Voters

August 1 is 99 Days to the 2022 Election (Nov. 8).  Every single person is, and has to be, the difference maker in a democratic republic as ours still is, and hopefully remains.

In 2020, there were about 240,000,000 eligible voters in the United States, of whom 158 million actually voted. 81, 282,632 voted for Joseph Biden.  His major opponent garnered 74,223,234 votes.  The remaining couple of million or so voted for a large assortment of non-starters.  App. 82,000,000 didn’t vote at all – about one-third of the total eligible.

Generally down-ballot and mid-term vote totals are much lower than the vote for President.  Therein lies the problem and the potential for 2022.

Then there’s the nitty-gritty for everyone: do you even know who  the candidates are for every electoral office in your area, and where they stand on the issues?

*

There is a bottom line: As noted above, every eligible voter has equal power.  This has nothing to do with personal wealth, status, race.  Every person has a single vote.

There are only two U.S. parties with popular standing and history: Democrat or Republican.  Votes for other party candidates are throwaway votes.  Those who don’t vote at all have zero standing.

In my opinion, the American voter has a stark choice November 8: the most reasonable, or most extreme candidate from either the Democratic or Republican Party.  But each person at the very least has to know who these people are.

For those with a Primary – Minnesota’s is August 9 – the ballot will be determined after the Primary election.

Then it is up to each us.  The polls don’t matter; neither do the ads, which will be ubiquitous and all misleading regardless of for which party.  Who we elect has consequences past Election Day.

It takes a little work to find out who your candidates are; and it takes a little work, perhaps, to find out how to register to vote and details about where to vote.  Do it.

There are a little less than 100 days to Election Day – more than enough time.

 

Uncle Vincent’s Pocket Knife…

PRE-NOTE to everyone:  August 6 and 9 are the 77th anniversary of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.  There is a significant on-line event relating to this with segments Aug 3, 6, 10, 17, 24, 31.  Details are here.  Pre-registration is required for each segment, and early registration is recommended.  This is worth your time.

To Minnesotans, Primary Election Day is August 9.  Know the candidates and the issues and VOTE well-informed.  More information here.  Click on the box “What’s on my ballot?” if not certain of issues in your area.

(Monday and Tuesday, August 1&2 I plan to have two politics-specific posts.  Do check back.)

Following are several items.  One or more may be of interest to you.

  1. A Memory: Uncle Vincent’s Knife.

We were enroute home July 20, and an apple beckoned, but I had nothing to cut it with.

At the time I was the passenger, and I remembered that in the glove box was Uncle Vincent’s key ring, which included the pocket knife which had given him long and faithful service.   That key ring went everywhere with him, farm and town; fishing, church….  The knife was a multi-purpose tool, not a weapon.  It would do things like cut rhubarb in the garden, and such.

I took the knife and ‘cleaned’ it like back on the farm.  A nearby ragged handkerchief did the duty.

The apple was delicious.

Why, you ask, was that key ring in the car?  Uncle Vince died over 7 years ago, the last of a large farm family which included my mother, his sister, (who was 16 when he was born).

Vince lost custody of his car keys a year earlier when his residence changed to the memory care unit of the LaMoure Nursing home.  Not an easy transition at age 89, but necessary.

I became the custodian of the keys, seldom had use for any of them. But they’ll be with me until I depart this earth, a reminder, I guess, of many rich conversations with my Uncle, and of family.  Thanks, Vince.

Vincent’s knife, July 20, 2022

2.  A Model: Virgil’s Oxbow Project

Two days earlier, I’d been up to rural Huot, near Red Lake Falls, MN, for a visit with my long time friend, retired Professor of French, and passionate French-Canadian, Virgil Benoit.

Virgil has been an advocate for over 40 years, and Oxbow at Old Crossing (new Facebook presence) is his most recent project.  Oxbow probably best conveys his true legacy, which is building community; truly crossing boundaries.

Virgil showed me the various projects in process on the oxbow.  They include tree planting and traditional gardening.  They involve more people than himself,  and the ideas are multifaceted.  Oxbow is a community working together.

Recently he sent a newsletter, with a description of the initiative.  Here is a copy for your perusal. Benoit Virgil Oxbow Fdn.

Virgil Benoit with young beet, Oxbow garden, Huot MN, July 18, 2022

3.  Another Model:  Annelee 

The trip north centered around our friend, Annelee, soon to be 96, in a time of transition in her own very long, productive and interesting life.

Much of her adult life, Annelee was a teacher in a northern Minnesota town.  I got a first look at her school on this trip, and found an unanticipated plaque on the wall of the school, with 13 other members of the “Hall of Fame”.  The light situation didn’t mitigate for a good photo, but here’s what I saw on the wall of the school about my friend.

Annelee was (and still is) an outstanding teacher, another unsung hero, as is Virgil, was Vincent, and so many others, everywhere who we come across in our daily lives..

4.  A Learning Opportunity for You: A Private Universe

Back in the late 1980s, my friend, Kathy, then a 5th grade teacher, sent me a handout from some inservice she had attended.  It had spoke to her.  I read it, and I kept it.

A couple of weeks ago for whatever reason she sent me the exact same handout she’d sent years ago.  It caused me to look at it much more carefully, and it spoke to me, and I think it can speak to all of us in these days when getting stuck in our own certainty is a major problem for our very society.

I think it came to me because she and I had recently chatted about the difficulty of conversing about politics in general, even with people we know well.

This time, I looked up A Private Universe on the internet, and I invite you to do the same.  In 1987 it was a learning research project with junior high school students, which apparently endures.

I invite you to in particular watch the videos #1 (the original, featuring junior high kids) and 8 (Q&A some years later with the ‘star’ of the original), which won’t take much of your time, and then translate their topic to your own contemporary idea about communicating with people with differing opinions from your own about most anything.

I think you’ll find the time well spent, and learn something about yourself as well.

Here’s the sheet Kathy sent me, not complete, but you’ll get the idea: Private Universe 1980s.  The videos will add much more.

*

We learn in small and sometimes seemingly insignificant increments.  For me, simply in this post, the “teachers” have been Mom, Virgil, Kathy, Annelee and many, many more.

Yours?

*

Two additional items well worth your time:

from Fred, re life in Russia:  Bill sent this very interesting take on the long suffering Russian people and the great writers who documented their eternal misery under despotism.

This article from the Atlantic, though less than encouraging, speaks to the hope that Russia can still overcome its long tradition of submission to despotism.
*

from Molly: Excellent and important article from Tom Snyder.  Not an upper of a piece, but important, thought-provoking,  and right on….

Also read the comment below the essay by Linda Macdonald (July 23)

Sigh.

Worry.

Work.

Molly

PS: if you’ve not read yet Snyder’s 2017 book On Tyranny, it is an important and fairly brief read…

Self-Rule and Survival

Or: What the War in Ukraine (and the Coup in America) is Actually About

COMMENTS (Also see end off post);

from Christine:

I have been particularly interested in this last post of yours. The family and rural environment that has been yours in your youth is so well described that I thought I was part of it.
Your analysis of the Ukraine/Russia war is given here a light that we don’t hear so often
Finally, your view on the US political ambiance seems easy to understand. It is precious for me as a European.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I read them regularly but do not always react and maybe I should.
I respect your continuous work of writing and I am honored to receive this blog of yours.
I hope you keep well as it seems.
I will be back to the US with my film over the Fall and, of course, you will be informed amongst the first since you are my friend and you are in it!!!
*
from Christina, now in her 90s:

My youngest sister spent a lot of time with us. She was only three when we got married. We had a baby one year after we were married and she was almost like one of our kids.  When  mom and dad moved to Fargo, and she was older, she spent most of her summers with us.

One day she was out bailing and had trouble with the twine string that was binding the bales and when John went to help her he said “A feller should always have a jackknife in his pocket.”  she said “but I don’t have a jack knife” and he pulled a jackknife out of his pocket.  It had a broken blade, and gave it to her and said “now you’ve got a jackknife.” Now that she’s been married and her kids are grown and married her kids found that knife in her treasury stuff.  They asked her about that knife…and she told them don’t ever touch that knife.  It’s mine.

I sent her your blog with the story of Vincent’s knife.  I think she will appreciate it.

 

Hubris

Tonight on prime time (Thursday July 21) is the 8th hearing of the Jan. 6 committee.  Following are some personal observations.

UPDATE July 22: Heather Cox Richardson, July 21, 2022

*

July 13, 2022.

After the last Hearing on July 12, I recalled the old saying: “give a man enough rope and he’ll hang himself“.  The link gives a history of the term.  Yes, this applies to women, too!

I watched the hearing as usual.  Here’s Heather Cox Richardson’s summary.

Early on at this space I’ve said that these Hearings are to establish a record for posterity.  What happens in court is separate and will come in its own time, if at all.

I have also said that the hearings have been structured, beginning with the small fry – the criminals who attacked the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021 – and ending with the spotlight on the godfather, so to speak. The Guy who orchestrated it all thought he’d accomplish the fraud, but the very long rope he’s relied on his whole life is now in the process of (figuratively) hanging him and his accomplices.  The truth is outing, as it is always  inclined to do.

Living a lie, large or small or immense, has consequences.  It only takes time.   (Of course, this applies to all of us as well, including lying to ourselves – manufacturing a false reality.  But that’s another topic.)

*

Doubtless the audience for the hearings has (and will) include legions of lawyers and students of law; plus the Big Deals of politics, including those who say they won’t watch.

This Congressional hearing is an entity of its own, and doesn’t operate by the same rules and timelines as Court.  The hearings are intended to inform we, the people.

Succinctly, the Law, parallel to the Hearing, is not Perry Mason,  or 48 Hours.

Anyone ever encountering the law, personally, knows it is not a simple process.  Law is a profession with a very long and honorable history, an adversary process, as opposed to mediation or conciliation, and effort towards Justice.

The Department of Justice is criticized for not moving more quickly, or moving at all.  The criticism is designed for public consumption.  The process is working as it has always worked, and we should be thankful for that.

The Legal and the Legislative process is methodical and involves lots and lots of what I would call committee deliberations in preparation, pro and con.

(The famous Nuremberg Trials after WWII began shortly after the end of WWII and concluded four years later, in 1949.  Not all stood trial, of course.  Hitler, the big fish, was dead.  Etc.)

July 21, 2022

I began this post July 13.  Much has happened in the intervening days, up to and including today.

On and on this goes.

Heather Cox Richardson has become, for me, a personal reliable source of honest reporting.  Here and here are her posts since July 13.  Her nearly daily posts are worth following.

The insurrection aftermath reminds me of another quotation from the past: “Oh, what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive“, a caution about consequences of lying.

It’s one thing when #45’s  empire was real estate and he was a one-man show. It is something else again when you are responsible for an immense country of great diversity and it is impossible to keep the lid on information which before you could hide behind things like non-disclosure agreements and such.

Personal Perceptions.

I have no idea at all what the final outcome will be in this, the worst constitutional crisis our country has encountered since the Civil War.

Neither does anyone else know, no matter how high and mighty they might be.  There are endless opinions and theories.  The process continues

I think the ex-president will be indicted and tried and  likely convicted, but the actual court decision, if it goes to trial, could be years off, absent some other resolution between.

The ultimate focus has always been the capo, the head, #45.  By all accounts, he has always been accustomed to winning by his own rules, and personal winning by any means necessary has always been his modus operandi.  “Me” is his only focus.

Winning the U.S. presidency was a plum he never expected.  It’s largest fringe benefit, I feel, was essentially a perception of immunity from accountability, including having the ability to pardon others, potentially including himself.  That was the biggest fringe benefit for #45 , the driver to lust to run again in 2024.

He still has lots of support including members of law enforcement military, bureaucrats, lawmakers, on and on.

He has plenty of allies.  Should he win, all of them will be like his opponents: the victims, short and long term.

Personally, I doubt we’ll ever actually see another ballot with his name on it, but again, nobody knows.

As they used to say on the farms, “the chickens are coming home to roost”.  The gig is up.

POSTNOTE: There is a larger issue here being fought.  For our entire history,  white men (meaning “men”) ruled, especially those already with privilege.  These folks not only made the rules, but controlled their enforcement.  This hegemony is being challenged, by women, by persons of color, by persons of less privilege, and so on, and it is a struggle that needs to happen until better balance of some sort is legally and permanently achieved.  I’m part of the privileged class.  I support the struggle for change.

COMMENTS (more at the end of post):

from Joyce: I so hope you are right about his being indicted and convicted. I’m not so optimistic, and I truly fear for our democracy.

response from Dick: Of course, I have no more or less knowledge of what will happen, but you have to remember that you and I are not the only people in the country that don’t want the American Experiment of over 200 years fail!!!!.
It will take a long while to get to the end of this, so I won’t make a bet. But…mark my words! Your guess and mine will be memorialized in the blog!!!

from Fred: We haven’t missed a word of these hearings. It’s a two buckets of popcorn night this time.

 

 

 

 

North Dakota

PRE-NOTE: What is North Dakota about?  This year you have the advantage of a new book which I’ve publicized at this space two or three times, and continue to highly recommend:  ” Clay Jenkinson’s “The Language of Cottonwoods.  Essays on the Future of North Dakota”.   There are many reviews.  Here’s the Table of Contents: Jenkinson Lang Ctnwoods Contents.   Whatever your connection with the state, if you’re at all interested, read this book.

*

Most of last week I spent in North Dakota.  It was not a secret trip.  Friend Jane, in California wrote: “North Dakota?  Sooo jealous.  The only state I haven’t visited yet.  Plan to go next summer, hopefully even get to Standing Rock.

Having grown up in ND, in many towns, and an almost annual visitor there, I can speak with some authority about the prairie state.   The book I recommend at the beginning of this post will do a much better job than my scribbles in defining present day North Dakota.

North Dakota is a pretty normal place with its pluses and minuses, as is true everywhere.  I could make lists.  No need.  Suffice, we’re a nation that defines others by labels and extremes.  We’re mostly just folks: think of yourself and the people you know, personally.  Then think of what leads the news, regardless of the medium; the latest of anything that brings the outside world to your attention….

A few personal notes here: DB ND July 2022

Below is my  2022 ND road map.  It seems a better visual than assorted random photos between Fargo and Bismarck.   Generally, had you been along, you’d have seen lots of green and open farm area, interspersed with tiny towns, mostly, along the mainline of the old Northern Pacific railroad and U.S. Highway 10.  Of course, the interstates intentionally by-passed the small towns everywhere, which didn’t help the local economy, but so goes progress

The weather was magnificent summer weather.  I travelled in the southeast quadrant: I-94 and a little south, as far west as the Missouri River.

There was a relatively small amount of summer road construction on I-94.  75 is the legal speed limit in ND. Bismarck to St. Paul is about the same distance as from St. Paul to Chicago…400+ miles.   It was a hike for someone my age, alone.

Fargo-Moorhead on the east border is the Prairie metropolis, truly.  Still, the centerpiece artifact at the Fargo visitor center is the woodchipper made famous in the Coen Brothers movie, “Fargo”, which really had nothing much to do with Fargo or North Dakota, but both added to the marketing appeal of the film.  Stereotyping?  Sure, but you take what publicity you can get.  As the quotation attributed to someone(s) goes:  “I don’t care what they say about me, just spell my name right.

North Dakota road map 2022

My first stop in N. Dakota, and my first visit, was with my friend, Larry, in Fargo on July 5.  I told him about Jane’s comment (above), and said I’d like to take a photo of a real North Dakota ‘hayseed’, and he was more than happy to oblige (more at the end of the post about him).  He’s lifelong NoDakker, escapes the bounds of the state now and then, but always returns.  He’s the real deal!

Larry at West Acres, Fargo ND July 5, 2022

Jane isn’t the first to have told me that ND has never been their destination.  We have some kind of reputation, I guess.

I thought about Eric Sevareid’s famous commentary in Colliers Magazine in 1956.  He was born and raised in Velva, not far from Minot and Karlsruhe (where I lived 1951-53).  “You can go home again” was the headline.  Between his growing up in Velva (1912-25), and the 1956 commentary, Eric had become a celebrity to those in my generation.  He only lived a while in Velva as a youngster, but in a sense he never left.

There was a time when I would hesitate to say I was from North Dakota.  That reticence is long past.  I’m proud I grew up there, and in a larger sense, I’ll never really leave, though I’m more than 57 years out of state, most of that a ‘city slicker’ in metro Twin Cities Minnesota.

North Dakota is a pleasant place to visit, Larry and others make it so.  For me, “others” this year meant 10 folks I know.  My particular business this year focused on the State archives in Bismarck where my family has a presence (collection 11082).  I’ve gone back to the archives about once a year or so, usually for a couple of days.  Enroute out and home, I enjoy my state and I visit. This year was no different.

*

What about Larry (picture above)?

I’ve known Larry G for over 60 years.  When I was in college, he was a high school classmate of my future wife.  I didn’t know him then, except that he was the announcer with a superb radio voice on local radio, KOVC in Valley City.

I didn’t know he was a high school kid.

He went on to success in other areas, and in retirement he blogs as I do.  His turf is HERE.    I think you will like his content.  His information is shared with his permission.   Take a look.  Pieces about Garrison Keillor, Louis L’Amour, “Fargo”, Bobby Vee….

One of my destinations last week came via a tip from him as we conversed.

Oldtimers will remember renowned singer Peggy Lee, who started life as Norma Egstrom of Jamestown ND [July 13: as my college roommate Richard reminds me, below, she actually grew up in tiny Wimbledon ND].   Turns out that she did her first live radio gig probably in the same KOVC studio where Larry Gauper did his announcing.

He told me about a mural on the side of the building that was the radio station and I stopped to see it.  Sure enough, there it is:

The stories go on and on.  If you have the chance to go to North Dakota, go.  You won’t regret it.

And pick up Clay Jenkinson’s book on the Future of North Dakota, “The Language of Cottonwoods”.

Cleveland ND on I-94 from the south July 5, 2022

Missouri River at Bismarck ND July 7, 2022

COMMENTS (more at end of post):

from Mark: Not So Wild a Dream  is one of Eric [Sevareid]’s best pieces of writing about our region.

from Debbie: Thanks for this, Dick.  I taught music in South Dakota on a Sioux reservation and would often go home with one of the teachers from North Dakota – Buffalo.  People there LOVED N. Dakota and called it God’s Country.

I think Lawrence Welk is from there too!  I drove through his home town once.
Unlike your friend Jane, I’ve been to all the states but Oklahoma.
*

from Fred:  My take away from your ND travelogue: Peggy Lee was born in North Dakota??!! That is something of which to be proud.

Actually, your journey sounded pretty interesting. But that’s coming from a big city guy from Red Wing, so what do I know?
*

from Jeff: Thanks Monsieur Bernard….I miss my several times a year visits to Fargo/Wahpeton/Breckenridge, and other points west, north and south in Nodak. I still vividly remember driving east on ND15 I think , between Northwood and Thompson, and a storm came in behind me from the west and I was watching a tornado move to my south maybe 2 miles away just moving along for about 3-4 minutes west to east before dying out….

It really is an interesting state…but the winds in the winter…uff dah.
Dick’s response: The wind is to keep the riff-raff out…!
*
from Rich: So we are fellow “No Daks” … I had to learn the song below in Miss McGraith’s fifth grade classroom in Minot. (Ironically, this is the NDSU choir … from the alma mater of Bill Haring.) As for me, Minot was a great place to grow up … Nestled in a river valley, 50 miles from Canada, it had some interesting history that caused it to be known by some as “little Chicago.” during prohibition.
from Dick: Rich provides a Facebook link to an article for those of you who do Facebook, here.
*

from Mary:  I think all ‘Bernard Kids’ get to be unofficial ambassadors of North Dakota!  Many versions and many memories.  I am sure I have told you of attending a function where a local well-heeled traveler bragged of having visited “all 49″ states.  Of course I asked which one she had not visited and got a hoity toity response…”well, North Dakota, but why would anyone go there!”   Another time I was ushering and a fellow usher was so intrigued with my home state connections that I became an immediate ’cause celeb’!  She brought friends to see me in the flesh and was genuinely thrilled with her find!

I have been to all fifty states and have worked in twelve states…but then again, I am old!

 

 

 

 

The Fourth of July

It’s a rainy day in our community, so the expression “rain on our parade” is probably appropriate for the nearby town of Afton’s annual parade.

July 4 is when we celebrate how exceptional we are.  This year “exceptional” has a very different definition than previous years, in my opinion.  We are awash in uncertainty and division.

Some opinion pieces reflect my personal opinion, this day:  One or more of these may be subject to a pay wall.  But all of them are well worth your time.

“Happy Fourth?” by Dan Rather and Elliot Kirschner

“For the first time in my life…” by Charles Pierce, Esquire

July 2 by Heather Cox Richardson

Our Gun Myths Have Held America Hostage for Too Long” by Franciso Canti, New York Times guest essay

Sunday afternoon I had the fortunate opportunity to watch a portion of the PBS program on the American Space Program of the 1960s, which began with President Kennedy’s famous speech calling on us to have a man on the moon by the end of the 1960s; the decade ending with three men accomplishing the goal on July 20, 1969.

These were three two hour episodes of American Experience: Chasing the Moon (#’s 3103, 3104, 3105)

I wrote of my personal experience that day 5 years ago: Apollo 11.

Of course, much life transpired between JFK’s aspiration, and the accomplishment of the goal, including the assassination of JFK; the Civil Rights accomplishments largely on Lyndon Johnson’s watch; the conflicts of the Vietnam era; the competition with the Soviet Union, on and on.  But the program did give excellent context to me about what we are going through now in our national conversation about what we are as a nation.

Of course, July 20, 1969, was a national celebration, literally.  A goal achieved, against all odds.  If you can, the referenced program is a good one to access if you can.

Peace

PRE-NOTE: Jan 6 Hearing 7 entitled “25” here.  Another post on July 4, 2022.  I’ll be off-line July 5-8.

The Nekoma ND Pyramid July 2009. (More at end of this post).

Call it what you will, but from time to time, events seem to come in seeming related groups.  I’ve experienced such often in my life.  I don’t think they’re ‘coincidences’ or random chance.

So…

Last weekend I finished a book I very highly recommend: Clay Jenkinson’s “The Language of Cottonwoods.  Essays on the Future of North Dakota”.  At page 300 came a 3-page segment on Father Robert Branconnier, in the 1960s Chaplain at the Newman Center at the University of North Dakota.  The discussion was about protesting the missile complexes cropping up in North Dakota   Branconnier late 1960s.  Nekoma (above photo) is part of this book segment.

A day or two later came notice that Twin Cities anti-war activist Marie Braun had died at 87; a day after that, notice of a webcast featuring anti-war activist Frank Kroncke, who went to prison for his anti-draft activities in Minnesota in the late 1960s.

In the same time period, Kathy sent a most interesting series of recommendations by a group of Catholics on the occasion of the current Synod on Synodality of Pope Francis.  Each of the actors referenced were Catholics during the time of their activism, so the final item is pertinent.

So, the news came in bunches this week….

*

I have been part of the peace movement since 9-11-01.  I couldn’t see anything productive coming out of our national collective response to the disaster we experienced on 9-11.  Almost every American agreed, then, that we needed to retaliate against somebody.  The disaster was a gift to the warriors among us.  As we all know, this started with Afghanistan, then Iraq, even though none of the 9-11-01 perpetrators were associated with these countries.

I got involved, and was so involved for a number of years.  In a sense I still am involved, and will always be so, but not as active as early on.  Those who know me well know the rest of my story.

*

Tuesday Stephen and then JoAnn let me know that Marie Braun had died, apparently unexpectedly and quite suddenly.  She was 87 and legendary in the Twin Cities Peace and Justice community, active for over 40 years.

I had my longest involvement with Marie and her husband John from 2006-08, when we and a half dozen others planned and carried out the major Peace Island Conference in St. Paul.  We essentially met weekly to plan what turned out to be a very successful event.  Here is a period photo of Marie and John, from July 23, 2007.

John and Marie Braun July 23, 2007

John died Nov 28, 2018.  He was always a partner of Marie.  He is remembered here.

The celebration of Marie’s life will be at St. Joan of Arc, Minneapolis, on Thursday, July 7 at 11 a.m.  Visitation at 10, and lunch after.  A memory of Marie can be read here.

 

The next day,  I joined a Zoom conversation featuring Frank Kroncke and Chuck Turchick, of the Minnesota Eight, both activists in the anti-draft times of the Vietnam War.

The entire one hour conversation can be watched here.  Scroll down to Frank Kroncke.

(This site is also access to the documentary, The World Is My Country, the story of WWII peace activist Garry Davis, well worth your time if you have not seen the film.)

At the Minnesota Eight link, there is also an 8-minute link to Fr. Harry Bury, still an activist in his 90s, and then pastor at the University of Minnesota Newman Center, remembering the Vietnam years.   Fr. Bury in recent times has been the inspiration behind Twin Cities Nonviolent, an annual 10 days dedicated to non-violence around September 21.  Here’s this years plans for 2022, thus far.  Check back.

*

I wasn’t active in the peace movement at the time of Frank Kroncke – I met him only in recent years.  I knew Marie, and she and I were not necessarily on the same page in how to approach the issue of Peace – her gig was anti-war; mine was more pro-peace.  In my mind, there is a difference.  People can disagree on specifics, but be in concert on the objective.  It’s part of living.  Marie richly deserves the accolades she will certainly receive this week.  She showed up….  And so did Frank, and Chuck, and Harry and Robert, and endless others, including today.

*

This brings the aforementioned Catholic “Synod on Synodality”  which you may find of interest even if not Catholic.  Many of those listed above were Catholic, and Catholics have always been central to issues of peace and justice.

The Catholic Church is an immense international entity and as a lifelong Catholic I can assure anyone that its membership is not cookie-cutter.  It is as subject to the current American tribalism as any other group.  People come and go, as do pastors and hierarchy, etc.  Nonetheless there is constant effort to paint with a broad brush what the Catholic Church is or is not; who controls what, or does not.

The world-wide Catholic Synod began in 2021, worldwide.  Personally, I haven’t participated – unless writing this connotes participation.

A few days ago my friend, Kathy, on the west coast, sent a summary document from an independent group who participated in a discussion by the process suggested.

Except for removing the specific description of the group and named persons, I am offering this “synthesis” as I received it: Synodality Synthesis June 2022.  (The only mention of “war” is #11 in Hopes and Dreams on the last page.  In #11 of “obstacles, the group reports on the what I agree is the reality of today’s Catholic Church: “…those who have left the Church are the second largest denomination in the U.S….”)

*

About the photo which leads this blog: The Nekoma Pyramid.

Some additional photos of/about Marie Braun.

Marie at meeting of Minnesota Alliance of Peacemakers Oct. 9, 2007, speaker Dr. Michael Klein from University of St. Thomas.

Marie speaking at a planning meeting for Minnesota Alliance of Peacemaker Nov. 9, 2010.  A dozen of us were talking about the future of our organization, which still exists in 2022.

Kathy Kelly and group Peace walk from Chicago to St. Paul August 29, 2008, Woodbury MN.  Marie worked closely with Kathy (in middle front row) on this project.

Personal observation:  By no means is the Peace and Justice movement dead, though my generation is passing on, and the situations to confront and the advocates of a new generation.

Then was the War in Vietnam; now Ukraine with all its deadly complexities….

I’m long enough with the Peace Movement to know that the road to peace is a very long slog, not amenable to simple solutions, if to solutions at all, rife with complexities not easily overcome.

As I write, the U.S. is heavily engaged in the Ukraine.  This is an extraordinarily difficult situation, with no simple solution; the Ukrainian people caught in the deadly middle; others of us dealing with other dilemmas: what to do when a peaceful nation is invaded by a neighbor attempting to claim it as its own; in the process upsetting a fragile international stability; and facing individuals with sacrifices they didn’t expect, such as high gasoline prices, and on and on and on.

(I’ve contributed another $100 to the Ukraine cause, this time here, featured on the July 3 NBC special presentation.)

Martin Luther King made famous the phrase “the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice“.  As we know, that arc is, indeed, very long, unsmooth and uncertain.  The natural tendency is to give up when success seems out of reach.

So might be said about peace, which is a twin of justice.

In my daily walk in life, I see a nation, indeed a world, of people who live in peace.  But my media conveys another story, and the political conflict seems to indicate that we are at war with each other.  Peace is far more popular than War; War gets all the attention….

Best we can do is to find ways that we can work together on a common goal towards a better world.  This absolutely requires compromise.

When I look at the pictures included with this post, all taken by myself, I see lots of people very much committed to peace.  Most of them are now deceased.  This does not mean, by any means, that the movement is dead.  But those of us who remain need to regroup and reassess how best to continue towards a goal which will probably never be reached.

I am a founding member of another group, The U.S. Peace Memorial Foundation.  And I would encourage your membership.  Details are here.  The Memorial is a positive aspiration.

Sep 1, 2008, St. Paul MN

COMMENTS (more at end)

from Brian:  Good stuff–interesting to read.

A question for you:  my friends in Germany are calling Pres. Biden a “neocon” because by helping Urkaine he’s supporting war and the US has had so stupid many of these.   What is your opinion about Biden and helping Ukraine militarily?   I’m for it, but I can also argue the other side and say let’s avoid a bigger war…

from Claude:  I remember during one of my business trips to the far end of North Dakota going out of my way to see the truncated pyramid in Nekoma. Years ago the Strib had an article on. It was only operational for about two weeks before it was closed down as part of the treaty with Russia limiting the very low frequency radio communications with submarines around the world (if I remember correctly). The local county and especially the small town of Nekoma had made all kinds of road improvements and expansion of sewage in anticipation of this permanent base that would bring federal dollars into the area for decades to come. But it was all over in two weeks. This was and is to me a perfect example of how our defense economy distorts and wastes limited resources.

Years before that visit in the fall of 1974 I interviewed with Morrison Knutson at the job site of the then under-construction landing strip at Cape Kennedy. During that three hour interview the interviewer made mention of this North Dakota pyramid that he himself had worked on. It was designed that way in order to withstand a direct nuclear hit as communications with our submarines would surely have been on the top list of targets the Russians had.

Fast forward to 2006 and my one and only trip Kazakhstan, I visited the glass pyramid in Astana as the capitol of the country was then called. It was and I believe is still used for a once every two year religious conference of faiths “of the book” (Hindus, Buddhists, Animists need not apply) that was organized by the “moderate” dictatorship. So the pyramid in the middle of Asia (Eurasia? You decide after looking at a globe) is dedicated to religion and the pyramid in the middle of the North American continent is dedicated to doomsday. Hmmm…

This just goes to show you that even if your readers don’t read every line of what you write, there are connections being made and insights shared with every post.

Thank for all you do, Dick,

from Jane:     Ironic that Independence Day this year falls on Day 837 of the Lock-Down!  Enjoy the fireworks.

response from Dick: Jane and I are friends.  She’s out-of-the-park progressive but (apparently) a contrarian on the approach to Covid-19.  So it goes.

25

Tuesday a young White House Aide and ketchup dripping on a wall in the Presidents dining room at the White House became famous (or infamous) depending on individual spin.

Here’s Heather Cox Richardson’s report on the two hour hearing (which I watched, as I have watched all of the hearings thus far).  Her June 29 has more, here.

The news was filled all week with the implication of the Aide’s testimony (I’m purposely not including her name).

The Jan. 6 hearings are not random events.  The following ones, I’m sure, will bring forth more and more evidence even closer to the ex-President.  The phrase “you can run, but you can’t hide” comes to mind.

*

Much is made in some quarters of the Aide’s youth, and that hers was a relatively low level position, just getting started.  In short, she wasn’t very important.  On the other hand, she obviously had passed the political litmus test, and was talented, and she was officed (albeit tiny) very close to the ‘scene of the crime’.  And, apparently, she couldn’t be bought off.

I strongly endorse the televised hearing strategy.  We are a society addicted to tv programming.

I especially noted the Aide’s age, which was said to be “25” – in other words, just a kid.

For me, “25” resonated.  Just yesterday I was looking at a photo of me at 25:

Christmas 1965, Valley City North Dakota, Tom and Dick Bernard

I had turned 25 about 7 months before.  Tom is my son, was not yet two.  (Last birthday he was 58.)

On the wall behind us is a picture of Tom’s mother, Barbara, when she was a little girl.  Five months earlier, Barbara had died at University Hospital in Minneapolis at age 22.  Kidney disease.

I had just turned 25.

At 25, I was truly just a kid, college, two years in the Army, two years of teaching under my belt.  It seemed significant at the time.

But just two years earlier, there was no conceivable way I could have predicted the two years ahead.

*

For the Aide, for every one who’s reached and passed 25, there are infinite variations on my own personal story.

Odds are that she will do very well, though all seems tumultuous at this moment in her own personal history.

I invite you to think back to when you were 25, and forward to today.  Most likely, your road hasn’t always been paved, straight and picturesque in perfect weather!

I’m reminded of “The Station”, which I’ve shared often at this space and in other places.  Here it is, again: The Station001

 

Items.

The headline for this blog does not do the job, but I can’t think of another that would fit.  Suffice: there is plenty going on, and more to come.  While you’re hopefully enjoying summer, take some time to get really engaged in the future of our society.  Several items follow which might be of interest and/or cause some personal reflection.  Personally, I will be out of state July 5-8.

PRE-NOTE: Just announced this afternoon a Jan. 6 Hearing tomorrow (Tuesday June 28) at noon Central time.  This was not in the regular schedule.

*

There have been two  recent posts I hope you visit and at least note:

  1.  Post 5th January 6 hearing here, including several comments from readers added on Jan. 26.
  2.  Comments re Roe v Wade decision here.

*

I have read two new books this summer which I believe deserve your time, regardless of where you live.

3.  Essays on the Future of North Dakota: The Language of Cottonwoods by Clay Jenkinson.

4. Frances Anne Hopkins, Hudson’s Bay Company wife, Voyageur’s Artist by Mary Ellen Weller.

Essays on the Future of North Dakota: If you have roots in North Dakota, or know someone who has, the Clay Jenkinson book is well worth your/their time, and excellent background for bookclub kind of discussion.  The book is near 400 pages and the author is North Dakotan.  The book is meant as food for discussion.  It is readily available through many sources.

Michael Jacobs Forward gives a good introduction to the book: Jenkinson Language of Cottonwoods

Frances Anne Hopkins….Voyageur’s Artist: Mary Ellen Weller has done a masterful biography on the life of an essentially unknown woman artist whose art has been very well known for years.  Witness the cover of the definitive book on the Voyageurs.  It is the work of Frances Anne Hopkins.

Frances Ann Hopkins art.

Mary Ellen’s work is the culmination of a 30 year project.  As she describes it, 30 years ago she was at the Minnesota Historical Society to find some art for her cabin up north.   She purchased several Hopkins prints that were being sold as posters.  Mary Ellen asked about the artist, and no information was available.  She researched at the local library, and there was no biography available.  Thus began her quest to fill in the life story of this wife of a Hudson’s Bay Company official who spent about 10 years in Montreal in the mid-1800s, actually after the Voyageur era.  But the Voyageurs and their area caught Ms Hopkins, and the rest if history, and very interesting history it is.

I told Mary Ellen, who’s a colleague and friend, that I’m an unlikely fan of art.  In college, Art Appreciation earned me a “D”.  Of course, kids grow up, and I did, but nonetheless, it took a little while to get into the book, and then I was all in.

Mary Ellen, a retired teacher of French at high school and college level, has done an extraordinarily thorough research of her subject who comes to life in the book.

I think the book would be a good addition to any gift shop at any art museum or bookstore, and I wish Mary Ellen the greatest success.

5.  In Minnesota, Primary election voting is now open.  The actual Election Day is August 9.  There are important issues in this election.  More information here.  Click on the box “What’s on my ballot?” if not certain of issues in your area.

 

Roe v. Wade

Yesterday’s decision by the Supreme Court is now history.

Personally, I have been on record about a woman’s right to choose for many years.  It is based on personal experience in 1965.  Use the search word “abortion” if interested in more at this blog site.

In “Death Wish” on June 8, I made my prediction: “The so-called ‘life’ constituency is in the 50th year of Roe v. Wade and they want it gone, and they think they’ll succeed.  In the long run, their campaign has already failed.  Not everybody, not even a majority, supports getting rid of the protections for women’s rights given through Roe v Wade.  They will never rid the world of abortion, in fact they might increase it, albeit more dangerously.  Whatever the ultimate words, the ruling will be analyzed endlessly.  It is expected probably the end of June.”

I have three observations, in an attempt to contribute constructively to this conversation. 

First, within the last month a situation has  come up within my own general sphere of notice, which seems very pertinent to the issue of Choice.  Because it is a private matter I have to be very circumspect, and decline to fill in many blanks.  You can fill in the blanks.

A young woman we know is pregnant, by choice, “out of wedlock”  as the saying goes.  She is adult, over 21.  This was with the agreement of the father-to-be.  They apparently agreed to co-parent the child, who has recently been determined to be a girl.  Most recently, the male has changed his mind.  There is no talk of abortion, but you can imagine how the issue plays out in the mother-to-be’s constellation.

All I can envision is an extremely rough road ahead, especially for the to-come baby.  Where will the support system be, particularly from the sanctity of life crowd, when push inevitably will come to shove?

I could add lots of pieces, but choose not to.  This is not going to be a simple deal, for anyone.

[POSTNOTE July 1, 2023: Recently I read an interesting column by an unsuccessful pro-life candidate for MN Governor on the topic of life policy.  It is here, and worth your time: Jensen Star Tribune June 28 2023.  The baby referred to is now six months old, and there is much to add to this story, but not public, except to say that this conversation is essential between people on all sides of this issue.]

*

Second, I have a bit of advice to those in my constituency, which is the “woman’s right to choose” group, and I pose an example from my own career.

Given: Roe v. Wade is a game perceived as one side won v. the other side lost.

Years ago – it was 1974 – a group of which I was Executive Director was challenged by a competing group which was  smaller, but very aggressive.  At stake was the right to represent well over 1,000 employees in a collective bargaining state.  The employees were spread about in numerous building units, basically isolated from each other.

As the majority, responsible for outcomes, we were vulnerable, and the minority used all of the tactics available at the time to amplify our vulnerabilities.

Each piece of paper that came from them, we answered.  This simply resulted in the next piece of paper on another issue.  We were constantly put on the defensive.

One day came the piece of paper that figuratively “broke the camel’s back”.  It was the last straw….

Somebody – possibly it was me, though I don’t recall that – decided enough was enough, and at that instant we decided to go on offense, rather than stay on the defensive.

Sure, we weren’t perfect – the grass could be shown to be greener, comparing us with some other place.  We were accountable, but given the local circumstances we had always represented the people well…and they knew it.

Not too long after that came the actual election.

It was a landslide, over 60% in our favor, if I recall.  It surprised us; it surprised our competitor even more.  The people had spoken.

My advice to the Freedom of Choice crowd: go, and stay, on offense, however you define the term.  You have the high ground, as viewed by the massive majority of your colleague Americans.

It will be a lot of work, but you’re up to it.

*

Finally, don’t lose perspective.

At the moment, the extreme Pro-Life faction appears to have won.  Yesterday’s win can be a pyrrhic victory for them.  I always think of how the successful campaign to make booze illegal failed, from the beginning of its legal success.  Yes, a different issue, different time, but the same kind of problem.

Best I know, the pure pro-life had more public support in the beginning they have now.  To “win” required polarization – dividing us into tribes, where for one side to win, the other had to lose.  Theirs was a take-no-prisoners approach.  No compromise.  You won’t hear it from them, but now they’re terrified.  Why else would they move to make it harder for the other side to vote, as they’ve successfully moved in any state where they’re politically in charge?

My church, the Catholic Church, is probably a good example of the quandary.  (Four of the five Justices who threw out Roe v Wade are Catholics.) In the years of this battle, in which the Catholic hierarchy has been at the forefront, the actual church membership has been divided in opinion, and the Church has lost many, both in terms of members and support.  None of this it would admit, but there are fewer in the pews, and probably less in the collection plate.  For the time being, the slack can be taken by wealthy conservatives, but that doesn’t last.

I see this, first hand.  I’ll be in church tomorrow morning.  I see it each time I go.

I am pro-choice, and I respect life deeply.  I think I am typical among those I know who are similarly pro-choice.

*

In the short and long term it is unproductive to everyone to lurch from one side winning, to the other – it just becomes a constant losing narrative for both.

In the short term, regardless of your partisan preference, there is probably no choice other than to work to elect the more moderate people to office at all levels.  To do this, not only do you have to vote, but to vote for the most moderate candidate.  It is probably the only way to get back some equilibrium.  Absent that, we will all have problems ongoing.  We will all lose.

POSTNOTE: At Basilica on Sunday there was not one word about the Supreme Court ruling.  Of course, the ruling was only two days earlier.  I expect more in the Diocesan newspaper (not on-line) about the official church spin.  I get the newspaper, and when it comes, I’ll pdf the article and post it here.  This may be as soon as Wednesday.

 

Jan. 6 Hearings 4, 5 and 6

UPDATE on June 28 hearing in the comments section.  Included below the Heather Cox Richardson Letters from an American for June 28.  Richardson is ideal for reading every day, if interested in public affairs.

*

Hearings 4 on June 21, 5 on June 23, and 6 on June 28  were especially powerful.  As with the others, I watched them in their entirety.

I expect to not publicize this post until June 26, specifically related to the Porter item, below.

Here are excellent summaries of June 21: Heather Cox Richardson’s Letters from an American for June 21; Digby’s Hullabaloo for June 22 (this includes several posts).       Here is an additional comment: Lady Ruby

For June 23, also Heather Cox Richardson, for June 23.

For June 28, also Heather Cox Richardson, for June 28.

These hearings, all of them, including those in coming weeks, are the hard evidence of the insanity we’ve had to live through in recent years.  They are ignored at our individual peril.

I have additional opinions, too, but will save them for a bit later.

In the interim: June 21, before the Hearing, I saw an e-mail from a reader who went to the same college as I, at the same time in history.  He forwarded a forward by a John Porter, and I’d like to share it with you, and invite your personal comments to the writing, which is overtly political.

The forward is here: Porter June 2022.  The hi-liting is mine.  At this moment, I have made no effort to find out who Porter is, etc.  I’m sharing it exactly as received.

I’d be delighted to hear your thoughts, which I can share as comments here.  (I have already passed it along to a number of regular readers who seem to have an interest in political matters, thus there will be several comments already received included here.  I will add these comments on June 26.)

POSTNOTE Sunday, afternoon June 26, 2022

Regarding the “John Porter” letter referenced above: June 23, I sent the above to a number of friends who I thought would be interested, and several responded (see below, and at end of the post).  I made an effort to find out who “John Porter” is – it’s a common name, and it’s unwise to accept at face value anything attributed to anybody.  There were some possibilities, but I couldn’t say for certain who the writer really is.  What I can say for certain is the language that is used in the letter is language I’ve seen in various forms, always from people who pretty obviously have been taught to despise the very word “democrat” and its variations, and cherish the opposing word “republic”.  The words are all that is important.  Whether based on fact or fiction is of no relevance.   Examples abound: Just yesterday the Governor of Mississippi praised the recent Supreme Court decision in behalf of the “God-fearing” people of his state; on the same day I received the Porter letter, the Secretary of State of Arizona, at the 4th hearing on Jan. 6, talked about his church’s belief that the Constitution is divinely inspired.  In his case, thankfully, the Secretary of State supported the interpretation of the Constitution about elections.  And I could go on and on.

Here, with thanks, are the other opinions offered on Porter and the issues raised.

from Joyce: This is about 3 1/2 minutes long, and well worth watching; it is an excellent response to those 6 annoying words, “we’re a republic, not a democracy”. Of course we’re a democracy.

from Peter: My reading of Mr. Porter’s statement is: he’s beating a long-dead horse.

“Wilderness continent” was never the case, just as it was never the case in Palestine when it was called “a land without people for a people without land.”

An “economic common market” was indeed the plan. Monarchy was already obsolete as far as the colonists were concerned. They wanted to pursue conquest and and slavery on their own and keep the profits.

It was a long time before the Bill of Rights applied to anybody other than the white landlords. It still does not extend to everyone, and business considerations determine individual rights for huge chunks of the population.

The nuances of language, “Republic,” “Democracy,” “Socialism,” etc. may once have had some meaning. But the present structure of our government is Fascism: government is at the mercy of corporate investment. If any legislator is told an idea will “send jobs overseas,” that idea will go no further. This is called “Capital Strike” (see “Levers of Power”)

This explains why no president or justice or legislator ever considers moving against the colossal war machine that serves the arms, drugs, and energy industries (today’s version of the Triangular Trade system).

The public has been short-changed as to health care, housing, education, and employment, to the point of serious food insecurity at unprecedented scale. We’re starving and freezing in front of our screens, which are blaming this on Russia and China. Momentum in this awful direction is still accelerating. Fixing the public misperception of democracy will make no difference whatsoever.

What will make a difference? This is a deep question with complex implications. For one thing our minds are very different today, now that communications networks have become an attention-extraction industry in themselves. But this was not possible without connecting human beings to each other, while ensnaring us in the behavioral data-mining system.

This enormous expansion of human relationships, across continents and even language barriers, especially with the advent of cheap videoconferencing software, has brought a paradigm change so profound, it’s as if we had driven the car into the canal. We’re stepping on the brakes at this point, while the water rises up the windows, but we may catch on quickly to a new way of being in this new world. Maybe we will return to our real relationship to the biosphere we’re currently destroying forever.

The boundaries of community have exploded, and secrecy (never mind privacy) is about to disappear altogether. We are all about to be rendered naked for all practical purposes.

If humanity is going to survive, the change is already well underway, and nobody alive can possibly comprehend it, because it is not an extension of anything that ever happened before.

One thing is certain. Congress, the Judiciary, and the Executive in their present form have been dysfunctional and obsolete for years. We have already moved on.

from Fred: Good to see James Reed’s [below] studied reaction to this fallacious drivel. I would add that the founding fathers were not in fear of the terrors of socialism and the mob when they created the Constitution. Monarchs, as they well knew, had pretty tight reign in Europe. Socialism didn’t really gather steam until the French Revolution broke out in 1789. French patriots overthrew their ruler, wrote a Constitution and established the nation’s First Republic. American leaders, at least the landed gentry, might have been pretty nervous over the later Reign of Terror, but they had already agreed on a Constitution.

 French lost their Republic to Napoleon. The flame of freedom flared into mid-1800s revolutions against European monarchies. Those uprisings didn’t work out, but the US got more than a few new immigrants and some revolutionaries after the failure to overthrow monarchs.
And the French eventually got rid of Napoleon and Second and Third Republics came along. Hitler finished off the Third Republic, then came the Fourth Republic (post-WW2 govt.) and today’s Fifth. The French are big on being part of a Republic. All this proves, through undeniable syllogistic logic and to Mr. Porter’s joy, that US and French have exactly the same form of government.
*

from Jeff: The gun decision will be probably overcome in states that are supportive of sound gun safety by new legislation defining places that concealed guns are not allowed.

The big news of course is the overturning of Roe v Wade.  Interestingly TFG thinks that this decision will be bad for Republicans in Swing and Purple states as suburban women will rebel against Republican candidates… you might see this as well in statewide places like Montana, Alaska, and Kansas where personal independence is a big deal….the hard red states are mostly secure.
The danger in this remains the whittling away of the 14th Amendment…though Alito’s majority opinion says this only applies to abortion,  Clarence Thomas’ concurring opinion clearly draws a direct line to allowing states to set their own rules on same sex relationships and marriages, contraception, and by extension I dont see how a state couldn’t logically ban interracial marriage if it wanted to…it isn’t any different in theory as these are all personal privacy issues.
So on Thursday the same majority took away the rights of states to some extent to make their own rules on gun safety, whereas on Friday it returned the right to discriminate against women’s control of their own bodies back to the states.  Clarence Thomas may be black ,but this is another step in the white patriarchy dominionist movement.
It will be interesting to see how the Catholic Church in America reacts… I mean the institutional church. Will this make the more conservative bishops more emboldened to deny communion to politicians and public figures who support choice in their states?
*

from Norm: I scanned Porter’s diatribe against representative democracy and have no interest in commenting beyond saying that is disappointing and a bit disillusioning to read that tripe from a fellow American.

Clearly, he agrees with the man child who would be king in thinking that American should be governed by an authoritarian cabal of some sort no doubt to make sure that “those” people with “those ideas” about self-government are not in charge and/ordo not have any say in how the government is run.

Porter sort of meets the description of some of the Proud Boys and others made by someone regarding the January 6th attempted coup hearings That is, that they are just little boys who cannot get girls!

Not worth my time to comment any further!

Again, knowing that thanks to the man child who would be king, too many people seem to agree with that kind of thinking and are ready and willing to give up on democracy!

Very disillusioning!

from Dick: The above comments were individually and independently made.  Additionally I had commented back to the person who forwarded the Porter piece to me in the first place.  I appreciate receiving the Porter piece.  It is very much the same as many other forwards I used to receive (not so much any more).  “Facts” were often not facts at all, just an exercise of someone’s creative writing.

I will correctly be identified as an active Democrat, “moderate, pragmatic” as I self-identify.  Everyone who knows me well, especially politically, [knows] that my political hero and indeed mentor was lifelong Republican and former Governor of Minnesota.  He died a dozen years ago, and he would absolutely be horrified by the current state of affairs in what passes for todays Republican Party.  I knew him well.  Todays Republicans are not Republican in any historical sense.
The words in Porter’s column were very obvious: Republicans are the good guys, men, founders of the Republic, God-fearing….  Democrats most relate to [are equated with] socialists, mobs, even Communist and Marxist, mobocracy.  You can read it in his column.  Democrat, symbolized by the Clintons, is the government mob.
I know lots of Democrats for lots of years.   If the labelling were not so horrible, it would be funny.  I know this myth has been cultivated for years, and believed, even if ridiculous.
*
POSTNOTE June 28, 2022:  I watched the two hours today.  The only witness was Cassidy Hutchinson, a young but obviously highly competent and loyal republican staff member who, in the time period of Jan. 6 and before, was officed in the West Wing near the Oval Office and the office of Mark Meadows.
*
Jim Klein (comment below) is critical of the made-for-tv aspect of these hearings.  I disagree.  For one thing, what is being established by the hearings themselves is a permanent public record which will last far beyond the hearings themselves, and regardless of what’s done or not done by the Department of Justice.  More importantly, the hearings are specifically designed to attract and hold the interest of the public who, in these times, is addicted to TV programs and communication by tweet.  In my opinion, the format, etc., is designed for todays audience.  It would not have been available in the 1970s, and not understood by the then-public.