#771 – Dick Bernard: Heritage. The Parish Picnic

NOTE TO SUBSCRIBERS AND FREQUENT VISITORS TO THIS SITE. PLEASE SEE NOTE AT THE END OF THIS POST.
Enroute to Mass at Basilica of St. Mary this morning, Cathy, my wife, told me that the annual parish picnic was today. That was news to me, though I usher at the Church. But they’re always fun.
Along the way we chatted about parish picnics we had known: me in rural North Dakota, and she in St. Paul.
They had common elements, these picnics: “potluck” meals (“bring a dish to share”), games for kids, and for adults, like the ever-popular cake walk; maybe somebody playing some music. “A good time was had by all” would be a usual and accurate descriptor.
I thought of one particular photo from my past: the only picture I know of from a parish picnic, at St. Elizabeth’s in Sykeston, North Dakota, probably from 1959, when the new Church was about completed. Here is the photo:
(click on photos to enlarge)

Sykeston ND, on the St. Elizabeth school grounds, circa 1959

Sykeston ND, on the St. Elizabeth school grounds, circa 1959


One of the ladies was holding, along with the Nun, something brought to the event. It could have been a cake. Something was heating in the pot. One of the ladies was wearing a hat – in those days, most of the ladies wore hats, all of them inside the Church, that’s for sure!
But the whole essence was community togetherness, relationship building over a hotdish, or a piece of cake or pie.
Cathy mentioned “Booyah”, something I never heard of out on the prairie but which is still a staple at big gatherings particularly in these parts of Minnesota and Wisconsin.
Some years ago I had occasion to look up the history of “Booyah”, and this is what I found. You’re never exactly sure what you’re going to get in a dish of Booyah, but it is likely to be pretty good!
Today’s event was more downtown big city, as one would expect at a major church on a major downtown Minneapolis street, but the principles are exactly the same. Get people together, often strangers (as we met today), and let people get to know each other over a casual meal.
For us, today, it meant meeting a young lawyer and Delta Air Lines ticketing agent and their three year old son who hailed from Louisiana and North Carolina respectively, and met in New Orleans several years ago, and now live in North Minneapolis. We had a great visit.
For us it was Famous Dave’s today, and not Booyah, but what difference does it make? It was a great time in the city!
Basilica Parish Picnic September 8, 2013

Basilica Parish Picnic September 8, 2013


Famous Dave's dishes up the goodies at Basilica September 8, 2013

Famous Dave’s dishes up the goodies at Basilica September 8, 2013


NOTE TO SUBSCRIBERS AND OTHER VISITORS TO THIS BLOG:
As blogs go, mine is very active, varied, and probably fairly small in readership. But I am always surprised by now many people actually stop by, and particularly comment, on one topic or another. A recent example is the Syria post of September 3, which would mostly be seen at the time it is published, but to which later comments have been added. This happens frequently.
In addition, over the history of this blog, I have found myself quite without intending beginning informal series on a particular topic. For instance, this is at least the 8th post in recent years specifically relating to some aspect of “heritage”. A very major current issue for me is the situation with the Minnesota Orchestra. Etc.
With this post, I am going to work harder to connect blogs of like topics, and to simply suggest to everyone who is a reader to bookmark some topic in which they might have an interest, so that they can check back once in awhile to see if there are additional comments.
This blog began as an experiment. It has sufficient history now to be a bit better organized.
Here are some topics. If there are several posts on a topic, the post highlighted below is more-or-less the index blog, from which all other related posts are linked. There are a number of other series, but most of these are on issues which have come and gone.
Thanks for checking in.
Matters relating to French-Canadians and French in America (September 1, 2012, a starter site for a planned French-American Heritage Foundation website)
Heritage (Oct 5, 2011, 1st of several)
Mary Ann Mahers Peace Corps Experience in Vanuatu South Pacific (Nov. 10, 2012, a continuing blog of Mary Ann’s experiences)
Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out (Aug 30, 2013, is anchor post. A major ongoing issue since October, 2012.)
On Growing Older, (May 5, 2013, and continuing in other posts.)
Remembering Sykeston ND (May 4, 2013, several posts linked from the original post)
United Nations Flag Issue at Hennepin Co MN (March 27, 2013, ongoing issue)
Valley City State Teachers College Memories late 1950s early 1960s (Jan 2, 2013, all related are linked within this post)

#768: Dick Bernard: Heritage. An Enchanting Evening at La Farm

Sunset August 31 was 8:02 p.m. CDT in rural Ashby MN. At that time I went outdoors to try to catch the moment in a snapshot:
(click to enlarge any photo)

Sunset at La Farm, August 31, 2013

Sunset at La Farm, August 31, 2013


(A small album of additional photos is on Facebook, here.)
Behind me, indoors in the small farm house, now a home and retreat place for family members, Patty Kakac, Anne Dunn and friends were presenting an enchanting “Grandmother Voices” concert. The “house” audience was only 18 of us, and it had taken us 7 hours, to and from, to get to the show, but it was an awesome and inspiring evening. Patti sang, and Anne shared fascinating stories. Part of me wished that the whole world could experience what we were experiencing; the other part of me, selfishly, reveled in the special time for just the few of us.
Both women perform gently, from the heart, taking their listeners into the subject of their song and story. They are serious and they are humorous, and their new show is a blend of two styles and different traditions. Except for my short trip outdoors to catch the sunset, I was enthralled, and I think the same could be said for those of us in the farm house living room.

(You can hear Patti sing in this YouTube segment. On occasion,
Anne Dunn has written for this blog. Links for Apr 12, 2009, May 3, 2009, Dec 13, 2012, Jul 18, 2013 are here. In 2000, she was the person behind Whispering Tree, a CD for school children which may still be available in some libraries.)
We all had an additional and unanticipated special treat on Saturday night.
Enroute to La Farm, a short distance west of Alexandria on I-94, we were slowed by a powerful thunderstorm with high winds and traffic-stopping rain. Since our destination was to the west, we called to inquire about the weather there. Indeed, the powerful thunderstorm had passed their way, earlier.
On the country road to the farm a downed tree nearly blocked our path, and in the yard, we were told that the power was out.
So, we watched the concert, from 7-9 p.m. in the dimming light of the sunset streaming through the window behind the performers. And then dusk, and then dark. Out came the candles, and the last of the concert was in the dark.
For me, and I think for the others too, the separation from electricity only enhanced the evening.
La Farm house reminded me of my Grandparents pioneer house in North Dakota: originally a very small rectangular house with downstairs and upstairs, with later add-ons like kitchen, bathroom, bedrooms…. Sharon Henneman, a grandchild of the original La Farm inhabitants, shared this story about the house and home: La Farm – a story remembered
Grandpa was a farmhouse fiddler, good enough to have a small band for neighborhood dances “back in the day”. From about 1927, the whole family gathered around the piano in the living room to sing songs.
Back then, there was no electricity, no interventions by man, other than lamps. There was no thought of power outages. The weather was as it was.
It was nice to experience, in a sense, the good old days Saturday night in the living room at La Farm.
I wish I could transmit last night to all to you. I can’t.
Maybe you have your own memories of similar days of old.
(Enroute home, about 11:00, a message came to us and others: the power is back on. Somehow, it was anti-climactic. That power outage was really an addition to an already rich evening.)
NOTE: Patty Kakac can be reached at pattykakacATgmailDOTcom. Her phone 320-834-4445. (See Patty’s comment after the photos) I have her 1998 CD, Patchwork, which is wonderful. I think it is still available through her. It brings the old days to life, as she and Anne Dunn did again Saturday night.
Patty Kakac and Anne Dunn, a half hour before sunset.

Patty Kakac and Anne Dunn, a half hour before sunset.


Anne Dunn tells one of her stories.  Night has about fallen.

Anne Dunn tells one of her stories. Night has about fallen.


La Farm at Sunset, the original two story pioneer home essentially surrounded by later additions.  The "concert hall" was behind the glass doors at left.

La Farm at Sunset, the original two story pioneer home essentially surrounded by later additions. The “concert hall” was behind the glass doors at left.


As dusk approaches, the concert continues, soon in the dark!

As dusk approaches, the concert continues, soon in the dark!


from Patty Kakac, Sep 3, 2013: I am enjoying reading about the concert from out there in the audience. Your writings about going back to childhood days reminds me of the song I wrote for a play called “Playing with Memories”. We started writing the play by gathering elder people together to tell us of their memories. So many recited the very same thing you have about the music…someone with a fiddle, someone on a piano. So I wrote the song using that theme. My method of writing these sorts of songs is to simply go through the words the people say and fit them together, somewhat like putting a puzzle together. Here are the words to the song…thought you might enjoy them. I had thought about singing the song that night but there wasn’t time or place where it fit in.
Thank you for such a beautiful review.
(It’s a waltz)
PLAYING WITH MEMORIES – lyrics and music by Patty Kakac
Playing with Memories so I can recall
People and places I love most of all
And when shadows of life darken my day
Playing with Memories chase the dark clouds away
Mama cooking in the kitchen would sing
Sister in the parlor made the old piano ring
Soft, lacey curtains blowing in the breeze
These are a few of my memories
Papa would bring out the fiddle and bow
Neighbors would come as soon as they’d know
We’d push chairs and table against the wall
Turn the old farm house into a dance hall
I’ve loved you all the days since we first met
How you danced in my arms I’ll ne’er forget
I’ll cherish your love as long as I breathe
Forever I’ll hold you in my memories
Patty was responding to this comment to her, Anne Dunn and the hosts at La Farm by myself:
Saturday night keeps rattling around in my brain, and I need to let the thoughts out!
To be honest, if [our guest, Christine] had not been interested in going out the La Farm, we probably wouldn’t have gone. We’d heard Patty and Anne doing a preliminary version of their show the previous year at my sister Flo’s, and the six hour round-trip was not especially appealing.
But, we went, and the power went out, and it was one of the most singularly powerful evenings I’ve personally experienced.
And the storm and the power outage enhanced the experience.
Saturday night we basically experienced the old days going way back before things like electricity and modern conveniences like indoor toilets.
Back then, what came to La Farm, came, of course, just like Saturday, a storm came through. It could have been welcome, or it could have brought hail, or a tornado. It simply happened.
And there the people were, isolated, coping as best they could.
But then there was the concert.
I have done a great deal of family history, and as I said in the blog, my roots, particularly my mother’s side, was full of farm music.
So, here we sat in a dark room, lit by a couple of candles (secretly, I wished the LED lights would be turned off!), in a community of music.
Back in the olden days, I know from family and other stories, these country gatherings were primary recreational and social events.
There were dances in hay mows (the upstairs of barns); community halls, saloons, houses…wherever people could gather and somebody had a fiddle, or a piano, people passed the short time between work and dark (except in the summer) doing what was done Saturday night.
If the original part of that house could tell tales, it would probably remember such goings on from time to time. They’d be small and informal, but unless the home owners were anti-social, they’d be happening. And to survive out there, you had to have an element of being social – what if the barn burned down, or such.
Today we can (it seems) manage everything. Cell phones get us out of the house when the phones don’t work; we can watch perfect events in perfect color and high definition, with perfect sound systems without ever having to interact with another soul.
Saturday night, you were, in my opinion, in pioneer days, not only in Minnesota, but most everywhere else in the developing United States and Canada.
It was really a great privilege to be there.
I could go on and on.
Maybe some of those on the copy list could add more….
Thanks to everyone who made the evening possible.

#766 – Dick Bernard: Changing the Ways of Political Conversation

This column speaks of politics, but not about parties, or issues, or positions. Rather, it is about process. This relates, also, to the previous two posts. Regardless of your ideology, I’d encourage you to read on, and at least consider what follows.
Change in any long term habit is difficult.
I doubt there would be much disagreement with that statement.
People who appear to succeed in being change-agents have managed to get themselves in a position of sufficient power to move their followers (i.e. employees, subjects, etc) along. This can happen at any level, from the tiniest group to the largest. But, as they all come to learn, temporary power does not have permanence. Sooner or later they become irrelevant, hopefully not doing too much damage in the process of controlling outcomes.
Remembering August 28, 1963, and looking back at that awe-inspiring (or terrifying) event 50 years later, gives an opportunity to dust off a failed proposal I made in September, 2008. My proposal was met with yawns, then – at least I saw no perceptible results amongst the several hundred who I shared the proposal with, and they were mostly “birds of a feather”.
My “campaign” began in the Spring of 2007. I was President of an umbrella Peace and Justice organization which had about 70 member organizations even then. The organization still exists, and I’m still a member of it.
In April of 2007, I convened an ad hoc group of people I knew to meet and simply converse about the possibility of changing the way we promoted change (demonstrations, etc.) to something potentially more productive. Both energy and effectiveness were, in my judgement, flagging.
Ultimately, perhaps 15 folks showed up to talk, and we had a good conversation.
But when we left the room, it ended: a typical kind of scenario. As I say, change is difficult.
A year later, the spring of 2008, out of office, but still concerned about our drift towards irrelevancy, I thought up an experiment, which proposed to change how we might achieve a different result by using different means. Once again, I had sufficient folks to try the experiment, which, again, failed. I called it “each one, reach two”.
In September, 2008, about the time the Republican National Convention ended, I published the “failed proposal” I describe above. It remains permanently on the web, and you can find it by putting the words “Uncomfortable Essays” in the Search Box at my blogsite, Outside the Walls.org/blog. There, you’ll be re-directed to March 8, 2011. Click the link in the 3rd line, and read pages 3-7 about my failed idea. (There are two other references there. I also wrote about the idea on March 26, 2013.)
Succinctly, if you’re not interested in going to the links: what used to work, what we used to call “organizing”, doesn’t work as well as it used to for all sorts of reasons most every reader could recite. People and technology are different. What worked in my day, doesn’t work as well today.
But, because the old rules are what we understand, that is our first default position: to do things as we always did them. Power people are as susceptible as the rest, perhaps even more susceptible to ‘staying the course’. After all, what they did, used to work. …they “used to work”.
“Each one, reach two” was my attempt to move a little bit towards what I would call the strategy (or is it “tactic”?) of networking: “each one, reach two”.
It has awesome potential.
But it seems too slow, and (perhaps worst) it can careen out of control, for the initiator, who often wants to control the final outcome.
Networking works.
Why not give it a try at the beginning of these next 50 years?

#765 – Rosa, Joyce, Bill, Carol, Madeline, Jane, Jermitt, Jeff, John, Dick, Will, Peter: The March on Washington August 28, 1963, reflections by folks who weren't there, but were impacted, then and now.

Related Post: August 27, 2013
Highly recommended book (still in print): Why We Can’t Wait, by Martin Luther King, published 1964, about the year 1963.

Rosa, who was raised in Orangeburg SC and is old enough to remember Aug 28, 1963, remembers...

Rosa, who was raised in Orangeburg SC and is old enough to remember Aug 28, 1963, remembers…


PRE-NOTE: This is a very long post (about 10 times the length of a typical post at this space), but (in my opinion) worth your time and your own reflection on your place in the conversation about race and other matters in todays United States of America. There is a lot of content.
For certain, take the time to read the comments of Will S, who grew up in north Minneapolis and is a lifelong resident of the Twin Cities; and Peter B, who grew up primarily in Philadelphia and for some years now has been a rural resident – living on a farm – in New Hampshire. Their comments are last on this very long page.
You can learn both by reading and reflecting on what they have to say. Neither were at the march, but do they ever have stories!
August 28, 1963, an event whose end result was unknown (or unknowable) even to the organizers. took place on the National Mall near the Lincoln Memorial.
The news this week has focused on those who were actually there – I would guess the 1963 event directly involved only about one of every thousand Americans at the time. Still, it was an immensely successful event with great long term and positive ramifications for our country.
Today, President Obama apparently speaks from the spot of the 1963 speech. But, as seems always to be true, the real action of August 28, 1963, and after today, happens amongst the others – the remaining 999 of every 1000 – who are back home. People like us.
This blog is entirely comments by persons who weren’t on the Mall August 28, 1963, for one reason or another (you have to be at least 49 years old to have had even the possibility of being on that Mall Lawn, August 28, 1963.) What they have to say, in diverse ways, is very important.
They are simply friends, who I invited to make any comments they’d like to share, and a few ‘took the bait’, and here they are, the short ones first:
Joyce D, Aug 20, 2013: I was rather young at the time (12), but what I do remember is the demonization of the people involved in the march; my parents and their friends were liberals about many things, but not about race, and I remember their disgust at African Americans who “didn’t know their place”. I didn’t really find out what the civil rights movement was about until I went to college and met some African American students. I had tried arguing with my parents about race when I was a young teenager (I went to college at 16, so I was still quite young in high school) but I didn’t have the information to argue with them successfully; once I was in college, however, and getting to know African Americans, I was able to break away from my parents’ influence on race.
Here is a wonderful oral history from the Smithsonian:
From Bill K, Aug 20, 2013: Dick, Martin Luther King was a great, great American hero to me. In the mid-1940s I attended one of the two high schools in St. Paul where, thanks to some gerrymandering by the School Board, nearly all Black students attended. These schools were John Marshall High ( which I attended) and
Mechanic Arts High. Central High located on the western edge of the predominant housing area of most Black families was off limits to them.
It always amazed me when I heard the Black students in my classes sing the Star Spangled Banner with the words “the home of the free and the brave” or say the Pledge of Allegiance with words
“with Liberty and Justice for all” when so very much of this did not apply to their lives. What utter hypocrisy existed in those anthems then and for many years until the Civil Rights Movement of the mid-1950s and the 1960s. I have so much admiration for those who actively participated in their campaign. I do not think I would have been brave enough having a wife and 4 children at the time but many others both Black and White did. They too are heroes to me; however, Dr. King’s “I HAVE A DREAM” speech was the crowning high point of this movement for Liberty and Justice for all Americans!! To this day I still get misty eyed when I hear a replay of his speech.
Joyce D, Aug 24, 2013: In response to Bill Klein’s comments regarding recitation of the pledge, my friends and I recited the pledge in high school (it was required) but we when it came to the phrase, “with liberty and justice for all”, we substituted, “with liberty and justice for some”. Only we knew we had changed the words, but it was important to us.
from Carol T, Aug 25, 2013: To my eternal embarrassment, I was paying no attention. I had just married and I’m afraid was centered on myself and my life. I can relate to the person who said their prejudice was against Indians. I graduated from Brainerd [MN], but of course there were not Indians in my school as they were all on the “rez.” Not a Black person in sight there, either – and basically none in St. Cloud where I moved. They lived in somebody elses world.
I was working at the St. Cloud VA Hospital in Personnel. I got my introduction to how institutional prejudice worked when it was necessary to hire PT or OT personnel. The law said that we had to hire from the top seven available candidates (highest test scores) on the lists provided. The best candidates seemed to always be from the South. My boss would comb through the resumes for evidence of race, like attendance at a Black university. Those were out. If a phone call to them was not answered, then it was documented that they were unavailable and he’d slide on down the list. Once he was in an absolute quandary as everyone on the list appeared to be Black, so he’d have to hire one of “them.” The new OT (Mr. White) was a wonderful gentleman, and attended our church with his family.
from Madeline S, Aug 25, 2013: I cannot recall specifically what I was doing that summer, probably working, knowing I would return to a second year at the Fergus Falls Junior College. My parents watched the news, so, living at home, perhaps I saw the march and the speech. West central Minnesota, “at that time,” had little mention of race. There was one black family in Fergus when I was in high school and I recall asking my parents how they would feel if I dated their son. To their credit, it would give them no concern if I did. He was a good kid and involved like all others in high school activities. At the Junior College we had two black professors, one a PhD in Psychology. [Following] is an email from a classmate shows how things were regarding racism in that area earlier in the century.
from Jane (friend of Madeline): Here’s an article Negroes MN 1915002 from way back in time, 1915 that was published in the Battle Lake [MN]Review.
Mary found this in many of her sister Noel’s oldies but goodies pile of collectable papers. It took me a while to enlarge the print to make it legible.
Hope you can appreciate how most people have become a more united and embracing society to all human beings. When someone says that we should go back to how things were in the past, this is a horrific example how people treated others that were not like them.
from Jermitt K, Aug 26, 2013: Dick: Thanks for your request on memories regarding the great march on Washington. I remember watching and listening to the presentations while on campus at the University of South Dakota. I was working toward my Master’s Degree in Botany. I was very interested in Dr. Martin Luther King’s presentation. I had met Dr. Martin Luther King three years earlier at a church conference in Florida. So I followed most of his activities from that time forward. His “I Have a Dream” speech had a very deep and emotional impact on me. While I was already teaching economically depressed children at the time, I made a commitment to continue working with children of all races who were struggling because of burdens of poverty, either directly or indirectly. I hope that I have been able to fulfill this commitment.
from Jeff P, Aug 26, 2013: I was 9 years old. I vaguely remember that, the big thing in my memory [President Kennedy Assassination] would come in November. I was in 3rd grade I think at St Sebastian school, we got let off for the day… sad days for those nuns.
from John B, Aug 28, 2013:You asked your blog readers about their recollections of the MLK I have a dream speech:
I am pretty sure I didn’t see the original MLK speech in August, 1963. I was beginning my first year at Saint Olaf College. I had likely just arrived on campus and nobody had TV sets. If I hadn’t been moved by the speech when I later heard about it, I have since, many times. It was a little hard to get whipped up about a speech, as I had already been whipped up in years earlier at a much more personal level.
All my heroes in my high school days were jazz musicians, especially Miles Davis and J.J.Johnson and Charlie Mingus, just some of my ideals I had pictures of hanging from the walls of my bedroom, along side of white musicians Bob Brookmeyer and Gerry Mulligan. I knew of the racial struggles. I tended to support a more radical expression of racial justice like advocated by SNCC and later, Malcom X and the Black Panthers. In my last year in high school I was in a speech activity called “play reading” where I played the roll of Walter Younger in Loarraine Hansberry’s 1959 play, A Raisin in the Sun. A few years later the play was made into a movie starring Sidney Poitier and Ruby Dee. I got into the role. My teacher, Barbara Feldman, helped me do this through some memorable conversations. She also gave me a copy of an LP record of by Oscar Brown Jr., named Sin and Soul, which poetically told the tale of being a Negro in America pre MLK. Although predisposed to fight for the underdog, I have since realized, I will always root for the underdog. This trait, as you know me Dick, is part of who I am. It was like I was hard wired to be a union organizer.
I remember where I was and how I felt when MLK was murdered in 1968 or 1969. I can’t remember which year, but I was at the Plaza Bar in Madison after a rehearsal of the Madison Municipal Band. It was devastating news, another kick in the face in the 1960s. Yes, progress has been made. There is so much left to do.
from Dick Bernard, Aug 20, 2103: August 28, 1963, best as I can piece together, I was in an Army Division practicing war in the outback of South Carolina. We arrived at the Air Force Base in Greenville SC, and perhaps a couple of weeks later departed from Ft. Gordon near Augusta GA.
In between, we were playing war. I was a company clerk in an infantry company, nearing the end of my two years.
Maybe some of us knew it at the time, but what we were about was practicing for the Vietnam War, then just a gleam in somebody’s eye.
So, I have no recollections of any March on Washington D.C.
But I do have recollections of race in that time.
I was a North Dakotan, and in my youth “negroes” were essentially unknown to me, though by then the Air Force bases at Minot and Grand Forks had come into being. So far as I know, the Army was fully integrated in my time in the service (1962-63).
In North Dakota, the race of choice for us to discriminate against was the Indians (I am using the terms of the time) who were in reservations, and certainly not “equal” in any sense of the word. Years later, I was asked to talk about the business of race at my Church in St. Paul. I still have the notes from MLK Day, Jan 18, 1995: Dick B Jan 18, 1995 Race001 . Just a white guy talking about race to a congregation with many African-Americans….
There are some recollections from South Carolina in the summer of 1963.
1. Most dramatic personal memory was in Saluda SC where, for some reason, we had some liberty time – a few hours, perhaps – in a town. I recall a laundromat, there, with a “colored” entrance which one could reach only by going in an outside door, in what we’d call the basement.
2. In the boondocks we came across a long deserted plantation house, looked sort of like the antebellum pictures you see, but in advanced state of deterioration.
3. Somewhere along the way, somebody came across an Atlanta Constitution newspaper. I remembered specifically an advertisement in that paper placed by someone named Lester Maddox for the PickRick Restaurant in Atlanta. This was an interesting ad: a full column, advertising Fried Chicken and spewing what we would now call racist commentary. Lester Maddox, of course, later became Governor of Georgia. Years later I looked up the PickRick ads in old Atlanta Constitutions. They ran once a week, always the same. Here’s the copy for the ad for August 31, 1963, three days after DC: Atlanta Ad 8-31-63001. The copy would have been submitted before the march, but the content is nonetheless revealing, as the photo of part of the ad shows, below:
(click to enlarge)
From the PickRick ad in the Atlanta Constitution, August 31, 1963.

From the PickRick ad in the Atlanta Constitution, August 31, 1963.


4. Some lucky ducky’s in our battalion came across a country high school and had an opportunity to take a shower, but only the white soldiers were welcome to this luxury; the same report was given later by some GIs who had a chance to eat in a restaurant, but their black friends were not welcome.
But, I remember nothing about August 28, 1963, not until well after Army Days.
from Carol, in response to Dick (above), Aug 28: I have a delightful little story which you may enjoy- given your North Dakota roots. My grandpa (who, unfortunately, died before I could know him) homesteaded in the boonies of ND. My aunts tell the story (early 1900s) of the time he hired a Black man to work on their farm. Neighbors got together and helped each other out at “threshing time,” but sometimes they needed more help. Grandpa went in to their little town to meet the train, as migrant workers often were on it. He brought home a Black guy – who the neighbors thought was good enough to work alongside them, but they complained to grandpa that they didn’t want to sit down at the dinner table with him. Grandpa told them, “Oh, you don’t have to, you can take your plate and eat in the kitchen, or on the porch…” After that they shared the table. My aunts remembered him playing with them during “down time” instead of trying to socialize with the white neighbors. One remembered asking him why his hands were so black but the palms were whiter, and he said he guessed he hadn’t washed them well enough. Love the story, and love my grandpa for it.
from Will S, Aug 25, 2013: If Dr. King were alive today, I think he would create not a memorial march to the site of the 1963 event but a march moving from the White House to the Capitol to the Pentagon to the offices of the CIA, FBI, NSA and other spook organizations, the Treasury Department, K Street where the PR people and lobbysists are officed and perhaps most important, the Supreme Court.
People would be armed with draft bills to achieve what they want.
They would sending back reports to hometown media with their high-tech phones in real time on real events.
They would focus on the present and the future and try to build on the past.
That’s what I think we should be doing and if we couldn’t go to D.C. for the memorial event, we can always visit the local offices of our two U.S. senators and House representative and tell them in person what we think and what we want.
Sitting home (as I probably do more than the rest of you) and typing away may be productive if LTEs get published and writing your Congresspeople on their websites always is recommended (by me) but there is nothing like a face to face meeting if it can be arranged.
The memorial march on Washington should not be a one-day event that quickly fades into history. It should be a revitalization of the cause of civil rights and the start of something on-going.
More from Will S, Aug 26, 2013: There are varying accounts of who the first Freedom Riders were. I knew several classmates at the U of M who went to Tennessee and Mississippi in the late 1950s to register voters. They were hassled by the police but not arrested. I could not go because I was just beginning a job in the newsroom of KSTP. They called in reports to us everyday, but most of the other media just were not interested.
Not long after, word was received that one of the cities that the Freedom Riders visited was going to retaliate.
They had gathered a group of unemployed black people, told them jobs and homes were waiting for them in Minnesota and sent them on a chartered bus to a city in southwestern Minnesota, forget which one. The group became known as the Reverse Freedom Riders.
I called the mayor of this town and he had no idea this was happening, understood what was being done, was appalled at how the blacks were lied to and said, “Don’t worry, we will find them places to live, we will welcome them and try to find them jobs.”
This became a national news story. I reported it on NBC radio and we sent a TV crew to film it for Huntley-Brinkley NBC Evening News although I was not part of that.
Eventually, the blacks returned to the South because they could not stand Minnesota winters.
The mayor said they not only were the first black residents of that town but the first blacks most residents ever had met. Churches there played a big role in taking them in.
Another time, a friend of mine and I went to the Minneapolis Auditorium to hear George Wallace speak. Some of the pickets became disruptive and someone called the police. They sprayed some kind of crowd dispersal gas on the audience and I helped a woman and her kids out of the building.
When someone sued the police department, I volunteered to testify and did.
Can’t remember the disposition of the case.
In my career in the news business, among the civil rights activists I met were Martin Luther King III who came here to speak often; Julian Bond and Andrew Young.
More Will S, same day. When I worked in PR at 3M, I was a resource person to the company’s African-American Arts Society. Sometime in the 1990s, when the actor James Earl Jones came to the Guthrie Theater, then located near Loring Park, Minneapolis, to act in a play about apartheid in South Africa, I got 3M to pay for tickets and arranged through the Guthrie PR person for our group to meet Mr. Jones after the performance.
Meet him? He kept the bar open until 3 a.m. and we discussed many subjects of concern to black men and women.
3M had trouble attracting and keeping black employees. They had good jobs but were put off by the relatively few number blacks then living here compared to where they had grown up and-or come from.
They wanted to socialize with other blacks, meet new people, maybe find marriage partners. Many left in despair. But one told me she had done the most daring thing of her life: began dating a white man (not me) and they were totally in love. Don’t know how that worked out.
Once in the 1990s, I was attending a play at black-oriented Penumbra Theatre in St. Paul. To my surprise, I found myself sitting directly behind the renowned black playwright August Wilson who came here from Pittsburgh.
At that time, I was editor of the newsletter of the Twin Cities Jazz Society. I knew Wilson was a big jazz fan and we did an interview during intermission. The subject: is jazz strictIy a music by and for blacks or is there room for whites and others? “Of course there’s room for others!” he yelled at me and everyone looked at us. We both laughed. I scooped the corporate media which then and now was no big accomplishment.
In 2002 I was in New York for a jazz convention. In the lobby, people had gathered around Jesse Jackson. He held court on a variety of problems and I found him well versed on jazz, too.
Still more, Will S, Aug 26: When I worked at Honeywell 1965-1974, I met an engineer who was a German Jew who barely had escaped Hitler. When riots and city burnings were flaring up all over the nation including a small one on Plymouth Avenue North, Minneapolis, where I was raised and where many of Minneapolis’ blacks lived, Hans Peter Meyerhoff, now in retirement with his Belgian Jewish wife, Rose, in Fridley, decided to try to do something to help blacks economically.
He prepared on a manual typewriter and replicated by carbon paper copies of a list of black business operators in North Minneapolis, called it “Buy Black,” distributed copies to his friends and associates and urged them to patronize these businesses. It grew slowly but steadily. South Minneapolis was added, then St. Paul, then others around the state.
I wrote a story about “Buy Black” for the employee newspaper and when I told a friend of mine at the local AP office about “Buy Black,” he put it on the national AP newswire and over the years, “Buy Black” took on a life of its own with a small staff and still operates.
At the same time, the Urban Coalition and other Twin Cities business people helped create a local chapter of the National Minority Business Campaign [NMBC], designed to help larger black-owned companies do business with majority firms.
By this time, I had moved to 3M and helped the director of purchasing write a guidebook designed to help minority business people deal with majority firms.
Word of this reached the White House and when I attended the national convention of NMBC in DC, I was invited to speak.
Just before we entered the East Room at the White House, Pres. Carter came down the steps connecting the family residence to the main floor. He was holding a copy of our 3M guidebook. When we shook hands, I told him I had written it. He said he wanted me to meet his Secretary of Commerce whose name I forget. She and I spent an entire day together discussing what the Carter Administration could do to improve interaction between government, the private sector and the black business community. She wrote the book on that.
I should have taken with me when I retired from 3M all of the photos, documents, awards etc. that 3M received but I l left them in a file cabinet and when I asked someone to search for them, they were gone.
“Buy Black” held a reunion recently but I could not get the media interested. They did cover the annual luncheon of the local chapter of NMBC, probably because it is closer to corporate culture than small business. Big mistake to ignore small, minority business.
Still more Will S Aug 26: Although there are many black men and women I would like to meet or hear speak or read their books (which I try to do) the foremost one is Angela Yvonne Davis.
A mainstay of The Black Panthers in the 1950s and ’60, companion and ideologue of murdered Panther George Jackson, her 10-year-old book The Angela Y. Davis Reader is light years ahead of most others in its ideology and ideas for the future.
You’ll probably have to find it on Amazon or some such but it is well worth the search as is the sometimes-difficult read when it seems less a book and more like a PhD thesis full of arcane terminology and references, but then, why should that make any difference?
Davis now teaches at the University of California/Santa Cruz, does few media gigs but seems to be alive and well and, I hope, still writing and someday will emerge from semi-seclusion to become a political leader again for all of us. ws
and still more from Will, Aug 26: thenation.com Sept. 2/9 largely devoted to the 50th anniversary of The March.
I don’t know about where you-all grew up but at Minneapolis North in the 1950s, now crime-ridden, relations among almost everyone were peaceful.
We grew up integrated before the term ever was invented.
There was a tiny bit of socializing between a few of us white boys and a few black girls. My parents didn’t care but the girl I was attracted to said if her father knew she was dating a white boy, he would kill me and she was not kidding.
She won a scholarship to what became known as a Historical Black College in Atlanta and I never saw her again.
On some hot summer nights, weather like this, we would meet at Theodore Wirth Lake where the Aqua Follies were held including recently-deceased Olympic swimmer Esther Williams.
A few of us swam nude and a very few of us became intimate. It became the best kept secret in the school. But no white girls participated; they were scared to death of sex and even more scared of black boys.
The most astounding event was in about 1950 when a white Jewish man (older brother of a friend of mine) eloped with a black woman to LA.
A strange thing happened at my bar mitzvah June 25, 1949 at Mikro Kodesh synagogue, 1000 Oliver Av. N.
In the middle of my recitation, the doors to the synagogue opened and in walked a half dozen very tall black men wearing mourning coats and that type of formal dress.
The rabbi stopped the service and went back to find out who they were. Turned out their letter never had arrived announcing that they were Ethiopian Jews on a tour of the U.S.
Many in the congregation were very prejudiced against blacks who were beginning to move into North Minneapolis but the rabbi seated them and they joined us for the traditional Jewish feast after the bar mitzvah.
They knew nothing about Yiddish but the rabbi said they spoke a dialect of Hebrew that probably dated back to Moses’ time!
Their next stop was Seattle so we called ahead to a synagogue there to receive them, put them on the Empire Builder and off they went.
I can see them as if it were yesterday.
Tall and lean, heavily bearded, all wearing the same clothing including top hats instead of yamakas which was all right with us!
Prejudice of many of the congregation against blacks led me first to leave the congregation and eventually, Judaism. Am now a devout agnostic.
and more yet from Will, Aug. 27, 2013: If you are interested in working for causes that come generally under the heading of civil rights, find the NAACP or Urban League chapter in your area and find out what their needs are.
It has been my experience that they welcome new members of any race and there is no doubt in my mind that the readers of Bernard’s Blog could help these organizations immensely.
I once attended an Urban League national convention and an NAACP national convention as a representative of 3M and met some the most dedicated people I ever was to meet.
We have some people like that here and they will be in D.C. for the March, but they have been marching all of their lives.
and still more from Will, Aug 28: After Dr. King was assassinated, a friend of mine at 3M, Ken Coleman of St. Paul, of African American descent, a company photographer, put together a memorial to Dr. King which he offered to his widow, Coretta Clark King, for use at the King Center in Atlanta. The company gave free rein to Ken to do his project and he became close to the entire King family.
A few years later, Ken left 3M to take a job in California and except for a few phone calls and one visit back to St. Paul, we have been out of touch but I can imagine, wherever he is, what he is thinking and feeling on the 50th anniversary of the March on Washington, and what he did help memorialize Dr. King.
If you ver go to Atlanta, you must visit the King memorial.
From Peter B., Aug 25 & 26, 2013:
Dick,
I missed that march, but made a lot of others; and I was deeply engaged with the Civil Rights Movement in those times. The Civil Rights struggle is far from over, and by many measures things have gotten far worse.
The marches on Washington were not media events. They were hundreds of thousands of people from all walks of life, who had tried every other thing they could come up with to change a terrible and quite deadly situation. Back then Washington was where we thought we could assemble for “redress of grievances.” Congresspeople still read their own mail. You could walk into the White House. Nobody knew what a “Jersey Barrier” was.
Most of the media coverage – newspapers and radio and black-and-white television – succeeded in watering down the real messages and minimizing the actual numbers of real people involved, and playing up the weirdos. Which in those times was anybody wearing a beard.
The coverage of Manning and Snowden and Assange today is much more skillfully bent. Old techniques still work reliably, and they were refined, such as “shoot the messenger” and “divide and conquer.” Who has seen any story about the actual content of the thousands of documents uncovered by these brave, pitiful human beings? Only those who are able to go find out themselves; and now, the NSA has your number.
We live in an Empire beset by “Terrorism.” Serious People discuss “The Terrorist Threat.” There is no possibility of functioning Democracy, none, it’s been gone for years, such as it ever was. Marches merely let off some of the pressure. A few big names get seen again. People go home tired, hoping they accomplished something. I don’t think any of the people born since the original March really understand what they are up against. Hell, we didn’t know back then what Hoover was up to (and now his kind of scheming has been legalized). King really went through some horrors at the hands of the State, and the miracle and mystery of that man is that he kept it up all the way to the bloody end.
King knew what we were up against. He had been convincingly warned. For the rest of us the message is clear: if you are effective at resisting Power, Power will fear you. And now, they have drones, and all your emails, and all your friends’ emails.
Weren’t we quaint, all those years ago, with our beards and our signs and our sit-ins? Our fire-hoses and police dogs? I got a copy of my personal FBI file. I was eighteen years old, and the Feds interrogated upstanding members of my community about me.
It is a scary thing.
Love
Peter
(Continued, next day)
Expanding a little on a previous observation:
Consider what comes across the Feed – most television content – these days, and how we – and when I say “we” I mean people of every race and kind – how we used to get our impressions about groups of human beings of which we were not members.
One source of info on this for me is my first marriage. She was about as “black” as possible, from the ghetto that was Philadelphia, PA. We were in a band that played every dive in the city. We were very young to get married. We moved into the heart of the worst possible neighborhood in North Philly, and my education began in earnest. For readers who don’t know me, I’m “white.”
What did I know about the life of an “inner-city” dweller? In my suburban high school the racism was comfortably entrenched. “They” lived down on Union Street. Today it is one of the better neighborhoods, but then it was the only street in town that “Negroes” would be shown by realestate agents. In elementary school the rhyme had been recently edited to go: “Eeny meeny miney moe / Catch a Tiger by the toe…” and I had seen one fight narrowly averted by a smiling-but-serious “Negro” child when the older version was pronounced pointedly in his direction. “Better watch what you say…” Most “White” kids I knew were quietly terrified of being caught alone and outnumbered by “Negroes” of any age or professional status. What nightmares did “Negro” kids suffer from? I just woke up from one last night, to my astonishment, about running out of gas in the ghetto, and suddently being surrounded by hostile teenagers who proposed to set me on fire.
These things get embedded deep and permanently in the brain. I have known people for whom I was the first “White” they had ever seen (they thought I was a ghost, and kept pinching my skin in fascination); and as a toddler, I remarked to a visitor from India: “Sharda, your face is dirty.” She replied, smiling, “Oh, Peter, you’re naughty!” So perhaps racism should be distinguished as, on one hand, the natural response to the sight of a person with obvious physical differences; and on the other, an insideous economic system based on this reaction.
This being a college town, there were professors and students from Africa, or the deep south, or Philly; to most of us kids they were all just “Negroes.” But I was brought up to believe racial references were impolite, and no basis for choosing our friends or restaurants or any other relationships, and we had also lived in Nigeria for a year when I turned sixteen, the year President Kennedy was assassinated. I had met Stokely Carmichael (look him up!) who told me in no uncertain terms exactly what kind of racist I was. He was a great teacher, and I took it to heart. I recognized my racist self right then, and it is probably the best lesson I ever learned.
And there was of course my first love, music. I followed it into Philly in the late sixties. Yet even with all this, I gues one could say inoculation, against the culural mindset of my “White” middle-class suburban background, I was totally unprepared for life in the ghetto, in America.
I have surprisingly little to say on this point: in the “inner-city” with the largest, deadliest gang, the Zulu Nation, with forty thousand members, where no non-“Negro” people existed for ten miles in any direction except pawn-shop and delicatessen owners, and very rarely, cops; where my soon-to-be brother-in-law was already shot dead on his front lawn, and my mother-in-law-to-be worked a second job downtown in a porn movie thearter selling tickets; I was always treated with the utmost kindness, respect and concern for my comfort. This had been true in Nigeria when I walked in the bush for days armed with a water gourd, a blanket and a stick, and the same genuine, authentic human compassion was extended to me everywhere I went in the most bombed-out slums in America.
Still I was constantly on my guard, because “White” kids in America were taught, by every subtle, invisible sign and signal, that “Negroes” were dangerous, unpredictable and hostile. This belief ran so deep in the culture as to be invisible, just a background assumption that would only appear in stories about running out of gas in the “wrong neighborhood,” or in the dirty stories young boys told in locker-rooms and behind the bleachers, in which “Negroes” all had straight razors and deadly animal instincts.
Now. What do kids know about “African-Americans” today? They have, mind you, the Feed now. The thing that comes into every suburban home, spewing a ceaseless torrent of multi-media experiences in which “African-Americans” are usually the enemy, the perpetrator, or just the helpless dysfunctional victim of “society’s ills.” Cosby? Are you kidding? Oprah? Again, are you kidding? The occasional doctor or church-lady or gospel singer only makes the contrast sharper in the flood of the “gangsta” and sports mythology industries. And no mistake, industries they are. In America today, racism is big, big business.
The only “White” kids you might see in a ghetto now are on posters and TV ads promoting lighter skin and products that promise lighter skin and straighter hair. And this is still the scale on which beauty is ranked. Any “White” kid contemplating, say, pursuing a career in jazz or rap by working up through the ranks from the street would be considered suicidal. Schools are more segregated, if possible, than ever before in history, and so are the commercial jails, of course.
Oh sure, there are lots of up-and-coming “African-American” (why are there no “Anglo-Americans?”) in the schools and community colleges, and quotas of same at the Ivy League schools (a bone of contention still). They are headed for the professions, and there are still some middle-class neighborhoods waiting for them, if the Banksters haven’t bought up all the foreclosed property yet. But in America, now, in 2013, Aparteid is on the rise, and accelerating.
Fifty years later, the system of racial prejudice is still with us, as institutional and complicated as ever, and now it is, like perpetual war, a cornerstone of “the Economy.” Progress, of a kind, but to my mind, retrograde, and terminal if we don’t wake up to it.
Love
Peter

#764 – Dick Bernard: "I have a dream", 50 years later

Published in 1964, and still in print, Why We Can't Wait by Martin Luther King Jr is an outstanding first-person view of the year 1963.

Published in 1964, and still in print, Why We Can’t Wait by Martin Luther King Jr is an outstanding first-person view of the year 1963.


Tomorrow is the actual anniversary of the “March on Washington” August 28, 1963 – it was a Wednesday then, too.
It occurred to me that almost all attention is paid to that day itself, in Washington, and that of the then-population of the United States perhaps one in 1,000 people were there.
The heavy lifting occurred before and after August 28, 1963. The event itself was extraordinary, but, like Rosa Parks sit-in on the bus in Alabama, only one part of a much larger story.
I decided to ask my own list to consider sharing some of their own memories related to August 28, 1963: “YOUR THOUGHTS? August 28 is the 50th anniversary of the March on Washington. Whether you were there or not, you may have some thoughts to share on how you felt at that time in history, and how that event has impacted on you and people you know.
Eight people weighed in, including Will Shapira and Peter Barus with very lengthy and interesting perceptions.
The entire file, now approaching 6000 words (a normal blog is 600-700 words, and this one is about 170 word at this point) was published August 28. You can read it here.
I invite you to at least scroll through, and to apply the comments to your own perceptions and memories and application to the future. The long ones – Will and Peter’s – are the last portions of the post.
Personally:
1) None of us are post-racial, in my opinion, and we probably will never be post-racial. It is part of our very fabric. Saturday we took Cathy’s friend Alyson to see “The Butler”, the movie about the White House Butler for a long succession of Presidents. Alyson came to the U.S. from Antigua in 1982 and is African and white descent, dark-skinned with the unique island accent. We asked her for her impressions afterwards. I don’t think she could relate to the racial aspects. In her island Republic, part of the British empire still, the top government officials are ordinarily black. It is not considered a big deal. She is of slave ancestry, certainly, but the white ancestry is prominent as well. Apparently, at least from her perspective, the American experience is rather odd.
2) There is lamenting about how far there is still to go to achieve the dream articulated August 28, 1963. I tend to prefer looking at how it was, versus how it is, now. In 1963, there was no question that ours was a society rife with racial tensions…the white attitudes prevailed. Fifty years later, it is the whites who remember the ‘good old days’ pre-1963 who are on the defensive. There has been a huge change.
3) But…we are a people who tend to do change, then take it for granted, with the inevitable repeating of history. So, it is not enough to rest on laurels, rather necessary to stay in action, and in conversation about the real issues which remain.
4) Which leads back to the comment that perhaps one in 1,000 Americans was in Washington on the Mall August 28, 1963.
The 999 back home, then, and still, are the ones who will in the long run make the difference, by their individual and small group actions where they live. There is no magic bullet. I understand that President Obama – a clear beneficiary of August 28, 1963, will be speaking at the Mall tomorrow.
He is just one person.
We must be, as Gandhi said so powerfully, the change we wish to see in the world.
It’s on all of our shoulders.
That’s 564 words, about 10% of tomorrows post. I hope you drop in on it, maybe look back once or twice to read it through in bits and pieces.

#763 – Dick Bernard: Congratulations, Tom and Jennifer, at your 25th Anniversary. "For everything, there is a season."

(click to enlarge photos)

Rick, Joan and Ron reminisce, August 21, 2013

Rick, Joan and Ron reminisce, August 21, 2013


Today is son Tom and Jennifers 25th wedding anniversary.
Congratulations to you both.
Achieving 25 years together is one of those significant accomplishments, not easy to attain. That’s long enough to experience both the unknown and unknowable. For a couple to reach 25 years together is a significant achievement, as anyone who has ever been in any relationship can attest.
For just a single example, Tom’s Mom, Barbara, and I married 50 years ago this year: June 8, 1963. Neither of us were expecting that she’d spend almost all of our very short marriage ill, dying little over two years later, July 24, 1965.
Roughly half-way through that brief marriage, Tom was born. He will turn 50 in a few months.
I became a single parent early.
Just two days ago I was out to Anoka, our first home after Barbara died, part of a reunion of fellow staff members of Roosevelt Junior High School in Blaine MN. I had signed a contract to teach there three days before Barbara, died, and I began teaching there scarce a month later, doing my best to cope, with the substantial help of new friends in my new home, far from ND, where we had lived the earlier years of our lives. I was there seven years, moving on in an unexpected direction which occupied my next 27 years.
Roosevelt Jr. High School, Blaine MN, Summer, 1968.  Photo by Dick Bernard

Roosevelt Jr. High School, Blaine MN, Summer, 1968. Photo by Dick Bernard


I told a colleague, Wednesday, that I still have not pieced together the events of that month of August, 1965…I guess it’s like living through a disaster: you remember it happened, but not exactly what. Survival trumps memory.
The picture which leads this post, was taken at that reunion two days ago: three of my colleagues from those early years. The photo started life as a mistake, but under the circumstances it is an ideal representation of times past. I taught with these folks. They are about my age. They can represent everyone I’ve ever known on the path of life thus far.
Earlier that same day, August 21, I received an e-mail from someone in Maryland, whose Mom remembers my parents, most likely in 1939-40, when they lived in Valley City, North Dakota, essentially next door to her then-young Mom and Dad. It caused me to dig out the earliest photo I have of myself, with my parents, 73 years ago in Valley City:
Henry and Esther Bernard with newborn son, Richard, May, 1940, Valley City ND

Henry and Esther Bernard with newborn son, Richard, May, 1940, Valley City ND


Her Mom has to be somewhere near 100 now.
(It’s odd what such pictures sometimes bring to the surface. For those of a certain age, who can forget the coal chute, whose door is visible behind the crib.)
We all know, as we age, priorities begin to change, often due to circumstances we couldn’t anticipate; often because our perspectives change.
Anybody whose life begins to approach old age is reminded of this when more and more frequently we attend someone’s funeral, or visit someone we know in a Nursing Home. To paraphrase the Bible phrase Ecclesiastes 3: 1-15, Weddings are replaced by Baptisms are replaced by Graduations are replaced by Weddings…. For everything there is a season. Fall is as certain as Winter, as is Spring and then Summer.
Last Saturday, at another reunion of former colleagues from the ever-more distant olden days of work with the Minnesota Education Association (1972-2000), an early must-do was to read a partial list of colleagues who had departed this life. It is an ever longer list. Each name, as read, brought back memories to all of us in attendance.
John reads the roll of departed colleagues, August 17, 2013

John reads the roll of departed colleagues, August 17, 2013


We were all young, once.
Enroute home on Wednesday, an unexpected detour on the freeway gave me an opportunity to stop in and visit a retired minister I’ve known and been good friends with for the last ten or so years.
Till very recently he, another friend and I have had a long-standing date, once a month, to meet for coffee and conversation.
Earlier this summer, William collapsed in Church, ending up in a convalescent facility.
Yesterday, I stopped to visit him there, and he’d been transferred to an assisted living facility, so I traveled a few more miles to visit him there. Returning home seems not an option for him any more.
Three short months ago, William and his wife had certain routines. He’s well into his 80s, now, so they knew the odds of change increased every day.
But we never like to anticipate the winter of our lives, whose evidence I increasingly see at funerals and memorials for people that I know.
Had Barbara lived, earlier this summer we might have celebrated our 50th anniversary. Such possibility was not to be.
“Lord willing”, as Dad would say, my 75th birthday is not far in the future. Wednesday night came a call that my once-young Uncle Vince is hospitalized once again. He’s made it to 88, but the slope is ever more slippery. At some point, reality becomes undeniable.
The family script mitigates against he or I or anyone within seeing 100, but that’s okay.
Contribute in some way to others lives today.
There may not be a tomorrow.
Happy anniversary, Tom and Jennifer.
We’re proud of you. We love you.
Barbara Sunde Bernard, June 8, 1963 - July 24, 1965

Barbara Sunde Bernard, June 8, 1963 – July 24, 1965


Dick Bernard and Barbara Sunde Wedding June 8, 1963, Valley City ND, with families.

Dick Bernard and Barbara Sunde Wedding June 8, 1963, Valley City ND, with families.

#762 – Dick Bernard: Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out. What's ahead?

UPDATE: August 21, 2013: This important link forwarded by John B, received from “my niece, an attorney in Albuquerque. She once worked for the MN Orch Youth Symphony and is a cello player from St. Olaf.”
August 24, 2013: In the 23rd Star Tribune an article appeared on page B3 of the Metro Section giving management site on the Domain name issue (referred to in the above link). The article did not appear in the on-line edition, at least was not found, but is now accessible. Here is the STrib link. Here is a pdf of the actual article in yesterdays Star Tribune: Orch Domain names001
The musicians website: here
Previous posts about the Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out: October 18, 2012; December 7, 2012; June 1, 2013; June 5, 2013; June 21, 2013; July 26, 2013; August 16, 2013; August 19, 2013.
When I began blogging in March, 2009, I had no idea what would evolve. Over the years, I’ve obviously been prolific. I’ve also noted that I’m eclectic – I am interested in lots of things, some passionately, and sometimes topics take root, like the Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out, now near a year old.
We went to the Community Forum about the future of the Minnesota Orchestra, sponsored by Orchestrate Excellence, last night, and I included a brief report and the links to the video and the handout here. I would urge taking the time to access both handout and video, and I would also suggest joining Orchestrate Excellence network (click on “Join the Coalition” tab). Orchestrate Excellence seems to be reasonable folks with an objective of keeping our World Class Orchestra intact, and finding some way to settlement.
I know collective bargaining all too well: it was my job for 27 years. My colleagues and I worked in diverse ways with thousands of collective bargaining negotiations and agreements in that time. We dealt with upsets, small and large, and occasional strikes (really pretty rare). Never do I recall a Lock-Out, and certainly no Strike that lasted anywhere near as long as this Lock Out has prevailed. The geniuses who devised and sold the Lock-Out strategy give meaning to a favorite country-western tune of mine: “What was I Thinking”.
But…that’s what they thought, and the way these situations often times go, once committed to a strategy, one follows it till death. And that’s the scary part of this conflict. The longer this Lock-Out has continued, the harder the cement in which feet are planted, and the bar for a “win” gets higher and higher. On the Union side, there’s nothing left to lose; on Management, a single-minded focus on destroying the Union. Very, very unhealthy.
We arrived early enough last evening to give me time to walk around the block and see the now infamous Lobby. I took a few photos.
(click to enlarge photos)

Orchestra Hall Lobby, Minneapolis, August 20, 2013

Orchestra Hall Lobby, Minneapolis, August 20, 2013


It was more than a little ironic, seeing “Orchestra Hall” on the side of the building, since the musicians who make up the Orchestra have been locked out without pay or benefits since October, 2012. And, of course, with the absent Orchestra, similarly locked out have been those of us who are called “Listeners”, the “Audience”.
As I walked down Nicollet Ave I noted through the window of the still-incomplete lobby a single step-ladder being used for something. Step-ladders are useful tools for achieving a goal.
I wondered what “step-ladder” exists to end the War at 1111 Nicollet Mall. A one-sided “victory” will be a Pyrrhic one, with no good end. Perhaps that Pyhrric event has already occurred. I hope not.
In our small group last night, I made a couple of comments which tend to summarize my feelings at this point in time:
1. The settlement will have to be made by the two parties to the bargain, the Orchestra Management and Orchestra itself.
2. As for us, the Locked Out audience, each of us in our own way need to do something; and that something should be a bit beyond our normal self-imposed limit. We can’t afford to sit on the sidelines. The ball is in our court. Last night was an excellent organized kickoff bringing together people of diverse opinions, all who care deeply about the future of our Minnesota Orchestra.
August 21, 2013

August 21, 2013


August 21, 2013

August 21, 2013


Comments:
from Mike R, Aug 20:

Thanks for keeping us in the loop, Dick.
We heard about the forum on KSJN and were wondering if it would help.
I have no confidence that MN Orch management bargains in good faith. What does your experience with labor negotiations tell you?
From Will S, Aug 21: Nobody knows what to do, not even my classical musician friends.
Nobody can tell us specifically what to do. They just don’t know.
It will play out by itself until someone comes up with a specific proposal to present to the governor and the Legislature and copy the public.
Response from Dick: This is a time for innovation. There’s nothing worse than doing nothing! Innovate.
from Cathy A, Aug 21: I was there [at the Forum] as well and inspired by the #s that showed up — but nothing in the newspaper this morning!
There will be a lot of PR work when (if) this thing is settled. I appreciate your comments and efforts.
from John B, Aug 21:
Is Minneapolis (and Minnesota ) becoming a cultural Detroit?
I’d like to see the comparison of salaries for the Viking players and the MN orchestra players.
What about the governmental financial subsidies for the MN Orch and the Vikings Stadium, etc.
Dick, you are correct in my opinion. The lockout is union busting, pure and simple!
From Molly R, Aug 21: Thanks, Dick. Fyi, this article up on MNPost today, too.
From John G, Aug 21: Dick, taking a stance of neutrality can have (and has been known to have) the opposite effect: namely, pressuring labor to cave in to management. I
hope that Orchestrate Excellence is being very careful to avoid that outcome. Fletcher’s one insistence that the lockout end unconditionally is his signal to the Board that there must be a level playing field for starters, or so it seems to me. Now is the moment, perhaps the last moment, for the MO Board, filled with leaders in our community, to take courage enough to initiate this way out of a debacle that our world-class Minnesota Orchestrate does not deserve. If Senator Mitchell can help pull this one out of the fire, he will have crowned his distinguished career with a historic last-minute “save” (with thanks for your contributions to a win/win).
From Vicci J, Aug 22 (retired music educator in St. Paul MN): Hi Dick, just read your blog, and here are a few comments.
Audience development to uphold the economy of arts tourism, is a state-wide and on-going generational project in all K-12 schools.
It will take 20 years to turn the MN Orchestra around, because it took 20 year for its demise. Today the MN Orchestra, as all major orchestras, need to payroll lobbyists capable of influencing legislatures to maintain the funding of music education programs.
In fact the only definitive insurance the arts tourism economy has, is arts programs in K-12 schools. So where are the lobbyists for music education?
Funding to school music programs was systematically cut, gradually, starting in the 1980s. If any one wants specific documentation regarding the politics of these cuts, read “The Manufactured Crisis” by Biddle and Berliner.” The proof is in the research and numbers.
A perfect K-12 program looks close to this:
Elementary School: Early Kodaly or Solfeggio in grades Pre-K-3. Maintain in classroom vocal music through grade 6.
In grade 3 start Suzuki strings; in grade 4 start wind instruments.
With early music education, in grade 3, students can read music, hear pitch differences and sing in-tune. In grade three, students are now physically ready to hold string instruments, and in grade 4, large enough to blow into a wind instrument.
These instrumental programs are scheduled in (a minimum of) 30-minute half hour, during school, pull-out-of class-lessons, with up to 4 instruments that are alike. To maintain National Standards in Music Education, there would need to be 2 such pull out classes per week. When students reach the end of their first year, a full rehearsal is added once a week.
This continues through grades 4-5-6.
Junior High: Students move into junior high: elective classes in choral; band; or orchestra classes.
Senior High: Students have elective classes, several academic levels, of band, orchestra, choral, and music classes. And lots of public performances.
This is how a community-city-state, develops a generational audience base for any major arts organization such as the MN Orchestra.
To A New Beginning: The Twin Cites Arts Tourism Economy is on the down-slide, and fewer young family’s will consider moving to Minnesota unless the public becomes vocal to state and city government officials about funding K-12 music education.
Governor Dayton has returned some funds to the education budget, but not enough to instantly repair the economic damage that has been done to both orchestras. Minnesota needs a brigade of arts lobbyists to accomplish this.
Who will find and hire them if not the arts venues?
from Alan S. Aug 23: I recently received an e-mail request from the Manager of Individual Giving for a donation to the Minnesota Orchestra Guaranty Fund. I believe that the people that are in management positions with what was once a great orchestra are now so far from reality that they as managers don’t begin to understand what they have virtually wrecked by locking out the people that made the music. The Director has already given his date that he will resign, quite a few of the musicians have left for other orchestras, and the management is looking for donations like they want to be rewarded for what they have done?
ADDITIONAL THOUGHTS FROM DICK BERNARD ON AUGUST 22, 2013:
Tuesday night, after Allen Fletcher’s talk, we were in a randomly selected group of 13 people to discuss the two questions in the Orchestrate Excellence handout (link above). All of the other participants were, presumably, in similar kinds of groups as ours: just ordinary folks talking.
I was aware, and I am aware, that few people are very aware of even the basics of collective bargaining. As for me, all the assorted aspects of collective bargaining were my full-time job for 27 years, and myself and my colleagues dealt with, literally, thousands of collective bargaining agreements.
I know collective bargaining.
Bargaining is, in my opinion, more than anything else, about relationships between people.
Here are some comments I heard within my own small group, and my interpretation of them. These are strictly my thoughts, based on my own experience:
1. Is there any analogy to an ordinary persons life in the present Lock-Out of the Orchestra? I think there is such an analogy: it’s called a divorce. Most all of us have either experienced a troubled marriage, or know well someone who has. Now, assume one partner has all of the temporal power: the money, the cars, the decision making authority; while the other party has all of the talent and most of the friends in the neighborhood. Mr. Fletcher, as I recall, described such an “asymmetric” relationship, where the Orchestral Association has everything; and the Orchestra members have nothing at all, except many friends who feel completely powerless to do anything.
Let’s say that right before Court, the parties agree to reconcile, to settle. Assume the asymmetric couple I just described above. How will this work if/when the impasse is broken, by whatever means, through whomevers influence.
Even most optimistically, this will be an extraordinarily difficult reconciliation.
2. Someone in our group said that Board members had ponied up $4,000,000 to essentially save the Orchestra. Don’t they deserve some sympathy? This is interesting, and the immediate response would be “yes”. But…this is a number without any definition whatsoever. It is just a number tossed out.
Assuming that the number is accurate and its use correctly identified (not safe assumptions, but let’s assume they are), there are about 80 members on the Orchestra Board. This would mean about $50,000 per Board member. Board members are basically “high net worth” people to begin with: that would be a normal criteria for nominating Board members to a large non-profit. It would take, at maximum, $1,000,000 of idle money to generate $50,000 a year, without ever touching the principal. And such a donation would presumably be tax deductible. It would take roughly 200 six-performance listeners to generate the same revenue, and such revenue would not be deductible.
In addition, an aggravation for me, which I expressed within the small group, is that, to my knowledge, we listeners were never asked nor informed about the change in orchestra direction, nor the supposed financial crisis. We listeners are a massive non-entity to the decision makers, except to the extent that we provide revenue.
3. Why doesn’t the Union just make a counter-proposal, even if locked out? This is a labor law problem that the vast majority of individuals would not understand, but that the Union bargainers are fully aware of. Orchestral Management would love to have such a proposal. My understanding of this is it would make breaking the Union even simpler. One of the very clear messages from Fletcher in his talk was that the Board needed to unilaterally end the Lock-out to make any settlement possible.
4. Why don’t we adopt some new model (i.e. musician representatives on the Board), etc? There are different models of governance. Unfortunately, we are stuck with the current labor-management model until after the current situation is settled. Some would like to fire the entire Board. I’m sure some would like to just get rid of the Union. Both have some logic. But both are crazy ideas. This is not normal labor-management relationships, and we’re stuck with the status quo until there is some kind of settlement, however that settlement looks. I can’t even speak intelligently about which management should be fired: the Orchestral Association Board activities do not seem open to public view. Imagine a local school board whose members were inaccessible to the public, and unaccountable to the public. Essentially, this seems to be the current Orchestral Association management.
5. What can I do? At one point in the small group, somebody asked how many people we had in our personal networks, and how we could work together. If I recall correctly, he said he knew about 15. I said my network was about the same (though this writing will go to a core group now including about 30 people). I don’t recall anyone else commenting on this. As an audience, a group of listeners, we are fragmented, and it is difficult to break this fragmentation – we know the people who we’ve come to know in our section of the auditorium, or others we know have been at one or another Orchestra event, but no one else.
The only remedy I can see to this is to plod along, by bits and pieces, creating a network for the future.
We didn’t plan to this crisis (which we didn’t know was about to happen), so we can feel justified in pleading ignorance. But we can no longer plead ignorance.
6. But I don’t know what to do? In the group, I said I had only two pieces of advice: 1) do something; 2) stretch yourself (I mention them both in the original post, above.)
Doing nothing, being defeated, assures only defeat. We can do a great deal, in many different and creative ways. From now on, IF I return to Orchestra Hall, the Orchestral Association Board is not going to be allowed to be anonymous and unaccountable.

#761 – Dick Bernard: A Full Moon, Pretty Flowers…and owning a mistake

UPDATE, August 20, 2013 9:45 p.m.
A short while ago we drove east from Minneapolis, driving into the Full Moon rising. The sky was clear and the view was spectacular. Pity that I only had my small camera, with which I took this snapshot. The moon was, for me at least, a positive harbinger of the future for the Minnesota Orchestra.
(click to enlarge)

Full Moon, August 20, 2013, at Woodbury MN

Full Moon, August 20, 2013, at Woodbury MN


We had just attended, along with several hundred others, a Community Forum on the Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out. The extraordinarily well run event was conducted by an apparent ad hoc organization, Orchestrate Excellence, and co-featured a keynote speech by Dr. Alan Fletcher, CEO and President of the Aspen Music Festival and School, and a large number of moderated small groups, largely of strangers together, dealing with two questions:
1. Does Minnesota want a world-class orchestra, and why?
2. What will you, as a community member, do to support a world-class orchestra, and how?
Dr. Fletcher’s talk is available at The UpTake and is well worth your time.
The handout we all received is here: OrchExcel 082013001
We thought our time to be very well spent. Ours was a diverse group, 13 of us, with diverse opinions, but we were talking.
If you have even a little interest in the Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out do take time to print out the handout, and watch the video, and enter into your own conversations within your own circles.
Personally, I think tonights meeting, along with other events recent and pending, mitigate towards a settlement, which must be between the two parties to the bargain. If I’m right, the settlement of the contract will only begin the hard part: to move ahead to heal and rebuild.
It won’t be easy.
Tonights full moon was, I found out, a Blue Moon. I’m not much of a moon person, but I liked its rising as we came home this evening. For some reason it brought a feeling of hope.
Here’s the earlier post….
Bergeson Nursery rural Fertile MN August 8, 2013

Bergeson Nursery rural Fertile MN August 8, 2013


This day this blogspace was to be about pretty flowers in a wonderful pastoral setting about 300 miles from our home in the Twin Cities!. Our tour guides on August 8 were Annelee Woodstrom, and her friend, Joyce Schlagel, who suggested we drive from their home in Ada to the Bergeson Nursery in rural Fertile MN.
The afternoon was a huge treat, and I posted 22 snapshots in this Facebook album. If you can’t access them, I’ve sprinkled two photos from the pastoral farmyard within this post.
At Bergeson Nursery August 8, 2013

At Bergeson Nursery August 8, 2013


Flowers can speak for themselves, but they speak as well for those who nurture them.
More compelling to me, right now, is the continuing tragedy of the Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out, nearing twelve months, with the next two weeks crucial.
I need to start by correcting a mistake I made in my August 16 Post. It is marked by [*] in the third paragraph, and acknowledged in the last two paragraphs. It was a foolish mistake, that I had no reason to make. I apologize.
Of course, mistakes do not begin and end with me.
One of the more memorable dissertations on owning a mistake is one I heard years ago, at a meeting, where a woman quoted her mother: “never apologize”. Nothing more was said about why the Mom said that to her daughter, at the time long an adult, but it stuck.
This morning I reviewed my entire Lock Out file. It is a couple of inches thick, my personal reference point for this disaster. It includes my letters to the Board: Nov. 24, 2012, to every Board member; Jan. 10, 2013, to the Officers; Feb. 18, 2013 to the Executive Committee.
There is one reply which seems genuine, dated Jan. 8, 2013, from Jon R. Campbell and Michael Henson, but it is just too perfect. It reminds me far too much of a letter I received about 1965 from a downtown Minneapolis office. I had been raising a complaint about some small and (in my mind) unjustified bill, and finally got a long letter, typed in the fashion of the day, with the salutation “Dear Richard I. Bernard (or anybody else)”. With that, I paid the bill, satisfied I got somebody’s attention.
The Lock Out of the Orchestra by Orchestra management was a horrendous mistake, and the “never apologize” rule is likely to be applied here by those same managers whenever this issue is over.
But sooner or later there will be a settlement, hopefully not imposed, and my signal to begin supporting the Orchestra once again will be an enthusiastic ratification of the agreement by members of the Orchestra Union.
They are, all of them, heroes to me.
It is time for a beautiful sunrise out of a stormy sky, such as the one I saw this morning enroute to coffee, and hurriedly snapped.
Sunrise August 19, 2013, Woodbury MN near corner of Radio and Lake.

August 19, 2013, Woodbury MN near corner of Radio and Lake.


Previous posts about the Minnesota Orchestra Lock-Out: October 18, 2012; December 7, 2012; June 1, 2013; June 5, 2013; June 21, 2013; July 26, 2013; August 16, 2013

#760 – Dick Bernard: The End of the Line for the late-great Minnesota Orchestra?

UPDATE August 19, 2013: here
IMPORTANT NOTE RE TUESDAY, AUGUST 20: click HERE
UPDATE: August 18, 2013: In the middle of this commentary are some pertinent thoughts about what is happening at the Minnesota Orchestra. Note the four paragraphs which start with the para “While no one has…” and end with “Do rank and file donors….”
My spouse alerted me to an article in today’s Minneapolis Star Tribune, “Proposal but no orchestra deal”. It is worth reading carefully.
In our paper – we’re long-time subscribers to the Star Tribune – only a serious reader would have found the article on page B3 of the Metro Section. The link in the on-line version is similarly in the shadows, within the Entertainment section. Perhaps it is because the [*]. Star Tribune Publisher and CEO Michael Klingensmith is also on the Board. I doubt the writer had free rein to report as he saw things….
This Lock-Out (a management strike against labor) is not Entertainment.
Little more than a week ago I was at a meeting where the speaker noted that the Minnesota Orchestra Management is represented by the same law firm which represented American Crystal Sugar during its deadly lockout of Union workers at its Moorhead plant. That Lockout lasted well in excess of a year; the union was decimated; many of the workers left for other jobs…the same formula applies against a world class Orchestra. (There is a famed piece of audio tape from 2011 where the CEO of American Crystal Sugar, speaking to a friendly audience, compared a Union contract to a large Tumor needing to be removed (the audio link is at the end of the article). Labor, pay attention, pay very close attention.) (See note at end of this post.)
As it happened, the day after I heard that the labor consultant for the Orchestra Association management was the same as for American Crystal Sugar, I happened to be in the area of the present day American Crystal Sugar Plant in Moorhead MN.
From a distance, it is a bucolic looking sort of place, but get closer up and all pretense of welcoming disappears.
(click on photos to enlarge)

July 7, 2013 early a.m.

August 7, 2013 early a.m.


American Crystal Sugar Moorhead MN July 7, 2013

American Crystal Sugar Moorhead MN August 7, 2013


American Crystal Sugar entrance July 7, 2013

American Crystal Sugar entrance August 7, 2013


American Crystal Sugar office entrance Aug 7, 2013

American Crystal Sugar office entrance August 7, 2013


The signage I photo’ed was very benign compared with the signage near the entrance to the actual production area. Frankly, even from the street I didn’t have the nerve to take the photos where I felt intimidated, even simply stopping along the street across from the the guardhouse.
I was directly involved in collective bargaining for 27 years, as a representative of labor (public school teachers). In those many years, there were often times of tension, and very rarely there were strikes. But never did the management resort to locking out its union such as is happening here.
Management lock-outs are labor strikes on steroids. The intention is absolute control through union-busting. Imagine a community tolerating a 10 months strike by union workers. A friend, yesterday, was pointing out the Hormel lockout in Austin years ago.
I congratulate the Minnesota Orchestra Musicians Union for hanging in there for now, nearing a year.
Check their website, and give them support.
From my vantage point, a good settlement for them will be one which they ratify. Absent such a settlement, my attendance at the Minnesota Orchestra in the future is likely history.

Footnote: Tomorrow some of us retired teacher union staff people will be having a re-union. I wonder what my former colleagues will have to say.
Related post here.
NOTE:
One would think that labor would support labor, but that is not necessarily true.
When the audiotape came my way in December 2011, from a relative, I responded, and then another relative who works in some non-union capacity at American Crystal Sugar in Moorhead responded as follows:
“You are missing one point* however….these people all have jobs to come back to, very good jobs, they have chosen not to sign the agreement. Most of the rank and file employee who call in every day all want to be back to work…they do not believe they can stand up to their union…… so it is sad…..they do have jobs…..
You certainly can read the agreement offered to them with good pay and good benefits and see if you disagree. Do you have free insurance with a $150 deductible per person/ $450 per family????? I think not….they have never paid a dime for insurance and they don’t want to…so their choice is to not sign and our choice is to keep our factories running and providing our customers with sugar…..so consequently we have and continue to hire replacement workers……..we all wish for a signed agreement but the outlook is not promising……
Also, yes the CEO did have a poor choice of words about the cancer and I know he did not mean it how it was taken, totally out of context…..if you knew the man, he is one of the most caring men I know. He has a heart of gold and is very established in the community and on the Board for the United Way for many years…..so don’t believe all that you read…..the media is very one sided……”

* – My relative was responding to this, which I had sent on December 6, 2011:
As you likely know, my full-time job for 27 years was representing teachers in a union with right to strike.
I learned many things in those 27 years among which were these:
1. Employee actions are very serious matters, not frivolous. If they happen there are very strong underlying issues, not always money.
2. The issues are distinct and different for each dispute, and unless I was there, on the ground, I don’t cast judgement on motives. Something is badly wrong.
3. By far the most offensive thing I’ve heard so far is the tape of the chief of ACS [American Crystal Sugar] comparing the union to a big tumor that has to be removed for the company to recover.

[*] August 18, 2013 the original version of this post, which was picked up by the Twin Cities Daily Planet, includes this erroneous statement: “owner of the Star Tribune, Douglas W. Leatherdale, was, back eleven years ago, in 2002, Chairman of the Board of the Minnesota Orchestra, and still remains on the big-business and wealth laden Orchestral Association Board.”
To my knowledge, Douglas Leatherdale is not part of the Star Tribune, and this was a “haste makes waste” error on my part. My apologies. I had listed the Board members in my June 21, 2013, post (see end of post for listing) and I could very easily have fact-checked this assertion. Again, my apologies.

#759 – Dick Bernard: A bookshelf reminder of Governmental Insanity, and its consequences for those not vigilant and engaged.

COMMENTS after NOTE 2
Yesterday, I spent a lot of time doing an unpleasant task. A project required going into a family room wall, which necessitated repainting of a small portion of the wall by our bookshelves, and I decided to repaint the entire wall behind the books.
Of course, this required taking out all of the books, first, to get at the wall. We have quite a few in our little library. The book shelf came with our 20 year old house, and isn’t fancy: just a frame with shelving. But it works, which is all that is necessary. And the project made sense, even though I knew what I was getting myself in for.

August 15, 2013

August 15, 2013


Handling the books was almost like rereading them. Both my wife and I have quite a number of books about Germany and World War II and the Holocaust (See Note 2 below) and they drew special attention this day.
Over the years we’ve revisited that insane time, roughly twenty-five years, in civilized Germany’s history. Both of us have ancestry there; I’ve visited German relatives whose Uncles or cousins were German draftees into WWII, farmers, who refused to talk about their experience afterward. Many elders served; some imprisoned; some died in that War.
I’m 73, and was thus alive all of America’s time in WWII. The two of us spent powerful time with about 40 other Christians and Jews in our party at Auschwitz-Birkenau and other horrendous places in 2000.
We’re reasonably close to having “been there, done that”, when it comes to WWII.
Just last week we visited our great German friend, Annelee, who was six when Hitler came to power in 1933, and was very nearly bombed out of existence twice near the end of WWII. She walked nearly 100 miles home, near starving, after the war was lost. She was then 18; she’ll be revisiting her Germany in about a month. Her Dad, who refused to join the Nazis, was drafted, and disappeared in Russia. They know he died in war, not sure where he was buried.
Just a week ago, at her home, I read a gripping book she had given me about the Allied bombing of Germany in the last years of the war. Nearly 600,000 Germans were killed under those bombs, I read. I wrote in part about that book, “Fire and Fury” by Randall Hansen, a couple of days ago. You can read the comments, with link here.
So, why this musing on this most pleasant Minnesota summer day, in 2013?
Ordinary Germans were like us, exactly, ordinary people who bought dreams and supported the politicians who they thought would produce on their promises, and believed the false promises (propaganda), until it was too late. More than once I’ve asked Annelee when she knew the War was lost. Always, she says 1943, when she was about 16. You can tell such things. By then it was too late, and the Nazis in charge just kept charging. Power has little long-term perspective. It “goes down with the ship” and those who think they’re powerless go first.
We are casually dealing with some similar governmental insanity in our own country at this point in time. No, our situation is not exactly the same as WWII era Germany. But we’re not all that much different.
My favorite blogger, Alan, wrote at length about it last evening. His post, here, is long but very well worth a read. It simply summarizes the efforts by what is called the “Tea Party” to leverage their rabble into permanent control of the U.S. government, while blaming others for the dysfunction.

You love the angry disorganized rabble that is the “Tea Party”? Be my guest. Maybe you fancy yourself to be a Tea Partier yourself.
I see Tea Party leaders (and those politicians who see them as their ‘base’) as pretty analogous to the rabble who leveraged discontent into control of the German government in the 1930s with the end results that are amply documented by many of the books in the bookshelf downstairs.
I’d suggest reading the long link, but most of all, think about the craziness of a small minority feeling it can use the government to bend all of us to its philosophy, especially since it is only the most loosely organized band of individualists who probably don’t agree with each other on issues, other than hating the opposition.
It may be tempting to not notice what is going on and enjoy a fine day, perhaps satisfied to blame “politicians” generally for the “mess in Washington”.
But the ball is in every one of our courts. It’s not “them”, it is us who must be, as Gandhi said, “We must be the change we wish to see in the world.”

NOTE 1: Annelee speaks publicly about her experiences in Nazi Germany 1933-45, and she always takes written questions (her hearing was badly damaged as a consequence of the bombing). More than once she’s referred to the lawyer who asked her to comment on how Obama compares to Hitler. The question astounded here.
“There is no comparison at all.”
NOTE 2:
I have noticed a great deal of tension around analogies to Nazi Germany UNLESS it applies to some sinister “other”. Perhaps the reason for this is that the Germans of pre-World War II were people very much like stereotypical “Americans” – white, European, educated, hard-working, “Christian”….
Rev. Martin Niemoeller, famous German dissident who survived the War likely because he was imprisoned, and too well known for the Nazis to execute, made many speeches after the war, which included some variation of the famous quote attributed to him:
First they came for the socialists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a Jew.
Then they came for me,
and there was no one left to speak for me.
If you are interested in a longer academic analysis of what and when the quotation originated, you may wish to visit this web address, which is interesting and may or may not be definitive….
The essence of the quotation is, however, very true. People are easily manipulated. The impoverished Germans after WWI were easily led, in what turned out to be a destructive direction. So it can be for us as well.
There is plenty of “fool’s gold” being dispensed by American politicians these days, and especially the Tea Party version of disrupt and confuse is dangerous to our Democracy. Yes, he ball is in each of our courts.
COMMENTS:
From Bruce Aug. 16:
As you’ve said many times, things are complicated. As I’ve said many times, Libertarian roots run deep into American history. I don’t think one should vilify the Tea Party or dismiss it out of hand. Some aspects of the Libertarian view cuts across the political spectrum.
Here is an interesting piece: Julian Assange admires Ron Paul, Rand Paul here.
Response from Dick Aug. 17: Interesting, odd, trio, Julian, Ron, Rand. They could have some interesting conversations if they lived together. Mr. Assange doesn’t seem to be a good example of libertarian ideals, essentially imprisoned as he is in the Ecuadorian Embassy in London. Leaving aside the reason he is isolated (except by internet), I’m not sure I’d like his idea of freedom.
Yes, it is “complicated”. I’ve become a big admirer of Garry Davis, who in 1948 renounced his U.S. Citizenship and became an unwelcome Citizen of the World since he had no papers identifying him as being without a country. His crime had nothing to do with revealing state secrets; he just was sick of war and killing people because they were within somebody’s political boundaries of the planet. His only crime was inciting freedom from war, as I understand him.
Yes, interesting and odd. It would be interesting to know how the Paul’s would view Assange.