Earth Day 2025

Yesterday was Earth Day.  The death of Pope Francis was top priority on the news.  On the other hand, it would be hard to find a more enthusiastic ‘fan’ of the whole range of sustainability than Pope Francis, and that is already being remembered in news we hall continue to see.

Heather Cox Richardson gives a good summation of the news of Earth Day here.

Each one of us has to be the solution we have been waiting for.  As the famous song said: “We are the World”.

Here is my post about Earth Day for this year, from April 12, 2025.

Pope Francis

Tomorrow, Tuesday April 22, is Earth Day: here’s what I wrote last week. Yesterday was Easter Sunday, thoughts about community.  Finally, some thoughts on immigrants on Good Friday.

*

Pope Francis died overnight.  I’d like to briefly share some tiny bits and pieces from my perspective, the first from a post I wrote on March 31, 2013,  about two weeks after his election as Pontiff.  You can read that post here.

It is no secret: I was and I am a fan of this Pope.  He walked the talk, a positive example for us.

Regarding what’s ahead, for anyone interested, I’d recommend looking up the recent film “Conclave” which gives a peak behind the curtain of the process for selecting the next Pope.  It is worth your time to at least learn a little about the College of Cardinals who will be the electors.  It is said that roughly 1 1/2 billions are Catholic world-wide, perhaps one-sixth of the worlds population.  Just considering the number, it is obvious that it a population of great diversity in all ways.  The Pope is more the image of the Church, than commander.  It is an important position.

Last night, hours before I heard Pope Francis had died, I’d leafed through Francis’ autobiography which I purchased a short while ago, but have not yet read.  The cover is pictured below, copyright 2025.  It comes highly recommended.  It will be my post-Easter project.

We were at Easter Sunday Mass at Basilica yesterday. and there was no inkling that the Pope was near death.  Later in the afternoon I happened across the last in a series about Christianity and Constantine and the Catholic Church.  I wasn’t looking for it – I don’t remember for certain whether PBS or History or other channel.  But it drew me in and was informative.

In the evening news, was a still alive Pope giving a brief message to the throngs at the Vatican, and taking a last ride in the Popemobile through the crowd – something I’ve witnessed personally, one time, in 1998 with Pope John Paul II.  It was very impressive.  I think we’re seven time zones west of Rome.

This morning, before leaving home, came a photo from my brother, taken yesterday at the Cathedral in Salt Lake City.

Salt Lake City Cathedral Apr 20 2025

This is a big world and there are lots of opinions.  I think this particular Pope made a big difference by his personal example.

 

COMMENTS

from Jeff:  I guess i find a photo of a full  Roman Catholic cathedral in Salt Lake City kind of funny…  having lived out west for a few years and the understanding that SLC is base camp central for the LDS…one wouldnt guess that many Catholics live there…but my guess is lots of Hispanics?

response from Dick: my brother has lived in SLC for over 50 years so the place called Utah is not unknown to me.  When he sent family members this photo last night, I had to use it.  Definitely, the census numbers belong to the LDS in Utah, nonetheless it seems that the Diocese of Salt Lake City, which comprises the entire state of Utah, counts about 10% of Utah’s population as Catholic.  I have been to this Cathedral and it is close to the downtown area, and a welcoming place.

from Carol: My cousin who lives in Central Europe sent this  Crol’s Cousin April 2025] out today to I think around 70 people.  Mike teaches American history and political science at a university.  Back in Bush’s run-up to invading Iraq, Mike sent out an alarmed e-mail that really impacted me.  I think he was very reluctant to do that again – but said that some things I had forwarded him  pushed him into doing so.

from Georgine: in below comments, Georgine attached a letter from Pope Francis to American Bishops 10 Feb 2025 relating to the migrant question.  It is a powerful letter, three pages.

three comments came about the same time today from people who don’t know each other: Carol:  I’m not Catholic, of course.   But Pope Francis was the most decent, genuine, humble and impactful Pope of my lifetime.  I love it that he hung on until after Easter.  Almost like he had some final business to take care of.  Flo: Thanks for sharing your views on Pope Francis. He had many positive beliefs, but I am still saddened by the Catholic Church’s view of women. Carter and I joined the United Methodist Church when we moved to Park Rapids in 1974.  Three years ago Carter decided to live his faith at Skunk Lake. I like it there too, but continue to attend services at Riverside UMC, walking there from home when the weather is good or otherwise getting rides to and from church by Carter or friends.   Peggy and Dale: out of the blue a comment from one of them, they attend what would be considered a ‘lefty’ Catholic Church, and were noting that their kids were raised Catholic but unchurched and that the hometown pastor where she grew up in very conservative in point of view.

The takeaway from myself, a lifelong Catholic: nothing that was said was unusual to me.  The church, regardless of what one thinks of it, is huge, and what is even more important is a creature of endless diversity which commenters try to interpret to others.  For myself, who often is ‘in the pew’ I see the diversity every time I’m in my church, which is very large.  For me, Francis gift to everyone was his ability to set a positive tone for all of us, regardless of where we are at on our own personal journey..

from Ellen:  He is a vibrant part of our human tapestry. I have gained a much clearer warmer understanding of our soul and everyone’s essence since Gary died. He and Mom were quintessentially Catholics. Gary called himself a Recovering Catholic. I am completely fascinated by the number of Catholics that I come accross. I have found my sense of belonging in Al-Anon, the 12 Steps and near death experiences. Quantum physics is also part of my tapestry. And of course the base beliefs of Catholisim.

He was a fine human being.

 

The Community of US.

Today is Easter Sunday.  This morning about 6 I was treated to a wonderful skyscape right before sunrise.  My choice for Easter Sunday is an e-mail received from a LaMoure County ND friend on April 3.  She sent me the below clip from the LaMoure Chronicle, the long-time weekly newspaper for the community of LaMoure and surrounding area.

I’m very familiar with the paper, as my maternal family, the Busch’s, subscribed to the paper for many years.  Each time I looked at the paper, there was always a looking back column, of happenings from a previous time, in this case “10 Years Ago, April 1, 2015”.  This particular snip brought back lots of memories for me, and an idea I want to share with you.

LsMoure ND Chronicle April 2025

Uncle Vince, age 90, was the last member of the LaMoure County Busch family, whose parents came to break ground in rural Berlin-Grand Rapids in 1905.  Vince was the last survivor of 11 people who lived and/or grew up on the farm.  He died in early February, 2015.  He had designated me to represent him.

The Busch’s were an ordinary rural family.  There had been pretentions of more back in the day, but the Great Depression in particular took its toll.  For Vince and Edithe, brother and sister, and indeed their parents and in a real way their siblings who went on to lives elsewhere, LaMoure County services were crucial components of their personal quality of life their entire life.  For instance, Vince loved to watch the LaMoure American Legion baseball in the summer.  On and on.

He and Edithe were regulars at the Grand Rapids Veterans Memorial Park.  Indeed, their Uncle and Aunt, Art and Lena Parker, were the first caretakers of the Park when it opened after World War I and through the 1920s.

The services were all either free or virtually so.  There was no admission to go to the park.  Nobody charged visitors to go fishing at the James River Dam area, maintained by volunteers.

After Vince died and I was trying to figure out what to do, with first responsibility to pay any bills due by the Busch’s, it occurred to me that there were many bills due, for which bills were never sent to the recipients of the service rendered, so I made a list of the places and services I knew Vince and Edithe supported by their attendance over the years, and from this came a list of, to my recollection, 16 local services, most of whom are listed above.  Also listed was what I decided to do to pay the bill, so to speak, to the providers of the service.

I really didn’t think of this until after Vincent died.  It just hadn’t occurred to me.  Nor had it occurred to him or his sister or his parents.  Of course, it was a bill subject to challenge, but it was also unique, and, long story short, the expenditure was acceptable.

Out of this experience comes a suggestion to everyone who has something to leave behind.  Perhaps you can build a similar list of similar services you’ve utilized in your community.  Consider making a list for whoever it is who will have to close your estate when you pass on, as you certainly will.

Happy Easter.

April 18, 1775

All best wishes to everyone on this Easter weekend.

250 years ago was a momentous moment is the history of the United States.  On the 250th anniversary, at the Old North Church in Boston, Heather Cox Richardson talked about the events leading later to the United States of America.  I am a subscriber to her commentary (I highly recommend subscribing) and I share here what she had to say on April 18, 2025.

Below is a snapshot I took of Old North Church in June, 1972.

Old North Church Boston, June 1972 (Dick Bernard)

The google map link of the church and area (which includes a panoramic overhead view centered on Old North Church, is here (caution and suggestions: go to this link last as you may be unable to go back to the post; also, to have the panoramic tour of the area, hover your cursor over the red marker showing Old North Church),

Personal Privilege: my father’s ancestry was 100% French-Canadian which means I’m 50%.  His last French ancestor to arrive in Quebec was Francois Collet, who arrived in Quebec in 1757 (St. Vallier), and as a 16 year old was likely attached to the French military.  The military connection was short.  In 1759, the British defeated the French at Plains of Abraham, Quebec City, thus beginning the English regime in Canada.  Only 18 years later came the events in Boston which led to the United States of America.

At the time I visited Boston in 1972 I really had no idea of my own French ancestry, or how inter-connected were the events in Quebec and in New England.  and didn’t actually visit my ancestral home country of Quebec until a 1982 visit there with my Dad and four others.  (My first French ancestor in Canada was Jean Nicolet, who arrived in 1618, 157 years before 1775.)

POSTNOTE: There is plenty more to write about, concerning current events and their implications.  These can wait till after Easter.    If you want an early start, I did posts on April 15 (Taxes) and 18 (Watch).  There are several more in the works in the next few weeks, and probably others not yet in mind.  A reflection piece is planned for Easter Sunday.

COMMENTS (more at end)

from Fred: I read it earlier and also endorse it. She did a terrific job.  We all know the story but she reconstructed so well. Actually, it brought tears to my eyes.

Watch

Today is Good Friday in the Catholic tradition, nearing Easter, at the end of what is called Holy Week which began last Sunday, Palm Sunday.  I have 84 years of experience with Holy Week in the Catholic Church.  Lots of memories.  More in a bit on that.

This week the really intense news emphasis is on a prisoner in the notorious Cecot prison in El Salvador.  The man is Kilmar Abrago Garcia of Maryland.  Yesterday Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland flew to El Salvador and met in person with Garcia. The news is flooded with stories about this prisoner and the others who were snagged by ICE and flown out of the country to this same prison.  Succinctly, I support Sen. Van Hollen’s efforts, as I support the Rule of Law, now under active attack in our own country.

A couple of days ago, a friend from a small conversation group I’m privileged to be part of, shared with us a memory, which seems an especially appropriate story for this dismal time in our history.  Her story in its entirety is shared with her permission:

“When I was living in Venezuela (1983-85), I met an Argentinian woman married to an oil man from Mexico. She told me about the military takeover of her country. People were “disappeared” by being snatched off the street, put on airplanes, and thrown out. No one would ever see them again – they were “the Disappeared.” She said she would never go back to Argentina. I was appalled, as I had lived a very sheltered life and had never heard of this bit of global news.
Never thought I’d be living in an America where people could be “disappeared.”

Her short story immediately brought back to memory a truly awful period in Argentine history.  I googled “Argentina Disappeared” and lots surfaced, including this summary.  My long ago and far away memory of this war was news back then of people being disappeared, and we later learned that many of them were flown out to sea and thrown out never to be seen or heard from again.  It seemed like a good idea to somebody –  the “disappeared” don’t leave evidence and will never talk.  Of course, the disappeared remained in the minds and hearts of people like their mothers, who slowly but surely took up the cause, and slowly but surely the despotic regime was finally disappeared, itself….

In the present circumstance, the architects of the current deportation hysteria thought they had it all figured out: round up the bad hombres, stick them on a plane and fly them to a private prison in another country.  Who needs Due Process or Habeas Corpus?  Nobody will give a damn about that – only that we got rid of them.  Out of sight, out of mind…or so they thought.

We’re probably not near the end of this story, but the cat is out of the bag now.

I think back to other fairly recent deviations from rules: torture (water-boarding) of bad guys in Iraq days; prisoners flown to Guantanamo, etc.  etc.  All supposedly legal according to a lawyer.

At the end of February, 2004, the U.S., Canada and France cooperated in removing the President of Haiti, Jean-Bertrand Aristide, and flew he and his family to, I believe, the Central African Republic.  It was not a benign decision.  He was disappeared.  (To my knowledge, Aristide and family live quietly in Haiti now.)  In the same era, 2003, I met in person Fr. Gerard Jean-Juste, a supporter of Aristide,  and later in Miami’s little Haiti in 2006.  In between Jean-Juste had been snatched up and imprisoned in Haiti, and later was essentially exiled to the United States….  Apparently it was decided he wouldn’t be able to stir up trouble in Haiti if he was in Florida.  I don’t know.  When I saw him in Miami, he seemed free as a bird, though in Haiti terms he was a crook….

There are many more stories, of course.  Hopefully, there will be some lessons learned in the wake of these first 100 days of #47’s first year.  That remains to be seen.  That is largely up to all of us, now.

Which brings me back to Good Friday and the Passion story, long a staple of Holy Week in the Catholic Church.  Last Sunday the story was read, as it always is.  This years booklet is here: Passion2025.   I ask you to look at the emphasized portions of page 4-7, and reflect on how you, personally, fit into the “crowd”, and other individuals and groups in this time in history, and consider what you can do to make a difference in today’s United States of America.  

Another word in those pages is Jesus.  Put yourself, in Jesus’ shoes.  Or the criminals, or the rulers, or….  Where does Justice fit in?  Forgiveness? “Rule of Law”…?  

Hard as it will be, leave religion out of your thinking.  This is about all of us, now.

Have a good Easter.

COMMENTS:
from Brian:

Oh, this is great, your post. 
I think A LOT about Haiti, as you know I volunteered there over the years working in microfinance.
Also, as you know, Haiti is the big reason the USA grew all the way out west.  Why?   Well,  Haiti in the early 1800s fought back against another control-freak, Napoleon, from France.    Napoleon was having his other wars back east.   So guess what?   He decided to sell a lot of what is now central USA to the USA when it was just at the east coast.
 
Yay Haiti!

 

Taxes

Today is tax day,   Ours is not yet filed – an extension because one piece of paper remains to be received.  There is no worry.  We file our taxes with no complaint.  We are ordinary people.  We feel taxes are the reasonable dues for a livable society.

I think my attitude is representative of the vast majority of my fellow citizens.  Taxes are shared responsibility for community debts for things we need, individually and collectively.  The closest-to-home taxes we pay are homeowners association dues.  They are not called “taxes” but in a real sense they are – for mowing grass in the summer, and shoveling show in the winter and repairing roofs and common elements after a storm; and taking care of garbage….  There are 24 buildings, 96 dwelling units in our association.  There is an Association Board.  As you know, even in smaller units, disagreements happen, and rules are necessary.  In short, Association, too, are conversations about ‘government’ and ‘taxes’, with neither word really ever uttered.

We want police and fire protection, and good streets, and parks.  And good schools for our children and those of our neighbors and relatives and friends.  And we live in a still United States (the concept is constantly at risk), where most of us have relatives and friends who live in many different states in all parts of the country.

Everyone of us could make a long list of why we choose to share responsibilities for many things.  And which things we pay for that we personally don’t use, but are important to someone else.

We are an immense world, with near 200 countries and billions of people, of which the U.S. is a relatively small part with an immensely disproportionate share of the worlds wealth.  I’ve previously shared a table illustrating this, which is several years old but basically still current I believe: Wealth of UN Countries.  I knew the creator of this table, and he was extraordinarily careful in use of data.  When he did his chart we had less than 5% of the world’s population and controlled near one-fourth of the world’s wealth.  What’s more is the huge disparity between the low and high wealth persons in the United States.

The real visible public debate seems to be about the issue most distant (seemingly) from our day to day life: The Federal Level, as in Income Taxes.  The Internal Revenue Service.  On an on.  Easy to throw stones at.

This issue has come out of the shadows: DOGE, chain saw, eliminating non-productive people, slash and burn….  You’ve heard of all of these.  If you can’t get rid of taxes, make it more difficult to enforce the rules – cut staff, etc.

In my opinion, briefly, the real issue in the U.S. now is whether the already wealthy will continue to have huge tax breaks, and if so, how to pay for them.

In December, 2017, the end of the first year of #45’s administration, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was passed by Republican House and Senate and signed into law by the President.  It is very complex – even the Wikipedia version runs to 45 printed pages.  But probably worth a scroll through.

From Wiki, here are the generalized tax tables carrying pre and post 2018 tables.:

Now, as any tax filer knows, the chart is just the framework.  The crucial parts of the 2017 Act were that corporate tax cuts were ‘permanent’, while the lower rates for the wealthy were set to expire in 2025.  In addition, every taxpayer got a ‘bonus’ check of $1,000 in 2018, the check signed by the President.  Supposedly this was ‘free money’.  Of course, nothing is free.  I remember complaints that the tax breaks for the corporations weren’t used to improve products or working conditions or more employment, rather they tended to be folded into other uses to make money for the corporation such as stock buybacks and the like.  The wealthy liked the lower taxes for the highest income, and don’t want to lose that largesse when the 2018 rates. expire in a few months.  In my opinion, that is the entire battle.

The results of #45’s term was a massive increase in the national debt.  Taking the chainsaw to things like medicaid for the disadvantaged doesn’t yield enough to make a difference, and brings out the protestors. Nobody knows how the sausage making will end up this year.  The Republicans again have the advantage, but it is closer this time.

I decided to look up the National Debt.  Investopedia has an interesting year by year data which seems credible.  Of course, the debt is huge – $36 Trillion which comes out to about $100,000 a person.  But then I looked up personal debt in the United States and that was about $18 Trillion.  My cynical view is that debt is essential to a very large sector of our population – mortgages, new car notes,  access to credit,etc., etc., etc.  Debt has fueled prosperity, in a sense.  But it has to be monitored carefully, both personally and politically.

Here’s a couple of more links I found which you may find of interest: How the $1,000 bonus in 2018 affected American Workers, from Los Angeles Times Feb. 9, 2018 ; and U.S. Personal Debt

COMMENTS:

from Jeff:  I think the Repubs have no choice but to pass the extension….so expect it.  The real battle is in the cuts…personally I suspect that Medicaid will be cut, but at less than the House wants…because there seem to be about 3 to 4 Republicans who are not happy about the steep cuts. (they realize they will hit Republican voters in Red states and rural areas, and they will, probably be the most impacted)  That means that the hole in the deficits and the national debt will continue.

Debt: you are indeed right, there is good debt and bad debt….bad debt is when you borrow on a high interest credit card to buy things you don’t need or take trips beyond your means….it adds up and gets worse.   Good debt is mortgages that make sense, borrowing to build new facilities ,  even govt debt for valid purposes.    Debt is and has almost always been a fundamental lever of capitalism and economic growth.  there are parameters…and obviously when it is monkeyed with like in 2006-2008 it had big repercussions.
The other thing I keep mentioning is the rule of law.  (obviously we know the authoritarian issues with civil liberty which is beyond frightening).  In the economy the rule of law props up debt by enforcing contracts.  Investors buy bonds and expect a return on their investment and return of their principal.  If the rule of law is eroded, then crony capitalism takes precedence (already seeing it)
and of course the mad king eventually decides who and what gets paid and repaid.  This has huge repercussions and I believe we have seen it short term in the first bond market collapse that was halted by Trumps recent postponement of the insane tarriffs.  There have been things posted on FB that Canada, France and the UK and Germany were joining forces to sell U.S. Treasuries before Trump relented.  Personally I believe China is already selling and will continue and they are the biggest single holder …moreover the lack of trust in the USA due to its breaking of global alliances and norms will eventually keep hurting the USA and the treasury market.  and …of course if tax cuts are extended and spending is not cut then rates will have to go up anyway…with less buyers…which means higher yields to attract buyers…  inflation and then recession.

from Carol: I saw where someone suggested that residents of the “blue” states for which Trump has threatened to cut off federal funds they’re entitled to (i.e., disaster relief) should refuse to pay their federal income taxes, and instead that money could be used to pay for their own state’s unmet needs.  Works for me.


from Fred:  I am a willing payer of taxes! It is amazing what we get for them. Fire and police protection and an emergency number to summon them. Lives saved by EMT’s responding to auto accidents and gun fire, round the clock. Safe water, safe food, safe utilities, a matrix of sanitary sewers to wash away our sewage and rain and flood waters. Streets, curbs and gutters, bike paths, public schools, public PARKS, public servants with credentials to keep all public assets in good shape. Round the clock snow plowing, six-day mail service, a military second to none to protect us from global bad actors. An incredible highway and road system and then keep them in repair. That’s just off the top of my head.

My problem with taxes is with those wealthy chiselers who work their way around them. Not all of them are pikers, of course, but the number is significant. I am fortunate enough that I have the financial situation that keeps me comfortable. I don’t waste any time worrying about crooks, but it would be nice if they would pony up their fair share.

 

 

Earth Day April 22, 2025

April 22, 2025, is the 55th celebration of Earth Day.  The official website is here.  I’m posting early about this so that there is some advance notice about this important annual observance.

Pat Hamilton’s commentary has been waiting patiently in the wings since I saw it in the Minnesota Star Tribune on January 8, 2025: Hamilton MN Star Tribune Jan 8 2025.  His commentary is very appropriate for Earth Day, worth high-lighting in this year of a million issues….

Pat’s spouse and our friend and this blog list member  J.Drake Hamilton, long-time Managing Director of Science Policy at Fresh Energy, called my attention to Pat’s article.  Fresh Energy merits a close look as well.  It has a long record of advocacy on planet friendly energy issues.  We have financially and otherwise supported the work of Fresh Energy for years.

There are more than adequate words in the above links for your consideration.

Friday morning at my walk the background music brought Louis Armstrong’s Rendition of Wonderful World.  Have a listen and have a great weekend.

*

POSTNOTE: I have added a postnote and there are several comments at the Protest post.  Please take a look.

I will repost this blog likely early Monday (April 21).  If you wish to add recommended links to this post, just let me know.  It is easy to do.

Have a good Easter, whatever your tradition and wherever you are in the world.

Protests

POSTNOTE April 12, 2025:  This afternoon I went to a community meeting including my state representative and state senator.  There were about 75 of us in attendance.  The purpose of the open meeting was to update us on the Minnesota Legislature now in session.

The meeting was remarkable in its civility.  The two legislators did an outstanding job.  There is no doubt that the state budget will be extremely adversely impacted and that “the cloud of federal stuff” causes daily uncertainty.  The obvious chaos at the federal level bedevils every level of government outside of Washington DC.  We in the audience were listening respectfully.

I got to thinking back to a blog I published right before the inauguration of the 47th President: “A House Divided” (Jan 18, 2025), which included these words: “Two days from now will be the inauguration of the U.S. President.  It feels, today, much like being in the eye of a hurricane.  All seems calm.  But no one knows for sure exactly when the chaos of the hurricane will resume and who it will damage worst or how.  The prudent persons have prepared for the worst, but if they’re unlucky the preparation will be in vain.  The hurricane is all of us.  We will determine it’s strength or weakness.  We’re all in the path of the storm.  I will not predict what the incoming President will say, though the temptation is strong.”

Added January 25: “…a tsunami, intended to demoralize and defeat – call it “shock and awe”.  Thus far, it has been worse than expectations.  This is a madman with a wrecking ball and the building permit to destroy.  On Jan 31: “a blitzkrieg, intended chaos” was added.

I review these words now 82 days into the 100 days,  and I was being very restrained.

In times of chaos, the temptation is to crawl into some hiding place and pretend the consequences can be avoided if you just don’t see them head-on.  My suggestion to myself, and to you if you wish: keep your mind and your heart fixed on the positive that you can be as an antidote.  It won’t make the task any easier, but you’ll be part of the solution.  The U.S. is you and I, after all.

*

If you can still access it, watch Cory Booker on Stephen Colbert last week.

Bruce Peterson authored an excellent column on the protest in St. Paul on April 5: Star Tribune Bruce peterson Apr 2025

Join Indivisible.  Minnesotans, I think the two main organizers of Indivisible are graduates of Carleton College.

Added April 10:  Add this to your required reading list.  In addition, pay special attention to Patsy’s comment in the comments section of this post.

*

My intention was to attend the demonstration at the state capitol last Saturday.  It almost happened.  What I wrote afterward: I drove over to the State Capitol area in St. Paul late Saturday morning.  The crowd was incredible and orderly with lots of signs.  Parking was an impossibility.  I managed to drive around the Capitol area before I headed home.  I would suspect the same report comes from other places as well.  The “proof of the pudding” will be the long term.  A large percentage of people engaged is less necessary than sustained effort – doing something every day wherever one lives.

I took a single photograph from my car, below

Bruce Peterson, who was there, writes perceptively on the event and the issue and public participation.  Do take the time to read his thoughts.  I know Bruce, and he is a reflective thinker and long experience as a Judge.  At the end of his column is a short bio about him.

I spent most of my work and retired life as an “organizer.”  To be an organizer is very simple: you just want to get people to show up, as those five people in the cross-walk were doing last Saturday.  Showing up they became part of a movement to make a difference.

But as any organizer knows, whether amateur or professional, this action, certainly essential, is only the beginning.  To act without followthrough diminishes the possibility of results.  It depends not only on what those five people above did by showing up at the gathering (and likely the nurturing of new relationships), but what they do afterwards back home, day after day for the long term.

The essence of organizing – I think all organizers would agree with this – is relationships.  I once heard relationships described as the greatest -“referent” – power, really the most relevant and perhaps most elusive power, eclipsing the common ones, as Money, Position, and the like.  In the end, people working and working together make all the difference.  Years back I did a little graphic about this.

When I couldn’t find a place to park on Saturday I decided to go home and find the local Tesla dealership.  I did.  Nothing going on there, and I did nothing.  Which accomplished nothing either.

Monday, I went back to the same place, same results, but this time I took a picture of the same scene I’d seen two days earlier.  I share the picture with you to at least demonstrate that sharing the experience is the greater part of the value of showing up….

Yes, I have lots of opinions about the immense number of issues we face, all of them.  But that’s for another time.  Time to get to work on your issue at your place and in your way.

Back to you, wherever you are, whatever your opinion.

Tesla Woodbury April 7. 9800 Hudson Road

COMMENTS (more at end):

from Lindsay:  I wanted to share some photos of the demonstrations that have taken place in Denver thus far. I have participated in all three and will continue to do so. I have a myriad of reasons for my personal upset. Not only has this administration been the antithesis of a great deal of what matters most to me on a personal level, my work in non-profit (supporting survivors, victims of violent crime, and their families) was briefly on the chopping block…and the outlook for the important work that we do continues to be a grim one.

I am sad, scared, and deeply worried for so many.
But…I strongly believe in the power of progress and will proudly march alongside those who strive for it.

from Dick: Lindsay sent along eight fine photos which I will print as pdf composite.  Stay tuned.  Here’s one of them:

Colorado demo, one of photos from Lindsay

The others are here: Lindsay, Denver Spring 2025(first photo includes Bernie Sanders)

from SAK:

Of course there will be protests after the fiasco that was caused by Trump’s favourite word, tariffs.

In the UK Liz Truss was the UK prime minister (PM) the reason she was the shortest serving PM was that the markets thought her economic policy was disastrous, the bond yield shot up & she was shown the exit. The bond yield in the US also went up significantly meaning the US would have to pay a lot more to finance its huge debt – & issue more debt. This was what made Trump reverse course.

According to Scott Galloway, the tariff fiasco was the definition of stupid.

Previous treasury Secretary & Berkeley economics prof, Yelen said:

Trump’s economic policies are ‘worst self-inflicted wound’ by any administration on an otherwise well-functioning economy.

In the picture you posted of a demonstration [see above] I noticed the placard:

That is fine but the foxy James Carville who coined the famous campaign slogan ‘It’s the economy stupid’, is still around & clever as ever. I read a short article by him, 25 February,  advising Democrats to basically sit still, giving Trump & co enough rope to hang themselves & then pounce when the time is ripe. I quote:

roll over and play dead. Allow the Republicans to crumble beneath their own weight and make the American people miss us

&

when they’ve pushed themselves to the brink and it appears they could collapse the global economy, come in and save the day. Be the competent party and not the chaos party

So yes to people in the street demonstrating but there will come a time for Democrats & others in Congress to pounce, “ripeness is all” – as Edgar says in Shakespeare’s King Lear.

from Dick: Tim Snyder offers a brief and powerful video about leveraging anti-semitism.  Here is his “Thinking About…,”It’s 7 1/2 minutes.

Thinking politically

The previous post got me to thinking about politics in my own life.  What I articulate below I have said before in various ways.  I doubt it will surprise anyone who knows me.

In my early times I had no particular interest in politics.  Dwight Eisenhower was President in my high school and college years, and I liked Ike (as everyone did).  He could have run as Republican or Democrat and won under either label.  He’s my first memorable President.

I was too young to vote for Kennedy or Nixon – voting age was 21 in 1960 and I was 20.  My guess is that I would have voted Kennedy.  I saw Nelson Rockefeller in person in Valley City in 1961 and he was impressive.  He was vying for the Republican nomination at the time.

The rest of the 60s were a blur for me – life got in the way of politics, so I wasn’t an activist politically.

Since the late 60s I’ve been pretty comfortably Democrat – a party which has the strength and the weakness that comes from diverse people and opinions.  Truly a “big tent”.    In 2020 I described Democrats s the party of “We”; what remained of the Republican Party as the party of “Me”.  You’ll find this defined in blog posts about August 1 2020.

Of course, labels are tricky.

The Republicans were founded as the party of Lincoln, and the segregationist south was Democrat for many years.

There have always been offshoot parties, but they are very small.  In my memory, the only declared Independents who did pretty well in national elections were George Wallace, H. Ross Perot and John Anderson.

Today, most people declare themselves to be Independent, but invariably the only parties that get many votes are either Republican or Democrat.

Numerous times I used this graphic to describe what I believe is the body politic in America: I see the “Hard Left” and the “Hard Right” as essentially identical twins – passionate, fairly small and unruly minorities.  Most Americans simply want the country to work, and in the end vote for who they think is the most reasonable choice.  I think the Tuesday election in Wisconsin reflected this reasonableness.

Just my opinion.

POSTNOTE: “Politics” and “Politicians” are things people love to hate.  In a democracy, we ARE politics and politicians, whatever we do, or don’t do, or try to evade responsibility for.  POLITICS is US.

Having said that, in recent times I’ve become aware of having a closer call than most to the institution called Politics.

Very Briefly: I didn’t expect Gov. Tim Walz to get the nod for vice-president nominee last summer.  He did.  I only met him in person one time, at a fund raiser in the summer of 2006, when he was doing his first run for public office.  (I recall him as a bit green then, but what else would you expect in a rookie.). He makes this small town teacher’s kid proud, cuz that’s what he is proud of himself.

June 23, 2011, I went to a local DFL (Democrat) picnic, and one of the speakers was the new chairman of the Minnesota DFL, Ken Martin.  Martin recently became the chair of the Democratic National Committee (DNC).  I know he’ll do a good job in an always impossible task.  Here’s a photo I took of him at the 2011 meeting.

Ken Martin June 23, 2011

When Martin left Minnesota his position was open, and on February 24, 2025, I was at a local meeting where a candidate for the vacancy met with us.  Richard Carlbom recently became the new chair of the Minnesota DFL.  Here’s his photo:

Richard Carlblom Feb 24, 2025

Richard was a young Mayor shortly after college graduation, won reelection, went to work on the first campaign for then school-teacher Tim Walz near 20 years ago and the rest is history.

Long and short, I’m privileged to have seen the real humans who now are in the news.  They are more than equal to the challenges they have to face.

 

Wisconsin…Hands-Off

Day 73 of first 100.

Tuesday was an important Election Day in Wisconsin.  There were also two elections in Florida.  I choose to focus on Wisconsin because I’m about ten miles “as the crow flies” from Wisconsin, and the Twin Cities media carried much of the advertising seen by Wisconsin voters.  (I’m the dot on the edge of western Wisconsin, below!  In reality I’m far smaller than the one on the map.   At the same time, I know that I am one of 75,000,000 who can do something, everyday, everywhere!))

My apologies to Alaska and Hawaii…You are states in good standing; and apologies to Mexico and Canada, countries in good standing as well!

I avoid predicting outcomes of events such as elections, so my last post was the day before the election in Wisconsin.  Anyone who is interested knows all about how that election is being spun: how much money was spent; the power actors, on and on and on.

The long and short of it is that the election was decided by individual voters for all of the many reasons they had to vote as they did.  Like me, every single citizen is the critical vote in every election in our still-democracy.

Saturday, April 5, will likely be a major beginning point for a continuing program of advocacy in the United States.  This is being organized by a group called Hands Off, and at the website is a link that identifies events in your area.  Check it out.

Strategies: Much of my work career was involved in the imperfect practice of the art of organizing people in Union settings.  Many years ago I sketched a couple of symbols about the dilemmas and potential of organizing.  The original sketch is here:

In my opinion, people tend to collect in groups of diverse sizes and purposes, and generally somebody becomes a leader.  These groups might be autonomous but ultimately they tend towards larger coalitions.  You can simply look at the groups with which you personally interact, and how they are led and with whom they have common cause.  This could be a church, or a club, almost anything.  Most of the people are at the base.  Without care a leader, even with the best of intentions, will become separated from the group he’s leading, symbolized by the cloud bank.  He or she may has started with the best of motives, but time brings changes.  He or she tends to find common cause with other leaders.  They are, as my illustration suggests, above the clouds.  The base is down there, to be manipulated.

Over the years working with organizations small and not so small, I noticed that leaders in various ways became bottlenecks, interfering with inputs to and outputs from their base.  They had more information, but controlled what they shared.

in the contemporary political world, the leaders and the managers of communication control what their base has access to.  The base, for instance, does not decide what the 6:00 TV news will contain.  That is decided by the producers who in turn, in our society, depend on advertisers, who are attracted by potential customers.  “Informing” is not the primary purpose of this model, in my opinion.

I think we see this every day in most every political act.  As I have said on numerous occasions, we, the people, are the “politics” we despise.  Only we can be the solution.  And apparently in Wisconsin on Tuesday of this week we saw an example of this.

The two elections earlier this week demonstrate that the body politic has considerable power if it so chooses.  We – each of us – are in the drivers seat, but only if we so choose.  The future is ours to make – not anyone else’s responsibility, rather our own, in the endless ways we can do this.  Let’s go to work.

Tesla in Woodbury April 1, 2025

A FINAL THOUGHT: Strictly by chance I happened to park behind a Tesla earlier this week.  Nice car….

As I mentioned in an earlier post, customers for Tesla’s as for any automobiles are no different than the rest of us.  In the case of Tesla, the Uber-wealthy sullied the reputation of his own claim to fame and incredible monetary wealth.  The car itself doesn’t deserve a bad reputation, but the brand is badly damaged.  We need to keep that in mind.  There are, after all, people like ourselves who built, sell, and maintain items like this vehicle, and they are part of our greater economy as well.

Some personal comments on Politics generally here.

COMMENTS (also at end of post): 

from Fred:

Dear Sir;
The addressee of this email has apparently fled the country with everything he owned and some stuff he didn’t. It seems the stock market crash has wiped him out. If you have any knowledge about his whereabouts, the reward is substantial.
J. Edgar Heaver, Loan service officer

from Dick, afternoon April 5:  I drove over to the State Capitol area in St. Paul late Saturday morning.  The crowd was incredible and orderly with lots of signs.  Parking was an impossibility.  I managed to drive around the Capitol area before I headed home.  I would suspect the same report comes from other places as well.  The “proof of the pudding” will be the long term.  A large percentage of people engaged is less necessary than sustained effort – doing something every day wherever one lives.

from James: When I read this (link in 4th para below) today, I immediately thought of some of our more recent conversations, both in person and on line.  So I thought I’d share it with you.

I don’t think I’ve told you (because I make a point of not telling anyone) who I voted for for President in the last three cycles.  Largely because, from my perspective, there is MUCH more information value in communicating HOW DIFFICULT a decision I regarded it to be each time.  I think partisans on both sides (or at least the extremes of both sides) quit listening – and surely quit truly hearing – the instant you tell them who you ultimately voted for (either way!) You know how much I read politics, and talk politics, and work campaigns, and so does almost everyone else I interact with, so there is “information value” in telling people that I (literally!) decided which candidate to vote for on my way into the polling place each time.  I try to avoid allowing anyone to conclude that I was all-in with Hillary-Biden-Harris or all-in with Trump, because… well… I WASN’T, and the way to get EITHER party to change – at all – is to help partisans understand that there are still “Persuadables” and it is NOT just “all about turning out the base”.  So the farthest I will go is to say that I have voted for at least one Republican and at least one Independent for a major public office… somewhere in the span of 1976-2024…!  But I will tell anyone about decisions I thought were “tough” (From an earlier time, the jumbled ideologies of the Skip-Ventura-Coleman Governor’s race come immediately to mind…)

There have been other opinion pieces that try to put into words my own sense that, while I still maintain roughly 90-95% of the core values and beliefs I held at any point from, say, 1980 to 2012, the Progressive Movement and the Democratic Party have changed to a great extent – and, with the arrival/triumph of Trump and “MAGA”, so have the Republicans.  (I was never one of those Dems who agreed with 100% of the party’s majority positions – but back then, 70 or 80% was good enough, and we didn’t try to kick anybody out over being on the “wrong” side of one or two or even several.  As a Catholic, I’m sure you can remember anti-abortion Dems, and there are lots of other examples… until only the last 10 years or so, when we started to insist on “purity”.  The harsh criticism that Gavin Newsome just took from leftists for saying out loud what 80% of all Americans, and 60% of all Dems, believe about the unfairness of biological men competing against women in sports astounds me…)  This piece, though, does the best job I’ve seen so far in capturing what I and a lot of other folks have sensed/felt/experienced/realized about the shifts in the parties of the last 10-15 years.


[I include the link provided by Jim to a column by a “MAGA Lefty” but note that it is pay-walled and long and (in my opinion) doesn’t add much to the conversation, and it is simply another opinion among the millions out there.  I have read it.]

I am not a “MAGA anything”.  I still regard myself as a Pragmatic Progressive – but I have to concede her point that when I say “progressive”, I mean something very different from what those who are all-in with “The Movement” mean today.  She sums up my issues with the progressive movement’s last 10-15 years exceptionally well – I think the fact that she and I each have such difficulty expressing out current political “identities” in simple terms, and, in fact, express them very differently from each other – speaks to how bizarre the political moment in which we’re living truly is.

On a related note, I recently read a piece on Cesar Chavez (who I heard speak in Berkeley’s Sproul Plaza – with Gov. Jerry Brown! – and with music by Donovan!  …back when I was in grad school)  That piece was written entirely to remind readers that Chavez had been – entirely – an ECONOMIC liberal/progressive, and, today, would be on the non-Progressive side of almost every SOCIAL issue – but especially everything having to do with the border, with “identity”, and with equity-over-equality.  Sometimes I almost get convinced that contemporary Progressive extremists might NOT be “gaslighting” me, so it’s good every now and then to read a piece like that or a piece like the one I’ve linked to above, to remind me that my memory is still good and my ethical/moral/policy instincts are, at the least, no less pure than they ever were.  There really WAS a time when the Democratic Party and liberal mainstream values were the ones I still hold.


response from Dick:  Jim and I are good friends and have good conversations.