French-Canadians: A Family History

PRE-NOTE: This post is a new book, presented with permission of the author.  More below.  There are four preceding posts you might wish to view as well: The Solar Eclipse (April 9); Propaganda (April 11); Senate District Convention (April 12); and Covid-19 first year (April 6).   The Covid post includes several recent comments.

*

The subject of todays post is a new and fascinating book,  the Roy-Collette Family History, here, by cousin, Dr. Remi Roy of Montreal.  The book  is accessible in its entirety at the link, with permission of the author.  I encourage reading and sharing this.  Anyone with, or who knows anyone with, any French-Canadian ancestry will find this book a useful template when considering how to reconstruct their own family history, most especially with French-Canadian background.

Take some time to browse the books contents pages.  You’ll not know what’s inside till you look.

My Dad was 100% French-Canadian.  We never lived in a French-Canadian enclave, so it wasn’t until half a lifetime ago, 1980, that I even began what became a deep dive into this rich heritage.  About 15 years ago, Remi and I first met – through the internet – and in the last few years he continued and completed his exploration of his families of origin (His great-grandfather and mine were brothers, Octave and Philippe Collette.  His maternal line were Germans from Russia; mine was German-American).  So both of us are 50% French-Canadian.  (My 23&Me Ancestry declares I’m 100% French and German, northwest Europe. I don’t know Remi’s.)

Remi’s Quebec ancestors routes to their future home are in the two maps below (pp 65 and 82 in the book).  There were tens of thousands of French-Canadian immigrants to the United States, primarily mid-1800s.  Their ancestors came to what is now Quebec in the 1600s and 1700s.

Back in 1980 the U.S. Census included a question about the ancestry of those counted.  Fourteen million (of then-226.5 million population in the U.S.) indicated some French ancestry, from France or Canada, including 8% of Minnesotans.  Most of these, I think I can confidently say, were of  French-Canadian descent.

Here in both pdf (French in U.S. 1980001 ) and jpeg is the page from the calendar produced annually for 18 years by Dr. Virgil Benoit and Reine-Marie Mikesell.  Note especially West Coast data.  I think I could state without too much risk, that most of the west coast French had their antecedents in French-Canada; indeed the Midwest.  This certainly was true in my family, going way back.  “Go west, young man….”

 

from Quebec to Saskatchewan

Quebec to Minnesota to Dakota to Manitoba. This would have been the probable route of most of my branch of the family, most of whom came as a group in 1864.

 

Have at it!

*

My own Bernard-Collette History is here.  Remi and my Collette great-grandparents were brothers, Octave and Philippe, who came west with their entire family in the 1860s, and were in what is now the Twin Cities area from about 1850s-78; thence to the Dakota Territory area that became Oakwood-Grafton-Walsh County, North Dakota.

Special thanks to French-American Heritage Foundation which added this writing to their Library section.

Take your time.  Enjoy.  If you wish to make contact with Remi, email dickDOTbernarddt1878ATicloudDOTcom and I’ll pass along.

POSTNOTE:  Here’s the European linguistic map I refer to in response to Mary Ellen Weller’s comment (below).  The Map is from Rand McNally Goodes World Atlas 1996.  European Languges

COMMENTS (more below):

from Richard: As for me I have perused the book of your recommendation two times. Since my area of study is generally West Central Minnesota before 1862, the second perusal was date specific.  It is an excellent piece of work, if not a labor of love. I plan to revisit it at a later date for a more detailed read.

from Kathy: I am just now opening the French Canadian history piece that you sent.  This is coming at a good time for me because I’m assessing ways of approaching my diverse family history…..past to present? present to past? or a little of both?… making an attempt to make family history understandable to my own family! Thank you for directing my attention to this labor of love!

from Brad: These histories are always great reading – especially the mysterious, unknown, and sometimes family secrets.  The hard work and journeys too of our ancestors.  Jeff and I are traveling to France and Spain next week for a month.  We will be in Paris, and SW France (Bordeaux, Bergerac, Biarritz).  Bilbao Spain (Guggenheim musée) afterwards.  We’ve been to Normandy before but never Brittany.  Some day we’ll visit Finistère and I’ll be on the lookout for “Colet!”

from Brian: Thanks for sharing!   We have a cabin in way upstate NY near the Quebec border and my Peace Corps hostess mother lives just north of Montreal so we find ourselves going up to French-Canada often.  Fun place!

from Carole: Thank you.  I have a Canadian daughter-in-law, a cottage in Nova Scotia, elementary schooling at the College Des Ursulines in Quebec, and two son’s educated in Canada (University of Kings College and Acadia). And, have read much history.   Always interested.

Senate District 47

Last Saturday I attended the local (Senate District 47 DFL) Political Convention.  I’m Democrat, so it was the DFL (Democratic-Farmer-Labor) Convention.  This was the second Convention enroute to Election 2024.  Precinct caucuses, (Feb. 27),  elected delegates to the District Convention; Saturdays District Convention elected delegates for the upcoming Congressional District Convention (May 4 in St. Paul); then comes the State Convention (May 31-June 2 in Duluth); then the National Democratic Convention (Aug 19-22 in Chicago).

All the Conventions are open to those who participate beginning at Precinct level, and are elected as delegates ,   The process is designed to be orderly and inclusive.  On occasion local issues create local dilemmas and controversy, and of course these get publicity.

Controversy was not the case for SD 47 this year.  Everything went smoothly, and by adjournment in early afternoon, 17 delegates from my Representative District (47A) had been designated to represent us at Congressional District 4.

Our Senator, Nicole Mitchell, could not be in attendance.  She was on National Guard duty, in which she is an officer and long-time member.  My Representative (47A), Amanda Hemmingsen-Jaeger, was in attendance, as was Ethan Cha, Representative for 47B.  Congresswoman Betty McCollum(CD4) stopped by, as did several others or their representatives making the rounds of District Conventions.  Here is a photo of the three legislators in attendance:

from left: SD47B Representative Ethan Cha, U.S. Congresswoman Betty McCollum; SD 47 Representative Amanda Hemmingsen-Jaeger. April 6, 2024

In addiition to electing officers and the like, including delegates to the next level, the other main task for delegates is to approve resolutions which will ultimately make up the party platform.  In our society, and within the Democratic Party, there are an infinite number of issues and points of view, but over the years the party has cobbled together a fair and efficient process to make sure anyone with a concern can get on the court with it.  This year 38 resolutions were approved in 12 subject areas, such as Consumer Protection, et al.  A Pre-convention committee assessed all resolutions submitted, dealing with duplications, and so forth.  The report and the ballot were clear and plenty of time was given to vote..

Here are the Resolutions presented to, and passed by, our Senate District (handwritten notes my own): DFLSD47 2024 Resolutions.  These will be further refined, included or dismissed, at later levels, ultimately making up the philosophical position of the Democratic Party.

The Convention itself was small this year.  Possibly this related to lack of controversy.

It is about 7 months to the election of 2024, and action will intensify.  Get on the Court, and stay there!  It’s about our future – all of ours.

Yesterday I did a post entitled Propaganda.  It is long, especially the Kanefield link, but I think it is pertinent

POSTNOTE: It is easy to forget that anyone elected to anything quickly learns a sometimes very hard lesson: they may have “won”, but their responsibility is to 100% of the people they represent, including possibly a majority of their constituency.  “We, the people” forget this too, at our own peril.  The blessing of Democracy is also the curse.  We have to work together to succeed.  If we don’t we all fail, to a greater or lesser degree.

The bag which held our Senate District delegate materials featured the most likely new Minnesota State Flag which will likely become Minnesota Law in a short while.  The design is below.  The right side of the real flag will be light blue in color.  This will replace a flag whose essence has been in existence for a very long time – since Statehood in 1858.  The process to this new flag was very long and deliberate in 2023.  As with any change, for some it was  controversial, to the point of hate mail.  This is one of the things every legislator has to reckon with, in every session, with every Bill on which he or she must vote.  The new flag misses the one thing I personally lobbied to retain from the old flag – L’Etoile du Nord.  On the other hand, I like the new design and I’ll get accustomed to it, as will all of us.  It’s government in action.

 

Propaganda

Lest it be lost, below, I urge you to set aside the time to read this long commentary from a blogger I’ve never heard of: Terri Kanefield (note the April 6 post) This is long.  Take the time, agree, disagree, but do take the time….  Thanks to Molly for letting me know about it.

*

Yesterday I caught an on-air conversation between Nicole Wallace and John Bolton. Their names may well be familiar: Nicole is a fixture on MSNBC, Bolton is a prominent Republican.  In an earlier life, Nicole worked for Jeb Bush in Florida, then his brother, George W. Bush at the White House, then for John McCain, as Republican candidate for President in 2008.  She was a California Republican.  Bolton is best known as UN Ambassador for George Bush in 2005-06; later National Security Advisor for the President of the United States 2018-19.  He has a recent book “The Room Where It Happened” about life in the White House.

What I found interesting was not unexpected.  Would Bolton vote for Biden in November?  There was the usual waffling, with the also usual ‘nutgraf’ that Biden’s foreign policy was worse than bad.

So goes the drill with political conversation in the United States in 2024.  Who, What is to be believed?  You won’t get it from highly placed sources who know that their every word of theirs will be interpreted, their every sentence and paragraph sliced and diced.

In the end, each of us as citizens has to decide, not only who to select for President, but every other elective office, and it best be an informed decision, including whether to vote at all.  Every voter action or inaction is consequential.

*

Terri Kane’s commentary highlights a dilemma most any of us have these days.  We have so many sources of information, so many choices, that it becomes difficult to even have a civil conversation – what I read you’ve never heard of; what you saw on television I didn’t watch – on and on.

My friend who sent me the link to the commentary admits she rarely watches the tube.

As for me, I do, but I try to at least get a sense of other perspectives.

Kanefield’s post reminded me of something I wrote in 1996, after the Presidential election that year.  My commentary is here: Politics 1996.  This is five pages, and a good piece of it takes a look back at a vignette in 1960 Presidential election time.  At least take a look.

The purpose of this post is not to advocate for anyone or anything; rather to encourage your own personal reflection in the interim between now and November 5.

 

Eclipse of the Sun, April 8, 2024

I was curious about solar eclipses in the United States since we became a nation.  Here’s the list.

Yesterday’s eclipse in Rochester NY, mid afternoon wasn’t directly visible to the locals.

Below photo by and of John Bernard in Rochester area on April 8….  The internet report about Rochester NY for April 8.  I knew my brother John was traveling from California to Rochester NY to watch the eclipse at our sister, Mary’s, home.

My requests were brief: “What some people won’t do to get free publicity.  Wave to the camera if you see one – I’ll look for you on the news tonight! Look forward to a full report” and
I’m expecting a Pulitzer quality shot of the eclipse in Rochester.  Nothing secondhand!
I watched part of it today.  I guess there are no unique stories.  Every sighting is unique!
Hope you saw something.  Sounded like the odds were pretty good.”

About 5:30 my time came three photos from John: the first of overcast sky in Rochester; the last of a sunshiny afternoon in Rochester; and in the middle, this one, taken at the actual time of the eclipse, featuring John and his “sun”.  So, nobody actually saw the eclipse in Rochester on April 8, but everybody experienced it, and in a few minutes it was over, everywhere.

And John gets his Pulitzer from me.  Or whoever had the idea to take this photo of the real world.

In the eclipse at Rochester NY mid-afternoon April 8. John Bernard represents the sun, and the humans, outdoors at Fairport.

Our sister, Mary, hostess, wrote a little later and added her few cents:

Hi guys..,.the much awaited April 8 Eclipse Spectacular event has come and gone.    
JB gave you the executive summary permitting me license to spin the rest of the story. 
 
Sunday evening, April 7, we attended a musical evening with classical, pops, ballet, vocal, troupe vertigo and video depictions of all things extraterrestrial.  It was held at the convention center and we weaved through a highly unusual Rochester traffic jam as multiple lines of traffic and drivers who do not understand the zipper merge went into the “20 dollar prepay” parking garage. The concert started 30 minutes late so I would imagine people who had allowed extra time to get there were a little annoyed at us and the other hundreds of  late comers.
 
T’was good though!
 
JB was on California time and plenty tired after some air delays Saturday and a busy Sunday of sightseeing his way from Pittsburgh to Rochester.   Monday, the big day, started mid morning at a busy local diner Donuts Delite/Salvatores Pizza. We also checked out the reservoir at Highland Park which is being drained after a recent crime and was to be site of the Channel 13 watch party.  A bit more traffic than usual, for sure, but the clouds were building fast and hopes of a clear blue sky for the spectacular at 3:15 PM were falling quickly.
 
However, our clouds were not of interest to national media outlets who were scattered along the whole path of totality to find a good spot.  Lucky thousands who chose the Indianapolis Speedway for their watch party!
 
Streets got quiet around noon as folks were gathering in various places to eat junk and wait for darkness.  There were plenty of watch parties but we stayed around Wickford.  JB took the bike for a short spin and I went to the JCC where at least one person in town didn’t know the 
Eclipse was happening.  At least that could be assumed from her “Oh, is that today” comment……also notable was the lifeguard who knew of the eclipse driven early closing of the fitness center but thought it was for ‘tollitarity”.
 
We are all better versed in Eclipse jargon today!
 
Finally-it is 3:15 PM.  It did get cooler, it did get very dark – there was no need for glasses to protect the eyes.  The clouds did a good job.  However, we could hear and see the sounds and sights of fireworks.   
 
 Would you believe that sun and blue sky re-appeared at 5:30 PM.  Local news covered local events and  Rotarians reminded us we could donate our gently used eclipse glasses or save them for the next total or partial sighting-should we be fortunate enough to continue to inhabit the earth.
 
And that, dear readers, is a part of the rest of the story! Have a great week, everyone!

In the evening came photos from Mary Ann’s son, Sean, in Houston TX, and daughter, Rebecca, who had driven from Springfield IL to Indianapolis IN.
from nephew, Sean: From Houston – L’s phone – very overcast today

Eclipse viewed in Houston April 8, 2024

from niece, Rebecca: Very clear in Indianapolis!  Had a great view with the Moody nephews at a park near Evin’s. Completely bemused by the animals not quite sure why night was 10 minutes long! 

Easy peasy drive back to Springfield [Il], minimal delays!
(Best I could do with my iPhone 🤷‍♀️)

Indianapolis IN April 8, 2024

from Nancy in Salt Lake City:  Thanks for the reports and the photos.  It sounds like a fun and interesting time, despite the clouds in Rochester (and Houston).  The corona sounds like it was the star of the show in places where it was clear.  It was relatively quiet and uneventful here.  

I appreciate everyone sharing their photos and experiences!

from Mary: I celebrated by doing three hours of a life drawing of five darkened sites transmitted by tv and filtered by nasa. Bob in speaker phone connection gave language to one corona.  equatorial….another was diamond…..another series of spots reflected light from moon valleys,,,,,,physicists are so much fun,,,,,text me if you want that work in progress photo…..

I celebrate that the sense of awe and wonder was directed by positive embracing of science and nature
*

So went the great eclipse of April 8, 2024, at least for one American family.  Doubtless the perfect photo is readily accessible on the internet.  The Minneapolis Star Tribune had a shot from Farmington Missouri dominating the front page of the paper.  I prefer the ones shared here!

I don’t think I’ve been proximate to past eclipses of the sun.  [Postnote 7 p.m. Apr 9: Apparently there was only one solar eclipse that passed over ND in my lifetime, and that was 1979 when I was long gone from there.  The next one is 2044.  Lunar eclipses are more common.

The one specific memory of a ‘heavenly object’ was watching Sputnik blink through the brilliantly dark night sky over the North Dakota farm in the fall of 1957.  I was a senior in high school, and the Soviets win in the space race got the U.S. up and running and the rest is still evolving history.

These events are important to the extent that they encourage conversation and learning.  Thanks, everyone.

POSTNOTE:

Twice before I’ve had actual reports from observers of U.S. eclipses.

Kathy in Mt Angel OR had an excellent view of the eclipse in 2017.  I think these photos were taken at the time the eclipse was occurring on an obviously clear sky.   Oregon August 21, 2017

Composite photo of the Oregon eclipse in 2017, from the area near Mt. Angel..

The same eclipse attracted my daughter, Lauri, who took a friend and several of their kids to  the St. Louis area August 21, 2017.  They had the same weather condition as Rochester, and ended up having lunch on the lawn at the Gateway Arch, closed at the time for renovation.

I think everyone in each of these vignettes found the time worthwhile.  And I’m sure it was shared.

Covid-19: The first year, some personal recollections

Four years ago, as Covid-19 strangled all of our ‘business as usual’ notions, there still seems a national PTSD.   We all have our stories.

I decided to use my time ‘in quarantine’ 2020-21 to sort through and label over 20,000 photos then-and-still stored on my computer.  Most photos were unlabeled.   (Most were digital, and I hadn’t noted in some cases, who or what they showed.  The digital ones were date-stamped, of course, so I could identify most.)

It was a lot of work, but I got the file essentially up to date…through 2019.  But I continued to take pictures, and fell into the same old habits of not finishing the task of labeling.

This past Wednesday I started again.  This time it was easier, and the first day I did 2020, the first year of the Pandemic, and at this writing I’m through mid-2021.  In this post I want to briefly translate my first 12 months in the Pandemic, through the photos I reviewed, and perhaps jog you to do something similar from your own perspective.

We’ve all lived through an immensely significant time in our history,  with lessons hopefully learned from this awful experience.  We’re not out of the now-four-year-war….

*

I archive all of my posts, which are all word-searchable.  The first post I did on Covid-19 was dated March 6, 2020, and can be read here.

What follows is completely jogged by my own personal photos. and speaks for itself.  Everyone has differing memories of course.  Maybe something I write will jog something in you.

Here goes:

By March, 2020, it had become undeniable that something very unpleasant was evolving in our world.  My first personal memory – my personal first notice – was the news of the Nursing Home deaths in Washington state.  My total ‘normal’ daily world was upended almost overnight.  At first,  there was no public alarm.  The first reports were perhaps two cases in Minnesota.  It turned out one of these was from a nearby suburb, but of course this wasn’t mentioned at the time.  But concern began to increase.

March 15 I went to church as usual, and ushered  It was a rather sparsely attended service.  At the end of Mass, the Priest announced that there would be no more Masses open to the public.  At the back of the church I took a photo of assorted disinfecting items.  At the time, no one knew exactly what we were dealing with.  But we were rapidly coming to know it was deadly.  Places like Italy and suburban New York City were harbingers.

I had planned a breakfast meeting with a friend on St. Patrick’s Day, March 17.  We were to meet at  a pancake house, which was supposed to be open.  My friend drove by and found that they wouldn’t be open for breakfast.  So the ‘official’ start of the Pandemic for me was St. Patrick’s Day.

March 20 was when ‘normal’ ended for everyone in Minnesota, and we weren’t alone.

*

I am a creature of habit, which created the necessity of adjusting to a new reality.  I began a daily practice of taking a photo or two of some evidence of life as it was evolving.

April 7 I photographed a chalked message on the sidewalk of my walking route: “Smile.  We Will Get Through this Together.”  It was a nice touch.  But even walkers were sparse, and most were masked, and gave lots of space.

April 22, I saw the first leaves of spring – a bush – and I took a photo of it.  It’s in the photo file.

April 23, a young woman friend of the family turned 21, and the family celebration was outside with lots of social distancing.  It was a unique gathering, which became common.  In this time frame I recall seeing a Memorial Service on a lawn for someone who had died.  I had begun a practice of one or two brief solitary drives each day to dull cabin fever.

By May 2, I knew my 80th birthday on May 4 would be a private affair, and I took a picture of the street sign at 80th Street South in the adjacent suburb of Cottage Grove.   A resident nearby was clearly suspicious of why I was taking the picture.  “I’m turning 80” was satisfactory for him, I guess.

Schools were closed, and on May 9 a local Middle School where my daughter is Principal had a Drive-by, where school staff waved to the students and parents driving by – sort of a parade.  Now, there is a Covid generation of kids, and the process of recovery is slow.  But it would have been insane to keep the schools open back then.

I did one screen shot of the first zoom meeting I was part of.  Another big adjustment.

By Mid-May, 2020, I had completely abandoned my outdoor walks.  Even walkers, even social distance, seemed not enough for some walkers I met.  It was a paranoid time.  I began doing ‘sanity drives’ a couple of times a day: just nearby places I’d not seen, no more than a few miles.  I got to know places like Newport, Grey Cloud Island, old Cottage Grove, and the like.  All solitary visits in a car.  Often I’d stop to get takeout coffee at my Caribou Coffee – there was no indoor seating, takeout only.

The evening of May 29, my friends restaurant, Gandhi Mahal, was burned to the ground in south Minneapolis, one of the last acts of violence in the wake of the May 25 murder of George Floyd.  To this day, the block on which the restaurant had stood has not been rebuilt, except the U.S. Post Office.  The Surveillance Camera was burned along with the building, and no one has been arrested.  Four years later, there remain significant residual effects of that awful week.  This was face-mask time, so perpetrators of this wanton violence were most likely masked, and only have their conscience as punishment.

June 3, 2020: the school year had been totally upset all Spring.  My daughter is Principal of a large Middle School, and I saw this in her office when I stopped in for a brief visit.  I gathered most school management was by laptop….

June 3, 2020 Oltman Middle School

June 7, grandson Parker graduated from high school.  It was a most unusual graduation – students made appointments to come, one at a time, to receive their diploma.  On the 12th, grandson Ben turned 15.  There were occasional other similar events, all outdoors.

August 12 I took a screen shot on the television of the Joe Biden/Kamala Harris candidacy for President.

September 19 I saw a sign at Basilica announcing that people could come to Mass, but needed to pre-register.  I gather one per pew was normal density, possible exception: couples.  Few attended, I think.  The church ventilation system had been upgraded, and a new on-line televised Mass initiated, which continues to this day.

October 2, I took a screen shot of the President being taken by helicopter to Walter Reed Hospital for treatment of Covid; October 6, another screen shot of the defiant President back at the White House.  All stops had been pulled to save his life, I gathered.  (For the rest of us, see February 4, below).

November 7, Joe Biden and Kamala Harris were elected.  Another screen shot.

January 6, 2021, I took 32 screen shots of the riot at the U.S. Capitol – the first at 2 pm. the last at 3:07 p.m. Central Time.  I watched the entire spectacle in stunned silence.

January 17, I took a screen shot of heavy security gathering at the Minnesota State Capitol in the event of some demonstration there.  I don’t think a lot transpired, but there was fear of violence.

January 19, a screen shot that Covid-19 had tallied 400K deaths, and 24.2 M cases (400,000 and 24.2 million).

January 20 screen shots of the inauguration of Joe Biden and Kamala Harris as President and Vuce-President of the United States.

I got my first vaccine, February 4, 2021.  The clinic was very well organized.   Since, have had 6 rounds, and am pending a 7th soon.  I was pretty diligent with masking through the first year; and some habits, like social-distancing in lines, are positive residual habits.

February 9, the 2nd impeachment of the past president began.

February 27, 2021: back in restaurant.  Life returning to normal, but lots of after-effects.

*

April 6, 2024: To date, we’ve avoided the virus, without becoming hermits, but we’ve been careful. The disease to now has taken over 1,000,000 American lives….

I tend to be an optimist.  I think enough of us have possibly learned a thing or two from the catastrophe which we experienced four years ago.  A primary re-learning for myself is that every single one of us on the globe is an interdependent part of a massive community.  We can’t survive by our own individual wits.  It is too easy to get careless, to not learn from mistakes, to pretend we can do this on our own.  I wish us well.

POSTNOTE: Reflections after Easter post, here.  Today is the local Senate District Democratic Convention.  I’m a delegate, and will write about that later.

COMMENTS below

After Easter: a time to focus on the future.

This morning I surprised a Ma and Pa Duck out scouting for a nesting place.  Memo to Ma and Pa: there are better places than a bush besides a busy sidewalk…good hunting.  A few minutes earlier I remarked to a fellow walker in the Health Center my prediction that there’s at least one decent snowstorm in Minnesota’s future before we actually have Spring.  Stay tuned.

Today ws the Easter egg roll on the White House Lawn.  There is ginned up  controversy about it, revolving around Christian themed Easter eggs, and the LGBTQ+ proclamation for March 31 which this year happened to coincide with Easter.    Here’s an article I received yesterday about the controversies.

*

March 17 I mentioned an 0n-line presentation Monday, March 25, featuring an Israeli professor discussing how Palestinians are presented to Israeli students.  I participated.  The presentation was one hour and excellent.  Here is the YouTube rebroadcast.  It is very worthy of your time.

Mary, who watched the replay said this about it: “Thanks for an exceptional talk.    Great to see you in action and good humor.   May share talk with neighbors on both sides…”

At the beginning of the March 17 post, I made this comment about the Professors topic, about how Palestinians are portrayed in Israeli school texts: “The emphasis…by Prof. Nurit Peled-Elhanan … is common in how national histories are conveyed.  All who feel they’re part of a dominant culture or ideology have their blind spots.  For instance, Native Americans did not factor favorably into the official narrative of American History, and still don’t…. ”  Of course, we all have our blind spots, as individuals, as subordinate groups….  The majority blindspots are the most dangerous in the short (current) term.

*

Given the continuing intense conflict in Gaza, I wondered and worried about how the issue would be addressed in my church during this years Holy Week commemoration of Jesus’ death and resurrection..

I’m a lifelong Catholic, so I’ve seen a lot of Easter seasons. I’m at church most every Sunday.   Over my 83 years I’ve had considerable interest in church/church & church/state relationships.

I’ve calculated that there have been over 1400 Sunday Masses since I joined Basilica of St. Mary in 1997, and while I don’t keep a tally, I rarely miss Sunday Mass at 9:30.  In my lifetime, over 4,300….

As such, I think would pass as a qualified observer of the Catholic liturgy as it has been practiced over the years.

This year I heard and saw the Passion read on Palm Sunday, and the Archbishop speak on Easter Sunday.  Friday night, Good Friday, I participated on-line in the annual observance of Tenebrae, which Molly tuned in and said as follows: “I really appreciated your advance notice regarding [Tenebrae]. It was powerful, and incredibly well-planned, and carried out. The participants’ work with light and darkness, and the interspersing of word and song, were beautifully sequenced. The addition of Rabbi Zimmerman at the end was a real surprise to me, and added depth, indeed.”

*

Of course, overlaying everything for me was the continuing situation in Gaza.  I understood that Rabbi Zimmerman (Temple Israel) would speak. She is not a stranger at Basilica’s Tenebrae, which has been an annual liturgy at Basilica for over 20 years.  She and colleague Rabbi’s have always impressed.

Overall, I felt the observances I witnessed at this years Holy Week were all appropriate and positive.  I wondered how the politics of the time in history would intersect, and how the Passion story would be treated.  There was no edginess at all, which was very welcome.

Rabbi Zimmerman, long-time Rabbi at Temple Israeli, gave a particularly outstanding message, not side-stepping Gaza.  Her focus was on Mother’s loss – the women who attended to Jesus’ body in the Passion story.  She called our attention to an international group, Parents Circles Family Forum, Palestinian and Israeli families who have lost family members in conflicts.  Take a look.

At the end of her remarks, Rabbi Zimmerman received a sustained standing ovation from the filled church.  This recognition is very unusual, and was richly deserved.

There is a long, long road ahead, but one step at a time and peace and justice can succeed, thanks to all of us.

We all, individually and as parts of groups, can impact positively on the future.  But we need to be on the court.

POSTNOTE April 2: 

Gaza is a terribly troubling topic to take a stand on, or to write about.  Just today Israeli precision bombs killed several food aid representatives in clearly marked vehicles.

People are forced into taking sides.  Like everyone, I’m a single individual, feeling impotent.

In the narratives in these kinds of situations, there is always an effort to target a person or an entity as being responsible.  So, it is said that it is Hamas; or it is Netanyahu; on and on.

For me, during Holy Week, I most engaged in trying to see how organized religion dealt with this most historically difficult issue – the crucifixion of a Jewish man by the Romans with the tacit approval of the Jews: the Passion story.

As I pointed out above, I felt the organized religion in my background – Catholic – in my area, handled the issue and all that surrounds it in a constructive way.  So it was with the Jewish leadership, and most likely the Muslim leadership as well.  Of course, my perception is mine alone.

It’s more complicated than that, of course.

My Church is an immense entity: it is said that about one in four Americans in one sense or another is “Catholic”.

But this designation is essentially meaningless.  All Catholics do not similarly participate; nor do they believe identically; or position on political or other issues.  Those who make policy may think or try to represent that they speak for everyone, but they don’t.  Like any association in this country, people can participate if/as they wish, and choose in the many ways available to them to take positions or not.  Catholics are no more an Army, than are Jews, or Muslims or anyone.  The problem come from who is selected to lead by whatever means.  That is an extremely complex topic.

For me, personally, I have come to the conclusion that I can have an impact, but that my impact will be very small.  But there are others who might agree with me – I may never meet them. – who advocate the same way for the same thing somewhere else.

Only by participating in the conversation can anyone make any difference at all.  It is not enough to blame someone or something else.  As Gandhi is supposed to have said, we all must be the change we wish to see in the world.  Even Gandhi didn’t’ see victory in his lifetime, or even still.  But there is no question that he made a big difference.  We can be so as well.

 

Windmill

Overnight Tuesday came an e-mail from a friend, commenting on a Frank Lloyd Wright home she know, somewhere.

The reference jogged me to think back to mid-October, 2013, visiting Wright’s Taliesin, Spring Green WI, and seeing a unique windmill there (see photos at end of this post).  In turn, that caused me to think of another windmill found at the North Dakota farm around the time of my Uncle’s death in 2015, which I came across in a box a short while ago.  It is below, simply a piece of farm art on a scrap piece of wood, doubtless a cooperative creation of persons very familiar with windmills, prairie farms and water.

I don’t know who did the above creation, measuring about 7″x12″.  It is likely a photo from a farm magazine glued on a piece of scrap lumber and then varnished to become a piece of home grown decoupage.  It was a hobby which I remember seemed to have caught on like a prairie wildfire among my elders for a time.  If there was a ‘culprit’, I would put my Aunt Florence near ground zero for planting the seed to decoupage.  But it could have been my mom, or any to the other sisters or female aunts.  You know how such things go.

Show this photo to anyone who’s ever had a close call with an old farm, and it will bring forth lots of memories.  Windmills were the farm “water works” – a source of hopefully fresh water from a fairly shallow well.

*

The windmill at Taliesin has its own story, which the internet helpfully searched for me.  Here, you can read the short story.

Oct 16, 2013 at Frank Lloyd Wrights Taliesin, Spring Green WI.  Photos by Dick Bernard

October 16, 2013. Taliesin

In a way, those windmills are like all of us.  In their lives they’ve seen a lot, and done a lot.

Unlike us, they spent their time stuck in place.  Most of us are capable of more flexibility, and making more of an impact than we feel we’re stuck with.

We take many things for granted, these days, which folks couldn’t imagine not all that many years ago.  Rural electricity replaced wind power on my grandparents farm in 1949.  An interesting diary of another North Dakotan adds to that story.  You can read the article here.

Now another spring begins.  A good time to take another look at how we, as individuals, can positively impact the status quo.  And then ‘spring’ into action!

*

Bonus PREVIEW, especially for those whose ancestry includes French-Canadian and/or Midwest.  Visit the French American Heritage Foundation website (here) , click Library tab, click books, and scroll down to Roy-Collette Family History.  This is brand new, a French-Canadian family story from France, to Quebec, to the United States, to the Twin Cities area, North Dakota, Ste Elizabeth, Manitoba and Lampman, Saskatchewan.  This is author  Remi Roy’s paternal grandparents story.  At least scroll through the document.  There will be a specific post on the book later in April, but the entire 315 page book is available.  Disclosure: Remi Roy and I are cousins through the Collette line.  At the same site is my 400+ page French-Canadian family history, Bernard-Collette Family History, which is also available in its entirety, from 2010.

COMMENTS (more at end of post):

from Fred:  Liked the Taliesen windmill. We visited Frank Lloyd Wright’s Spring Green hangout probably around the same time you did. I don’t remember the windmill, though. We greatly enjoyed the visit. Wright actually influenced how we sited the house we are now in. Instead of going up a few stories for a better river view, we opted for a land-conforming walkout rambler style. It still feels like the right decision.

I vividly recall looking at windmills when the family was driving to relatives and friends in the area. Every farm still seemed have them in the 1950s. No matter which way we traveled out of the Red Wing metroplex, I got to see windmills. They fascinated me.


from Lois:  Happy Easter Dick – may you continue to send “thoughts towards a better world” for a long, long time.  I enjoyed thoughts of windmills on my mom’s family farm.

I have heritage of 9X great grandparents who arrived from France in the early 1600s as well as 8X GGF from Netherlands – this was a nice reminder of my ancestors.  The first family to settle in Luverne area of Rock County originated in England – to Salem MA and left for Canada after death of 2ndgeneration mothers execution as a witch.  Their journey continued to reach here thru Wisconsin in the mid- late 1800’s.

from Mary: Hi Dick,  Yes for sure my mom [Florence] was into decoupaging.  I have a few of her pieces.  She loved Norman Rockwell calendars.  Also wedding invitations.  She asked our dentist who was located in Hannaford ND for his old dental tools.  She carved her edges with those.  Never on barn wood that I saw,  but dad cut her boards for her.  She taught classes the County Extension Service and home makers clubs.  My mom was always busy and very gifted with her hands.  Loved her so much.

 

Easter

PRE-NOTE: I recommend the on-line program Monday March 25.  Details, scroll down here.

This morning (Saturday March 23) at 6 a.m. I was arriving at my coffee shop, and directly ahead of me was the most striking view of a full moon I have ever seen.  It was about tree top level, soon to set.  The atmospheric conditions were apparently perfect.  (Technically, the full moon is actually Monday morning, March 25, but no difference.  This mornings was spectacular, even given the hand-held snapshot. )

Woodbury MN 6 a.m. CDT March 23, 2024 Dick Bernard

Easter is next Sunday, March 31.  Each year, Easter  moves around on the calendar.  By definition, it is set as the Sunday after the first full moon of the Vernal Equinox (Spring).  I asked my computer about the dates of Easter: “The earliest possible date for Easter is March 22 and the latest possible date is April 25. Easter can never come as early as March 21, though. That’s because, by ecclesiastical rules, the vernal equinox is fixed on March 21“.  (The earliest vernal equinox is March 19).

Out at the farm in North Dakota, in the early 1900s, my grandparents received and kept pictorial cards received from the home folks in Wisconsin.  The family was Catholic.  About half of the well-over 200 cards received and kept were Christmas themed; about one-fourth Easter themed.  40% of the Easter cards had a religious orientation.  (Only about 10% of the Christmas cards had religious orientation.)

Easter was a time of rebirth everywhere: Spring, Baby Chicks, snow melt, Easter bunnies, re-greening of the earth.

Of course, everyone reading this can fill in the abundant blanks about how Easter has played out in their own lives over the years.  (Often Passover comes at about the same time as Easter.  This year Passover is April 22-30.   Ramadan this year is March 11 – April 9.  The three intersect about once every 33 years, the last was in 2023.

In my particular faith, Easter weeks starts with Palm Sunday, tomorrow; thence Holy Thursday, Good Friday and Easter Sunday.  Here is the schedule at my church.  Always and still central is the Passion, which this year can be read here (scroll down to the gospel).  This will be read on Palm Sunday.   Herein comes the reference to the Jews, which has created so much tragedy for the Jews over history.  As a lifelong Catholic, I’ve witnessed the assorted ways this narrative has been handled by my church – the words are the same, but how they are presented have differed.  (Normally, we’d be at Church tomorrow.  A winter storm is predicted here overnight.  We’ll see.)

At my church, Basilica of St. Mary’s in Minneapolis, for over 20 years, there has annually been an evening service (7 p.m.) on the Friday before Easter called Tenebrae (see schedule in preceding paragraph).  I have not attended this every year, but traditionally, and I believe this year as well, it is customary for a Rabbi from nearby Temple Israel to speak.  This year, Tenebrae, March 29, 7 p.m., will be live-streamed, as will most of the other rituals during the week.  To access, go to the Basilica website at the time/day of the event.  The reading of the Passion will be live-streamed as part of the 9:30 Mass on March 24.

early 1900s postal greeting to the ND farm

COMMENTS (more at the end):

from Joyce: From a Jewish perspective, Easter is quite fraught; it was, historically, an extremely dangerous time because of the blood libel, which resulted in mass murders. I love Fiddler on the Roof, but it depicted a pogrom as nothing more sinister than property destruction. Pogroms were deadly; even infants were killed. It was because of pogroms that my grandparents came to the US at the end of the 19th century.

Another Jewish holiday starts after sunset tonight, Purim. Most of our holidays can be explained as: they tried to kill us, we survived, so let’s eat. Purim is a bit different; they tried to kill us, we survived, so let’s party. If the weather allows I’m going to the children’s Purim service at _____ with my grandchildren tomorrow; there should be a lot of laughter. The children will all be in costume; traditionally, children wear costumes and go from door to door giving out sweets.

Response to Joyce from Dick: I think your growing up background was in a major U.S. city.  Mine was tiny (literally) midwest towns – I once went to a high school with two seniors.  These towns were basically homogeneous – usually basically Catholic or Lutheran dominated, and rarely very mixed.  Jews only appeared in the Passion story, and if there were speaking parts for the reading, Jesus was always the Priest, the “Father”.  Palestinians were not even an abstract idea….  I have thought quite a bit about this over the years.  The only message we got about Jews was that they killed Jesus, and this was basically at this important season, and it wasn’t elaborated on to my recollection, anyway.  I don’t remember any reference of any kind to Father Coughlin, the anti-semite radio Priest who was very powerful in the 1930s and into the 1940s.  I guess the bothersome part of this particularly in this tribal age is the intensification of labeling of the ‘other’, whoever that might happen to be.  We do it all the time – Super Bowl, Final Four, Muslims, and on and on and on.  That’s one reason why I want to listen in on the talk on Monday (above) and why I want to see how or even if the issue is addressed by the Rabbi at the Basilica on Friday.

Thank you for your willingness to be in dialogue.

from Flo: Easter certainly has mixed meanings for many people. I’m now attending Sunday worship alone at RUMC, but also with friends who pick me up at home or bring me home after the service. Carter is also my driver, occasionally. During this Easter I decided to read the Bible beginning from the first page. It’s definitely not my favorite reading, but it certainly makes it clear that Adam and Eve started something that has kept “The Faithful” floundering! I forgot to bring my Bible with me to our Thursday-Saturday stay at the cabin, so now I have a lot of make-up reading ahead of me. Wonder how long I’ll stick with the effort…

from Florence: thanks, wonderful picture.

Israel/Palestine

The emphasis of this post is the upcoming talk by Nurit Peled-Elhanan (see below).  All I know about the talk and speaker is what you see below.  To be clear, what the speaker will likely talk about is common in how national histories are conveyed.  All who feel they’re part of a dominant culture or ideology have their blind spots.  For instance, Native Americans did not factor favorably into the official narrative of American History, and still don’t….  I encourage you to join this webcast.  I will be enrolling myself.  I’ll probably reflect, personally,  on the indigenous, settler history in ND and Minnesota.  There is a lot of very uncomfortable history.

*

Recently I was at a meeting at a local Middle School, and around the cafeteria were many national flags.  I’m not sure of the back story, but my guess is they relate to the international flavor of the school – persons of many nationalities are students.  Two or three miles away is the international headquarters of 3M.  We’re part of a global community, and that’s a good thing – albeit not always easy.

World Flags at Woodbury Middle School MN March 2024

A few days ago came two announcements of current international interest – in both cases, specifically related to Israel and Gaza.

Molly sent a note March 14:  Senator Chuck Schumer (D-NY) gave an amazing and very powerful speech in the US Senate today.  It is about 45 minutes.

There is, of course, all sorts of commentary up online about it:
 some blasting Schumer for saying anything; some saying he’s treasonous; some saying he doesn’t go far enough; some praising it; and everything in between. 
I thought it was worth watching in full.
Blessings, all, as we pray for the end of this carnage,

I did watch it in full, and it is very worthwhile.  Certainly, as he was well aware himself, there is something for anybody and everybody to agree and disagree with.  That’s part of its power.

*

Nancy sent a notice on March 16, which I’ll definitely participate in:
Sponsored by Citizens for Global Solutions, Minnesotaplease share with your members and friends, and join us!
 
CGS-MN HUMAN RIGHTS FORUM: Palestine in Israeli School Books: Ideology and Propaganda in Education
Date: Monday, March 25, 2024
Time: 12noon – 1:00 pm (Central Time – USA)
Where: Zoom (register at link below)
Cost: FREE and open to the public

Register in advance here (scroll down to the specific program):
After registering, you will receive a confirmation email containing information about joining the meeting.

Nurit Peled-Elhanan

Guest Speaker: Nurit Peled-Elhanan is an Israeli philologist, professor of language and education at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, translator, and activist. She is a 2001 co-laureate of the Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought awarded by the European Parliament. Her book, Palestine in Israeli School Books: Ideology and Propaganda in Education, was released in the U.K. in April 2012. She states that the only representation of Arabs in Israeli books is as “refugees, primitive farmers and terrorists,” claiming that in “hundreds and hundreds” of books, not one photograph depicted an Arab as a “normal person”.

Description: Professor Nurit Peled analyzes the presentation of images, maps, layouts and use of language in History, Geography and Civic Studies textbooks, and reveals how the Israeli books might be seen to marginalize Palestinians, legitimize Israeli military action and reinforce Jewish-Israeli territorial identity. Nurit Peled provides a fresh scholarly contribution to the Israeli-Palestinian debate, relevant to the fields of Middle East Studies and Politics more widely.

*

A FINAL THOUGHT, March 17:  This weeks church newsletter at Basilica featured a column by Fr. Joe Gillespie, which included this paragraph: “As we get closer to Jerusalem on our Lenten journey, we can dare to dream of a better world to come.  However, the raging wars in the Ukraine and Gaza sap our strength and ratchet our fears of ever achieving peace in the Kingdom.  Searching for heroes or heroines to lead us on a journey of hope, we must resurrect the images the likes of Oscar Romero, Martin Luther King, Jr., and Alexei Navalny to remind us of Jesus’ statement: “Unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies, it remains just a single grain but if it dies, it bears much fruit.

This is the second to last paragraph of the excellent column, “Who Was That Masked Man”, shared in entirety here: Fr. Joe Gillespie March 17 2024

Haiti

The major headline in today’s Minneapolis StarTribune: “U.S. ups embassy security in Haiti.  Military flies to capital with gangs largely in control“.

This is not the kind of publicity one likes to see.  The details are readily available on-line, so I won’t go into the current event.  Rather, I want to afford an opportunity to look back at the Haiti I saw in two visits in 2003 and 2006.

Tens of thousands of Americans have been to Haiti, very few of them as ‘tourists’.  Haiti is a small impoverished nation just to the east of Cuba.  After my first visit I did a sketch map comparing Haiti with Minnesota (special thanks to Paul Miller for refinement):

There were two memorable trips, both about a week: both intensive study trips.

The first trip centered on Port au Prince and environ in early December, 2003.  There were six of us in a journey expertly organized by Paul Miller.  The second trip came in March, 2006, organized by the Microfinance group, Fonkoze, and focused on the interior of Haiti out of Hinche (Ench in kreyol), another extraordinary trip. (Ench is a community of about 50,000 approximately where the H in Haiti appears on the above map.)

I wrote about both trips on my return from each trip, and these and other observations are easily available to anyone interested here (click at Haiti in Focus).

Succinctly, I have very positive memories of the Haitian people I met on both trips.

Less than three months after we returned home in 2003, President Aristide, who brought democracy to the island nation, was deposed and exiled.  We had primarily met with persons who shared his values and aspirations for the Haitian people.

The second trip our focus was on the poor in Haiti, aspiring to a better life.

I do not recall a single instance of fear or even tension on either trip, though particularly on the first trip there was clear political tension.

In my opinion, Haiti since it’s beginning as a French colony was noteworthy by its Declaration of Independence, by slaves, in 1804.  It was far too close to the brand new slave holding nation of the United States, and I believe that one of the early actions of the new U.S. Congress was to refuse to recognize the country as a free nation.  Books have been written about this difficult history.

We arrived in Port au Prince on December 6, 2003, and on December 7 – a Sunday – we went to a Catholic Church where Fr. Gerard Jean-Juste was pastor.  Fr. Gerard Jean-Juste knew we Americans were in the pews and his remarks were directed our way, effectively.  I took this photo of him with a parishioner at the time of the Mass.

Fr. Jean-Juste Dec. 7 2003

Later the same day we met with him at the guest house where we were staying.  He was very impressive.

Being “impressive” to the common Haitian was not an asset in December, 2003.  Fr. Jean Juste ended up in prison not long after we left Haiti.  He was an apparent threat to the desired status quo.  Three years later I met him  again in Miami’s Little Haiti where he had effectively been exiled.  He was apparently too dangerous for Haiti, but safe on the streets of the U.S….

Take time to learn more about Haiti.  With all of our good qualities as a nation, we have lots to learn about relationships with others.

Haiti timeline I prepared after the 2003 trip.  Errors in content are mine.

POSTNOTE March 16:

Here is a photo of the 2003 Study Group, in Haiti:

Dec. 8 was a wonderful day.  The week to come was full and peaceful but at times intense.  We were in the country when the storm clouds of a coup were far advanced.  But the stereotype of recent news was not our experience in 2003, nor was it our experience in the interior in 2006.  Personally I never felt at risk.

I was and I am not naive.  But subsequent to the first visit I made a personal list of incidents proximate to us, or which played out after we returned to the states.  For example, someone we met at a school. a few hours later was apparently assassinated near the Haiti Capitol building>. Someone else I met – a Priest – apparently was murdered by poisoning a year or so later…Fr. Jean-Juste thrown into Prison in Haiti, and then exiled to what essentially was freedom in Little Haiti in Miami, where I met him again in 2006, seemingly free, but far away from home – an interesting variation on being sent to Siberia.  He seemed on community arrest.  If he stayed in Little Haiti, no problem….  Or so it appeared.

In 2006 we were in the interior, very poor environment, but our group of perhaps 15 being shown around by Fonkoze was very well treated.  In this second trip I can recall no nervous moments (other than traveling on roads which were definitely not thoroughfares – sometimes very dicey),

In neither year did we tempt fate by foolish decisions: it was less risky to go to church than to some neighborhood bar; less risky to visit with people trying to eke out a living, than getting into a political argument on the street.  Come to think of it, even here at home, there is prudent or careless behavior.  If one seeks trouble, one can find it.

Unfortunately, it seems that Jan 6, 2021, at our nations capitol, is now happening most every day in much of Haiti.  Well armed gangs have taken over.  Who knows what the solution might be…there is a solution, just what that is, is probably impossible to imagine at this tense time.

There are, of course, narratives about Haiti and about its governance, etc., etc.  There was, there is, and there will remain mis- and dis-information.  I don’t pretend to be an expert; Haiti is not a perfect society, neither is our own.  All I can report on is what I experienced, and what I learned afterwards, including the aftermath of the 2010 massively destructive earthquake which killed hundreds of thousands.  The website links give my personal impressions from the past trips.

Today, I gather, we could not fly into the PaP airport if we wanted to, and if we could and did we would be fools.  And activities such as we participated in would now likely be very dangerous.

Today, with Gaza. and Ukraine, and all other places facing tension, we live in an unfortunately tribal society, I can only hope for positive outcomes.

What happens in Haiti, and Ukraine, and Gaza, and in our own country will affect all of us.  It is far too easy to blame somebody for the problems.  All of us need to be part of the solution.  Keep on keeping on.

POSTNOTE 2 March 17:  I was a geography major in college, and taught Junior High School geography for nine years, and probably could have headed for a career as a geographer had I not diverted into union work over 50 years ago.

Still, when I agreed to travel to Haiti in 2003, I really had very little knowledge about the island nation.  I have had almost a college education since.

The group I traveled with was led by a supporter of Jean-Bertrand Aristide, the Catholic Priest elected as the first democratically elected President of Haiti, whose orientation was to the poor, which were the vast majority of Haitians, almost all illiterate, and who spoke a dialect which sounded like basic French, but was not the official French of the country.  They were numerically superior, but almost totally disenfranchised.

Aristide came to power by an election opened to people who had never voted before, who could not read the ballot unassisted.  Nonetheless, when the opportunity was given the people of Haiti underwent the hardships and the risks of casting their ballot, to freely elect their President.

Aristide was largely viewed as an outlier, an enemy really, of the developed world (i.e. the United States, et al).  There are many roadblocks that can be, and were, thrown up to quash success of Aristide and those who supported him.  If you look at the above timeline you will get a sense of this.  At my previously mentioned website, I recounted my efforts to determine the legitimacy of the last Aristide election.  At https://www.chez-nous.net/haiti3.html, scroll down to the link to Anatomy of an Official Lie, and read the link.  It is, of course impossible for someone like myself to do a truly deep dive into “fact”, but in this case I think I got close to the truth.

In my opinion, Aristide was on the right track in Haiti, but this was frightening to the protectors of the status quo.

POSTNOTE3 March 18:  I was listening to Jose Diaz Balart on MSNBC a few minutes ago, and he was talking about 63 years of chaos in Haiti – I specifically heard “63”.   My experience with Haiti began 20 years ago, and my two contacts with the country are described above.  63 years ago would be about 1960, during the early times of Papa Doc Duvalier, whose repressive regime with his son Baby Doc spanned nearly 30 years, from 1957-86.  The Duvaliers were not supporters of Democracy, nor champions of the poor.  On the other hand, it seems they were reliable ‘friends’ of wealthier nations at the expense of their impoverished citizens.

I looked up Diaz Balart, who has a really interesting background and family.  He is Cuban, raised in Spain, after Castro took control in Cuba in 1959.  It is unclear where he was born, but mostly his early life seems to have been in Spain.

Credibly commenting on the Diaz-Balart comments would be foolhardy for me.  But I have a guess that I know more about Haiti than Jose does, and more reliably as well.  At the same time, when I visited and with whom I visited was a time when Democracy had had a brief chance in Haiti, but was also quite clearly quashed by forces outside the country, not the least of which were the United States, Canada and France.

I happen to like Balart’s work, but the comment about Haiti troubled me.  Haiti is, after all, Cuba’s next door neighbor.