#586 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #26. Dr. David Schultz: Wealth vs Democracy: The Battle for America's Soul.

Preliminary Note from Dick Bernard: At the Annual Meeting of the Minnesota Chapter of Citizens for Global Solutions June 21, 2012, Dr. David Schultz gave an important talk entitled “Wealth vs Democracy: The Battle for America’s Soul”.
Rather than attempting to summarize what he had to say, I asked Dr. Schultz if he would be willing to share the actual outline of his remarks with our group and the readers of this blog.
Dr. Schultz graciously agreed.
The outline, 6 pages in all, is here: Wealth v.democracy talk June 21 2012
The richness of his presentation, including the many questions and dialogue after his formal remarks, cannot be completely captured in written form. At the same time, he made some important points which deserve discussion within all ideological communities. Your comments are solicited.
(click to enlarge photos)

Dr. David Schultz, June 21, 2012


Part of the group at the June 21st meeting


From the June 21 program announcement:David Schultz, a professor in the Hamline University School of usiness, is the author or editor of more than 25 books and 90 articles on American politics, campaigns and elections, media and politics, and election law. he is frequently interviewed by local, national and international media on these subjects. His most recent book is Politainment: The Ten Rules of Contemporary Politics.
Occupy Wall Street brought renewed focus to the growing gap between the rich and poor and the power of wealth in the United States. The battle is not simply one between the haves and have nots, but over the political soul and future viability of American democracy. At a time when progressive groups are fragmented and solutions for reform are scattered, [Dr. Schultz’] talk describes both what is politically viable and imperative for the people to creat a “Second progressive Era” to restore democracy.”
A previous talk by Dr. Schultz, including the outline of his remarks, can be found here.
Dr. Schultz blogs regularly Schultz’s Take, here.
For other posts relating to Election 2012, simply put those two words in the search box, click and a chronological list will come up.

#584 – Lee Dechert in his own words

UPDATE June 26, 2012: Here is the obituary on Lee Dechert.
NOTE: Comments on Lee from Andy Driscoll and Will Shapira can be found at the very end of this post. There may be others, later.
Richard Lee Dechert (that’s as in French: pronounced d-share) passed away quietly at home on June 21. Years ago I heard a man eulogized as follows: “he lived before he died; he died before he was finished”. This would fit Lee Dechert who passed away June 21, 2012, in St. Paul.
There will be a formal obituary in the metro newspapers shortly. I am thinking that Lee would want his own words, which follow, passed along as well.
Every one who knew Lee, knew that his death was imminent. The cancer finally had its way. He was quietly eloquent about the progress of the disease and other ailments. They were simply part of his life as he lived it.
Lee (the only name I had for him) died with uncommon grace. May 17 I gave him a ride to (as far as I know) his final outside event, the Third Thursday program of Citizens for Global Solutions. Also in the car that night was the speaker for the evening, Pat Hamilton of the Science Museum of Minnesota. There are a couple of photos from that final outing for Lee at the end of this post.
My knowledge of Lee came from attendance at meetings with him, and occasional visits when I gave him a ride home. There were bits and pieces shared: his Air Force service in the 1950s, including a visit to Haiti; going to the University; his great pride in his daughter, son-in-law and then grandson; his love for his sister; sometimes a little talk about the illness, but never much. I gathered he was divorced, but we didn’t talk much about that, and when that was a brief topic, there was no sense of bitterness. Things apparently just didn’t work out. It seemed there was a continuing relationship of some sort.
At home I would hear from Lee from time to time. When I knew that his death was soon approaching, I consciously began to keep his e-mails. There were perhaps 15 of them in all. From those 15 I’ve decided to include several which articulated Lee’s passions and history. I’ve left the contents exactly as received. They are Lee talking, not me. I noted my computer spell check found nothing. Lee was meticulous.
This is a very long post. The counter says 4068 words. At minimum, scroll through….
If you knew Lee, you’ll want to read on. (Click to enlarge the photos which, except for the final one, came from Lee Dechert.)

Lee, daughter Sabrina, son Luc, Son-in-Law Marco and Jim Pagliarini, President of TPT Channel 2 December 20, 2011


About TPTs Almanac Program April 4, 2012. Lee honored us by having us as audience stand-ins for him at Almanac May 11, 2012.
As Caitlin Mussmann says, you’re “go” for the show. Some background: Now approaching its 28th year, Almanac is the longest running (and most successful) local news and public affairs magazine in PBS history, and is a “must appear” venue for any aspiring candidate of a major federal, state or municipal office. Its co-creators, Bill Hanley and Brendan Henehan, are still senior staffers. Brendan is Almanac’s Executive Producer, and you’ll likely see him in the Control Room with longtime Associate Producer Kari Kennedy and longtime Director Jeff Weihe. Other members of the show’s crack production crew have been there 15 to 20 years or more. The late Judge Joe Summers was the first Co-Host along with Jan Smaby. In the 1960’s I knew Joe as a DFL activist, and I knew Jan as a teenager at my and my wife’s Lutheran parish near the U. of M. campus.
Under Bill’s leadership as Vice-President of Minnesota Productions, tpt launched the part-time local, digital Minnesota Channel (now MN Channel) 10 years ago. In 2006 it became the nationally acclaimed 24/7 statewide service it is now, with a groundbreaking business plan of co-producing or co-presenting a rich array of programs with local, state and regional non-profit organizations, and providing seed grants for low-income producers. Brendan is also the Executive Producer for the MN Channel’s public affairs programs. A major off-shoot of Almanac is Almanac: At the Capitol, created in 2006 with Kari as its Producer and Mary Lahammer as its Host. David Gillette became its Special Correspondent in 2010. Mary and David also report or commentate on Almanac. A major off-shoot of the MN Channel is the superb MN Original arts series that was launched in 2010 with funding from the State Legacy Amendment. Over the years Minnesota Productions has created a multitude of award-winning programs.
As you may recall Dick, then KTCA-TV operated from its Como Ave. studios near the State Fairgrounds. In 1988 it moved to the newly constructed Telecenter next to the St. Paul Union Depot on Fourth St., and became digital tpt in 2002. I started in the Member and Viewer Services unit in November 1991 and retired in May 2007; I had major throat surgery in June. Working with the public entailed working with staffers in every station unit, and I was blessed to be there when we began our fascinating transition from analog to multi-channel digital programming that culminated in 2006. With Governor Ventura presiding, in 1997 [1999? Ventura was elected in 1998] Minnesota’s first broadcast digital signal was switched on at the State Capitol; it subsequently led the state in a series of digital firsts. With the Governor was Jim Pagliarini who became the station’s President & CEO in 2007. Under his leadership tpt has remained one of the “gems” of the Public Broadcasting Service.
In 1982 my sister Bobbie, who died from cancer in October 2008, served as an MCAD arts intern at the station. In 1983 I, my wife Ann and daughter Sabrina were in the audience for the second-ever live filming of the half-hour Newton’s Apple show that aired on PBS until 1998. In 2006 Sabrina returned from Paris and opened her first stained-glass studio overlooking the Farmers Market from the Northwestern Building, a block on Fourth Street from the Depot and two blocks from tpt. Last December Sabrina, Marc-Antoine and little Luc took the James J. Hill Empire Builder from Seattle to St. Paul. And as the attached photos indicate, on December 20 Luc met some of my tpt associates who were thrilled to see him.
That is Luc, Marc-Antoine and I beneath the Almanac banner at the Lobby entrance; Luc, Sabrina and I before the Minnesota: A history of the land graphic in the Lobby; and the four of us with Jim Pagliarini at the station’s “Wall of Fame” across from Studio A. On the “Blenko Buddies” date Sabrina, Marc-Antoine (Marco) and I attended a special Studio A wine and cheese event for a Blenko Glass Company pledge show. On 8/2/07 Bobbie and I attended the station’s 50th Anniversary Alumni and Staff Party, and on 5/29/09 Bobbie’s partner John Sherrell met his friend Cathy Wurzer when he and I watched Almanac in Studio B and the Control Room much as you and your wife will. In her office my former manager Margaret took the photo of four-months old Luc checking his first gift from “Santa” (via me), a furry Minnesota Wood Duck. She also took our “Wall of Fame” photos.
If you wish, ask one of the Almanac crew for a marker to place your names and date on the massive “Wall” that graphically represents over 50 years of political and cultural history in Minnesota; First Lady Hillary Clinton is also on it. Before you leave also take a few minutes to review the station’s history at the hallway entrance to the studios. I’ll be there in spirit.

At TPT, December 20, 2011 photo received from Lee Dechert April 2012


On his own family history and Politics: (August 26, 2009)
Along with Ann, I was a DFL State Convention delegate supporting A.M. “Sandy” Keith for Governor of Minnesota* when young and handsome Ted Kennedy, escorted by Irish bagpipers, delivered a stirring address on behalf of the party at the State Capitol Mall Armory in the summer of 1966. That was less than three years after his brother John’s death and he was treated with great reverence.
Ted and I were both born in 1932 a few months before FDR was elected in the depths of the Great Depression. My grandfather Everett, who married and lived with Nanny Kennedy in southern Ontario, and who died about a year after Uncle Lloyd was born in 1908 and mother was born in 1910, was a Scotch-Irish Kennedy whose clan history Bobbi traced when she journeyed through the British Isles in the 1990s. [Lee specifically noted that his Kennedy line was not part of that other Kennedy line!]
I still have the fine clan scarf she gave me, and wear it when I attend the St. Patrick’s Day Parade in St. Paul. It marches down 4th Street past the historic James J. Hill Northwestern Building where Sabrina had her stained-glass studio, and Twin Cities Public Television where Bobbi and I attended the 50th Anniversary Alumni and Staff Party on August 2, 2007. In 2008 Sabrina and I watched the Parade on a cold, windy March 17.
As I’ve mentioned before, when I hear those bagpipes and drums and see those magnificent uniforms, I always think of the Essex Scottish Regiment when it paraded through Great Grandmother Nanny Kiff’s Ontario village of Harrow to celebrate Dominion Day in the late 1930s and early 1940s. Grandfather Everett was a member of that Regiment and received one of the highest medals of the British Crown for his bravery in South Africa’s Boer War.
Long live the Kennedys! Long live “The Lion of the Senate”!
*”Sandy” lost the DFL nomination to incumbent DFL Governor Karl Rolvaag in a historic 21-ballot battle that lasted two days, lost the primary election, but went on to become a distinguished Chief Justice of the Minnesota Supreme Court. Our efforts were not wasted.
My Contribution to the Peace and Justice Community October 18, 2011. (Included here, Lee lays out the medical situation he was facing.)
[See] “Global Warming, Climate Chaos and Human Conflict” [here]. The initial text concludes by saying:
“CO2 and other greenhouse gas emissions have raised the mean global temperature by 0.8 degrees Celsius since 1900, and 0.6 more has been locked in by climate system inertia. With the temperature continuing to rise about 0.2 degrees a decade since 1990—and with the U.S. and other Accord nations not doing enough to reverse the rise or adapt to it—the 1.5 and 2.0 limits will likely be exceeded well before 2050,[13-16,19] and the chaotic impacts of human-induced global warming will become the paramount issue of the 21st century.[6-9,20-23]
“Rampant conflict within and between nations is one of those impacts. Yet many U.S. ‘peace and justice’ organizations have not embraced a climate chaos agenda that could prevent or reduce the conflict. The APPENDIX of 26 conflict reports shows why such an agenda must be a key part of every organization’s actions. Moreover, because decades of human-induced global warming are locked into our planet’s climate system,[5] that agenda should primarily focus on implementing measures that will enable populations in our nation and other nations to adapt as best as they can to increasing climate chaos.[24]”
Dick, unless there were signs protesting the CO2 that was streaming from the tail pipes of the passing vehicles, “a climate chaos agenda” was not “a key part” of the Lake Street agenda. So I regard such
“peace and justice” protests as largely treating the symptoms of worldwide
“human conflict” rather than its underlying
“global warming” causes in which too many people are vying for too few resources in an increasingly hostile environment.
I just returned from a four-day visit with my sister, her partner and my nephew in the Rocky Mountains above Denver. I told them that the carcinomoid form of renal cell cancer that began in my surgically removed right kidney has metastasized to my lungs, is inoperable, can’t be treated with radiation therapy, and is usually fatal in less than a year with or without chemotherapy. Today I’ll have a third set of MRI and CT scans to determine how much the tiny “nodules” in my lungs have increased, and tomorrow I’ll meet with my oncologist to decide on initiating chemotherapy or palliative care. I’ll then inform my daughter and her husband in Seattle where I was the first family member to see and hold Luc two days after he was born.
If I’m able to attend Thursday’s Forum, I’ll distribute printouts of my piece. I hope to see you there.
Honduras Constitutional Crisis: A Proper Resolution (August 28, 2009)
I’ve reviewed over 500 reports and opinion pieces on the crisis from a wide range of sources and perspectives. In my judgment Honduras’ Supreme Court–supported by the Supreme Electoral Tribunal, Attorney General and democratically elected National Congress–had strong “probable cause” to arrest and detain President Manuel Zelaya for abuses of office and other crimes.
As prescribed by Honduras’ Constitution, President of Congress Roberto Micheletti (and leader of Zelaya’s Liberal Party) was selected to replace him (by a nearly unanimous 122 to 6 vote) as the interim President only until the November 2009 national elections are held and his term ends in January 2010.
However, Zelaya’s right to defend himself in a due-process proceeding was circumvented when military officers responsible for executing the Supreme Court’s order to arrest and detain him violated the order (and the statute that prohibits extradition of Honduran citizens) by forcibly expelling him to Costa Rica.
Since then the Supreme Court has ruled that Zelaya’s interim replacement by Micheletti was Constitutional and its order to arrest and detain him must be enforced.
Unfortunately if not tragically, the officers’ illegal expulsion has been erroneously conflated with the Court’s legal order, and both have been branded as a “military coup.”
Therefore, instead of circumventing that order by arbitrarily restoring him to the Presidency as the US-supported OAS Resolution demands and Oscar Arias’ San José Accord proposes, Zelaya should agree to return to Honduras and be duly adjudicated for his alleged treason, abuses of office and other crimes. Only then can his guilt or innocence be legally established and Honduras’ Constitutional crisis be properly resolved.
In addition the officers who expelled him should be duly adjudicated along with pro-Micheletti and pro-Zelaya forces who have violated the civil and human rights of Honduran citizens and foreign nationals. If Micheletti’s interim government does not curtail violations by army, police and other pro-Micheletti forces, even stronger economic and diplomatic sanctions should be applied by the US, OAS, UN and other international actors. Pro-Zelaya forces must also curtail their violations.
Moreover, Venezuela (supported by Cuba, Nicaragua and others) must end the blatant intervention in Honduras’ internal affairs that has exacerbated the crisis and violated the OAS and UN Charters.
In short, ALL parties to the crisis must resolve it by honoring the rule of law, not just the ones we may ideologically or politically favor.
Global Warming, Climate Chaos and the 2012 Minnesota Legislative Session (January 26, 2012)
As I’ve noted before, because of our climate system’s inertia in reacting to human-generated greenhouse gases, our state and the rest of our planet are locked into decades of chaotic global warming–even if all emissions were halted today. As I’ve also noted before, shaping government actions at state and local levels is crucial in adapting to warming impacts that include more frequent and extreme weather events in Minnesota and the Upper Midwest region.
As best as I can I’ll monitor the 2012 session, and if possible testify in behalf of legislation that will enable our state to better adapt to the chaos. I no longer use the term “climate change”; for urgent, effective adaptation it’s clearly outdated.
For those who wish to monitor the 2012 legislature, daily sessions are broadcast and streamed via the statewide Minnesota Channel (TPT-2 in the Twin Cities); e-mailed schedules are available from the House and Senate media services and from key committees; and daily reports are available from the the Minnesota Environmental Partnership (below) and Midwest Energy News; the latter also has regional and national reports; both can be Googled.
Regarding another warm environment, many thanks to the Board members who attended the delightful luncheon at the Olive Garden, and those who couldn’t attend but sent their best wishes.
RLD
======
Hopes for 2012 Legislative Session: Jobs and the environment, together
by Steve Morse, Minnesota Environmental Partnership [a former state legislator]
The 2012 Legislative Session kicks off this week!
While it’s anticipated that this session will focus on bonding, the Vikings stadium, and various constitutional amendments, important environmental issues will still be part of the policy discussion.
As legislators return to the state Capitol, we urge them to remember that policies that affect our water, clean energy future, and Great Outdoors are vitally important to Minnesota voters – regardless of political party affiliation.
In fact, a 2012 poll* of Minnesota voters found that the majority of voters do not believe that we have to choose between helping the economy vs. protecting our environment. A whopping 79% of voters polled said we can have a clean environment and a strong economy at the same time without having to choose one over the other.
Join us and tell your legislators and Governor Dayton that choosing the economy over the environment is a false choice – Minnesotans want and deserve both.
Having a strong economy and a healthy environment together will make Minnesota better today and for generations to come.
*From a statewide telephone poll of 500 registered Minnesota voters, conducted Jan. 9-11, 2012, for the Minnesota Environmental Partnership by the bipartisan research team of Fairbank, Maslin, Maullin, Metz & Associates and Public Opinion Strategies. The margin of sampling error for the full statewide samples is 4.4 percentage points, plus or minus; margins of error for subgroups within the sample will be larger.
Precinct Caucuses (February 1, 2012)
I’ll be the convener for my DFL precinct caucus in District 55A (partly Maplewood and North St. Paul). I’ll try to have my global-warming resolution passed and become a delegate to the District 55 Senate Convention where the resolution can be further discussed and hopefully passed on to the DFL State Convention.
I attended my first Maplewood precinct caucus with my wife Ann in 1966. We became delegates to the historic 20-ballot DFL State Convention at the Leamington Hotel in Minneapolis where A.M. “Sandy” Keith prevailed over Gov. Karl Rolvaag, but was defeated in a bitter primary election. Rolvaag was reelected and several years later “Sandy” was appointed to the State Supreme Court and became one of its finest Chief Justices.
I was also the titular campaign chairman, a lead organizer, and media publicist for a Catholic middle-school teacher in the Maplewood-North St. Paul School District by the name of Jerome “Jerry” Hughes. He upset a longtime GOP Sen. Les Westin, eventually became Chairman of the Senate Education Committee, received a Ph.D., authored groundbreaking early-education legislation, and spent the final years of a distinguished 28-year career as President of the Senate. I coined the campaign battle cry of “Less Westin and More Hughes!” It worked.
In 1968 my wife and I were delegates to the even more historic and divisive DFL State Convention at a St. Paul venue I don’t recall where Sen. Hubert Humphrey prevailed over Sen. Gene McCarthy. I was an anti-Vietnam War pro-Humphrey delegate and the District 50A Vice-Chairman. Our district was one of two in the entire Twin Cities region that sent Humphrey delegates to the ill-fated Democratic National Convention in Chicago. I received a personal letter of appreciation from Hubert, and he later autographed my book on “Midwestern Progressive Politics” at the Leamington.
That premier hotel where many historical events were held and guests like Richard Nixon, Dwight Eisenhower, Ronald Reagan, Lyndon Johnson, Hubert Humphrey and Duke Ellington stayed was demolished in 1990. Much of the site is a parking ramp for Orchestra Hall. I think of those 1960’s
events every time I attend a concert at
the Hall.
Here We Go Again…More Rollbacks for Environmental Protections (February 27, 2012)

As many of you may know, in the 2011 Minnesota legislative session the GOP-controlled House and Senate passed bills that repealed much of our state’s progressive environmental legislation—including laws that limit greenhouse gas emissions from coal-fired power plants and prohibit construction of new plants. Except for one relatively minor bill, Gov. Dayton vetoed them. This session they’re taking a different tack by passing bills that repeal state environmental rules and regulations—then require them to be submitted for approval by the legislature before state agencies can enforce them. Minnesota Environmental Partnership Executive Director (and former state senator) Steve Morse further explains that in his linked Loon Commons message and brief video. It is a major assault on public health and safety that’s occurring or has occurred in other states where the GOP controls the legislative process. It is similarly occurring in the U.S. House with the EPA and other federal agencies.
I hope our Chapter will join with other organizations in sending a letter opposing these bills to their authors and Gov. Dayton. I’m still available to assist in doing that.
Offer to include a link of Lee’s at AMillionCopies.Info (February 26, 2012)

Dick, thanks for your offer! As we know, without a livable environment there will be no lasting peace. The United Nations Environment Programme (note the spelling) is perfect for your page. UNEP is celebrating its 40th birthday and on June 5, 2012 it will celebrate World Environment Day. Its Website is a treasure trove of information. I would place its link directly below the CGS link. RLD
Finally, I noted four of my blogposts where Lee ‘appeared’, usually with a comment at the end of the post. They can be accessed here.

Luc, December 20, 2011, from Lee April 4, 2012


Lee, Sabrina and Luc at TPT, December 20, 2011, from Lee April 4, 2012


Photo taken Dec. 20, 2011, from Lee Dechert April 4, 2012


Andy Driscoll, June 22, 2012;
Well, now this calls for a short essay, which I’ll spare you right now. But, Lee Dechert was one of the smartest, most contradictory people I’ve ever known – not that being progressive and contradictory are necessarily mutually exclusive. He could be both, in series and in parallel.
This retiree from Channel 2, tpt, was ever critical of his colleagues for being in bed with corporations but who would defend to the death the institution’s value to the community and its viewers, even in retrospect. He was, for a progressive, immensely critical (if not totally accurate in his facts) of the RNC anarchists and journalists who goaded law enforcement into overreaction rather than place responsibility for restraint on the over-armed and over-armored former that confronted dissenters in the streets and were more violent than any of the protesters could possibly have been, putting property above person.
But Lee defended all of it, insisting that the aim of disrupting a constitutionally assembled convention was not theirs – the dissenters – to pursue. Certainly not with any sort of violence in their plan. And he let me know same in many an email and in no uncertain terms.
Lee was a great advocate of new technologies in the media while being an old-fashioned moralist himself and a critic of the direction mainstream media was taking – or ignoring – at our constitutional peril.
He could be one’s best friend one minute, grinning and praising and tearing you a new one the next, depending on the topic. But he never really held a grudge for the same reason.
I knew him not at all, despite these observations, but knew that he cared more for at least one of his sister’s health than his own during the days we worked together on the Media Reform Conference in Minneapolis.
And the hits just kept on coming. He was an excellent writer – off the cuff and after much work. Whether or not his reasoning coincided with the prevailing convention, it was ever his own, today a maverick, tomorrow a laissez-faire defender.
He will be missed – and remembered for all of that and more, and I heap my condolences on his family and friends.
Andy Driscoll
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Andy Driscoll, Producer/Host,
TruthToTell – KFAI FM 90.3/106.7
Will Shapira, June 22, 2012
He was one of my best friends from Ch. 2-17 days and will be greatly missed by all.
He faced death more bravely than anyone I’ve ever known.
All Detroit sports teams should fly their flags at half mast.

My last photo of Lee, May 17, 2012, at Citizens for Global Solutions Third Thursday program featuring Dr. Pat Hamilton.


May 17, 2012

#583 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #25. Half-thinking (or not thinking at all)

Earlier this week I was sitting in my Caribou Coffee “office” and a friend I see from time to time wandered in and joined me for a few minutes.
Talk quickly got around to the political world and the upcoming election. He told me he’s filed for one of those important but seldom noticed positions that are on the second page of ballots, don’t have full page ads or lawn signs, and are very often passed over by voters (“who’s he, what’s this office?”).
“George” got around to talking about a younger friend of his who makes over $250,000 a year and thinks there isn’t enough poverty in this country. Yes, this guy said, there should be more poverty, not less.
The reasoning was simple: desperate people will work harder at more disagreeable jobs.
This might make sense, if you rely on half-thinking.
I wondered aloud how greater poverty would improve this six-figure guys bottom line. After all, it takes people with resources to buy the stuff that makes rich people rich. But, no matter. This young well-to-do half-thinker doesn’t need to be bothered with any other side of the story.
I kept thinking of an arrest of “illegal aliens” in North Dakota a couple of years ago. They had been hired by a farmer to plant onions. The farmer couldn’t find any locals who were willing to do that hard and menial work. “The rubber hit the road” out in North Dakota…. Send those Mexicans back where they came from.
I’ve begun to assert, seriously, that the crown jewel of unfettered capitalism might well be desperately poor Haiti. There are doubtless billionaires in Haiti, or who’ve made much of their money off Haiti, and they aren’t bothered by unions, or regulations or such.
They are in a perfect environment for ‘job creators’….
Half-thinking doesn’t stop at the borders of the well-off.
A friend, a retired teacher who lives in Wisconsin, said that 40% of union members there voted against the recall of avowedly anti-union Gov. Walker in the June 5 election.
Now, there might be many reasons why one person voted to retain the Governor, but protecting their self interest was irrelevant to the 40%, apparently.
I thought of an e-mail I got from a distant cousin in Iowa about a year ago.
He was forwarding something about a supposedly corrupt Wisconsin teacher union that was driving the school district into bankruptcy. The forward turned out to be so misleading as to be false, as almost all such documents are. Such documents only need allegations. Facts really don’t matter. All that matters is the story.
I didn’t know anything about my relatives background, so I asked him. He knew my background was as a union rep.
Here is his e-mail, verbatim (bold-face emphasis added): CAVEAT. I don’t agree at all with any of his blanket indictments – the evidence if given didn’t support the indictment. But no matter. In his mind, he’s right. End of story.
August 2, 2011: “My wife taught school for 40 years and in the NEA [National Education Association] that long and in the __EA for over 30 years. I was in the meatcutters union for 23 years. The union publications and meetings always slanted toward the left. One union rep told us that as members work for years and become financially solid they vote republican because of all the taxes that come out of their check. We have all heard for years countless examples of welfare fraud, where people collect benefits and food stamps without deserving them. Its the democrats that cannot spend enough tax money to create dependents to get their votes. This has worked well for the dems for 60 years, but the country is in a different mood now, demanding accountability and responsibility. The debt ceiling vote was nothing more that politicians wanting to hold on to their power. Look what socialism has done to the European countries, they are going bankrupt. They are running out of other peoples money to spend, and that is exactly what Obama wants for this country. The best definition of a liberal I have ever heard is “someone who would love to give you the shirt off of someone else’s back”. That is so true. There are a lot of republicans who also need to be retired.
Look at the _____ WI school figures–from a $400,000 deficit to a $1,500,000 surplus because of the union shackles being shed [this is a union guy talking]. That is tax money that will go into benefiting kids instead of democratic politicians. That’s why they protested so long and loud and even ran away and hid for so long. There is a city in Rhode Island that recently declared bankruptcy because of all the lavish public union pension and healthcare benefits they were forced to pay but cannot afford [no evidence provided] Look at Detroit [an always example] – a run down slum-like mess, and run for 60 years by democrats. California and New York (liberal havens) are billions in the hole. When I was young and naive I was a democrat but as I became aware of politics I sided more with republicans but now I would consider myself as an independent. Show me a conservative democrat and I would vote for him. I am sick and tired of our federal government being run like a giant Santa Claus operation, with a Robin Hood attitude that spouts class warfare all the time. Socialism has its roots in jealousy, envy, and greed and promotes robbery through taxation and produces dependency. I don’t care to continue writing about politics.
I know I have my thoughts and you have yours and neither of us will change our mind so lets leave it like that
.
Is my relative half-thinking? Of course. Not even half-thinking. And then not even being willing to talk about it.
I haven’t heard from him since. He must’ve sent me 20 of those ‘forwards’, similar fictions, till he faded into the woodwork last summer.
This litany could go on and on. Over and over and over and over again I hear/see examples of half-thinking, from all sides.
And like my relative, their mind is made up. Don’t bother with any alternative realities.
What a country!
For other commentaries on Election 2012, simply put Election 2012 in the search box, and click enter.

#580 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #24. I'm in….

I don’t consider myself a political junkie. I am liberal Democrat but I am not, nor have I ever been, heavily immersed in party decision making.
I do think that there is little more important than active involvement in the task of selecting good reasonable people to represent us all in all elective offices, and then supporting them. So, I try to engage in one way or another so as to be a reasonably well informed and aware citizen, and to try to have something responsible to say in political conversations…and not avoid those conversations.
My core belief: we are a complex country, and we are ill served by attempts to dominate or control by fringe ideologies. If that makes me sound anti-Tea Party and the like, so be it. These are polarized times, and we will rue the day we lose control to right wing ideologues (the ones who are by far the best funded, and money does talk).
This past week seems to have been the week I decided to dive in to the pool of Election 2012 activism.
There are endless ways to be constructively engaged, and here are some of mine, and what I learned.
There are a number of candidates I know I will support. Not all are listed below.
This week I met with my preferred candidate for state legislature, JoAnn Ward, a lady I have known for 14 years who is very well grounded in this community, but has not run for office before (every one who’s ever been elected to anything had to run for the first time, sometime, so that is never a liability, in my opinion.)
JoAnn didn’t tell me anything I didn’t know this week. Running for office, even for state House of Representatives, is an immense task. There is a great deal to learn. Many issues, many opinions on the issues. When one takes a step into running for office, one is made aware, instantly, that this is not an arm chair activity. There is a lot of very hard work.
Also this week I went to a fund raiser for another local candidate, Ann Marie Metzger. Ann Marie loves public engagement. But there are limits.
I asked a single question at the fundraiser: how many doors are there in our legislative district (candidates need to get out and doorknock.) The answer came back quickly “about 24,000”.
There is no way a single candidate can physically knock on every door in his or her legislative district, even if only a House of Representatives district. Other helpers are needed to do the task. And it is an unreasonable criteria to demand that the candidate actually stop at your doorstep to qualify for your vote. It would be nice, but impossible to achieve.
Of course, candidates at all levels need money. Unless you’re the Koch Brothers or other big money types, money for things like campaign literature, mailing expense, etc., does not grow on trees. it has to come from individual donations.
Ditto, the political parties do not have full-to-overflowing money trees. Money is needed. It needs to come from citizens.
If a candidate you like is going to have any chance of election, he or she needs your physical and economic help, and not $10 two weeks before the election.
We are electing people at all levels to make our society work. We are not wise to sit the election out, arms crossed, pretending we’ll be “independent” and then at the last minute decide who gets our vote. It’s risky business.
Then there’s the matter of exposure of the candidates to public view. Today I did my first parade, in the unit for Senator Amy Klobuchar in the neighboring town of Cottage Grove. This one was touch and go for rain out, but the weather cooperated and it was a good parade.
There were a dozen parades in Minnesota today, the coordinator of our unit said. The candidates obviously cannot be at every event, and that’s why there are an assortment of volunteers carrying signs, maybe looking uncomfortable. But there to say “I support this candidate”.
While walking the parade route, I do “people watch” the folks along the sidewalks. They’re at various places and stages, but hopefully they at least see us go by.
In a few weeks we’ll be at four months to the election.
Get in, and help out!
(photos, at Cottage Grove Parade June 16. click to enlarge.)

People watching from the parade. 3M won the prize for most effective handouts along this particular route. A good idea....


Some of my fellow paraders June 16, 2012


An Indian Runner Duck was part of our parade unit. Novelties like the duck, and, of course, kids, add a great deal....


...and don't forget those partisan dogs, wearing a candidates tee-shirt!


For past and future posts on this political season, enter the words Election 2012 in the search box.

#578 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #23. Politics of Losing…and Winning

The weekend just past was hot, at least as for us in this area. The temperature was in the low 90s till Sunday night rainfall moderated it.
Some of our grandkids were involved in post-school year athletic activities.
Over at the local high school, first-grade Ben competed in several events, including successfully passing the baton in the second leg of the 4×100 race. That afternoon, 10 year old Parker was part of a team that played five baseball games in a tournament on Saturday and Sunday, and won third. We saw the third game. He’s a good competitor, Parker is. (see photos, click to enlarge) His team is a good one: they work well together; there’s a sense of co-ownership which you can “feel” as a spectator. They’re a team.

Ben passes the baton at the end of the second leg of the 4x100


Parker on first.


Sunday we missed another grandsons baseball game because of a competing event: another grandsons 12th birthday party. Ted’s cake was decorated with the symbol Pi (of 3.1416). His gig is numbers and math. His sister, Kelly, showed off some pottery she was making in some summer class.
And on it went. It was a good weekend.
I contrast this with what we witnessed again this weekend: the lose-lose talk of politics as war.
The Republicans are proclaimed to be riding high because of Walker’s win in Wisconsin; and a verbal gaffe – a single sentence – of President Obama was expertly snipped out and exploited by his enemies this weekend. Unfortunately, contemporary Politics is Civil War, and I think the piece I wrote a few days ago is worth reading and sitting with as you ponder the next few months of bloody battles.
Politics is a team activity. We are all in teams: a country, a state, a legislative district, a local community. We cannot survive as a bunch of individuals who choose to watch the game, or not, and then decide at the last minute whether or not we should even show up to mark a single ballot for some candidates on November 6. Politics as Civil War, which is what is has become, is not healthy to Team U.S.A., Team State of Minnesota, Team World….
This weekend there were two particularly impressive competitors I saw.

Fan at Parker's game going around showing us the score.


Finishing the race


The little girl, doubtless somebodies sister, wasn’t content to just sit on the sidelines, but felt a need to participate in some way in the game she was watching, and her way was to help announce the score to the rest of us.
But it is the boy in the last picture that wins my prize: he was dead last in his 440 heat, way dead last. But he had absolutely no intention of dropping out, of quitting.
I saw him afterwards, and he was still tired. But he wasn’t a defeated tired, and that’s a critical distinction.
He’d run the race, he’d finished, and of all the competitors I saw this weekend, he’s the one who won top prize in my book. He’s the winner.

There is a huge amount of stake in the 2012 election. Those little kids in the above pictures, and their cohort, everywhere on the planet, are the ones who will benefit, or be damaged, by our wisdom or stupidity; our short or long-term vision for our future.
At the very least, get on the court, and stay there till the finish line. Politics is not a spectator sport.

For other entries on my view of Politics this season, just enter Election 2012 in the search box.

#577 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #22. The Wisconsin Recall Election. Some Musings Driving U.S. Highway 61

As it happened, Tuesday morning June 5 came an unexpected phone call from one of my relatives in Wisconsin. Marion, 95, called to say that her nephew, Dave, had died on Sunday at age 77 “and the funeral is tomorrow at 10:30 in Hazel Green”.
They had misplaced my phone number and don’t do computer, thus the late notice. They didn’t expect anyone to come, but these were people well known to me, and I decided I wanted to go. (Dave was life-long and well known and respected in this area of Wisconsin. There were perhaps 200 at the funeral, and 700 signed the book at the wake the previous evening.)
So, on Wednesday, June 6, the day after the Recall election, I embarked down U.S. Highway 61 from my St. Paul suburb to within a mile of Illinois, across from Dubuque, Iowa, perhaps 100 miles west of Madison.
I was gone from 5 a.m. to 8:30 p.m., including from 8 a.m. to 5:30 in Wisconsin, driving alone, no radio, no television, no newspaper, no computer and no other data source.
Not a word was mentioned about the Wisconsin election that had climaxed the day before.
At home, I gathered only that there was no recall of Governor Walker, that one Wisconsin Senator had been recalled, and that Senatorial election has reshaped the balance of power in the Wisconsin State Senate – a very big deal, if true.
THOUGHTS
First and foremost: I’m not here to second-guess tactics in this election. I worked an entire career with people organizations and have seen the best made plans fail; and the worst, succeed. You might be able to make a perfect ball-bearing, but when people are involved, all bets are off, for all the reasons any human being knows.
As I write this, after noon on Thursday, June 7, I have not, on purpose, read anything, even comments from friends, about the recent Wisconsin election.
I have done this in hopes to keep focus on my own few observations.
As I drove the stunningly beautiful 500 mile round-trip on major highway U.S. 61 yesterday, about half in Minnesota, half in Wisconsin, I decided to notice what I could about the ‘residue’ of the election along the way (mostly signs), and to think about the implications of the just-completed election, and not only for Wisconsin. (For the record, I do not recall a single person saying a single thing about the election. Nothing. And I saw a lot of people at the funeral.)
Here are some thoughts, and a few photos:
1. SIGNS: I was clearly in Walker country in southwest Wisconsin. But there were very few signs, and I didn’t see a single Billboard. (My trip was only a few hours into the first day after the election. Some signs may have already been taken down, but I doubt many had been moved.)
The Walker signs were (in my mind) pretty brilliant in their very simple message (see photos, click to enlarge).

Hazel Green WI June 6, 2012


I didn’t see any large Barrett signs. The roadside ones were small and simple. But there were one or two pretty nicely done hand-made signs like the below two-sided sign. One Walker supporter had a nicely done hand-made sign as well.

Street side in Viroqua WI June 7, 2012


Two-sided sign north of Boscobel WI June 6, 2012


The other side....


I am not a fan of campaign signs, largely because they grow like weeds prior to the election, and overwhelm each other and underwhelm the potential viewer, at least in my view. In this single issue election (with some Senate recalls in some areas of WI), I do think the signs served a very useful purpose, especially the hand-made ones.
I also noticed three themes (at least as I translate them:
A) the Walker signs said, I’d contend, “we elected him, he should have his chance”. (I’m pretty sure there were a lot of Walker voters June 5 who probably thought he and the Republicans over-reached when they took control. But they weren’t willing to politically execute him in favor of someone unknown. I don’t think the negative anti-Milwaukee ads had that much impact on most voters.)
B) The Recall signs were a much harder “sell”: “we want him unelected” without a convincing reason that the alternative would be any better is not an easy argument to accept. Recall is a weapon to be very sparingly used. On the other hand, Walker was elected because lots and lots of Democrats in Wisconsin stayed home and didn’t even bother to vote in 2010. Voter turnout matters a great deal. Turnout, turnout, turnout.
C) Elect Barrett signs weren’t (and probably couldn’t be) very convincing, even though I’m sure Barrett was a good candidate. There had to be a candidate, and he was the one chosen, at the last minute. He was the anti-Walker candidate, not the pro-Wisconsin one.
2. WINNERS AND LOSERS. I can’t see any big “winners” in the exercise just past, but I do think there are “losers”, including Scott Walker, Big Money and the Republican Party.
Wisconsin was big moneys first really major experiment, and while it will claim victory in Walker’s remaining in office, Walker’s power has been eroded, as has his reputation with the general population (my opinion). And he has even less power in moving his agenda in the state. The next two years will be long ones for him.
Those who organized the Recall effort have a huge opportunity if they don’t allow themselves to become dis-spirited. It will be hard to find a resident of Wisconsin who doesn’t have at least an idea about what the issues are. This is a time for community dialogue, and the winner will be those who facilitate these dialogues without set agendas. Communities need to talk this through as communities, not just strategy sessions of ‘power’ people.
In my mind, BIG MONEY LOST in this election. Given the huge disparity in financial resources available, and given #1, it should have been a walk in the park for Walker. Plus, the providers of the Big Money are now public figures in their own right, where they would prefer to hide in the shadows. Hard to believe, also, they, too, have limited resources to spend on such things like state-by-state campaigns. They are not invincible.
3. THINKING BACK IN MINNESOTA HISTORY. On the return trip I found myself thinking back to another last minute election I witnessed here in Minnesota. It was the U.S. Senate election in 2002, when in the wake of the Wellstone’s tragic death, Walter Mondale agreed to stand for election in Paul’s stead.
One can hardly imagine a candidate more qualified than Mondale: former Minnesota Senator, Vice-President of the United States, candidate for President, Ambassador to Japan. And still very much alive today, 10 years later. One can hardly imagine a better stand-in, and a more compelling reason to vote for a candidate in the wake of a tragedy. But when all the votes were counted that November day, his opponent won.
And that is history.
See also previous post, here.
For other related posts, simply put Election 2012 in search box.
UPDATE June 7 5 p.m.:
Dick: I am less and less inclined to look at macro and short-term analyses, and more and more inclined to look at the longer-term and micro (personal) aspects of this and any election, for that matter. It was actually good to drive through that rural country and try to imagine how people in those rural houses and little towns went about making decisions on things like who to vote for on Tuesday, or whether to vote at all. Then there was that large crowd at the church in Hazel Green for the funeral. How do they decide? A lot of it, I’d guess, comes down to feelings and relationships, with a very large dollop of sloppiness and disinterest mixed in. The conversations, including on this network, are very, very important, more so than some grand game-plan, or what someone shoulda done. But, that’s just my opinion, as everyone has a right to have! (I also did a post on Election Day, which I haven’t linked, but which is pertinent to this conversation, I feel. It’s here.)

#576 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #21. Post Mortem Wisconsin

I’m writing this post before the polls close in Wisconsin. I haven’t heard any predictions, or talk of the turnout, or any such thing. So the post-mortem won’t be in this post. There’ll be plenty of those without me….
Love it or not, Scott Walker is the face of the contemporary Republican Party in the United States. Reince Priebus of Wisconsin is Chair of the Republican National Committee. Rep. Paul Ryan is the darling of the House of Representatives and budget issues. Very deep, and in early in Wisconsin politics post 2010, are the Koch Brothers. This is THE place where outside money ran amuck; it’s just a preview of what’s ahead in the next few months.
Wisconsin is my neighbor state. It has a progressive tradition. It also had Sen. Joseph McCarthy.
My grandparents migrated to North Dakota from rural Wisconsin near Dubuque. Wednesday, I’ll be driving to the town of Hazel Green for a family funeral. It will be a long nice drive, lots of time in border area Wisconsin. Very, very nice people down there in the Dubuque area.
Likely we won’t talk politics at the funeral, neither place nor time.
But I do have personal feelings about all of this.
Scott Walker’s signature issue taking office was to do as much damage to public unions as possible. He succeeded.
Had a Republican Governor been elected in the State of Minnesota, my state, the results would have been the same here. Luckily for my own Republican local reps, they had a Democrat Governor to be a check and balance on their colleagues many ideas to slash and burn the public sector, especially teachers and public education, otherwise they’d be running in defense of what they did.
In Michigan, the situation is probably even worse, and Ohio had its flirtation.
Some might say “good”. I take it personally.
I spent most of my work career representing teachers in a union of public employees called MEA, Minnesota Education Association, and now Education Minnesota. The other nine years I taught public school. My parents were career school teachers.
Public Unions made a huge contribution to this country, along with private sector unions, but they, along with the middle class are in the Republican bullseye through the super-rich and the word I’m coming to despise – “business”.
During this scorched earth campaign I had one retired union member from another state, who is married to another retired union member, send me an anti-union – and false – “forward” about a supposedly bankrupt Wisconsin school district due to teacher union greed. And this person believed the tale, without any checking. I can only guess why he, whose success was made by being union, now despises unions.
With union members like these (and there are union members like these), unions don’t need enemies.
The good thing about the last year and a half in Wisconsin is that we’ve seen, up close and pretty personal, what the right wing agenda is, and it isn’t about fairness to the middle class.
The next five months we’ll see Wisconsin-look-a-likes all over the U.S. in the so-called “battleground” states – the places that are believed to be ‘in play’ by the master strategists.
Minnesota has been one of those battleground states, and it’s not pretty.
Maybe the 2012 experience will be bad enough that the geniuses in the U.S. Supreme Court will begin to take another look at what they’ve wrought but opening the floodgates to big money in elections, but I’m not holding my breath.
Maybe sufficient numbers of citizens will think a bit before casting their vote this fall, including actually showing up to vote.
It’ll be a long summer and fall.
Get informed and active.
And Vote in November.
YOU depend on it.

#575 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #20. A History of "Decisive" Battles in Warfare

Today is election day in Wisconsin; five months from today is the United States General Election.
There is a serious question embedded in the following: how do we change American political warfare before we are all – winners and losers and, indeed, country – lying dead in the weeds?
The past couple of generations of Republican politics, more or less 40 years, perfected by people like Lee Atwater and Karl Rove and their many disciples, has been based on principles of Warfare. Negative emotions of people, as fear and loathing, are harnessed and used as the bullets to kill the opposition. Now unlimited and almost totally unregulated money has entered the conversation. Somehow the following commentary seems most appropriate for today, the day Wisconsin decides. I keep thinking of two books….
For some years my bookshelf has held two old books I found some years ago in a box at my Grandparents North Dakota farm.
Both have copyrights of 1898.
One, 592 pages, by U.S. Senator John J. Ingalls (Kansas) is entitled America’s War for Humanity “A Complete History of Cuba’s Struggle for Liberty and the Glorious Heroism of America’s Soldiers and Sailors”.
The second, which is the focus of this post, by Brig. General Charles King, is Decisive Battles of the World, and highlights, in its 956 pages, 52 “Decisive” battles in the history of Humanity. His “Decisive Battles” are listed at the end of this post.
Curious to me is why these books ended up on the farm of my Mom’s parents, which my grandparents established after migrating from southwest Wisconsin in 1905. I don’t know anyone on that ‘side’ of my family who was actually in the Spanish-American War.
More logically, they’d have ended up on the shelf of my other grandfather, Henry Bernard, some hundreds of miles away, who, seven years earlier, was in the Spanish-American War in the Philippines. It appears he was in the same unit commanded by author General King, and at the same places in the Philippines. But King’s book focuses on a battle in Cuba, and not the Philippines.
Ah, the unanswerable questions the very existence of these volumes on a North Dakota farm bring forth!
A more obvious “decisive battle” than the others is the last in King’s book – the 52nd. It is the battle for Santiago Cuba, including the famous story of the Charge up San Juan Hill, with the iconic Colonel Theodore Roosevelt (who in the book is one of four officers pictured, but is the only one in civilian clothes). The others: Major Generals H. W. Lawton and Adna B. Chaffee; and Brig. General Leonard Wood. The Spanish-American War was the war of the authors generation, and of his own participation. This last chapter is written by Henry F. Keenan. Keenan himself is an intriguing character. Why he writes this chapter is unknown. The first few pages are here: Santiago Decisive Battle001
Here’s the Battle for Santiago Map, as published in the book: (click to enlarge it). The invasion began at a place called Baiquiri (yes, the word Daiquiri is also mentioned in the book!)

Page 918 of Decisive Battles of the World by Brig Gen Charles H. King, U.S.A.


The 64 page chapter about Cuba is not quite the standard stuff of war histories written by the victors. The conquest of good (us) over evil (the Spaniards); the heroism and losses of especially the officers (though nothing is said about the schoolboy story I learned of the charge up San Juan Hill led by Teddy Roosevelt.) The natural elements – heat, water, terrain – seem more an “enemy” than the Spaniards, but, whatever….
The Spanish-American War was a triumph of public relations, begun by the mysterious sinking of the battleship Maine in Havana Harbor and nudged along by what came to be called “yellow journalism”. Then came the rush of volunteers to serve, including my grandfather Bernard in the Philippines (“remember the Maine“); and ending, as the author vividly states, “In nearly every one of the thousands of newspapers published throughout the United States, the participants and victims of the Santiago campaign contributed personal observation of the battle; the combined testimonies, if ever collated, would give definite account of every instant of time from the moment the armada left Tampa, until the flag of the republic was flung out over the civic palace of Santiago….”
All that changed over the 2500 years of warfare were the weapons of choice.
Here’s how the weapons of 1898 were described: Sp Am War weapons001
Decisive Battles skips the 20th century because the 20th Century had not yet begun.
War has continued, and the rules of war have only changed, including in Wisconsin, today, where the war is counted in Dollars spent on campaigns and management of misinformation and disinformation. Words have become the weapons. Last I heard, the Democrats are heavily out-gunned in at least the money war: 7 1/2 to one (though those numbers are themselves moving targets.)
Likely no one will physically die, at least directly of the election, but most definitely the intention is to Win, not Lose, a 21st century “Civil War” of a new kind….
But is a “win” in war “decisive”? Maybe, but only for the moment.
As General King had no way of knowing, Santiago turned out to not be “decisive” at all, at least for the peasantry who remained poor. Then someone named Fidel Castro took over Cuba in 1959…and now an American of Spanish Cuban descent, Florida U.S. Senator Marco Rubio, is being prominently mentioned as a possible Republican vice-presidential candidate in the U.S. presidential election…politics does make strange bedfellows.
But even in War, even the victors ultimately lose.

We can make the Rules of War less relevant in the political battles to come.
Brig-Gen. King’s notion of the 52 Decisive Battles of the World:
Marathon 490 BC
Thermopylae 480 BC
Plateau 479 BC
Leuctra 371 BC
Mantinea 362 BC
Arbela 331 BC
Cannae 215 BC
Zama 202 BC
Cynoscephal 197 BC
Manesia 190 BC
Pydna 168 BC
Pharsalia 49 BC
Philippi 42 BC
Chalons 451 AD
Tours 732 AD
Hastings 1066 AD
Jerusalem 1099 AD
Acre 1191 AD
Cressy 1346 AD
Orleans 1429 AD
Constantinople 1453 AD
Leipsic 1631 ad
Lutzen 1632 AD
Vienna 1683 AD
Narva 1700 AD
Pultowa 1709 AD
Blenheim 1794 AD
Ramilies 1706 AD
Gudenarde 1708 AD
Leuthen 1757 AD
Kunersdorf 1759 AD
Torgau 1760 AD
Bunker Hill 1775 AD
Saratoga 1777 AD
Marengo 1800 AD (first of five Napoleonic battles)
Austerlitz 1805 AD ” ”
Jena 1806 AD ” ”
Auerstadt 1806 AD ” ”
Waterloo 1815 AD ” ”
The Alamo 1836 AD (expanding United States)
Chapultepec 1847 AD ” ” ”
Balaclava 1854 AD (Europe)
Malvern Hill 1862 AD (first of five U. S. Civil War)
Manassas 1862 AD ” ”
Chancellorsville 1863 AD ” ”
Gettysburg 1863 AD ” ”
Nashville 1864 AD ” ”
Five Forks and Lee’s Surrender 1865 AD ” ”
Gravelotte 1879 AD
Plevna 1877 AD
Port Arthur 1894 AD
Santiago 1898 AD
By my counting, here are number of his decisive battles by time period:
13 – BC
2 – Pre-1000 AD
6 – 1000-1500 AD
13 – 1600-1800 AD (two American)
18 – 1800-1900 (five Napoleon, six Civil War, two against Mexico)
Directly related to this post: here.
For other political commentary, simply place the words Election 2012 in the search box and click.

#574 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #19. One week to the Recall Election in Wisconsin

UPDATE June 1, 2012: I posted the below on Tuesday May 29, and there are quite a number of comments at the end.
This is an election with far more than routine long-term implications, far beyond “right” vs “left”, “conservative” vs “liberal” or “union” vs “right to work”. This one, with “divide and conquer” to the absolute max, is the ultra-rich and powerful versus the rest of us, which means almost all of us, including everyone I know.
We sent $50 “across the border” so we’ve now become part of the outside money. It doesn’t quite match the $500,000 from the “swift-boat” guy in Houston TX or the $500,000 from the Beloit billionaire (see blog)- and these are only the contributions to the sitting Governor which they have to disclose (see Minneapolis Star Tribune front page article for June 1 here.) There’s pots full of “swift boat” money that doesn’t need to be disclosed as to source.
The only people who will see this blog of mine are people from the middle class – working people like I am, representing the overwhelming vast majority of potential voters in the upcoming election. In the next five months, starting Tuesday, we determine our fate…
Pay attention. Get involved.
(click on photos to enlarge)

Wisconsin State Capitol March 4, 2011


Less than a week from now the Wisconsin recall election will be history. Those of us in the border area media markets, sitting much like spectators at a parade, will have been inundated by the same half or non-truths as our neighbors across the St. Croix, but we won’t have an opportunity to vote for any candidates. That is as well, because those policy makers elected don’t make policy for our own state.
Those in Wisconsin will have to live with their decision next Tuesday.
We outsiders simply have to put up with the Wisconsin circus for a few more days. And in the process we can learn what’s ahead for us in the coming months.
It has long been known that Citizens United money would come in by the gazillions of dollars for this election. I call it “Citizens United” since it arrives by the boatload largely from very wealthy interests and is essentially anonymous. It is what pays for those ads, the assorted (and abundant) “dirty tricks” we’ve read about, and will continue to hear about through June 5.
Then, like the aftermath of a tornado, on June 6 Wisconsin will sift through the rubble to see what is left standing.
A couple of weeks ago, more or less at the same time, I heard two pieces of information about Wisconsin that seem to well frame the over-arching Election Issues for the election.
1. There is the now famous “divide and conquer” video of Gov. Scott Walker meeting with the billionairess from Beloit; the lady who wanted assurance that her contribution would lead to a permanent “red state”. I’m sure the video is readily available, and anyone can look it up, very easily.
2. Then came the flap over the apparent reluctance of the Democratic National Committee (DNC) to cough up $500,000 to at least help match the tornado of money coming in to support Walker. If memory serves, estimates were that the Republican-Democrat campaign money differential might be as much 25 to 1.
I was less than impressed by both narratives.
“Divide and Conquer” is a frequently used strategy, and it never works, except in the short term.
Perhaps one of the worst examples of a supposedly successful “divide and conquer” strategy is the disaster that has been Wisconsin since Jan. 2011. Scott Walker and his party won by division. That is all. But they conquered nothing, at least not permanently. The people of Wisconsin are the losers, and if they have some collective intelligence they will repudiate what they’ve had to live through, and not tolerate such nonsense again. Whoever wins next week will inherit abundant anger from those who lost. There is no “win” for anyone.
As for the Big Daddy (or Big Party) Cash Cows coming to the rescue of Walker of the Dems, I can’t see how that helps either.
Conventional wisdom these days (which is not very wise, in my opinion) is that you win and lose by dollars spent on media advertising and the like.
But where the election next week will be won or lost is by the presence (or lack of) local “boots on the ground”, and, then, people actually showing up at the polls next Tuesday.
Daddy (or Mommy) Warbucks can have ships full of money to dispense, but in the end they are – each of them, including that billionaire – a single vote, just like everybody else. Those who vote uninformed, or stay at home and don’t vote at all, are de facto voting by their absence.
We’ll probably spend a few bucks across state lines (I emphasize “few”), but in the end, the win or the loss will come from the people of Wisconsin who actually show up on Tuesday. It is for this reason that I had little sympathy for the crew that wanted a national group to come in and rescue local people from their own necessary efforts. We’ll never succeed in getting money in politics under control, if we try to win every battle by money alone.
Next week we’ll know what Wisconsin decided.
And in a few months we’ll have our own demonstration in our own state of whether we care enough, or not.

Governors Office, Wisconsin State Capitol, Madison, March 4, 2011


(For other election 2012 commentaries, simply enter the words election 2012 in the search box, and other postings will be identified.)
UPDATES (COMMENTS)
Andrena: We’re 85% on the same page. I still believe the DNC should have given the WI Dems what they requested. The money could have been targeted to the GOTV efforts & media. Moreover, it would have been nice if the DNC could have strategically produced media ads ready to go regardless of who won the primary. In any event, I’ve signed up to phone bank this weekend. I don’t think I would be as effective door knocking in Hudson as an African American woman with MN tags might not go over well with the local folk. My phone voice is flat – aa midwestern/Canadian accent as I’ve often been told.
Fred: Thanks for the report from the front and your response. You’ve got to feel sorry for Wisconsin and its people. Every state has similar political divisions these days but this already-partitioned territory has to publicize the news to the nation. And when it’s over, the anger of the losers will deepen.
Jeff: (1) Just spent the weekend in Madison. And previous weekend in Hayward.
Walker signs are all over most of rural Wisconsin, barely any Barrett signs seen up en route to either city in our drives.
I didn’t watch much local tv, so cannot say about advertising.
Turnout is expected to be 60 to 65 pct, the recall proponents will need to get every last vote.
Polls are pretty much the same… Walker has a 4% lead with the margin of error 4%.
My daughters boyfriend, is a firefighter and EMT, he is canvassing for the recall, and has been a bit frustrated from Dems he calls on … they don’t seem energized… the unions and the teachers and the hardcore are energized, but the hoi polloi seems a bit lackadaisical. Maybe fatigue is the right word, I think a better chance he will be indicted in the ongoing corruption investigation in Milwaukkee county might be more fruitful
There seems to be a portion of Dems and independents who don’t like the guy but also are not in favor of recall. That is the margin of error.
Another report I read said that Walker will take suburban Milwaukee and Wausau and Green Bay; Barrett will take Madison and the surrounding counties, the city of Milwaukee and the Southwestern part of the state
So they say the margin of victory in out in the small towns and rural areas of central, western and northern Wisconsin.
(2) It is risky, but latest polling shows it is getting tighter… Barrett and recall forces have had to wait to spend until the last week. Its going to be a turnout battle. Lets hope the recall works. Another person in Wisc. Told me they think if Walker wins, that Feingold will run against him in 2014.
Denise: Thank you for your posting to your blog on Tuesday! This must be very frustrating living so near to Wisconsin and having to listen to all of this. It is even more frustrating living here and having to deal with our current governor.
Here in Racine, we have a tough unemployment situation. There are jobs for skilled labor, but the cuts to the local technical college have made it even more difficult for anyone who wants the training to attend classes. Some local employers are training interested high school students with the promise of a job after graduation, but the situation is still so aggravating.
We all want a good outcome and positive changes here. Even if Scott Walker is ousted, which I hope that he is, all of this billionaire advertising will pit neighbor against neighbor for a long time.
Our prayers for peace are not only for what happens abroad, but also for our own neighborhoods due to this divisiveness.
Corky: Well worded Dick. We are flooded with calls, letters and pictures like never before. The WEAC supported Democratic candidate fell a LITTLE SHORT of a win in WISC primary. What qualifies as middle class today? Where is the national agenda for education from either party?
Stephanie: Beautifully said, Dick. I was in Hudson the other day and was encouraged by the homemade signs supporting Barrett …there were more of them than the pre-fab Walker signs…this would be such a sweet win for working people…heck, for everyone who cares about a sane society.
Leila: Sane society? We just had a entire Michigan school district turned over to an “emergency manager” who proceeded to hire a charter school company and fire all 80 teachers because the district was $12 million in debt. I hope that Minnesota remains poised to fight off attacks on public education because they are really fighting dirty in Michigan.
Jermitt: Walker is a very dangerous man. He has created great harm to public education, the environment, the poor and the elderly. This past year he paraded around with his rich friends, mostly from states other than Wisconsin, and raised multi-millions of dollars from his rich friends. Wisconsin is losing it reputation of being a “clean political” state with all the corruptions and big money taking over.
Patricia: Yes, those of us in the Duluth-Superior area know only too well what you mean about being inundated with ads. I ALSO think our being just across the bridge with adds to our understanding of the situation. A lot of the “outsiders” manning picket lines etc. are from our side of the border. Duluthians and North Shore residents shop in Superior a LOT, our kids go to UW@S, we work on either side of the border and feel a strong kinship.
Norm: Recall elections of any kind let alone of this magnitude are hard to win and Walker will probably win by the current poll margin of 4% or so or about the same margin as he beat Barrett by last time. Many union folk apparently are not all that enthusiastic about Barrett having preferred another candidate in the primary so that may explain the lack of enthusiasm that Dick mentions in his fine blog. As per Dick, I have also heard of many Democrats who don’t like Walker but feel that he should be allowed to serve out the term to which he was elected by the voters…and that will be a crucial factor in a close election as Dick noted. And there are always a certain number of folks, as Dick and others very well know that have a continuing [grievance] against public employees that can easily be exploited in their favor by the supporters of Walker and the ALEC agenda. As a public employee myself, I am well aware of the negative feelings of many citizens about us regardless of whether they have a rational reason for feeling that way.
Walker will likely win by a small margin although the margin could be larger and surprise all of the pundits and so on…prior to the start of the predictable adaseum analyses on whether or not outside money affected the race or not.
Jeff: Look past Madison. The economy here is slowing down in concert with the impending euro collapse and its tsunami effect worldwide. China and India are also slowing down and no longer have the froth to prop up the world as in 2008-2009.
This is not good for our mutual friend the POTUS [President Obama], I would have said he might have won if things kept improving slowly, but if things head the other way which is what I am seeing in past 60 days, this election is a toss up. Just like in Europe, its really not an ideological things, incumbents will be punished regardless of the party.
Dick, responding to Jeff: The American blood sport is to blame the President for everything. It is prudently noted that the first act of the Republicans when President Obama was inaugurated in 2009 was to obstruct everything, and create failure, hoping they could take credit later and blame him for the current problems. Never forget where the dominos were first set up to fall: easy credit and paying for a long war on the national credit card beginning in 2002 in a heavily Republican dominated government.
Will: The Wisconsin recall election is America in microcosm. In this election year, it will tell us a lot about where the electorate is re the Nov. 6 election.
Always remember that Republican master strategist Karl Rove has as his goal installation of a permanent Republican majority in the three branches of government. He has the Supreme Court in hand by a consistent 5-4 margin on key issues for the nation. Whether he can succeed for the long haul in the House and Senate remains to be seen.
John: My baptism into the teacher union movement was in 1968-69 when I was chief negotiator of a first contract for the Albany EA with the Albany , WI public schools. This was bargained under the provisions of the Wisconsin public sector bargaining law. After a few more years of teaching music, in 1971 I began my professional career as a union organizer for with the Minnesota Education Association, later known as Education Minnesota. Just as I was retiring last year, after 40 years with the union here in MN, Gov. Walker was throwing a monkey wrench into the works in my home state. It seemed, and still does, as unbelievable.
Make no mistake: the assault on public sector unions in Wisconsin is part of a much bigger push by the right wing to dis-empower all workers, unionized or not, both public and private. The fight to recall Walker and his conservative legislators has been intriguing to observe. I am pulling for a successful outcome. If only the right wing push in Wisconsin were an aberation! All to many citizens either “think” they are in the top 1% or expect to be (winning the lottery?) and don’t realize how assaults on any workers is an assault on them.
The motto of the State of Wisconsin is “Forward”. Let’s all act on another slogan: “Forward ever, backward never”.
Susan: Dick, well written and true, although Wisconsin (where I live) is a flashpoint for all the battles in this country. We can’t win with money – the boatloads went elsewhere. But we can fight back with bodies knocking on doors. We Wisconsinites will have to live with what happens. And Minnesota has its own challenges too.
Sabrina: I sent postcards to the DNC and asked that they openly support the Democrats in Wisconsin. The Democrats have got to also be concerned with what state legislatures are doing cause they are the ones working to take away our rights.
Mary Ellen: Thanks, Dick. It’s not easy living in Wisconsin lately. But, neighbors are still friendly and we all try to avoid the divisiveness promoted in every political ad and sound-bite. We’re also refusing to take their dumb polls. The 4% is bogus. Walker is on his way out. It’s only a question of how big a margin it will be. Tuesday can’t come soon enough. That’s the day we can prove that the vote is mightier than the dollar.
Dick 8:30 p.m. June 3: Latest report, on CBS news this afternoon, was that Gov. Walker had a 3 to 1 advantage in $’s for his campaign. I suppose somebody could say that “that’s almost even”. Of course it isn’t almost even….

#572 – Dick Bernard: Election 2012 #18. Four days without the "news"

Last Friday I took a four day one thousand mile trip related to family matters in North Dakota. The trip included a visit to an Aunt and Uncle and a drive to a family funeral near the Canadian border. Over half of the trip was by myself, which always makes a trip seem longer, at least to me.
The 450 mile portion of the trip with my Uncle – my Aunt was not feeling well and stayed home – was a pleasure, albeit connected with a sad occasion: the final memorial and burial of one of my cousins.
There was lots of time for us to just visit, in the country manner.
In those four days there were scant idle moments. If I wasn’t doing something, I was sleeping. Such is how it goes.
As I age, it takes longer to recover from these trips, but they all have their pleasant aspects: “visiting”; arriving at the assisted living facility to find a couple entertaining the residents with karaoke; taking a side trip enroute home from the funeral to see the dikes attempting to hold the ever-swelling Devils Lake from flooding even more territory (my Uncle seriously tempted to stop to do some fishing); going to church; doing some routine work on the home farmstead; experiencing a whole lot of old-fashioned hospitality….
In 1000 miles, 450 of it essentially new territory for me to actually see, one sees a lot of interesting things, and much beauty, even in an ever more sparsely populated state like my home state of North Dakota.
Something else happened this trip.
I didn’t watch television, listen to radio, or even read newspapers, not even the local weekly, The Chronicle, which I am in the habit of buying when at my relatives town. The Chronicle is a throwback to the ‘old days’. Indeed, when it is published tomorrow, I will appear as “news” in the community events section of the paper. I was a visitor, after all, and such things are noticed in those not-always mythological “towns that time forgot and the decades cannot improve” of Garrison Keillor.
*
Then I arrived home Monday night and was reunited with the real world conveyed through television and newspaper.
This particular time, the evening of May 21, 2012, the battle was still raging over what Mayor Corey Booker of Newark NJ had passionately opined on one of the Sunday morning news program. The topic is irrelevant, but the outcome was predictable.
Because the statement was passionate, probably not scripted, and because Mayor Booker is identified as partisan, favoring one candidate for President over another, the statement was quotable, and it was instantly manipulated into useful sound bites for political advertising and partisan commentary, and required response from the other side.
The statement seemed to have basically swamped the news cycle of this particular day in history. It had even outlived the traditional one-day ‘moment of fame’.
Mayor Booker’s major sin, it seems, was that he was honest in his expression of opinion. Honesty in politics is truly politically dangerous, We seem to not only expect, but demand, that our politicians be dishonest.
I had come back from my isolation in “Lake Wobegon” to the battlefield of today’s contemporary politics where the objective is for one side to win, by making another lose; the elevation of an ever meaner and nastier side of what passes for political conversation in this country.
We witness it all, most of us from an easy chair in front of a television screen, too many of us picking up our reality from one extremely partisan side, or another.
It is not a winning strategy for our country, our larger community.
Election 2012 is looming.
Either we are part of the solution, or part of the problem…and the solution is not demolishing by any and all means the opposing ‘other’, or dismissing the other point of view.
We are, after all, part of a very large family of humankind.
*
Monday early afternoon, visit over, it was time to head back to “the Cities”.
Out the window at the assisted living facility I had noted that the American flag on the flagpole was badly frayed from too long in the North Dakota wind.
Down to the hardware store I went, and picked up a replacement which will be posted in time for Memorial Day, in memory of cousin Pat, and for all of us.
Happy Memorial Day.
*
An album from May 18-21, 2012: (click on photos to enlarge)

Karaoke program at Rosewood


Remembering a life at Langdon


A little lunch after the service


The ritual photo at Mom and Dad...and Sisters...grave at Dresden


spring


Wimbledon


Bedstead and old harnest in the haymow of the old barn


In the old barn. Dad helped make these beams when the roof of the old barn blew down July, 1949.


1915 Stanchions for milking cows


An old stove in a shed


where the old house used to be, from the haymow of the barn


Uncle Vince planting tomatoes