Cox Richardson sheds some light on the rhetoric during the crisis.  It is worth your time.  It doesn’t take long to read.  Take the time….

Paul Krugman’s take on the issue.

OTHER NOTES:

Last night I came across a very informative hour program on CNN: Fareed Zaharia on the history of Iran and Nuclear.  If you have only snips of knowledge about this issue, this fairly short program will be enlightening.  I noted the comments which are the usual combination of opinions.  I know enough about the history of both nuclear and U.S. policy and even Zakaria to observe that I think Zaharia’s commentary is credible.

Saturday evening we watched the latest Stepen Spielberg sci-fi film “Disclosure Day“. It is an interesting film.  It caused me to recall the first Spielberg film I ever saw: ET.  This was released in 1982.  Disclosure Day is adult fiction with a lot of food for thought and discussion.  Check it out.  Two hours.

Apparently today, the U.S. President leaves for a chat with the Execs of China and Russia, and Elon Musk is going along.  Perhaps the world has essentially been divided into three spheres, each controlled by strong men – at least that is the fantasy.  The outliers – places like Africa, Australia, Antarctica – are unassigned, at least not officially.  1984 lives….  Note to anyone interested in retaining a democracy: this is no time to take a vacation from activism.

COMMENTS

from Jeff:  Both [commentaries, Richardson and Krugman] are excellent and put the lie to Duffy’s nonsense and bluster, especially Richardson’ s explanation of appropriated $$ unspent

chaos, corruption and incompetence over and over again

2026 Election Retrospective

 

On purpose, since October 1 I’ve been silent about the 2026 election (see first brief paras of the post).  I decided to wait until all of the returns for House and Senate seemed to be solid.  As I write, Alaska Senator  seems close to closure, and a few seats too close to call.  Time to talk.

First, I don’t predict outcomes in advance.  This year I thought the Democrats (my brand) would make enough headway to  get a small majority in the House, but no headway in the Senate.  I was astonished as the week unfolded.

Re the bizarre shutdown of airports Friday afternoon: it has all the earmarks of a set-up by the President of the United States to punish American voters,,,  Proof?  None, except the now long and exhausting pattern of retribution by the President to his perceived enemies – the ones who don’t bow down.  It is the Presidents “brand”.  By 2024, we knew what we’d be getting….

Below is some data, most of which (excluding 2026) I shared a month ago:  Election of U.S. President 2018-2024.

Friday I. found an interesting source about the 2026 election: The 2026 Election by the Numbers by James Lindsay from the non-partisan Council on Foreign Relations.  It is referenced below.

A few personal thoughts: at 86, I consider myself pretty well informed as a citizen, politically.

Nov. 3, 2026, was reality and not rhetoric.The people (every vote, including those who didn’t vote), sp0ke volumes.  Anyone seeking proof that every vote matters, and has equal weight regardless of the voters personal wealth or perception of influence, need only look at this years results, everywhere.

Like you, and everyone, I have a personal ‘base’.  These are the people I see frequently: people I know, and people I don’t, in all sorts of contexts, like post office lines, etc.  Family members of all ages, etc.

I have lived 26 years in this suburban community which was politically dominated by Republicans; and began a transition in the 2000s.  Fast forward: Nov. 3 every political position with party identification – State House and Senate and Congressperson – continued as Democrat.  So did Governor, constitutional offices like Attorney General, and U.S. Senator.

We “liberals” are not in any sense of the term “radical”.   My personal home town ‘base’, (and I think almost everyone’s base), is made up of genuinely nice people, who simply want government (which is all of us, after all) to work and be fair for everyone.  We differ on lots of things, civilly.  I have an expansive view of this: everyone, everywhere should have a chance to thrive regardless of circumstances.  I have always resonated to the Theodore Roosevelt definition of a ‘square deal’.  Roosevelt came from wealth, but had an understanding of the worth and values and struggles of the common person.

There is no room in my definition for reservation of rights to Trillionaire individuals or companies.  Excess power is not a gift to be misused.  Nov. 3 2026 was a demonstration of power to the people through the ballot.

Caustic politics (I win, you lose) is self-defeating.  Whoever won office last Tuesday, assumes office with an obligation to represent everyone.  My preference is “We” politics, which I ascribe these days to Democrats, as opposed to the “Me” politics of winner take all, loser, shut up.  Years ago, in the 1980s, I scribbled a little illustration of what I felt was the Political Scrum.  I offer it here, for your consideration.  I still think of myself as I thought of myself then, a moderate, pragmatic Democrat….  Where do you fit?

When we elected persons on Nov. 3, they were generally elected for 2, 4 or 6 year terms.  Their terms do not begin until January, 2027.  Many continue in office until later election.  You owe it to yourself to know your ‘cast of characters’ and figure out how you, individually, can make a difference from now forward.

Happy Thanksgiving.

Political Scrum 2024 (pdf)

COMMENTS 

from Fred:  Thanks Dick.

I was particularly interested in reviewing the final Minnesota votes for president, 2016, 2020, 2024. Everyone knows, of course, Dear Leader won by landslides in all of them and 2024 (if you don’t know just ask him) and was behind Biden in the 2024 election stolen by radical, terroristic, stoopid Dems and their radical Left (Commies, Immigrants, Somalis, Trangenderists, rapists, perverts, pedophiles, unattractive uglies, traitors).
But I digress. Dear Leader didn’t fare too badly with liberal, low information, Minnesota voters in any of them (I haven’t seen the official totals for 2026). Wonder how he will do in 2028?

from David: I too was expecting a close election but that may have been me setting a low bar so as not to be disappointed. Over the border where REAL MEN reside, St. Croix County [WI] voters went for the Repubs in all races except our Assembly District 30 where Kevin Knoke knocked off incumbent Shannon Zimmerman. District 30 includes Hudson which tends to vote a bit bluer than the rest of the more rural parts of the county. It also helped that Knoke is associated with a top-notch ice cream and candy shop in Hudson.

 

Armistice Day 2026

Today, November 11, is an important commemorative day.  Historically it was called Armistice Day; generally in Europe it seems to go by Remembrance Day; in the U.S. since the 1950s it’s been designated Veterans Day.  In every instance it brings to public attention the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month of 1918, when WWI officially ended.

Of course, such endings are always ragged,  and the end of WWI  was as well.  But the war officially ended, and with it came the hopes and dreams of no more war which, in this case, spawned the even more deadly WWII and all of the assorted conflicts which followed, including the current war with Iran.

But today honors veterans – I am one (1962-63 – U.S. Army) – of the people who have served in various ways over the years.  In my case, two brothers are both Vietnam veterans (Air Force officers), and grandson Spencer is a Marine Sergeant, presently on assignment for a year as a Marine recruiter.  On and on.

Personally, I’m a peacenik, one of the lucky Vietnam-era veterans who was being trained for but never had to go to Vietnam.  I’ve never regretted military service, even if it was not always agreeable.  Today I wore my Army dog tags to a program across the Mississippi from me.  The program was remarkable and informative, featuring four panelists with emphasis on the Vietnam era.  See NOTE at end of this post.

My particular focus this day is my Uncle Frank Bernard, Dad’s brother, KIA on the USS Arizona at Pearl Harbor, Dec. 7, 1941.  (Photo of Frank in Honolulu below, some time before December 7, ’41)  Frank was one of the crew who went down with the ship.  His entire Navy career, 1936-41, was ship fitter on the Arizona.  In early December two of my daughters will be at Pearl Harbor for a Disinterment Ceremony, continuing a process made possible by DNA technology to hopefully identify human remains recovered and interred for 85 years for which there was no identity.  (See the first three paragraphs of the letter which I received in May 2026: Arizona Battleship disinternment.)  There is no assurance that Uncle Frank’s remains,, or any other crew will be positively identified, but we’re grateful for the efforts. Third paragraph from the end of the letter is the link for live stream viewing.

Frank Bernard, Honolulu pre-Dec. 7, 1941

NOTE: The panel on Veteran’s Day in West St. Paul MN;  Gary Gilson, Stephen Young, Samuel Verdeja, and Larry Johnson.  Larry is a long time good friend and author of a well received book ‘Sixty One’.  The pdf identifies two on-line videos by Gary Gilson, and four books by Stephen Young: Gary Gilson, Stephen Young.

Two personal heroes of mine are Joe Schwartzberg and Lynn Elling.  Since 2008, I’ve had a website largely dedicated to them.  Both were military officers at one point in their lives, Army and Navy, respectively. https://amillioncopies.info/.

POSTNOTE: Overnight came a very pertinent post on Veteran’s Day by Heather Cox Richardson on the topic of Veterans Day.  Most of my personal career was representing public school teachers.  During that period (till retirement in 2000), the American Legion was a key sponsor of American Education Week in public schools.  In fact, programs like AEW were key reasons why the American Legion was formed after WWI.

COMMENTS:

from Larry: (one of the speakers at the panel referenced above): I [was] on the 10-11:30 panel … with veteran friends, Gary Gilson and Sam Verdeja.  Gary is a journalist and past director of the Minnesota News Council.  Sam has worked in public policy, especially as it impacts Veterans.  My place on the panel is as someone who has worked with children all my life, and as an intense volunteer with VETERAN RESILIENCE PROJECT.  On my 61st birthday I did a 61 mile hike calling for an end to wars having more to do with bottom line profits than legitimate defense.  The walk also called for an end to obfuscation of Veteran care, especially for mental health and exposure to war toxins.  At 11 I will ring the Armistice Bell I made with other Veterans on a 2013 State Arts Board grant, calling back to a time when even Presidents made resounding speeches saying, “We’re gathered to honor all those who served.  There is no greater tribute we could pay than to work hard so that many fewer individual need to make the sacrifice that make them Veterans.”

from Sandy: Thanks for sharing!

from SAK:

I am sorry to read on your web page about those who fought & died, happy to read about those who returned from the war unharmed. Sadly many died fighting very shortly before the armistice was declared. One such was a major British poet, Wilfred Owen. His mother received the telegram as the bells were ringing on the 11th of November, 1918. What a happier world it would have been had the armistice been declared at the start of the war & spared all these young men – aside from the civilians. . .

Owen was not one of those who were enthusiastic about violence & war at all having seen the effect of poison gas & experienced the trenches. A poem that comes to mind is Dulce et Decorum est which refers to a line from Horace meaning it is sweet and proper to die for the country, except that Owen’s last stanza declares this line from Horace to be “the old lie”:

If in some smothering dreams, you too could pace
Behind the wagon that we flung him in,
And watch the white eyes writhing in his face,
His hanging face, like a devil’s sick of sin,
If you could hear, at every jolt, the blood
Come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs,
Obscene as cancer,
Bitter as the cud
Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues,–
My friend, you would not tell with such high zest
To children ardent for some desperate glory,
The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est
Pro patria mori.

from Remi:

TO BE CANADIAN ON REMEMBRANCE DAY — MAÎTRES CHEZ-NOUS
During World War II, the Canadian military was a formidable force. After Normandy, the First Canadian Army fought through France and Belgium to the Netherlands. My father was stationed in Belgium in September 1944 as part of that campaign.
The First Canadian Army led a ferocious campaign to expel German forces from Walcheren Island in the Netherlands, one of the bloodiest campaigns of the war for Canadian forces. After the island was liberated, my father was deployed there with other Canadian soldiers to prevent a German counterattack. They stayed until the Canadian Army completed the liberation of the Netherlands in May 1945. He was just a few miles across the water from enemy-held territory.
While stationed in Belgium, my father was also only a few miles from Flanders Fields, where so many Canadian soldiers had fallen during the First World War. Every Remembrance Day, at our town’s ceremony, he recited In Flanders Fields. He did so year after year, until Alzheimer’s disease began to take its toll. We were there when he struggled to recite the poem for the last time. Some of us cried.
In liberated Dutch towns, Canadian soldiers were welcomed by overjoyed and starving civilians who had endured four years of Nazi occupation. Soldiers shared their rations and gave chocolate to children who had never tasted it. Over the years, my father received letters from some of the grateful people he had met. Thousands of Canadians who died liberating the Netherlands are still honoured in cemeteries throughout the country.
By the end of the war, Canada had the fourth-largest armed forces in the world. Yet Canadian soldiers were still officially British subjects. My maternal grandfather, born on the shores of the Black Sea to parents of German ancestry, became a British subject by naturalization—his 1941 Canadian passport, which also bears my grandmother’s name, records that status. The war marked an important turning point in Canada’s emergence as a nation. The sacrifices of its soldiers helped establish Canada’s place in the world and strengthen its national identity.
After the war, my father waited almost a year in Paris to be repatriated. He was billeted with a French-speaking family. He once told me that his parents didn’t speak “real” French. He was wrong. They spoke North American French. The French pioneers of New France and the English-speaking settlers who followed from the British Isles and the American colonies came from different shores, but over generations both developed distinctive North American languages and cultures, shaped by the same continent. North American French was passed down by the young women who crossed the Atlantic nearly 400 years ago and became the mothers of a continent. Their descendants now number more than 12 million, half of whom live in the United States.
Many of these women were poor orphans known as “les Filles du Roi” (the King’s Daughters).

Minnesota Orchestra

Minnesota Orchestra before the concert Nov. 5, 2026, Orchestra Hall Minneapolis

Tonight (Friday Nov 6 8 p.m. CST) is a marvelous free orchestra concert conducted by Thomas Sundergard: MN Orch Nov 5 2026.  We saw it live yesterday at Orchestra Hall (photo above before the concert began).  The live performance will be carried on Minnesota Public Radio and Twin Cities Public Television, and  also on the Minnesota Orchestra’s YouTube Channel.

You’ll be glad you took the time.

This weeks concert was the first of three events of the Orchestras Nordic Soundscapes Festival, and the only performance to be live-streamed.  November 8 (Sunday) is a family concert “The Musical Tales of Hans Christian Andersen”.  Nov. 13 and 14, conducted by Oslo Vanska, will feature music by Danish and Finnish composers.

NOTE:

Personal comments on the Nov. 3 election will come after the last Senate and Congressional races are decided.

Nov. 3, 2026

I voted October 2, 2026. October 1, I wrote “I plan to be ‘radio silent’ politically until after the election Nov. 3“.   Here I am, late afternoon Nov. 3.  The polls are closing on the east coast, and the rest of the night will be reports.

My main contribution to the post-election conversation  is U.S. Election Data 2016, 2020, 2024: Election of U.S. President 2016-2024.  Two pages worth keeping about voting by we Americans in the last 10 years.  Also worth at least a quick look: Census reports on 2018 election, and a 2021 Analysis of voting.

We collectively choose who governs us.  There is no escape from our shared responsibility.

We’re all single ciphers among the hundreds of millions who are eligible voters, including those who don’t vote at all.  We each have equal power: the vote.  What can I learn from the last 10 years, including tonight.  What can I do to keep our 250 year democracy?

I’ll muse about what this past month and the ten years preceding it mean to me in a following post, probably in the next week.  I solicit your thoughts as well.

*

If you wish, a few other morsels recently:

Advice from Robert Reich to those “who don’t do politics” (three minutes)

An excellent commentary on Polls by Charlotte Swasey in “The Opening Argument”: Polling

Robert Reich shares and highly recommends Barack Obama’s speech in Cleveland Sat Oct 24.

From the New York Times, a one hour podcast Oct 23: Ezra Klein and Sarah Longwell: “What Hundreds of Focus Groups With Trump Voters Revealed“.   Gift article from The New York Times.  Sarah Longwell has conducted hundreds of focus groups with Trump voters, and many of them are feeling betrayed.”

COMMENTS:

from Brian:

Hello Dick!
I LOVE your post!   I actually voted today, for the first time in years.   Yay!   I so appreciate what you wrote 🙂
Good luck!
E pluribus unum.  I live in a neighborhood with Jews, Christians, Arabs, and of course Haitians.   I LOVE it!
Thanks for your email and post.  🙂


from SAK:

Many thanks Mr Bernard,

Congratulations!

I just heard Mr James Talarico speak. What a good, loving fellow. What a different president he would make.

from Jeff: to quote a country song lyric:  “God Bless Texas.”

from Carlo:

Finally, Americans have learned the importance of Midterms!
Next on the list the importance of the Census year!

from Kathy: Thank you Dick for all you do! I have 28 folks that are in my Neighborhood Leadership turf -all Dem/NA voters and 100% of them voted this midterm!

Our ineffective Dem Governor narrowly made it -5 points from mega candidate but Oregonians came through!
So excited about electing so many diverse folks. Now they have to get to work and we the people need to be prodding them to move forward for meaningful change!

 

One month to Nov. 3, 2026…

One month to Election Day.  VOTE.GOV if you need information about your state….  For Minnesota, the information is HERE.  For my Senate District HERE.    I voted on October 2.  Very normal process.  Only a longer ballot – more offices to elect. I plan to be ‘radio silent’ politically until after the election Nov. 3.

 

 

POSTNOTE: My general political position published Sep 18 is here.

COMMENTS;

from Dick: I elected to not publish any opinion other than as stated above except to my own city group, to which I sent my position earlier this week, which Norm replyed to below.  For anyone who might be interested, I’m including what I sent to the smaller list below Norm’s comment.

International Day of Peace

PRENOTE: My post about the 2026 election is here.

September 21, 2026, the International Day of Peace, was so designated by the United Nations on September 7, 2001, four days before 9-11-01.  Yesterday, the third Tuesday in September, is now the official opening day of the UN in New York City.  The creation of the UN dates back to the end of WWII in 1945.  I am a strong supporter of the United Nations, acknowledging how difficult it has to be these days.

Sunday, September 20, 2026, was the 100th birthday of our friend, Annelee Woodstrom, and we attended the celebration of her 100th birthday in Fargo, North Dakota.  The previous day there had been a similar event in her community of Ada MN.

More so than most of us, Annelee was and is a personal witness to the foundation story of the UN.  She was born in 1926 in Germany, and grew up in Hitler’s Germany through the end of WWII.  She experienced the horrors of war.  She was 18 when the War ended.  In 1947, not yet 21, she came to the U.S. to marry her Gentleman Soldier, Kenny Woodstrom of Crookston MN.

The marriage was not without complication.  She was, first of all, an “alien”, enemy no less, who spoke no English.  The laws had been amended to permit “war brides’, so that was okay.  She was over 18, so of legal age to marry here.  But there was a complication: she was not yet 21 and under German Law permission of her father was required to marry.  Annelee’s father had been killed in the war.  Though over 40 at the time, her Dad was a draftee who had declined to join the Nazis, and presumably was killed somewhere in Russia near the end of the war.  I don’t think that it has ever been established exactly where he died, or where he is buried.  That is the nature of war.

Kenny and Annelee married and had two children.  Kenny died in 1998, a year after the 1997 flood devastated their town of Ada.  They had been married 51 years.

While she had only completed 8th grade equivalent in Germany, during her marriage she went  to and graduated from college, becoming a career public school teacher in Twin Valley Minnesota, and a finalist for Minnesota Teacher of the Year.

Their daughter, Sandy, and two of her friends,  were struck and killed by a drunk driver in the 1970s, and are buried next to each other in Ada.  Her son and daughter-in-law had three children, and she has several great-grandchildren.

She documented her life in three books: War Child, Empty Chairs, and So It Was – all remembering her life as she lived it in Germany and in the United States,  I am not sure she is still selling the books on line, but if so, they are certainly worthwhile as a story of a life.  I know she has books available, but I am not sure of their accessibility, so will have to leave that as an open question.   Hers is a remarkable story among millions of remarkable stories about all of us.

POSTNOTE: As it happens, the International Day of Peace is always the day after her birthday, and the United Nations convenes on the Third Tuesday in September, this year September 21, 2026.

We are not at a time of peace in our country or world.  Here are the summaries from the UN General Assembly on September 22, 2026. Heather Cox Richardson and Paul Krugman, and Heather Delaney Reese among others.

Election 2026

Today, Sep. 18, 2026, is the first day open to in-person voting in Minnesota.  The final day of voting is 46 days away, Nov. 3, 2026.

For Minnesotans everything you need to know can be found here, the website of the Minnesota Secretary of State.   If you happen to live in my community, Woodbury MN, check SD47 for Democratic candidate information.

For those from states other than Minnesota,  Vote.Gov can direct you to the official website of your state.

PERSONAL OPINION:

First, I did an epilogue to my 9-11-01 posts on September 12.  if interested read here.

We voters have all of the power in our society.  Each of us have equal power.  In my opinion, citizens who do not vote, effectively are potentially ‘voting’ against their own self interest.  Unfortunately we can easily be our own worst enemy, by not voting at all, or voting uninformed about candidates on our ballot, or voting for someone with zero chance of success.  An instant decision – who to mark our ballot for, or even whether to vote at all – can have major consequences for us, as we are learning in real time.  You cannot undo that single action, often for years.

There are many offices up for election this year, including every member of the U.S. House of Representatives.  My local ballot includes candidates for over 30 positions. Write-ins are authorized in all cases.  A few positions are non-partisan. (20 positions are for District Court Judges where there is only one candidate; one, which represents my area, has two candidates.)

I never ask a person how or if he/she voted.  All that matters in the end is the collective result.

Personally, every post I’ve published at this site since 2009 – over 2000 posts in 17 years – has my personal declaration at upper right.  I am a moderate pragmatic Democrat (“DFL” in our parlance: Democratic Farmer Labor)

A MAGA friend once challenged my “pragmatic” descriptor.  There are a number of definitions of pragmatic.  This definition fits for me.  Pragmatism comes from work and life experience.  I respect differences of opinion, and prefer resolution of problems over win-lose strategies (which I consider to be lose-lose in the long run).

I am a moderate Democrat, whose main political mentor was a progressive Republican Governor (Elmer L. Andersen), and whose hero was a Democratic President (Jimmy Carter) who was progressive but carefully conservative..

I will vote for Democratic (DFL) endorsed candidates this year as in the past because the. DFL party, generally, most closely subscribes to the “we” aspect of political thought on issues that matter: we all matter, not only the have’s.  We know that reaching agreement can be messy.  Life is not “king on the hill” game of our childhood.

The main opposition party has become totally subordinate to “me” – someone in control.  “We” is essential for survival as a country like ours, born of liberty and freedom and a hard-won tradition of inclusion rather than exclusion.  “Me” – winner take all – is antithetical to  what we are as a country.

I will vote before Election Day, knowing who I am voting for and why.  See you at the polls.

Vote as though your and our very future depends on how you vote, because it does….

COMMENTS (more at end): 

from Carol: Great writing, Dick.

Altho’ I recommend asking EVERYbody you come in contact with whether they are registered to vote – and then later if they’ve voted.  A number of those young people who wait on you in stores, etc. are becoming voting age.  They need to be encouraged to vote but maybe don’t know how to register.  Direct them to the Secretary of State’s website.  It’s their world we’re busy screwing up.  One year I actually printed out slips of paper to hand out to people.  Not telling them HOW to vote – but where to get information about their ballot, local polling place, etc.  I’ve been thinking I need to take time to print some out again.
One year I had conversations with a kid working at Subway in Newport.  I think he was too young to vote, but said his grandpa had had polio or something and wanted to vote but wasn’t comfortable getting into the polling place.  I told him that the law requires an election judge come out to the car and help a handicapped person to vote.  I kept reminding him to remind grandpa – and he reported that grandpa voted!

response from Dick:  I have no issue whatever with what you say.  We each have to assess our own environment and personality and do what we can.  Whatever the case, my generation (I’m 86) is in the rear view mirror now, and the task is for our kids and grandkids to save their own future, hopefully relying at least a little on our residual wisdom.  I admit being nervous letting go, but that’s how it has to be.

A NOT SO GENTLE REMINDER:  Individual voters – lots of them – elected the reality we are living now, especially the current President and the Republican majorities in both U.S. House and Senate.  Those voters who had the opportunity and made the free choice to not vote at all, or to vote for some candidate who had zero chance of success, in effect “voted” against their own interest.

Updates: A Personal Opinion on AI (Artificial Intelligence); and Iran

In progress.  Check back later.

August 6, From a Distance

August 11, Forrest Gump

Iran

Feb 23 and Mar 3, Iran

Apr 11 ref Apr 5, Jim Klein

Apr 23, Jim Christie

Epilogue. 9-11-01

Friday night, after I published comments about 9-11-01,  I took time to read the eight additions to the conversation.  It occurred to me that the eight reflections were probably a good cross-section of  millions in the U.S. and elsewhere, who in similar ways tried to make sense of the insanity we all witnessed in real time in a few minutes beginning early 9-11-01 in New York City.

We are – we cannot deny it – a global community.  Even 25 years ago, we were not alone.  The casualty list for 9-11-01 speaks to that reality.  Many from other nations died in the carnage.  And 9-11 was only chapter one of a continuing tragedy.

Here is my attempt to fill in some personal blanks in my experience of that awful day and the days following.  This is only a tiny summary.

AFTER SEPTEMBER 11, my first vivid memory was the silence.  We live relatively near the Twin Cities  and St, Paul airports, and their flightpaths.  Those days I walked outdoors, and before 9-11 there was often a plane heard or seen overhead;  September 12, and for a few days following, nothing.

It was a new and very unusual day in America.

By September 24, it was becoming obvious that peace was not to be forthcoming.  There were other plans being discussed about the future.

Some time earlier in the summer we had booked a flight and accommodations for a week or two in London, England.  We decided to go ahead with the trip, and were glad we did.  We were treated very well.  We flew home from Gatwick on Armistice Day, Nov. 11, 2001.  At 11 a.m. that day, on the dot,  the PA announcer in the terminal asked for two minutes of silence, and the busy airport fell completely silent. I don’t recall even a babies cry.

At home, by November, 2001, the mood had been changing.  By late September a strategy was developing to avenge the injury inflicted on the United States, and by early October came a poll  where 94% of Americans supported bombing Afghanistan where Al-Qaeda hung out.  I don’t recall similar retribution plans against Saudi Arabia or Egypt, where Osama bin Laden and most of the airplane high-jackers were from.

I made my first visit to an antiwar protest in early October, 2001.  I didn’t know any of the speakers, nor the organizers.  My dominant memory, even today, is of a very vocal antagonistic group of U.S.-flag-brandishing anti-protestor protesters….  WAR on Evil was their message to the gathered peaceniks.

I became a peace activist.  For three years, 2005-07,  I was President of a group of organizations, the Minnesota Alliance of Peacemakers; and was part of the organizing committee for a major “Peace Island” Conference at the time of the 2008 Republican National Convention, both in St. Paul MN.   I became very aware of the seductive beat of the drums of war in competition with the gentle sounds of peace.  Maybe it’s part of human nature to revel in conflict, especially if you win by domination.  We desperately need peacemakers.

Feb. 5, 2003, Secretary of State Colin Powell had solemnly told the UN that Saddam Hussein was going nuclear, and Powell  was trusted.  The focus had switched from al Qaeda to regime change in Iraq.  Game on.  First came “Shock and Awe” over Baghdad in March.  May 1, 2003 came the now-infamous Mission Accomplished speech on the deck of the USS Abraham Lincoln by President Bush announcing the victory over Saddam Hussein.  Aside from the press releases, there was never a victory, as we all know.  (Saddam was captured in December, 2003, and executed in December, 2006.)

For awhile after 9-11, I climbed aboard the 9-11 conspiracy train, which became very active and had reputable representatives and supporters.  Many of their arguments made sense.  That movement lasted quite awhile.  Finally the movement largely evaporated, as much from media leaders accepting the administration line that there was “no there, there”; joining in ridiculing those who suspected less than clean hands of others in the success which came from the chaos.

Of course, then, it really made no difference.  The damage was done.  There are those still carrying the torch, but they have no audience.  and in this media dominated society, it is easy to bury problems, just by not mentioning or making it possible to effectively debate the issues. It is justly said that history is written (or buried) by the victors through the official story – a major concern in todays assault on what history will say about the present in which we are living today.  About the best that we might be able to do is to keep the memory alive at least to the distinct possibility that there is more to the story than we will ever learn.

In the 25 years since 2001, a particularly low point for me came in the summer of 2009 when I visited the International Peace Garden on the North Dakota/Canada border.  The story is in a blog of mine posted in summer 2009.  It was as if War had vanquished Peace at the Peace Garden.  A long-standing Peace symbol had been converted to a War monument by the governing Board of the Peace Garden.  Parts of the World Trade Center wreckage were displayed on the grounds; newspaper accounts of 9-11 were on display in the chapel.  I don’t know the current status there….  It was jarring, then.

And on its gone for 25 years.  Each of us have our own stories, worth remembering and sharing in our own circles.  We can learn by listening to ourselves and to others.  What will we make of the 25 years ahead?

*

There is one further story, important to me, personally, from another time in our history.

This day, I recall another horrific day in the life of America: Pearl Harbor, December 7, 1941.  Every December 7, this years 85th anniversary no exception, we will all see the USS Arizona blow up spectacularly on TV clips or newspaper photos, etc., one of the consequences of an attack by 353 Japanese aircraft.  Each time I see this, I’m watching my Dad’s brother, Uncle Frank, who I actually met as a one year old in early July, 1941, die in the explosion.  He was a ship fitter, his entire six year Navy career was aboard the USS Arizona.  Here’s one of over 20 photos I have of him.  He died at 26 years of age.

Frank Bernard, sometime between 1936 and 1941, USS Arizona

This year two of my daughters are going to be at Pearl Harbor, representing Granduncle Frank’s family..

A couple of years ago I got a letter from a Department of Defense subgroup that had received funding to attempt to match flesh recovered from the Arizona after Dec. 7, but till DNA impossible to match with any casualty that awful day.  Male descendants were invited to give DNA samples for analysis, and I did.  Uncle Frank is one of the unknowns.

This summer came a followup letter: Arizona Battleship disinternment

To my knowledge, no match has been found to my uncle…at least not yet.  But several other unknowns have been identified through the process, and this year will be the first such commemoration, and I’m glad that Frank’s grandnieces can be in attendance.

Let’s have a conversation, all of us, everywhere.

Dec. 8, 1941, Japan and the U.S. became deadly enemies to each other.  At the end, four yers later, two horrendous bombs over Hiroshima and Nagasaki officially ended WWII.

Those of us old enough can remember the details of the ensuing years rebuilding relationships between Japan and the U.S., and the lesser known details of what may have been the reasons the Japanese chose to attack America’s outpost at Pearl Harbor.  War is simple, yet very, very complicated.  Might does not make right.

“Let there be peace on earth, and let it begin with me.”

Each and every one of us is the solution, one action at a time.

POSTNOTE Sep 13: At Basilica of St. Mary this morning, the new Pastor, Ralph Talbot, commented on 9-11-01.  His was an on point homily, and mirrored his comments in the Sunday newsletter, copied here: Basilica Ralph Talbot Sep 13 26

ADDITIONAL COMMENTS;

from Larry Sep 11: Wow…Dick! What a fantastic piece of work you did on this whole project in two parts. Excellent commemoration of this day we will never forget. I too thought it was a small plane hitting a building in NYC. I was on the treadmill at the time. Then the whole thing started hitting me. Got to work and my dept. set up TV sets in the cafeteria so employees could follow this on their breaks.  Horrible, unprecedented day that changed the world.  I see the link to the interview with John. Works great!  Nicely done – your entire work on this…thanks!  LG

from Joyce Sep 11: This is an excellent compilation of experiences of 9/11. I was thinking, just now, of how we have abandoned, even demonized, expertise in this country. In the weeks before the 2000 presidential election I watched a man being interviewed on TV, and he said he was voting for GW Bush because, he said, Bush was just an ordinary farmer. Of course Bush was nothing of the sort, he had bought his ranch when he decided to run for president, and he sold it soon after leaving office, but aside from that, since when is an “ordinary farmer” a better choice for president than someone with years of experience and accumulated knowledge and expertise? Consider the incompetents running our government right now because people just couldn’t vote for a woman with years of experience in all three branches of government.  Consider all the newspaper articles interviewing Trump voters in rural diners, and the absence of interviews with educated people who voted the other way. I will never understand this lionization of ordinary, inexperienced, poorly educated men, and I use the word men deliberately.

from Larry J Sep 11: Attached for those who want to get it and those to whom I wish to send it.  When we heard the announcement that JFK was assassinated, I was in Mr. Ruud’s physics class at Bloomington High, using slinkies to learn about the wave theory of light.  When 9/11 happened, I was teaching storytelling and video in a Minneapolis school.  The maintenance person barged in and said, “I told your group shooting video they had to get back in here.  A plane just crashed into the World Trade Tower.”  Today I just want all of us to come together in love.

Larry added his recent column in the northwest Minneapolis newspaper Sun Post: Larry Johnson Sun Post 9 10 26

from Fred Sep 11:  Find the Jimmy Kimmel interview with James Talarico on You Tube. The Federal Communications Commission torpedoed Kimmel’s efforts to use it on his live TV show

First off, it is really entertaining but also because Talarico comes off so well. I’ve seen him before and like the guy, but he really smooth, but not cocky, while being interviewed. Talarico is now leading in Texas even though the GOP is in all in on stopping him.

from Kathy Sep 12: a letter one of her 5th graders wrote to a “New York student” after9-11-01