I voted

I cast my ballot today in the special election Nov. 4 for 4 school board members of South Washington County SD #833, and new Senator for SD47.  I voted at the new Washington County Center which is essentially behind Kohls Department store, just off Woodlane Drive.

I have lived the same address for the last 25 years, and my entire life has either been in or very close to public education, including 27 years representing public school teachers.

My ballot today was for three school board incumbents, and one new representative.   Those who got my vote are incumbents Louise Hinz, Katie Schwartz and Sharon Van Leer, and candidate for newly open position, Elizabeth Bockman Eckberg.  The four are recommended by the local teachers union.

Amanda Hemmingsen-Jaeger is my choice for Senator in SD47.  She has been my state representative and I have been very pleased with her approach to the job of representing not only ourselves, but all citizens.  She is endorsed by a large group of organizations.

The campaign fliers for all are here, for the School Board candidates, and for Amanda Hemmingsen-Jaeger: 1). School Board ISD 833 Nov 4 2025; 2). School Board ISD 833 Bockman Eckberg Nov 4 2025;  3)  Amanda Hemmingsen-Jaeger SD47 Nov 4 2025

Here are a few personal comments: 1. I strongly support Amanda Hemmingsen-Jaeger for Senate for SD47.  She is my local state Representative (47A) and she has been an outstanding representative.  There are endless issues for any legislator, and I have a sense that she has the ability to listen to and represent differing points of view, crucial in a government official, particularly now.

2. I endorse the slate of school board candidates supported by the District 833 teachers union.  Three of the candidates are incumbents; the fourth is a new candidate.  My entire life has been in public education in one way or another.  I do not actively engage in the affairs of the local school district, and my assessment is, just from local news over the years.  In a large and diverse system (nearing 19,000 students), there are infinite possibilities for conflict about this or that.  The school district is well governed even in these difficult times.  The three incumbents are positive leaders.

I had the opportunity to hear the 4th candidate present her points of view in person last week.  She is a strong candidate.  Check out her website.

“Tolerance” is an very important word in my assessment of effective government officials.  Ours is a very  large school district with infinite points of view and tolerance is an essential.

POSTNOTE: I do note that all of the candidates I’m supporting are women.  I recall that earlier in my career, the 1970s and earlier, women were conspicuously absent from elective positions.  The present day change is welcome.  And men, too, run and are elected in all areas, and probably still outnumber women.

October 13, 2025: Columbus Day? Indigenous People’s Day?

Yesterday at Mass, Fr. Taste hit another homer in his homily based on Luke 17:11-19, the one where the Samaritan Leper is among 1hose who are healed, but is the only one who goes back to say Thank You….  Father T is in my neighborhood age wise, and he started his sermon with a quotation from one of Garrison Keillor’s books – where a couple had a little party on their 50th anniversary, and it wasn’t until afterwards that the Mr. got around to telling the Mrs. he loved her.    I interpreted the message he had for all of us: be grateful to ourselves and to others.  There are infinite ways, the best, small.  In these days, gratitude is something to practice.

*

For the last several weeks I have been watching the fascinating Nova series, “Human”, on PBS.  The final local showing (Episode 5) is on TPT Channel 2 on Wednesday October 15, 8 p.m. Central Time.  For the entire series, check in with Nova.  If you can watch at home, the entire series is well worth your time.  Narrator and host Ella Al-Shamahi brings the story of homo sapiens to life.  This weeks episode, the final one, apparently explores the most recent historical period of humankind – most likely the pre- and post-Christopher Columbus periods.  Check out the series: it’s okay to see the last episode first!

Heather Cox Richardson discusses the history of Columbus Day in her October 12 column here.

In my state, Minnesota, today is recognized as Indigenous People’s Day, in concert with the annual United Nations event.  Minnesota is one of 17 U.S. states recognizing and celebrating the day.

*

Yesterdays Basilica of St. Mary newsletter commentary by Janice Andersen was very relevant to the current days, I felt.  Here it is: Janice Andersen Oct 12 20250001  

*

The big news on Sunday, and of course today, the pending peace in Israel/Gaza.  I am not inclined to go overboard on optimism.  Today is a single day in a very long and troubled history in the region and is are no magic long term solutions.  Stay tuned.  Last news I saw or heard – on purpose – was yesterday afternoon.

COMMENTS (more below)

from Jeff: [Columbus Day] is a “Democrat” holiday…hahaha…trump must not have known…

It’s silly to make Columbus the poster boy for the ills of all colonialism, but he was a despicable human actually per historical fact
I see the old line Italian americans always defending Columbus….for gods sake they should dump him and elevate Frances Cabrini…

from Joann: Thank you, Dick.  Your messages are insightful and helpful.

from Brian:  I work a lot with Native Americans.  I’m on the board of one of their credit unions, in Montana, that I helped them start.   Thanks so much for your great post!

from Norm: I want to offer the following comments regarding the agreement in Gaza:

Like you, I am very cautious about making too much out of the agreement given the history of that area of generations of conflict and tribal that raise serious questions of whether the Palestinians will ever be able to rule themselves should that ever be allowed.
I remember that Arafat when he was the leader of the PLO was so loved by his fellow Palestinians that it was claimed that he never slept in the same bed and location on more than one night having to change every night to stay alive.
Now granted, Trump being the insecure, arrogant and narcissistic fellow that he is, is making a big deal out of how he had brought peace to the Middle East something that no other US president has ever done and, of course, as always, claiming that he is the smartest and most accomplished  and successful US president ever…
And publicly claiming that he should be and/or have been awarded the Nobel Peace Prize or the Noble PP as he calls.
Such an insecure man who continually has to tell himself let alone tell world how great he is also makes him a very dangerous man-child to be the leader of a major national power.

“Influencers”

Please note “ADDITIONS” at the end of this post.  If it’s been your inclination to sit this one out, get off the couch.  Our future as a democracy is at stake, and we’re the only solution.

INFLUENCING

Every now and then a new word crops up and has its day in the headlines.  A current one is “Influencer“.  If you search the internet you will find numerous definitions.  Here’s one I selected, from the Oxford English Dictionary.

Today, it seems, you have to go viral to consider something successful.  Or have a very large boatload of “followers”. whatever that means.

I want to propose a new definition of “influencer”: first each person has to convince him or herself that he or she can make a difference as an active individual wherever he or she lives….

Since November 2024, when my ‘side’ ‘lost’ the election, I have said that 75,000,000 of us agreed on an alternative outcome, but we were a tiny bit short of a plurality.  There was no “landslide” “victory” or “loss” last November.  Every one of us were “influencers”.

Of course this also means that 77 million influencers voted for the opposing candidate, as were the 90 million or so who didn’t vote at all, or the free who voted for minor party candidates with no chance of being elected.

In short, every single one of us who were qualified to vote, whether voting or not, is the only ‘influencer’ who makes any difference.

If each person takes on the task of helping one other person make up their mind, change can happen pretty dramatically…there is no ‘yah but’.

As we’re all learning the hard way, elections are no spectator sport.  All of us are the “team”, period.

*

Re the Team, I’m really no different than anyone else.  First, I have to talk myself into taking some unfamiliar action – in other words, to change customary behaviors.

The viral bunch is always an annoying noise in the background, like those fine-tuned ads for the perfect pet food for the perfect dog or cat.

For all of us, perfection is a dream, and we clomp along trying to do our best.

My challenge, become an influencer, just by doing a little bit more every day, getting a little out of your comfort zone.

You read this this far.  You are an exceptional person.  Keep on keeping on.

POSTNOTE: As I was drafting this I thought back to a workshop I’d attended in Grand Rapids MN in the late 1980’s.  The speaker, Don Keck, was an organizer for the National Education Association, and his talk was about Power,  In my memory, his talk had five bullet points about Power and who has it.  The first four were obvious: Knowledge, Position, Money, Information.  There were other sources of power, but these were primary examples.

It was the final power that caught my attention, and that he spent the most time with: Referent Power, the power of relationships, which he called “Referent Power”..

In my blog archives, there are nine that include the word “Referent” in one way or another, At the end of my post for February 10, 2011, I expanded a bit on the word, as follows:

Message to the Proles March 10 2010: ** – Power defined. I once heard an excellent talk about some of the many kinds of “Power” in plays in all of our lives. As I remember them: there is the power that comes with authority (“I can fire you”, or variations usually involving money); there is the power that comes with the capability of defining the rules of society (“I can make laws”). Power comes with family connections – a family marries into a family with power. The list goes on.
But there was one power I paid most attention to, and the speaker called it “referent power” or “the likeability factor”. For people immersed in the other kinds of power, this is the scary one: this is the problem of relationships, and builds outside, and independent of, the others.

ADDITIONAL SUGGESTIONS: 

Some things you can do:

Facilitate helping with registering to vote: Joyce Vance October 7, 2025

Check out and participate in No Kings Day on October 18 (we’re signed up).  In the lower left corner of the home page is a box.  Enter your zip code and find the nearest group in your area.  Additionally, take time to watch this 10 minute Tim Snyder video Who was who in Weimar Germany; and a three minute one, No Kings – Freedom

Check out “No data day” here.  This is very interesting.

Lori Sturdevant, long time highly respected commentator on politics in this area, had a must read column in the October 8 Minnesota Star Tribune: Lori Sturdevant STrib 10 8 25

I have added several references after “Do something” in the Darkness or Light post.

POSTNOTE:  I think back to my most recent visit to Niagara Falls three years ago, this time of year.  I visualize the people in a barrel, an occasional stupidity there, where someone thinks they can capitalize on surviving a trip over the falls.  It is one thing to read about it; it is another thing entirely to stand there, at the lip of the falls, and imagine what it would be like.

At the moment, America – all of us – are in a barrel, about to go over the edge.  If you’re excited about that, be very careful what you pray for.  Odds are against victory.

Dad at Niagara Falls 1972

Darkness or Light?

Related Post “The Generals”, October 1, 2025.  (There are several comments.)

September 30 – October 1, 2025, seems to potentially be as historically as significant as January 6, 2021.  The ultimate outcome is going to depend on the American Citizen, collectively, you, I, everyone else.  I’d suggest that you at least take the time to read Robert Reich’s post, and the Wiki about Russell Vought, one of the chief architects of Project 2025.  I’m also including for your own information some photos and information about the East Wing of the White House, which is apparently under construction as an immense formal ball room.  Apparently it will not be a victim of the cuts.

You and I and our fellow citizens are the solution, period.  There are millions of ways to impact.  Sitting on the sidelines is not one of them.  It will not be easy, to complain is not enough.  You’re needed for the long haul.

Do Something.

It is better to light a candle than to curse the darkness.

Robert Reich October 2, 2025.  [Also, from Robert Reich in my inbox October 5, 2025: “A National Trauma”] And Oct. 6.

Wiki About Russell Vought, Office of Management and Budget, apparently a crucial architect of Project 2025.  More from Heather Cox Richardson Oct. 6

Also take the time to get acquainted with Stephen Miller, a key leader of the deportation crowd.

Oct 7.  An excellent summary of the Ku Klux Klan from National Geographic publication “Secret Societies” 2017, republished 2020.  Complete Title of Publication: Secret Societies True Tales of Covert Cults and Organizations and Their Leaders.

*

History: East Wing of the White House

White House Postcard view of East Terrace 1902.  “East Wing” added about here in 1905 by Teddy Roosevelt.  This postcard dates from 1904,

The U.S. presidents and the U.S. Capitol, 1905. All Presidents shown up to and including Theodore Roosevelt (standing second from right). Found in the basement of the North Dakota farmhouse of my grandparents, who came to North Dakota in 1905.

POSTNOTE October 3:

There’s no need to dig deep on this current disaster: Revenge against Democrats (which is people like me) is front and center in the Presidents rage; but paramount is favoring the filthy rich.  Best to have “friends” who  own the ship of state (whatever that happens to be) rather than help the masses who in the final analysis are always the ones who are the source of the riches in the first place: they do the work and spend their money to buy the goods which generate the profits for the lifestyle of the rich and famous.

Every Sunday I go to Mass at the Basilica of St. Mary in Minneapolis, and every Sunday we get a newsletter with an assortment of news related to the Parish.

Last Sunday, the Gospel was Luke 16:19-31 “The rich man and Lazarus”.  It is not an affirmation of those who pine for the gilded age, particularly those who have fought their way into the temporal heaven (Scrooge McDuck comes to this old man’s memory – cavorting in his money bin….)

Last Sunday Fr. Gillespie had a column on the front page of the newsletter, “Mind the Gap” which was spot on, and I’d like to share it with you: Fr. Gillespie on Lazarus… 9 28 25.  You don’t need to be Catholic, or Christian, or believer in any religion to relate to this story, which is even more timeless today than long ago when whoever authored Luke wrote the story.

None of us have any idea what happens with our spiritual essence when we die.  There are endless beliefs.

Fact of the matter is that the idiots who are the filthy rich won’t be taking it with them, and likely the ones who win the lottery when their benefactor dies may not be dedicated to continue their commitment.

I haven’t read the book Fr. Gillespie mentions, on the “Have-Yachts”.  But, anyway, take a look at his column, and maybe even read it.  He is a brilliant writer.

COMMENTS (more below)

from Mary: Thanks for sending this.

from SAK:

Many thanks Mr Bernard,

Of course I am going to read Mind the Gap – having heard that so many times on the London Underground (Subway). In fact in Lego Land once I noticed a miniature train station & the speakers shouted “Mind the Gap” when the train approached.

Fr. Joseph Gillespie is indeed a good writer. I thoroughly enjoyed the article/sermon. It is loving in the sense that he does not attack this or that policy or politician but still makes a point.

 

The Generals et al

We can’t know how September 30, 2025, will play in the history books years from now, but today is the first day.  Pay close attention and get, and stay. in action.

My first thoughts this day go back to Union staff days where, on infrequent occasions, we “Union Thugs” were asked to help a local union planning to strike.  (One time I was President of the Union staff for the state teachers Union that employed us.  Now, that did make the news.  That strike lasted only a few days.  It was 1979, if I remember correctly.)

*

The Government Shutdown started at midnight Sep 30, 2025,

The shutdown has all the earmarks of a labor-management conflict.  Without going into the weeds, I have one observation (among many) unresolved disputes often have something in common:  at some point matters came to a head, and there is a walkout.  It’s always the other sides fault….

In my experience then, which was only from the labor side, walking out was the easy part.  Getting back in, and back to normal, was the hard part, and the prudent local and the opposing management considered this fact.

I only knew the Labor side over 50 years ago; but Management had exactly the same problem – just “the other side of the same coin”.  Regardless of the issues, ultimately there had to be an agreement to settle, which required compromise, whether the walk-out was one day or a month or even more….

I can’t remember any local going on strike more than once.  This is not to say that there were no frustrations, or threats in subsequent negotiations.  The prospect for both sides was too dismal to reprise.  Best to eat crow in essentially private arguments in bargaining, rather than enter into a public spectacle over which both sides had little control.

*

Which brings me to “The Generals”, the title of this post.

Also on September 30 was street theatre day at Quantico Marine Base in Virginia.  Fox News personality Pete Hegseth and guest star of “The Apprentice” (aka “Management”) came to wow a gaggle of generals (aka Labor) from all over creation. The Big Show was obviously made for TV where management could be in the spotlight as “star”.

*

This is not to make light out of what are two hugely significant events which not coincidentally happened on the very same day.

We will be well advised to not only follow this carefully, but also become active participants.  The stakes are immense.

*

As for the Generals, I think one of the problems the Public has is that relatively few adults have actually been in the military and make their judgements based on TV/Radio, movies, social media and print news: chaos and blood.  As the old saying goes “if it bleeds its leads”.   The President wanted a big show; he got it, with no applause….  In the theater it was a big dud.

I am not naive about the military, both from personal and family experience.

I was in the U.S. Army voluntarily for a tour as an enlisted man in 1962-63,  I didn’t realize it at the time, but the “Vietnam era” had begun about a year earlier, and we were being trained for future service in Southeast Asia.  I declined the opportunity to go for officer training; and ended up as Company Clerk in an Infantry Company which, a few years later, saw heavy action and lots of losses in Vietnam.  I and my colleagues were the lucky ones.  But we safely experienced in training what our later colleagues had experience in person.

Dog Tags. U.S. Army 1962-63

Never have I regretted my experience in the military.  Those Generals who have risen to the top of their respective pyramids are generally very strong and effective leaders, as are their subordinates, down to the most basic level.

I have absolutely no idea what those Generals were thinking yesterday, as they sat obediently in a theatre where doubtless legions of Marines have sat in the past for one lecture or another (one of my grandsons approaching his 7th year as an active duty Marine, though not at Quantico.)

As for the Generals, the stark fact is that we, all of us, every one of us, have to be the “Generals” in the days ahead.  We are the one who decide who or how we’ll be governed, and we do this by our actions (or lack of same).

POSTNOTE: For historian Heather Cox Richardson’s view of September 30, 2025: here. Also,  Robert Reich, today short video.

250 Days

By my count, today is the 250th day since the inauguration of the 47th president Jan. 20, 2025.

Months ago, I had a fantasy that maybe it was true he would be dictator for only one day; or that it might be true he really had no idea that there was such a thing as Project 2025.  But I decided on Day One to begin keeping the A section of the Minnesota Star Tribune for his first 100 days (photo below).  If someone ever looks they’ll find all but a tiny few of the A sections there.  The missing ones were inadvertent.  The box has near 250 of those A sections.  September 30, 2025, will be the final addition.

I will continue to be informed and in action, but if somebody else wants to start the next 250 days collection, be my guest.  Here’s my collection (and what your box would look like 250 days from now):

There is an immense amount of readily available and credible information available of what is happening on a daily basis.  We, together, are an immense resource for good but only if we get into action in the millions of ways available to every one of us wherever we live, on whatever issues are important to you.

We know the reality, now is time to get into, and stay in, action.

I plan to keep writing and staying informed and in action, but my emphasis here will be other topics.  The most recent are these:

September 11 was the gun death at Utah Valley University.  There has been immense attention to this since, culminating with a Memorial service in Glendale Arizona September 21.  I decided to do an alternative post entitled “A Gun” on September 18.  It speaks for itself, and I think it’s worth your time.

A long-time passion of mine is family history, and a recent book about over 100 French-Canadian immigrants to the small community of Dayton MN caught my attention since my Dad was 100% French-Canadian, and more than one reference in the book was to some of our ancestors.  Take a look: A French-Canadian Enclave in Twin Cities Minnesota.

September 23 I added a postnote to an earlier post from April, 2024, entitled “Consequences”.  It refers to the conviction of my former State Senator in a heavily publicized case that began in April 28, 2024.  I suggest you scroll to the end to the Postnote for September 23, 2025, and I further suggest you read the link there which was my personal letter to the Judge in the matter.

Back on July 12 and 28 I recommended and saw the new film “Superman”.  It took a while, but Tim Snyder recommended it in his post on September 23.  (I only wonder why he didn’t mention The Rift)….  If you’ve got the time, check the film out.  It speaks in one way or another to today.

*

FYI:  Among those I personally depend on for fact-based news, most on Substack (alpha listing):  Ruth Ben-Ghiat,David French,  David Frum, Garrison Keillor, Paul Krugman, Minnesota Star Tribune, Doug Muder (The Weekly Sift), Robert Reich, Jennifer Rubin, Heather Cox Richardson, Timothy Snyder, Mary Trump, Joyce Vance.  There are many more whose writings I see on occasion, forwarded by someone I know. There is absolutely no lack of credible information if one wishes to be informed.

*

Brief Reflection Sep 26, 2025: After I had completed the above post, I opened Mary Trumps post for September 26.  Mary is Donald J’s niece, and she knows her uncle very well.  Take a moment to read the first five paragraphs (if you’re a subscriber, you can hear her tell the same story.)

Mary’s five paragraphs are a bullying story, from a TV show she saw as a youngster.  She describes the show and its main character, a youngster who terrorizes everyone else, adults and all.  She relates the character to her Uncle Donald, both then and now.

At a point in time in my teacher representation career, there was a strong push to rein in bullying in public schools.  Anyone who’s had a normal life knows bullying from real life, maybe as a victim, possibly as a perpetrator.  I don’t need to cite examples.  Where there’s people, there are bullies.  Each of us can identify our own.

In the instant situation, today, we as a country for some reason have elected a bully, twice, to be President of the United States.  For some reason the United States Supreme Court has further empowered this bully.  We are living through the implementation of a bully-run society, and in recent days it perhaps reached its current zenith in a speech at the United Nations, and it is possibly connected in some way to the upcoming and surprise short-notice meeting of all of the major U. S. military officers in Virginia, called by the Secretary of Defense.  At this writing, no one knows for sure what this meeting is even about, but it comes soon.

The principles and consequences of bullying are simple and well known to all of us from life experience.  A bully has allies who enable his (or her) behavior.  So it is today in our national conversation.

But so do the victims of bullies, and if and when they make the decision to strike back, there are also peaceful strategies to neutralize and defeat the offenders.

During the time when tamping down bullying became an important public school initiative in my state there were lots of positive results.  I’ve been retired 25 years, so I don’t know the current reality.  But I do know that bullies can be handled by their victims, but it takes courage to say and mean “enough!”.

*

A few weeks ago – a postnote to the Sep 7 post “The Hangman” – I offered a musical memory: “POSTNOTE September 8, 2025:  For some reason, the old standard of Harold Melvin and the Blue Notes is running through my head: “If you don’t know me by now“.  If we don’t know the issues that face us now in the United States, we will never….  When will we wake up and get into action as individuals – the only real solution ia each and every one of us.

 

 

A French-Canadian Enclave in the Twin Cities Minnesota

POSTNOTE Oct 5 2025: longer article by Mark Labine dated Sep 30 here: dayton with a French accent.  Also, Oct 5 article about Dayton in Minnesota Star Tribune: dayton STrib 10 5 25

September 4 2025 at this space, I published a post about a new book about over 100 French-Canadian families who settled in what is now Dayton MN, about 25 miles upriver from St. Anthony Falls, bordered on one side by the Mississippi River.

Ruins 14620 Dayton River Road Dayton MN September 2025.  This ruin of some building is about a mile east of the Blondeau farm, also along the Mississippi River.

The book particularly interested me because a branch of my family tree, the Collette’s, arrived there about 1875, via Old St. Anthony, where they settled 1864 to 1875.  They came from  St. Lambert de Luzon QC, on the Chaudiere River about 20 miles south of Quebec City.

(Franco-American history is truly ancient, beginning in the 1500s, more or less marked as officially starting with the founding of Quebec City in 1608, and thence existing as a autonomous entity until the British defeated the French at the Plains of Abraham in 1759 – 28 years before the newly minted United States of America arrived on the scene.  The phrase, ‘lots of water under that old bridge’ comes to mind.  There is lots and lots of not always comfortable history between English, French, French-Canadian and “Americans” over the last 400 years – and that’s just in North America.)

The book, expertly compiled by Caroline Meilleur over a three year period, includes morsels of the histories of likely well over 1,000 French-Canadian families.  It is a feast for those interested in genealogy, particularly if part of that genealogy is French-Canadian, and involves some connection with the Dayton community.  You’ll want it part of your family history resource.

Below is part of a single page from the book, (in pdf pp 83-84 Blondeau page 83-84 Dayton French) and jpeg form (below).  Simon and Adelaide were my great-great grandparents.

Portion of p. 83 from Dayton With a French Accent

TO ORDER the book: here.  (For the moment, my review is this writing.  I didn’t purchase the book through Amazon, and apparently this disqualifies me from posting a review there.)

A BONUS: Another family in the book, Daniel Louis LaVallee and Basilisse Elizabeth Beaudreau site Graveline had a Catholic Nun and Historian descendant Sr. Ann Thomasine Sampson, who wrote about her own venture into her own family history.  Her writing, from the publication Sep-Oct 1997 Chez Nous can be read here: Sampson Sr Ann Thomasine Fam Hist.  Chez Nous in its entirety can be accessed at https://fahfminn.org, click Library, click chez nous.  This newsletter is indexed and near 1000 pages.

A Gun

In the wake of yet another killing-by-gun at Orem Utah on September 10, 2023, I offer a tribute to a gun by its lover, Dr. Soren Kolstoe.  I offer it specifically to encourage conversation among those with different  opinions about guns, especially in these violent days.  It is brief, and food for thought.  The poem is probably over 50 years old.  It can be read in its complete context in Part Three of Lyrics of the Prairie by Dr. Kolstoe.  It is within a post about him that I wrote and published July 21, 2013.  t seems especially appropriate at this highly charged time.

from Lyrics of the Prairie by Soren O. Kolstoe ca 1960s with permission of the family.

Gun by Soren Kolstoe ca 1960s

Disclosure, I qualified as expert with the M-1 in my Army time in the early 1960s.  Subsequent I have never owned, kept or use a firearm.  My general position, shared with my legislators, is at the end of the post I did after the Annunciation shooting some weeks ago.  Scroll to the end of my August 25, 2025 post.  Following are five brief points made there.  There will be success with much persistence, but it will never be complete success.  Winning to me would be a return to the Soren Kolstoe philosophy.  While I never knew him personally, my guess is that the reason for hunting game was to serve a primordial instinct to harness for for personal use….

POSTNOTE September 6, 2025:  There have been subsequent photos and stories in the local paper, but I decided to call a halt at September 1.  I hope lots of people take up the issue with their legislators – that is where the solution has to begin.  It will continue to be a very tough sell.  People love their guns….

“Guns” have been part of over 100 posts at this space over the last 16 years.

If you looked back at them, you’d see a consistent set of talking points.

  1. I qualified as an expert marksman with the M-1 in Army days, 1962-63.  But I have never owned or had a gun or in fact used a gun in all the years since.
  2. Getting rid of guns in this gun-ridden society is impossible.  It is as difficult as it was to get rid of booze during prohibition days.
  3. It is easily possible to regulate guns through registration and other means, and stiffer penalties for violations.  A minority of the citizenry owns a large percentage of the guns, especially the most lethal ones.  Best I know from the Annunciation case, there was a single assailant who fired over 100 rounds in a very brief time period.  There is absolutely no reason in a civil society for that kind of armament being allowed on the street.
  4. Having and using a gun to facilitate a crime is no guarantee of success.  In the Annunciation case, the perpetrator apparently committed suicide.  Those who survive their felony have almost zero chance of evading accountability.
  5. In my state, state legislators are probably the most crucial focus of lobbying, followed by other elected officials, local, state, national, who depend on being elected to hold office.

Utah Valley University

10:24 a.m. September 12, 2025: The news conference is over and the apparent killer is in custody.  I just read a pretty compelling commentary by Thom Hartmann about the “Both Sides” argument which has already begun to rage.  I think it is important was a primer on the issue of rhetoric.  Here is the link.  I will add my own observations at the end of his post a little later.

12:14 p.m. Sep 12: A History of Violence from the Bulwark

RELATED: 9 minute video from Ukraine by Tim Snyder.  Worth your time.  I hope you can access it,

Thursday, September 11, 2025, 10:07 a.m.:   Google map link of the site of the killing yesterday is at the end of this post, after comments.  You can scroll in or out or move image around.

I do not jump to conclusions, except that the ramifications of this incident are incredibly serious.

As soon as I think there is something reportable, I’ll make an addition at this space.  Because google maps seem to be destination documents, any revisions to this document will include the map link at the end of the post.  [Sep 13 9:30 a.m.  I simply added to the map link at the end of the post, the location of the apparent home town of the alleged assailant in the Charlie Kirk killing.  I have many thoughts, as possibly you do as well, but I will defer on sharing these till later.  I will say that out of this there is an opportunity to learn for all of us.]

Signed personal opinions are welcome.  I’ll time-stamp them, as I am here.

Today of course is the 24th anniversary of 9-11-01.  Here’s what I wrote on Sep 17 and 24, 2001: Post 9-11-01001.

COMMENTS (more at end of post):

from Amy 9:42 a.m.: The silence on the assassination of [Melissa] Hortman is deafening.

from SAK 1:15 p.m.:  As you wrote this incident has serious ramifications.

The first and important thing to say is may Charlie Kirk rest in eternal peace. It is also a given, to me at least, that violence ought to be condemned.

Of course we must all wait until more information is available but already politicians & journalists have been giving their views. I have looked at various sources and clearly the killing will increase the polarisation and some politicians, instead of calling for unity and urging restraint, have already tried to rally their own side. Sad.

Since Amy has already commented on the assassination of Melissa Hortman, here’s another article that focuses on that event:

I am reasonably sure one can open the link in the US but just in case here it is:

Charlie Kirk shooting

Utah Republican senator faces backlash over post condemning Kirk’s killing

Only months ago, Mike Lee had posted disparaging tweets after Democrat Melissa Hortman and her husband were fatally shot

The official X account of Mike Lee, a Republican US senator, drew backlash after quickly condemning Wednesday’s killing of the influential conservative activist Charlie Kirk in Utah – less than three months from when the politician initially responded to the shootings of two Minnesota Democratic lawmakers by boosting misinformation about that case.

A post from Lee, who joined the Senate in 2011, denounced Kirk’s murder as “a cowardly act of violence” while hailing the Turning Point USA executive director as an “American patriot” and “inspiration to countless young people”. His post also solicited prayers for the 31-year-old Kirk’s widow, Erika, and their children.

“The terrorists will not win,” Lee said shortly after Kirk’s death while speaking at an outdoors gathering on the campus of Utah Valley University had been confirmed. “Charlie will.”

While some of the platform’s users replied positively to the post, many others immediately alluded to how Lee focused on advancing conspiracy theories in the aftermath of the 14 June shootings that killed Minnesota’s former house speaker Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark, while wounding state senator John Hoffman – her fellow Democrat – as well as his wife, Yvette.

“This is what happens,” Lee wrote in an X post, “When Marxists don’t get their way.” Attached to the post was a picture of the suspect charged in the shooting, Vance Boelter, evidently wearing a latex face mask.

There was no evidence Boelter is a Marxist. Friends have told local media he was right-leaning. And while Minnesota voters don’t list party affiliation, Boelter was registered as a Republican in Oklahoma in 2004.

Separately, under another picture of Boelter, Lee wrote, “Nightmare on Waltz Street”, which appeared to be a reference to Tim Walz, Minnesota’s Democratic governor, who was Kamala Harris’s running mate in the 2024 presidential election won by Donald Trump.

Lee’s allusion to Walz came as conservative influencers misleadingly suggested an alliance between the governor and Boelter. Walz’s Democratic predecessor, Mark Dayton, appointed Boelter in 2016 to a 60-member voluntary advisory board. Boelter’s appointment was renewed in 2019 by Walz, who did not know him.

Tina Smith, a US Democratic senator from Minnesota, confronted Lee two days after the shootings in her state to tell him his posts were “brutal and cruel”, as CNN reported. “He should think about the implications of what he’s saying and doing.”

Lee didn’t say much to Smith and seemed surprised she had confronted him, as she put it. However, he subsequently deleted the posts in question.

After Wednesday’s killing, Lee told reporters that Kirk had recently texted him about being excited to visit Utah. Lee also exalted Kirk’s “boundless energy and great love for his country”.

Lee’s lament prompted one X user to rhetorically ask the senator “what has changed” because he had “expressed no sympathy” after the Minnesota lawmaker shootings.

“It seems you do know how to respond appropriately to tragedy,” another user replied to Lee. “I wish you would have … shown that same respect to Melissa Hortman and her husband, Mark.”

Yet another reply added: “I pray for Charlie Kirk’s family. They should not have to go through this. Nor did Melissa or Mark Hortman right??”

Smith posted about Kirk on Wednesday nearly an hour before Lee published his tribute to the staunch Trump ally.

“Horrific,” Smith wrote. “We all need to condemn these acts of political violence that are becoming far too commonplace in this country. We can’t continue like this.”

from Flo: 1:30 p.m.: I continue to firmly support controlling the sale and purchase of any kind of gun. They’re only getting to be worse!   Still, I enjoy eating the meat Carter and Eric both hunt for in the cabin area every November. They occasionally get one. Last year Carter got a big Buck he saw only about 12 feet from it.

GOOGLE MAP OF OREM UTAH AND Utah Valley University: For reference, here is the google map of the site of the killing yesterday.  You can scroll in or out or move image around.  Apparently the home of the suspect in the killing of Charlie Kirk is Washington Utah, in far southwest Utah near St. George.

Deceased

Yesterday I got a note that someone I knew had died in mid-July in a neighboring state.  He was 87, and apparently had been in failing health for some years.  He was a Superintendent of Schools in large school districts in three states, including the one where I was the teacher’s union rep during the first six years of his 15 year career there.

Lew (his first name) was respected in my district.  The nature of our jobs tended to be competitive, but there was no animosity.  I left the district nine years before he did, we shared common ground for about six years, dealing with issues as our respective jobs required.

I don’t think he was run out of town on a rail!  Leastways I’ve never heard that from others I know who were there the entire time period that he was Superintendent.

I looked at Lew’s obituary, which was essentially the standard verbiage except for one missing piece of information: there was not a single word about his 15 years as Superintendent in my school district, which was then and remains among the largest in Minnesota.

Some months earlier I’d been to another memorial for another former colleague, Patrick, who was in his 90s and had even longer service with his employer.  He had been my boss.  Similarly, nothing was said about his work in our organization, from which he’d been retired for over 30 years.  A couple of us had some open-mike time to at least acquaint the others about the Pat that we knew.

I can think of many other similar examples I’ve seen over the years.  Unfortunately the blank spaces make sense, in a sense, at least.

When you get old, memorials seem to be the primary social gatherings – reunions as it were….  It has occurred to me especially in the more recent years that the deceased is not much able to plan his or her own funeral, much less write the remarks somebody will make about the dear departed who is no longer available.

Unless the person takes the time, before it’s too late, to write something as simple as a timeline of significant events in his or her life, the survivors left to plan the celebration of life will be left to their own devices, and will have to rely on their own memories.

So…before it’s too late, give some thought to how you’d like to be remembered; write it down and give it to someone who’ll likely have to deal with your last public appearance.